Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
185 lines (166 loc) · 26.9 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

185 lines (166 loc) · 26.9 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for element-hq/element-web

Mitigation Strategy: Implement a Strong Content Security Policy (CSP)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Implement a Strong Content Security Policy (CSP)
  • Description:
    1. Define Policy in Element Web Configuration: Within Element Web's configuration files or build process, define a CSP header. This might involve modifying server-side headers if Element Web is served directly, or configuring meta tags if CSP is set client-side.
    2. Restrict script-src in Element Web: Set script-src directive to 'self' to primarily allow scripts from Element Web's origin. If external scripts are absolutely necessary for Element Web's functionality (e.g., from trusted CDNs for specific libraries used by Element Web), explicitly list those trusted origins. Strictly avoid 'unsafe-inline' and 'unsafe-eval' within Element Web's CSP.
    3. Restrict other directives relevant to Element Web: Configure style-src, img-src, object-src, media-src, frame-ancestors, base-uri, form-action, connect-src, font-src, and manifest-src directives to restrict resource loading to trusted origins and sources specifically needed by Element Web.
    4. Report-URI/report-to for Element Web: Configure report-uri or report-to directives to receive reports of CSP violations specifically occurring within the Element Web application, allowing for monitoring and policy refinement tailored to Element Web's behavior.
    5. Testing and Refinement within Element Web's context: Deploy the CSP in report-only mode initially to monitor for violations without breaking Element Web's functionality. Gradually enforce the policy and refine it based on reported violations and Element Web's specific needs.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (High Severity): Prevents injection of malicious scripts into Element Web by limiting script sources.
    • Data Injection (Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of injecting malicious content through various resource types loaded by Element Web.
    • Clickjacking (Medium Severity): frame-ancestors directive can prevent embedding Element Web in malicious iframes.
  • Impact:
    • XSS: High reduction specifically within Element Web. CSP is a very effective control against many types of XSS attacks targeting Element Web.
    • Data Injection: Medium reduction in the context of resources loaded and used by Element Web.
    • Clickjacking: Medium reduction for attacks targeting embedding of Element Web.
  • Currently Implemented: Likely Implemented in Element Web itself. Modern web applications and frameworks often encourage or default to CSP implementation. Element Web, being security-focused, likely has a CSP in place. Check the HTTP headers served by Element Web or its configuration.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Policy Refinement for Element Web: The existing CSP in Element Web might need to be reviewed and strengthened to be as restrictive as possible specifically for Element Web's functionality without breaking its features.
    • Report Monitoring for Element Web: Ensure CSP violation reports are actively monitored and used to improve the policy specifically for Element Web.

Mitigation Strategy: Utilize Subresource Integrity (SRI)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Utilize Subresource Integrity (SRI)
  • Description:
    1. Generate SRI Hashes for Element Web's External Resources: For each external JavaScript and CSS file loaded by Element Web via <script> or <link> tags (e.g., from CDNs used by Element Web), generate an SRI hash.
    2. Add integrity Attribute in Element Web's HTML: Add the integrity attribute to the <script> and <link> tags within Element Web's HTML structure, setting its value to the generated SRI hash and specifying the algorithm.
    3. Ensure crossorigin="anonymous" for Element Web's CDN Resources: For resources loaded from different origins (like CDNs used by Element Web), include the crossorigin="anonymous" attribute in Element Web's <script> and <link> tags to enable CORS and allow SRI checks.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Compromised CDN/Third-Party Dependency used by Element Web (High Severity): Prevents execution of malicious code if a CDN or third-party resource used by Element Web is compromised and its content is altered.
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) Attacks targeting Element Web's resources (Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of MITM attacks injecting malicious code by tampering with external resources loaded by Element Web during transit.
  • Impact:
    • Compromised CDN/Third-Party Dependency: High reduction specifically for Element Web's dependencies. SRI effectively prevents execution of altered code from external sources used by Element Web.
    • MITM Attacks: Medium reduction for attacks targeting resources loaded by Element Web. SRI provides a strong integrity check for these resources.
  • Currently Implemented: Likely Implemented in Element Web itself. SRI is a standard security best practice for modern web applications, especially those relying on CDNs. Element Web development likely uses SRI for its external resources. Check the HTML source of Element Web to see if integrity attributes are used on <script> and <link> tags for its external resources.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Coverage in Element Web: Ensure SRI is applied to all external JavaScript and CSS resources loaded by Element Web, including those loaded dynamically within Element Web's code.
    • Hash Updates in Element Web's Build Process: Implement a process within Element Web's build process to automatically regenerate and update SRI hashes whenever its external dependencies are updated.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Audit and Update Element Web Dependencies

  • Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Audit and Update Element Web Dependencies
  • Description:
    1. Dependency Scanning for Element Web: Integrate dependency scanning tools (e.g., npm audit, yarn audit, Snyk, OWASP Dependency-Check) into Element Web's development and CI/CD pipeline.
    2. Automated Checks for Element Web: Configure these tools to automatically scan Element Web's project dependencies for known vulnerabilities on a regular schedule (e.g., daily or with each build of Element Web).
    3. Vulnerability Monitoring for Element Web's Ecosystem: Subscribe to security advisories and vulnerability databases specifically related to Element Web's dependencies and the Matrix ecosystem it relies on.
    4. Prioritize Updates for Element Web: When vulnerabilities are identified in Element Web's dependencies, prioritize updating affected dependencies to patched versions within the Element Web project.
    5. Patch Management Process for Element Web: Establish a clear process within the Element Web development team for evaluating, testing, and deploying dependency updates, especially security-related updates, for Element Web.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Vulnerabilities in Element Web's Dependencies (High Severity): Addresses known vulnerabilities in third-party libraries and components used by Element Web, which could be exploited for various attacks (XSS, Remote Code Execution, etc.) targeting Element Web users.
  • Impact:
    • Vulnerabilities in Element Web's Dependencies: High reduction. Regularly updating Element Web's dependencies is crucial for mitigating known vulnerabilities within the application.
  • Currently Implemented: Likely Implemented within the Element Web project itself. Dependency management and security scanning are standard practices in modern software development, and crucial for a project like Element Web. Check Element Web's project's CI/CD pipeline and dependency management practices.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Automation Level in Element Web's Pipeline: Ensure dependency scanning is fully automated and integrated into Element Web's CI/CD pipeline.
    • Update Cadence for Element Web: Establish a clear and frequent cadence for dependency updates within the Element Web project, especially for security patches.
    • Monitoring and Alerting for Element Web's Dependencies: Set up robust monitoring and alerting for new vulnerability disclosures specifically affecting Element Web's dependencies.

Mitigation Strategy: Minimize and Sanitize User-Generated Content in Element Web

  • Mitigation Strategy: Minimize and Sanitize User-Generated Content in Element Web
  • Description:
    1. HTML Sanitization Library in Element Web: Integrate a robust and actively maintained HTML sanitization library (e.g., DOMPurify, Bleach) into Element Web's codebase.
    2. Sanitize on Server-Side (Homeserver) and Client-Side (Element Web): Ideally, sanitize user-generated HTML content on the Matrix homeserver and perform a second layer of sanitization on the client-side within Element Web before rendering it in messages. This defense-in-depth approach is best. If only client-side is feasible, ensure robust client-side sanitization in Element Web.
    3. Context-Aware Encoding in Element Web: Properly encode all user inputs (text, URLs, etc.) within Element Web based on the context where they are displayed (HTML, JavaScript, URL parameters). Use appropriate encoding functions within Element Web's rendering logic for each context to prevent injection attacks.
    4. Content Security Policy (Reinforcement for Element Web): CSP (as described in point 1) further reinforces sanitization within Element Web by limiting the execution of inline scripts and styles, even if sanitization in Element Web fails in some cases.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) through User Content in Element Web (High Severity): Prevents malicious users from injecting scripts into messages or other user-generated content that could be executed by other users within the Element Web application.
    • HTML Injection in Element Web (Medium Severity): Prevents users from injecting arbitrary HTML that could alter the page layout or display misleading content within the Element Web interface.
  • Impact:
    • XSS through User Content in Element Web: High reduction. Effective sanitization and encoding within Element Web are critical for preventing content-based XSS vulnerabilities in the client application.
    • HTML Injection in Element Web: Medium reduction. Sanitization within Element Web limits the impact of HTML injection within the client interface.
  • Currently Implemented: Likely Implemented in Element Web. Sanitization of user-generated content is a fundamental security requirement for chat applications, and especially for Element Web as a Matrix client. Element Web likely uses an HTML sanitization library. Check Element Web's codebase for usage of sanitization libraries and encoding functions.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Server-Side Sanitization (Homeserver Integration): If not already present, investigate and advocate for implementing server-side sanitization on the Matrix homeserver to complement client-side sanitization in Element Web.
    • Sanitization Library Updates in Element Web: Ensure the chosen sanitization library in Element Web is regularly updated to address new bypass techniques and vulnerabilities.
    • Contextual Encoding Review in Element Web: Review all instances of user input rendering within Element Web's codebase to ensure proper contextual encoding is applied in every case.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Client-Side Storage in Element Web

  • Mitigation Strategy: Secure Client-Side Storage in Element Web
  • Description:
    1. Minimize Client-Side Storage in Element Web: Reduce the amount of sensitive data stored in browser storage (localStorage, sessionStorage, IndexedDB) by Element Web as much as possible. Store only essential data client-side for Element Web's functionality.
    2. Encryption at Rest in Element Web: If sensitive data must be stored client-side by Element Web, encrypt it using browser-native APIs like SubtleCrypto or a robust JavaScript encryption library (if browser-native is insufficient). Implement encryption within Element Web's code.
    3. Key Management in Element Web: Securely manage encryption keys within Element Web. Avoid hardcoding keys in Element Web's JavaScript code. Consider deriving keys from user credentials or using browser-provided key storage mechanisms (if available and suitable for Element Web).
    4. Access Control in Element Web's Storage Logic: Implement access controls within Element Web's code to limit access to stored data.
    5. Regular Audits of Element Web's Storage Usage: Regularly audit Element Web's usage of client-side storage to ensure best practices are followed and minimize the storage of sensitive information.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Data Theft via XSS targeting Element Web (High Severity): Prevents attackers from stealing sensitive data stored in browser storage by Element Web if they can successfully execute XSS attacks against Element Web.
    • Local Data Exposure from Element Web's Storage (Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of sensitive data stored by Element Web being exposed if a user's device is compromised or accessed by unauthorized individuals.
  • Impact:
    • Data Theft via XSS: Medium to High reduction (depending on encryption strength and key management implemented in Element Web). Encryption significantly increases the difficulty of data theft even with XSS targeting Element Web.
    • Local Data Exposure: Medium reduction. Encryption protects data at rest, but physical device security is still important for users of Element Web.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented in Element Web. Element Web likely stores some data client-side for functionality (e.g., user settings, session data). The extent of encryption and secure storage practices within Element Web needs verification. Check Element Web's codebase for usage of browser storage APIs and encryption mechanisms.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Encryption Implementation in Element Web: Verify if sensitive data in client-side storage used by Element Web is currently encrypted. Implement encryption within Element Web if missing.
    • Key Management Review in Element Web: Review the key management strategy for client-side encryption within Element Web to ensure it is secure and robust.
    • Storage Minimization in Element Web: Re-evaluate the necessity of storing sensitive data client-side by Element Web and explore alternatives to minimize storage within the client application.

Mitigation Strategy: Maintain Up-to-Date Element Web Version

  • Mitigation Strategy: Maintain Up-to-Date Element Web Version
  • Description:
    1. Regular Updates of Element Web: Establish a process for regularly updating deployed instances of Element Web to the latest stable version released by the Element Web project.
    2. Release Monitoring for Element Web: Monitor Element Web release notes, security advisories, and community channels for new releases and security updates specifically for Element Web.
    3. Testing and Deployment of Element Web Updates: Implement a testing process to validate new Element Web versions before deploying them to production environments.
    4. Automated Updates (If feasible) for Element Web: Explore options for automating the update process for Element Web where possible, while still maintaining testing and validation steps.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Known Vulnerabilities in Element Web (High Severity): Addresses known security vulnerabilities within Element Web itself and its underlying Matrix SDK that are fixed in newer versions.
    • Outdated Security Features in Element Web (Medium Severity): Ensures deployed instances of Element Web benefit from the latest security features and improvements incorporated into newer Element Web versions.
  • Impact:
    • Known Vulnerabilities in Element Web: High reduction. Updating Element Web is the primary way to patch known vulnerabilities in the client application.
    • Outdated Security Features in Element Web: Medium reduction. Staying updated ensures access to improved security mechanisms within Element Web.
  • Currently Implemented: Likely Implemented for Element Web development itself. For applications using Element Web, the implementation depends on the application's update process for its components, including Element Web.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Application Update Process for Element Web Component: For applications embedding or deploying Element Web, establish a clear and reliable process for regularly updating the Element Web component.
    • Version Monitoring for Deployed Element Web: Implement monitoring to track the currently deployed Element Web version and alert when updates are available for the client application.

Mitigation Strategy: Educate Users on Key Verification and Cross-Signing within Element Web

  • Mitigation Strategy: Educate Users on Key Verification and Cross-Signing within Element Web
  • Description:
    1. In-App Guidance in Element Web: Provide clear in-app guidance and tutorials within Element Web on how to perform key verification and understand cross-signing. Make these resources easily accessible within the Element Web user interface.
    2. Educational Resources for Element Web Users: Create accessible documentation, FAQs, and help articles specifically explaining the importance of key verification and cross-signing for E2EE security within the context of using Element Web.
    3. Promote Best Practices within Element Web's User Communication: Actively promote best practices for secure key management, device verification, and understanding trust relationships in Matrix through Element Web's user communication channels (e.g., blog posts, in-app announcements).
    4. User Awareness Campaigns for Element Web Users: Conduct user awareness campaigns to highlight the importance of E2EE and the role of key verification in maintaining secure communication specifically for Element Web users.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • E2EE Impersonation/MITM when using Element Web (High Severity): Reduces the risk of attackers impersonating users or performing MITM attacks on E2EE conversations within Element Web by encouraging users to verify keys and devices using Element Web's features.
    • Compromised Account Access via Element Web (Medium Severity): Helps users detect and mitigate unauthorized access to their accounts when using Element Web by understanding device verification and cross-signing features available in Element Web.
  • Impact:
    • E2EE Impersonation/MITM: Medium reduction. User education is crucial for effective E2EE in Element Web, but relies on user participation.
    • Compromised Account Access: Low to Medium reduction. User awareness within Element Web can help detect unauthorized access, but technical controls are also needed.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented in Element Web. Element Web provides features for key verification and cross-signing. However, user education and promotion of these features within Element Web and its user community can be improved.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Enhanced In-App Guidance in Element Web: Improve the clarity, user-friendliness, and accessibility of in-app guidance for key verification and cross-signing within Element Web.
    • Proactive User Education within Element Web: Implement more proactive user education initiatives within Element Web, such as onboarding tutorials and regular security tips displayed within the application.
    • Usability Improvements in Element Web's Verification Features: Continuously improve the usability of key verification and cross-signing features within Element Web to encourage wider adoption by users.

Mitigation Strategy: Advise Users on Browser Security Best Practices for Element Web

  • Mitigation Strategy: Advise Users on Browser Security Best Practices for Element Web
  • Description:
    1. Browser Update Reminders within Element Web Context: Provide in-app reminders or notifications within Element Web to users to keep their web browsers updated to the latest versions, emphasizing the importance for secure use of Element Web.
    2. Extension Security Warnings for Element Web Users: Warn users of Element Web about the risks of installing untrusted browser extensions and recommend reviewing extension permissions, especially in the context of using Element Web.
    3. Security Awareness Content for Element Web Users: Create and distribute educational content (blog posts, help articles, FAQs) on general browser security best practices specifically relevant to using Element Web securely in a browser.
    4. Permission Review Guidance for Element Web: Guide users of Element Web on how to review and manage browser permissions granted to websites, including Element Web itself.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Browser Vulnerabilities impacting Element Web (High Severity): Encourages users to patch browser vulnerabilities that could be exploited when using Element Web by staying updated.
    • Malicious Browser Extensions impacting Element Web (High Severity): Reduces the risk of users being compromised by malicious browser extensions that could interact with or compromise Element Web.
    • Phishing and Social Engineering targeting Element Web Users (Medium Severity): Improves user awareness of general web security threats that could target users of Element Web.
  • Impact:
    • Browser Vulnerabilities: Medium reduction. Relies on user action to update browsers, but proactive reminders within Element Web can increase user compliance.
    • Malicious Browser Extensions: Medium reduction. User awareness promoted by Element Web can help prevent installation of malicious extensions that could affect Element Web.
    • Phishing and Social Engineering: Low reduction. General security awareness is helpful but not a direct technical mitigation for specific Element Web threats.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Element Web may have some basic guidance or links to external resources. More proactive in-app advice and education within Element Web could be beneficial.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • In-App Browser Update Reminders in Element Web: Implement in-app notifications within Element Web to remind users to update their browsers.
    • Extension Security Prompts in Element Web: Consider adding prompts or warnings related to browser extension security within Element Web, perhaps during initial setup or in settings.
    • Centralized Security Education Hub within Element Web: Create a dedicated section within Element Web's help or settings within the application itself for security education and best practices relevant to using Element Web securely.

Mitigation Strategy: Monitor for Client-Side Errors and Anomalies in Element Web

  • Mitigation Strategy: Monitor for Client-Side Errors and Anomalies in Element Web
  • Description:
    1. Error Logging in Element Web: Implement client-side error logging within Element Web using browser APIs (e.g., window.onerror, addEventListener('error', ...)) or error tracking services (e.g., Sentry, Rollbar) integrated into Element Web.
    2. Anomaly Detection in Element Web's Client Logs: Monitor client-side logs generated by Element Web for unusual patterns, frequent errors, or unexpected behavior that might indicate security issues or vulnerabilities within Element Web.
    3. Alerting and Response for Element Web Errors: Set up alerts to notify security teams or Element Web developers when critical errors or anomalies are detected in Element Web's client-side logs.
    4. Log Analysis for Element Web Client Logs: Regularly analyze client-side logs from Element Web to identify potential security vulnerabilities, misconfigurations, or malicious activity targeting Element Web users.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unreported Vulnerabilities in Element Web (Medium Severity): Helps detect potential vulnerabilities within Element Web that might not be immediately obvious through code reviews or testing.
    • Runtime Errors Indicating Attacks against Element Web (Medium Severity): Can identify runtime errors in Element Web that might be triggered by exploitation attempts or malicious input targeting the client application.
    • Configuration Issues in Element Web (Low to Medium Severity): Helps detect client-side configuration problems within Element Web that could have security implications.
  • Impact:
    • Unreported Vulnerabilities in Element Web: Medium reduction. Monitoring can provide early warnings of potential issues within Element Web.
    • Runtime Errors Indicating Attacks against Element Web: Medium reduction. Can help detect some attack attempts targeting Element Web in real-time.
    • Configuration Issues in Element Web: Low to Medium reduction. Monitoring can identify configuration problems within Element Web.
  • Currently Implemented: Likely Partially Implemented in Element Web. Basic error logging is common in web applications, and likely present in Element Web. More advanced anomaly detection and alerting specifically for Element Web's client-side behavior might be missing.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Anomaly Detection System for Element Web Client Logs: Implement a more sophisticated anomaly detection system to automatically identify unusual patterns in client-side logs generated by Element Web.
    • Automated Alerting for Element Web Client Errors: Set up automated alerting for critical client-side errors and anomalies detected in Element Web's logs to enable faster incident response for client-side issues.
    • Log Analysis Tools for Element Web Client Logs: Provide tools and processes for security teams to effectively analyze client-side logs from Element Web for security-related events and trends.