Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
71 lines (59 loc) · 7.39 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

71 lines (59 loc) · 7.39 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for daneden/animate.css

Objective: To degrade the user experience or subtly manipulate the application's UI/UX through malicious use of animate.css, leading to potential phishing, misinformation, or denial of service (at the animation level).

Attack Tree Visualization

                                      [Attacker's Goal: Degrade UX or Subtly Manipulate UI/UX]
                                                      |
                                      ---------------------------------
                                      |                               |
                      [+1.2 Introduce New via XSS+]  [!!!2.2 Hijack Animation!!!]
                       (If XSS vulnerability exists)   [!!!End Events!!!]
                      =========================          |
                      |                           |      |
                      |                           |      |
            [!!!1.2.1 Reflected!!!]       [!!!2.2.1 Redirect!!!]
             [!!!XSS!!!]                   [!!!to Malicious!!!]
                                           [!!!URL!!!]

Attack Tree Path: [+1.2 Introduce New via XSS+] (Critical Node)

  • Description: The attacker leverages a Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) vulnerability to inject malicious CSS or a link to an external malicious CSS file into the application. This is a critical node because XSS is a prerequisite for many of the other high-impact attacks. Without the ability to inject code, the attacker's options are severely limited.
    • How it works:
      • The attacker finds an input field (e.g., search bar, comment section, form input) that is not properly sanitized.
      • The attacker crafts a malicious payload containing either a <style> tag with malicious CSS or a <link> tag referencing a malicious CSS file hosted on an attacker-controlled server.
      • The attacker submits the payload through the vulnerable input field.
      • If the application does not properly encode or validate the input, the malicious payload is either reflected back to the user (Reflected XSS) or stored on the server (Stored XSS).
      • When the vulnerable page is loaded, the browser executes the injected CSS, applying the attacker's malicious animations.
    • Mitigations:
      • Strict Input Validation: Validate all user input on the server-side to ensure it conforms to expected data types and formats. Reject any input that contains unexpected characters or patterns.
      • Output Encoding: Encode all user-supplied data before displaying it in the HTML context. Use appropriate encoding methods (e.g., HTML entity encoding) to prevent the browser from interpreting the data as code.
      • Content Security Policy (CSP): Implement a strict CSP to restrict the sources from which CSS can be loaded. This can prevent the loading of external malicious CSS files.
      • Use a Framework with Built-in XSS Protection: Modern web frameworks (e.g., React, Angular, Vue) often have built-in mechanisms to prevent XSS vulnerabilities.
      • Avoid innerHTML and Similar Methods: Use safer alternatives like textContent or DOM manipulation methods that do not directly interpret HTML strings.

Attack Tree Path: [!!!1.2.1 Reflected XSS!!!] (High-Risk Path)

  • Description: A specific type of XSS where the malicious payload is included in a URL parameter or form submission and is immediately reflected back to the user in the server's response. This is a high-risk path because reflected XSS vulnerabilities are relatively common and easy to exploit.
    • How it works:
      • The attacker crafts a malicious URL containing the XSS payload in a query parameter.
      • The attacker tricks the victim into clicking the malicious URL (e.g., through a phishing email or social media post).
      • When the victim clicks the link, the browser sends the request to the vulnerable server, including the malicious payload.
      • The server processes the request and reflects the payload back to the victim's browser in the response (e.g., in an error message or search results page).
      • The victim's browser executes the injected CSS, applying the attacker's malicious animations.
    • Mitigations: (Same as for general XSS prevention above).

Attack Tree Path: [!!!2.2 Hijack Animation End Events!!!] (High-Risk Path)

  • Description: The attacker exploits the animationend event in JavaScript, which is triggered when a CSS animation completes. This is a high-risk path because it allows the attacker to execute arbitrary JavaScript code after an animation finishes, potentially leading to significant security compromises.
    • How it works:
      • The attacker first injects malicious CSS (likely through XSS) that defines an animation.
      • The attacker also injects JavaScript code (again, likely through XSS) that adds an event listener for the animationend event to an element that will have the malicious animation applied.
      • The injected JavaScript code within the event listener performs a malicious action, such as redirecting the user to a different website, modifying the page content, or stealing cookies.
      • When the animation completes, the animationend event is triggered, and the attacker's malicious JavaScript code is executed.
    • Mitigations:
      • XSS Prevention: As with other attacks, preventing XSS is crucial.
      • Careful Event Listener Management: Be extremely cautious when using animationend (and animationstart) event listeners.
        • Validate the Event Target: Ensure that the event listener is attached to the intended element and not to an element that the attacker could control.
        • Sanitize Event Data: If the event handler uses any data from the event object, sanitize that data before using it.
        • Avoid Sensitive Actions: Do not perform sensitive actions (e.g., redirects, authentication, data submission) directly within an animation event handler without additional security checks.
        • Consider Alternatives: If possible, avoid using animation events for critical functionality. Explore alternative ways to achieve the desired behavior that do not rely on potentially vulnerable event handlers.

Attack Tree Path: [!!!2.2.1 Redirect to Malicious URL!!!] (High-Risk Path)

  • Description: A specific and highly impactful instance of hijacking the animationend event. The attacker uses the event to redirect the user to a malicious website (e.g., a phishing site or a site hosting malware). This is a high-risk path because it directly compromises the user's security.
    • How it works:
      • Follows the same steps as [!!!2.2 Hijack Animation End Events!!!], but the JavaScript code within the animationend event listener uses window.location.href = "malicious_url"; (or a similar method) to redirect the user.
    • Mitigations: (Same as for [!!!2.2 Hijack Animation End Events!!!]). Extra emphasis should be placed on never performing redirects based solely on animation events.