Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
179 lines (147 loc) · 16.3 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

179 lines (147 loc) · 16.3 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for element-hq/element-web

Objective: Compromise Application Using Element-Web

Attack Tree Visualization

Root Goal: Compromise Application Using Element-Web [CRITICAL NODE]
├───[OR]─ 1. Exploit Element-Web Vulnerabilities Directly [CRITICAL NODE]
│   ├───[OR]─ 1.1. Exploit Client-Side Vulnerabilities in Element-Web Code [CRITICAL NODE]
│   │   ├───[OR]─ 1.1.1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) Attacks [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   ├───[OR]─ 1.1.1.1. Stored XSS in Messages/Room Data [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   │   └───[AND]─ 1.1.1.1.2. Script execution on other users' clients viewing the data [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   ├───[OR]─ 1.1.2.2. Insecure Client-Side Data Handling (Local Storage, Session Storage) [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   └───[AND]─ 1.1.2.2.2. Exploit vulnerabilities to access or manipulate stored data [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   ├───[OR]─ 1.1.3. Vulnerabilities in Third-Party Client-Side Libraries [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   └───[AND]─ 1.1.3.1. Identify vulnerable client-side libraries used by Element-Web [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   └───[AND]─ 1.1.3.2. Exploit known vulnerabilities in identified libraries [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   ├───[OR]─ 1.2. Exploit Server-Side Interaction Vulnerabilities via Element-Web [CRITICAL NODE]
│   │   ├───[OR]─ 1.2.1.1. Matrix Server-Side Injection (if Element-Web constructs server-side queries) [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   └───[AND]─ 1.2.1.1.2. Inject malicious payloads to manipulate server-side queries [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   ├───[OR]─ 1.2.1.2. Application Backend Injection via Element-Web (if Element-Web interacts with application backend) [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   ├───[OR]─ 2.2. Misconfiguration of Element-Web within Application [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   ├───[OR]─ 2.2.1. Insecure Deployment Configuration [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   └───[AND]─ 2.2.1.1. Identify insecure configurations in Element-Web deployment (e.g., exposed debug endpoints) [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   └───[AND]─ 2.2.1.2. Exploit insecure configurations to gain access or information [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   ├───[OR]─ 2.2.2. Weak Integration Security Measures [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   └───[AND]─ 2.2.2.1. Identify weak or missing security measures in application's integration with Element-Web [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   │   └───[AND]─ 2.2.2.2. Exploit weak measures to bypass security controls [HIGH-RISK PATH]
├───[OR]─ 3. Social Engineering Targeting Element-Web Users [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   ├───[OR]─ 3.1. Phishing Attacks Targeting Element-Web Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   └───[AND]─ 3.1.1. Create phishing page mimicking Element-Web login [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   └───[AND]─ 3.1.2. Trick users into entering credentials on phishing page [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   ├───[OR]─ 3.2. Malicious Links/Content via Matrix Messages [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   └───[AND]─ 3.2.1. Send malicious links or content through Matrix messages via Element-Web [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │   └───[AND]─ 3.2.2. User clicks link or interacts with content, leading to compromise (e.g., drive-by download, XSS) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

Attack Tree Path: 1. Exploit Element-Web Vulnerabilities Directly [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • This is a broad category encompassing direct attacks targeting weaknesses within Element-Web's code, dependencies, or server-side interactions. Success here directly compromises the application through Element-Web.

Attack Tree Path: 1.1. Exploit Client-Side Vulnerabilities in Element-Web Code [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Focuses on vulnerabilities residing in the client-side JavaScript code of Element-Web. Exploiting these can lead to direct user compromise within the application.

Attack Tree Path: 1.1.1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) Attacks [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Injecting malicious JavaScript code into Element-Web that executes in users' browsers.
  • Types:
    • Stored XSS in Messages/Room Data [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
      • Attack Vector: Injecting malicious scripts into messages or room data (names, topics) that are stored on the server and displayed to other users.
      • Impact: When other users view the compromised message or room data, the malicious script executes in their browsers, potentially stealing session cookies, credentials, performing actions on behalf of the user, or redirecting to malicious sites.
      • Example: An attacker sends a message containing <img src=x onerror=alert('XSS')> in a chat room. When other users open the chat room, the script executes.
    • Script execution on other users' clients viewing the data [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:
      • Attack Vector: Consequence of successful Stored XSS. The malicious script injected in 1.1.1.1.1 now executes on every user's client who views the affected data.
      • Impact: Widespread compromise of users interacting with the affected data.

Attack Tree Path: 1.1.2.2. Insecure Client-Side Data Handling (Local Storage, Session Storage) [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting vulnerabilities to access or manipulate sensitive data stored client-side by Element-Web, such as encryption keys or session tokens.
  • Impact: If sensitive data is stored insecurely (e.g., unencrypted or with weak encryption), attackers can potentially:
    • Steal session tokens to impersonate users.
    • Obtain encryption keys to decrypt private messages.
    • Modify application state or settings.
  • Example: An attacker uses browser developer tools or a malicious browser extension to access local storage and retrieve an unencrypted access token.
  • Exploit vulnerabilities to access or manipulate stored data [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Consequence of insecure client-side data handling. Attackers successfully access or manipulate the sensitive data.
    • Impact: Direct compromise of user accounts or data depending on the sensitivity of the accessed data.

Attack Tree Path: 1.1.3. Vulnerabilities in Third-Party Client-Side Libraries [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting known vulnerabilities in JavaScript libraries used by Element-Web.
  • Impact: Depending on the vulnerability and the affected library, attackers can achieve various levels of compromise, including:
    • XSS (if the library has an XSS vulnerability).
    • Remote Code Execution (in rare cases, if the library has a severe vulnerability).
    • Denial of Service.
    • Data theft.
  • Identify vulnerable client-side libraries used by Element-Web [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Using automated tools or manual analysis to identify outdated or vulnerable libraries in Element-Web's dependencies.
    • Impact: Gaining knowledge of potential entry points for exploitation.
  • Exploit known vulnerabilities in identified libraries [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Using publicly available exploits or developing custom exploits to leverage known vulnerabilities in identified libraries.
    • Impact: Successful exploitation leads to the impacts described above for "Vulnerabilities in Third-Party Client-Side Libraries".

Attack Tree Path: 1.2. Exploit Server-Side Interaction Vulnerabilities via Element-Web [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Focuses on vulnerabilities arising from how Element-Web interacts with server-side components, including the Matrix server and potentially application backends.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1.1. Matrix Server-Side Injection (if Element-Web constructs server-side queries) [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Injecting malicious code or commands into server-side queries constructed by Element-Web when interacting with the Matrix server. This is possible if Element-Web improperly handles user input when building these queries.
  • Impact: If successful, attackers could:
    • Gain unauthorized access to Matrix server data.
    • Modify Matrix server data.
    • Potentially execute commands on the Matrix server itself (depending on the type of injection vulnerability).
    • Disrupt Matrix server operations.
  • Inject malicious payloads to manipulate server-side queries [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Consequence of successful identification of injection points. Attackers craft and send malicious payloads through Element-Web to the Matrix server.
    • Impact: Matrix server compromise as described above.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1.2. Application Backend Injection via Element-Web (if Element-Web interacts with application backend) [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Injecting malicious code or commands into requests sent from Element-Web to the application backend. This is possible if Element-Web passes user-controlled data to the backend without proper sanitization and the backend is vulnerable to injection.
  • Impact: If successful, attackers could:
    • Gain unauthorized access to application backend data.
    • Modify application backend data.
    • Execute commands on the application backend.
    • Compromise the application backend infrastructure.
  • Example: If Element-Web uses user-provided room names to query a backend database, SQL injection might be possible if the backend doesn't properly sanitize the input.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2. Misconfiguration of Element-Web within Application [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Exploiting insecure configurations of Element-Web when deployed within the application environment.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.1. Insecure Deployment Configuration [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting common deployment misconfigurations that expose vulnerabilities.
  • Types:
    • Exposed debug endpoints [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
      • Attack Vector: Debug endpoints left enabled in production deployments can expose sensitive information, provide administrative access, or allow code execution.
      • Impact: Information disclosure, unauthorized access, potential system compromise.
    • Default credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
      • Attack Vector: Using default usernames and passwords for administrative interfaces or services associated with Element-Web.
      • Impact: Unauthorized administrative access, full system compromise.
  • Identify insecure configurations in Element-Web deployment (e.g., exposed debug endpoints) [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Using automated scanners or manual reconnaissance to identify misconfigurations in the deployed Element-Web instance.
    • Impact: Gaining knowledge of exploitable weaknesses.
  • Exploit insecure configurations to gain access or information [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Leveraging identified misconfigurations to gain unauthorized access or extract sensitive information.
    • Impact: System compromise, data breach, depending on the nature of the misconfiguration.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.2. Weak Integration Security Measures [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting insufficient or missing security measures in the application's integration with Element-Web.
  • Types:
    • Missing authentication/authorization between Element-Web and application:
      • Attack Vector: Bypassing weak or non-existent authentication or authorization mechanisms between Element-Web and the application backend or other integrated components.
      • Impact: Unauthorized access to application features and data.
    • Insecure communication channels:
      • Attack Vector: Intercepting or manipulating communication between Element-Web and other application components if communication channels are not properly secured (e.g., using unencrypted HTTP).
      • Impact: Data interception, man-in-the-middle attacks, potential compromise of communication endpoints.
  • Identify weak or missing security measures in application's integration with Element-Web [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Security audits, penetration testing, or code review to identify weaknesses in the integration security.
    • Impact: Gaining knowledge of exploitable weaknesses.
  • Exploit weak measures to bypass security controls [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Leveraging identified weak integration security measures to bypass intended security controls and gain unauthorized access or actions.
    • Impact: Bypassing security controls, gaining unauthorized access, potential system compromise.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Social Engineering Targeting Element-Web Users [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Exploiting human behavior to compromise user accounts or systems through Element-Web.

Attack Tree Path: 3.1. Phishing Attacks Targeting Element-Web Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Creating fake login pages that mimic Element-Web's login interface to trick users into entering their credentials.
  • Impact: Account compromise, unauthorized access to user accounts and data.
  • Create phishing page mimicking Element-Web login [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Developing a fake website that visually resembles the legitimate Element-Web login page.
    • Impact: Preparation for phishing attack.
  • Trick users into entering credentials on phishing page [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Distributing the phishing link via email, messages, or other channels and using social engineering tactics to convince users to enter their credentials on the fake page.
    • Impact: Credential theft, account compromise.

Attack Tree Path: 3.2. Malicious Links/Content via Matrix Messages [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Sending malicious links or content through Matrix messages via Element-Web to trick users into clicking or interacting with them, leading to compromise.
  • Impact: Depending on the malicious content, impacts can include:
    • Drive-by downloads of malware.
    • XSS attacks (if the link points to a vulnerable page).
    • Credential theft (if the link leads to a phishing page).
    • Exploitation of browser vulnerabilities.
  • Send malicious links or content through Matrix messages via Element-Web [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Crafting and sending messages containing malicious URLs or embedded content through Element-Web's messaging functionality.
    • Impact: Distribution of malicious content to users.
  • User clicks link or interacts with content, leading to compromise (e.g., drive-by download, XSS) [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
    • Attack Vector: Users are tricked into clicking on malicious links or interacting with malicious content within Matrix messages.
    • Impact: User system compromise, malware infection, XSS exploitation, credential theft.