Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
137 lines (113 loc) · 19.1 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

137 lines (113 loc) · 19.1 KB

Deep Security Analysis of bpmn-js

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

Objective: The objective of this deep analysis is to conduct a thorough security assessment of the bpmn-js library, focusing on its key components, potential vulnerabilities, and mitigation strategies. The analysis aims to identify security risks related to the library's core functionality: rendering, manipulating, and validating BPMN 2.0 diagrams within a web browser. We will pay particular attention to how bpmn-js handles user input and interacts with the DOM, as these are common attack vectors in web applications.

Scope: This analysis focuses exclusively on the bpmn-js library itself (version identified from package.json if possible, otherwise latest stable). It does not cover the security of the embedding application, backend systems, or network infrastructure, except where bpmn-js directly interacts with them. We assume the embedding application handles authentication, authorization, and secure storage of BPMN diagrams. The analysis considers the library's use as an npm package, as described in the deployment diagram.

Methodology:

  1. Code Review: We will examine the bpmn-js source code (available on GitHub) to understand its architecture, components, and data flow. We will focus on areas relevant to security, such as input handling, XML parsing, DOM manipulation, and event handling.
  2. Documentation Review: We will review the official bpmn-js documentation, including examples, API references, and any security-related guidelines.
  3. Dependency Analysis: We will analyze the library's dependencies (listed in package.json) to identify potential vulnerabilities inherited from third-party libraries.
  4. Threat Modeling: We will identify potential threats based on the library's functionality and the identified attack surface. We will use the STRIDE model (Spoofing, Tampering, Repudiation, Information Disclosure, Denial of Service, Elevation of Privilege) as a framework.
  5. Vulnerability Analysis: We will assess the likelihood and impact of identified threats, considering existing security controls and accepted risks.
  6. Mitigation Recommendations: We will provide specific, actionable recommendations to mitigate identified vulnerabilities and improve the overall security posture of the library.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

Based on the provided design review and a preliminary understanding of bpmn-js, we can identify the following key components and their security implications:

  • XML Parser (e.g., moddle, saxen): bpmn-js relies on an XML parser to process BPMN 2.0 XML files.

    • Threats:
      • XML External Entity (XXE) Injection: Maliciously crafted XML input could include external entities that, when processed, could lead to information disclosure (reading local files), denial of service (resource exhaustion), or even server-side request forgery (SSRF).
      • XML Bomb (Billion Laughs Attack): A specially crafted XML file with nested entities can cause exponential expansion, leading to denial of service by consuming excessive memory or CPU.
      • Xpath Injection: If user input is used to construct XPath queries, attackers could inject malicious XPath expressions to access or modify unauthorized parts of the XML document.
    • Mitigation:
      • Disable External Entities: The XML parser should be configured to completely disable the resolution of external entities and DTDs. This is the most crucial mitigation for XXE.
      • Limit Entity Expansion: Implement limits on the depth and size of entity expansion to prevent XML bomb attacks. This can often be configured within the XML parser.
      • Input Validation and Sanitization: If user input is used in XPath queries (which should be avoided if possible), strictly validate and sanitize the input to prevent injection. Consider using parameterized queries or a safer alternative to XPath if feasible.
      • Regularly Update Parser: Keep the XML parsing library up-to-date to benefit from security patches.

  • Diagram Renderer (SVG/Canvas): bpmn-js renders BPMN diagrams using SVG (Scalable Vector Graphics) or potentially Canvas.

    • Threats:
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via SVG: Malicious JavaScript code could be injected into the SVG elements, potentially through user-provided labels, descriptions, or other attributes within the BPMN XML. This is a significant concern.
      • Denial of Service (DoS): Extremely complex or large diagrams could potentially overload the renderer, causing the browser to become unresponsive.
    • Mitigation:
      • Strict Output Encoding: All user-supplied data rendered within the SVG (or Canvas) must be properly encoded to prevent XSS. This includes labels, descriptions, and any other attributes that might contain user input. Use appropriate encoding functions for the specific context (e.g., HTML entity encoding for text content, attribute encoding for attribute values).
      • Content Security Policy (CSP): Implement a strict CSP that restricts the sources of scripts, styles, and other resources. This can significantly limit the impact of XSS vulnerabilities. Specifically, disallow unsafe-inline scripts and limit script sources to trusted domains.
      • Input Validation (Length Limits): Impose reasonable limits on the length of user-supplied text to prevent excessively long strings that could contribute to DoS or be used to bypass other security controls.
      • Sanitize SVG Attributes: Specifically target and sanitize known dangerous SVG attributes that can execute scripts, such as onload, onclick, and href attributes on <script> or <a> tags within the SVG.

  • Event Handling (User Interaction): bpmn-js handles user interactions with the diagram, such as clicking, dragging, and editing elements.

    • Threats:
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): If event handlers are not properly implemented, they could be vulnerable to XSS attacks. For example, if user input is directly used to construct JavaScript code that is executed in an event handler.
      • DOM Manipulation Attacks: Malicious code could manipulate the DOM to alter the diagram's appearance or behavior, potentially leading to phishing or other attacks.
    • Mitigation:
      • Avoid Inline Event Handlers: Do not use inline event handlers (e.g., <div onclick="maliciousCode()">). Instead, use addEventListener to attach event listeners programmatically.
      • Sanitize Data Before DOM Manipulation: Before updating the DOM with user-provided data, always sanitize the data to prevent XSS and DOM manipulation attacks. Use appropriate encoding or escaping techniques.
      • Use a Templating Engine (with Caution): If a templating engine is used, ensure it provides automatic escaping and contextual output encoding to prevent XSS. Be aware of the security implications of the chosen templating engine.

  • API (Programmatic Access): bpmn-js provides an API for programmatic access to the modeler and diagram data.

    • Threats:
      • Injection Attacks: If the API allows for arbitrary code execution or does not properly validate input, it could be vulnerable to injection attacks.
      • Unauthorized Access: If the API is not properly secured, it could allow unauthorized access to diagram data or functionality.
    • Mitigation:
      • Input Validation: Strictly validate all input to the API to prevent injection attacks. Define clear data types and validation rules for each API endpoint.
      • Secure Coding Practices: Follow secure coding practices to prevent vulnerabilities such as buffer overflows, format string vulnerabilities, and other common coding errors.
      • Documentation: Clearly document the security considerations for using the API, including input validation requirements and potential risks.

  • Dependencies (e.g., diagram-js, min-dash): bpmn-js relies on several other libraries.

    • Threats:
      • Vulnerable Dependencies: Dependencies may contain known vulnerabilities that could be exploited by attackers.
    • Mitigation:
      • Dependency Management: Use a package manager (npm) to manage dependencies and keep them up-to-date.
      • Vulnerability Scanning: Regularly scan dependencies for known vulnerabilities using tools like npm audit, snyk, or GitHub's Dependabot.
      • Dependency Pinning (with Caution): Consider pinning dependencies to specific versions to prevent unexpected updates that could introduce new vulnerabilities or break compatibility. However, this should be balanced with the need to apply security updates.

3. Architecture, Components, and Data Flow (Inferred)

Based on the codebase structure and documentation, we can infer the following:

  • Architecture: bpmn-js follows a modular architecture, with separate components responsible for different aspects of the modeler's functionality. It's primarily a client-side library, with minimal server-side interaction (handled by the embedding application).
  • Components:
    • Core Modeler: Provides the main interface for creating, importing, and manipulating BPMN diagrams.
    • XML Parser: Parses BPMN 2.0 XML files.
    • Diagram Renderer: Renders the diagram using SVG.
    • Event Bus: Handles events and communication between different components.
    • Modules: Various modules provide specific features, such as editing tools, context pads, and overlays.
  • Data Flow:
    1. Import: The user imports a BPMN 2.0 XML file (or creates a new diagram).
    2. Parsing: The XML parser processes the XML and creates an internal model representation.
    3. Rendering: The diagram renderer creates the visual representation of the diagram using SVG.
    4. Interaction: The user interacts with the diagram, triggering events.
    5. Event Handling: Event handlers process user actions and update the internal model.
    6. Re-rendering: The diagram renderer updates the visual representation based on changes to the internal model.
    7. Export: The user exports diagram to BPMN 2.0 XML file.

4. Specific Security Considerations and Recommendations

Given the nature of bpmn-js as a client-side BPMN modeling library, the following security considerations are paramount:

  • XSS is the Primary Threat: The most significant threat to bpmn-js is Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) due to the potential for user-supplied data (labels, descriptions, etc.) to be injected into the rendered SVG.
  • XML Parsing Security is Crucial: Properly configuring the XML parser to prevent XXE and XML bomb attacks is essential.
  • Input Validation is Key: All user input, whether directly entered or included in imported BPMN XML, must be strictly validated and sanitized.
  • CSP and SRI are Highly Recommended: Implementing a Content Security Policy (CSP) and Subresource Integrity (SRI) provides strong defense-in-depth against XSS and other attacks.

Specific Recommendations:

  1. Disable External Entities in XML Parser: This is the single most important mitigation. Ensure the XML parser is configured to completely disable the resolution of external entities and DTDs. Verify this configuration through code review and testing.
  2. Comprehensive Output Encoding: Implement rigorous output encoding for all user-supplied data rendered in the SVG. Use appropriate encoding functions for the specific context (HTML entity encoding for text, attribute encoding for attributes). Test thoroughly with various attack payloads.
  3. Strict Content Security Policy (CSP): Implement a strict CSP that:
    • Disallows unsafe-inline scripts.
    • Restricts script sources to trusted domains (e.g., your own domain, a CDN for trusted libraries).
    • Limits object sources (e.g., Flash, Java applets) if they are not needed.
    • Consider using a CSP reporting mechanism to monitor for violations.
  4. Subresource Integrity (SRI): Use SRI for all externally loaded scripts and stylesheets to ensure they haven't been tampered with.
  5. Input Validation (Length and Character Restrictions): Implement input validation to:
    • Limit the length of user-supplied text.
    • Restrict the allowed characters to a safe subset (e.g., alphanumeric characters, common punctuation). Avoid allowing characters that have special meaning in HTML or JavaScript (e.g., <, >, &, ", ').
  6. Regular Dependency Audits: Use npm audit or similar tools to regularly scan dependencies for known vulnerabilities. Update dependencies promptly when security patches are available.
  7. Security-Focused Code Reviews: Conduct code reviews with a specific focus on security, paying attention to input validation, output encoding, XML parsing, and event handling.
  8. Automated Security Testing: Integrate automated security testing tools into the CI/CD pipeline. This could include:
    • Static Analysis Security Testing (SAST): Use tools like ESLint with security plugins to identify potential vulnerabilities in the code.
    • Dynamic Analysis Security Testing (DAST): Use web application scanners to test the running application for vulnerabilities.
    • Fuzz Testing: Use fuzzing techniques to test the XML parser and other input handling components with unexpected or malformed data.
  9. Security.md: Maintain and update SECURITY.md file.
  10. Sanitize SVG Attributes: Specifically target and sanitize known dangerous SVG attributes.

5. Actionable Mitigation Strategies

The following table summarizes the identified threats and provides actionable mitigation strategies:

Threat Component Mitigation Strategy Priority
XXE Injection XML Parser Disable external entities and DTDs in the XML parser configuration. Verify this configuration through code review and testing. High
XML Bomb (Billion Laughs) XML Parser Limit entity expansion depth and size in the XML parser configuration. High
XSS via SVG Diagram Renderer Comprehensive output encoding of all user-supplied data rendered in the SVG. Use appropriate encoding functions for the context (HTML entity encoding for text, attribute encoding for attributes). Test thoroughly with various attack payloads. Implement a strict Content Security Policy (CSP). Sanitize SVG Attributes High
XSS via Event Handlers Event Handling Avoid inline event handlers. Use addEventListener instead. Sanitize data before DOM manipulation. High
Injection Attacks (API) API Strictly validate all input to the API. Define clear data types and validation rules. High
Vulnerable Dependencies Dependencies Regularly scan dependencies for known vulnerabilities using npm audit or similar tools. Update dependencies promptly when security patches are available. High
Denial of Service (DoS) via complex diagrams Diagram Renderer Implement input validation (length limits) for user-supplied text. Consider limiting the complexity or size of diagrams that can be rendered. Medium
DOM Manipulation Attacks Event Handling Sanitize data before DOM manipulation. Use appropriate encoding or escaping techniques. Medium
XPath Injection XML Parser Avoid using user input in XPath queries if possible. If unavoidable, strictly validate and sanitize the input. Consider parameterized queries or a safer alternative. Medium
Unauthorized Access (API) API Implement authentication and authorization mechanisms in the embedding application. The API itself should not handle authentication or authorization, but the embedding application should control access to the API. Low

This deep analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the security considerations for bpmn-js. By implementing the recommended mitigation strategies, developers can significantly reduce the risk of security vulnerabilities and ensure the safe and reliable operation of the library. Remember that security is an ongoing process, and regular security audits, testing, and updates are essential to maintain a strong security posture.