Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
139 lines (123 loc) · 13.7 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

139 lines (123 loc) · 13.7 KB

Okay, let's perform a deep security analysis of the asciinema-player based on the provided design review.

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

  • Objective: To conduct a thorough security analysis of the asciinema-player's key components, identify potential vulnerabilities, and propose actionable mitigation strategies. The primary focus is on client-side security, as the player operates within a web browser. We aim to identify vulnerabilities that could lead to XSS, data exfiltration, or other client-side attacks. We also want to ensure the player's design and implementation minimize the risk of introducing vulnerabilities into the embedding website.

  • Scope:

    • The core JavaScript code of the asciinema-player (as represented by asciinemaPlayerJS in the C4 Container diagram).
    • The interaction between the player and the embedding website.
    • The handling of recording data (JSON).
    • The build and deployment process (focusing on security-relevant aspects).
    • The optional interaction with asciinema.org or other recording sources.
    • CSS styling in relation to security.

  • Methodology:

    1. Architecture and Data Flow Review: Analyze the provided C4 diagrams (Context, Container, Deployment, Build) to understand the player's architecture, components, data flow, and interactions with external entities.
    2. Codebase Inference: Based on the design document and the nature of the project (a JavaScript-based terminal emulator), we'll infer the likely structure and functionality of the code. We'll assume the use of common JavaScript patterns and libraries for DOM manipulation, event handling, and potentially asynchronous operations. Since we don't have the actual code, we'll make educated guesses about potential vulnerabilities based on common coding errors in similar projects.
    3. Threat Modeling: Identify potential threats based on the identified components, data flows, and inferred code functionality. We'll focus on threats relevant to a client-side JavaScript component, particularly XSS and related injection attacks.
    4. Vulnerability Analysis: For each identified threat, we'll analyze potential vulnerabilities that could allow the threat to be realized.
    5. Mitigation Strategies: Propose specific, actionable mitigation strategies to address the identified vulnerabilities. These strategies will be tailored to the asciinema-player and its context.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

  • asciinema-player (JS) (Core JavaScript Code):

    • Threats:
      • XSS (Cross-Site Scripting): The most significant threat. Maliciously crafted recording data could inject JavaScript code that executes in the context of the embedding website. This could lead to data theft, session hijacking, or defacement.
      • DOM Manipulation Attacks: Even without full XSS, malicious recording data could manipulate the DOM in unexpected ways, potentially disrupting the embedding website's layout or functionality.
      • Denial of Service (DoS): A very large or complex recording could consume excessive browser resources, leading to a denial of service for the user.
      • Escape Sequence Injection: Malicious escape sequences within the recording data could potentially interact with the terminal emulation logic in unintended ways, leading to unexpected behavior or vulnerabilities.
      • Prototype Pollution: If the player uses vulnerable JavaScript libraries or patterns, it might be susceptible to prototype pollution attacks, which can lead to XSS or other unexpected behavior.
    • Vulnerabilities (Inferred):
      • Insufficient sanitization of recording data before rendering it to the DOM. This is the primary vulnerability that could lead to XSS.
      • Improper handling of escape sequences.
      • Use of innerHTML or similar methods without proper escaping.
      • Vulnerable JavaScript libraries (if any are used).
      • Lack of input validation for URL parameters or configuration options.
      • Logic errors in the terminal emulation that could be exploited by specially crafted input.
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Robust Input Sanitization: Implement a strict whitelist-based sanitizer for all recording data before it interacts with the DOM. This sanitizer should:
        • Allow only a specific set of safe HTML tags and attributes (if any are needed for terminal rendering). Do not rely on blacklisting.
        • Escape all other characters.
        • Validate and sanitize escape sequences according to a well-defined specification. Consider using a dedicated library for parsing and sanitizing ANSI escape codes.
        • Be applied recursively to all parts of the recording data.
      • Use of Safe DOM Manipulation Methods: Avoid innerHTML whenever possible. Prefer safer methods like textContent, createElement, and setAttribute. If innerHTML must be used, ensure the input is thoroughly sanitized first.
      • Content Security Policy (CSP): Implement a strict CSP on the embedding website. This is a crucial defense-in-depth measure. The CSP should:
        • Restrict script execution to trusted sources (e.g., the CDN hosting the player).
        • Disallow inline scripts (script-src 'self').
        • Disallow eval() and similar functions.
        • Restrict object sources (object-src 'none').
        • Consider using a frame-ancestors directive to prevent clickjacking if the player is embedded in an iframe.
      • Sandboxed iframe: Embedding the player within a sandboxed iframe provides an additional layer of isolation. Use the sandbox attribute with appropriate restrictions (e.g., allow-scripts, but not allow-same-origin).
      • Regular Expression Review: If regular expressions are used for parsing or sanitizing input, carefully review them for potential ReDoS (Regular Expression Denial of Service) vulnerabilities.
      • Dependency Management: Use a dependency management tool (e.g., npm, yarn) to track and update all dependencies. Regularly check for and apply security updates. Consider using tools like npm audit or Snyk to automatically identify vulnerable dependencies.
      • Rate Limiting/Resource Limits: Implement limits on the size and complexity of recordings that can be processed to prevent DoS attacks. This could involve limiting the number of frames, the size of individual frames, or the overall recording size.
      • Testing: Thoroughly test the player with a wide range of inputs, including:
        • Valid recordings.
        • Recordings with various escape sequences.
        • Maliciously crafted recordings designed to exploit potential vulnerabilities.
        • Large and complex recordings.
        • Fuzz testing can be beneficial.
      • Error Handling: Implement robust error handling to prevent unexpected behavior or information leakage in case of errors.

  • asciinema-player (CSS):

    • Threats:
      • CSS Injection: While less common than JavaScript injection, CSS injection is still possible. Malicious CSS could be used to:
        • Overlay content on the page, potentially tricking users into clicking malicious links.
        • Exfiltrate data using CSS selectors and external resources (e.g., background images).
        • Disrupt the layout of the embedding website.
    • Vulnerabilities (Inferred):
      • Dynamically generated CSS based on untrusted input (e.g., recording data or URL parameters).
      • Use of external CSS resources without proper integrity checks.
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Avoid Dynamic CSS Based on Untrusted Input: Do not generate CSS styles based on recording data or other untrusted input. Use a predefined set of CSS classes.
      • Subresource Integrity (SRI): If loading CSS from a CDN, use SRI to ensure the integrity of the CSS file. This prevents attackers from tampering with the CSS file on the CDN.
      • CSP: The CSP can also restrict the sources of CSS (style-src).
      • Review CSS: Manually review the CSS code to ensure it doesn't contain any potentially dangerous constructs (e.g., expression() in older versions of Internet Explorer).

  • Recording Data (JSON):

    • Threats: This is the primary vector for attacks against the player. The threats are the same as those listed for asciinema-player (JS).
    • Vulnerabilities (Inferred): The vulnerabilities are in how the player handles the recording data, not in the data itself.
    • Mitigation Strategies: The mitigation strategies are the same as those listed for asciinema-player (JS) – primarily robust input sanitization.

  • Website/Documentation Platform:

    • Threats: The player could be used as a vector to attack the embedding website.
    • Vulnerabilities (Inferred): The embedding website might trust the player too much, failing to implement adequate security measures (e.g., CSP).
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Implement a strict CSP: This is the most important mitigation strategy for the embedding website.
      • Treat the player as untrusted: The embedding website should not assume that the player is secure. It should implement its own security measures as if the player were a potentially malicious third-party component.
      • Consider using a sandboxed iframe: This provides an additional layer of isolation between the player and the embedding website.

  • asciinema.org (optional):

    • Threats: If the player fetches recordings from asciinema.org, there's a risk of:
      • Man-in-the-middle (MITM) attacks.
      • Compromised asciinema.org server serving malicious recordings.
    • Vulnerabilities (Inferred):
      • Lack of HTTPS.
      • Insufficient validation of data fetched from asciinema.org.
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Use HTTPS: Always use HTTPS to fetch recordings from asciinema.org or any other external source.
      • Validate Data: Even if fetched over HTTPS, the player should still thoroughly validate and sanitize the recording data as described above. Do not assume that data from asciinema.org is inherently safe.
      • Consider CORS: If fetching recordings from a different origin, ensure that the server sends appropriate CORS headers.

  • Build Process:

    • Threats:
      • Compromised build server.
      • Introduction of vulnerabilities during the build process.
      • Use of vulnerable dependencies.
    • Vulnerabilities (Inferred):
      • Lack of security checks in the build pipeline.
      • Outdated or vulnerable build tools.
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • SAST (Static Application Security Testing): Integrate SAST tools into the build pipeline to automatically scan the code for vulnerabilities.
      • Dependency Analysis: Use tools to identify and update vulnerable dependencies.
      • Secure Build Environment: Ensure the build server is secure and protected from unauthorized access.
      • Code Signing: Consider code signing the released JavaScript files to ensure their integrity.

3. Summary of Key Recommendations

  1. Robust Input Sanitization: This is the most critical security control. Implement a strict whitelist-based sanitizer for all recording data.
  2. Content Security Policy (CSP): Implement a strict CSP on the embedding website.
  3. Sandboxed iframe: Embed the player within a sandboxed iframe for additional isolation.
  4. Dependency Management: Regularly update and audit dependencies.
  5. Secure Build Process: Integrate SAST and dependency analysis into the build pipeline.
  6. HTTPS: Use HTTPS for all external communication.
  7. Thorough Testing: Test with a wide range of inputs, including malicious ones.
  8. Avoid Dynamic CSS: Do not generate CSS based on untrusted input.
  9. Subresource Integrity (SRI): Use SRI for externally loaded resources.
  10. Error Handling: Implement robust error handling.
  11. Rate Limiting: Implement rate limiting to prevent DoS.

4. Addressing Questions and Assumptions

  • Compliance Requirements: While the player itself doesn't directly handle personal data, if it's integrated into a system that does, the integration must comply with relevant regulations (GDPR, CCPA, etc.). The player should be designed to minimize any potential impact on compliance.
  • Traffic Volume: High traffic volume reinforces the need for robust DoS protection (rate limiting, resource limits).
  • Integrations: Any integrations with other systems must be carefully designed with security in mind, following secure authentication and authorization practices.
  • Vulnerability Reporting: A clear process for reporting security vulnerabilities is essential (e.g., a security.txt file, a dedicated email address).
  • Malicious Content Reporting: A mechanism for users to report malicious content is important for maintaining the reputation of the project and protecting users. This could be a simple "report" button or a more sophisticated system.

This deep analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the security considerations for the asciinema-player. By implementing the recommended mitigation strategies, the developers can significantly reduce the risk of vulnerabilities and ensure the player is a secure and reliable component for embedding terminal recordings on the web. The most important takeaway is the absolute necessity of robust input sanitization to prevent XSS attacks.