Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
205 lines (184 loc) · 28.3 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

205 lines (184 loc) · 28.3 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for expressjs/express

Mitigation Strategy: Careful Middleware Selection and Review (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Research Express Middleware Before Use: Before integrating any new middleware package into your Express application, thoroughly research its purpose, functionality, and security reputation specifically in the context of Express.js. Check npm for download statistics, maintenance status, and reported issues related to Express integration. 2. Review Express Middleware Code (If Necessary): For critical or less well-known middleware intended for Express, consider reviewing its source code on GitHub or npm to understand its implementation and identify potential security concerns within the Express request/response cycle. 3. Prioritize Reputable and Well-Maintained Express Middleware: Favor middleware packages that are actively maintained, have a large community within the Express ecosystem, and are known for good security practices in Express applications. 4. Minimize Express Middleware Usage: Only use middleware that is strictly necessary for your Express application's functionality. Avoid adding middleware "just in case" as it increases the attack surface within your Express application. 5. Regularly Review Used Express Middleware: Periodically review the middleware used in your Express application. Check for updates, security advisories, and consider if any middleware is no longer needed or can be replaced with a more secure alternative within your Express setup.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Vulnerable Middleware (High Severity): Exploiting vulnerabilities in Express middleware can lead to full application compromise within the Express application context.
      • Malicious Middleware (High Severity): Using intentionally malicious middleware in Express can grant attackers direct access to your application and data via the Express request flow.
      • Misconfigured Middleware (Medium Severity): Improperly configured Express middleware can introduce vulnerabilities like CORS bypass, session hijacking, or information leakage within the Express application's behavior.
    • Impact:
      • Vulnerable Middleware: High Risk Reduction - Reduces the likelihood of using vulnerable middleware in Express by promoting careful selection and review.
      • Malicious Middleware: High Risk Reduction - Makes it less likely to introduce malicious code through Express middleware.
      • Misconfigured Middleware: Medium Risk Reduction - Encourages developers to understand Express middleware configuration and reduce misconfigurations.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • Developers are generally encouraged to research Express middleware before use.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • No formal process for Express middleware review or approval. No regular audits of used Express middleware are performed. No guidelines on prioritizing reputable Express middleware are documented.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure CORS Middleware Configuration (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Understand CORS Requirements in Express: Determine if your Express application needs to handle cross-origin requests. If not, CORS middleware might not be necessary in your Express setup. 2. Configure cors Middleware Precisely in Express: When using cors middleware in Express: * Restrict origin: Instead of origin: '*', explicitly list allowed origins as an array of strings or use a function to dynamically validate origins based on request headers within your Express application. * Control methods: Specify only the necessary HTTP methods (e.g., ['GET', 'POST', 'PUT', 'DELETE']) that your Express application needs to handle for cross-origin requests. * Control allowedHeaders: List only the required headers that your Express application expects in cross-origin requests. * Understand credentials: true: Only set credentials: true if you need to send cookies or authorization headers in cross-origin requests to your Express application. Be aware of the security implications and potential for CSRF if not handled carefully within your Express application's CORS configuration. 3. Test CORS Configuration in Express: Thoroughly test your CORS configuration in your Express application to ensure it allows legitimate cross-origin requests while blocking unauthorized ones. Use browser developer tools or tools like curl to test different origin scenarios against your Express endpoints.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • CORS Bypass (High Severity): Misconfigured CORS in Express can allow unauthorized cross-origin requests, potentially leading to data breaches, CSRF attacks, and other vulnerabilities within your Express application.
    • Impact:
      • CORS Bypass: High Risk Reduction - Properly configured CORS in Express effectively prevents unauthorized cross-origin access to your application.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • cors middleware is used in Express, but configured with origin: '*' for development and staging environments.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • origin is not restricted to specific domains in production for the Express application. methods and allowedHeaders are not explicitly controlled and use defaults in the Express CORS setup. credentials: true is enabled without full understanding of implications in the Express CORS configuration.

Mitigation Strategy: Input Validation and Sanitization Middleware (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Choose Input Validation Middleware for Express: Select middleware like express-validator or create custom middleware specifically designed for input validation within your Express application. 2. Define Validation Rules for Express Routes: Define validation rules for each expected input parameter (e.g., request body, query parameters, headers) for your Express routes. Specify data types, formats, allowed values, and required fields relevant to your Express application's data handling. 3. Implement Validation Logic in Express Middleware: Use the chosen middleware to apply these validation rules to incoming requests within your Express middleware pipeline. 4. Handle Validation Errors in Express: Implement error handling within your Express application to gracefully reject invalid requests. Return informative error messages to the client (without revealing sensitive server-side details) and log validation failures for monitoring within your Express error handling flow. 5. Sanitize Input (If Necessary) in Express Middleware: In some cases, sanitization might be needed to remove potentially harmful characters or format input before processing in your Express application. Use sanitization functions provided by validation libraries or custom sanitization logic within your Express middleware.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Injection Attacks (SQL Injection, NoSQL Injection, Command Injection, XSS) (High Severity): Insufficient input validation in Express is a primary cause of injection attacks targeting your Express application.
      • Data Integrity Issues (Medium Severity): Invalid input in Express can lead to data corruption or application errors within your Express application's data layer.
      • Application Logic Errors (Medium Severity): Unexpected input in Express can cause application logic to behave incorrectly within your Express route handlers.
    • Impact:
      • Injection Attacks: High Risk Reduction - Significantly reduces the risk of injection attacks in Express by preventing malicious input from reaching vulnerable parts of the application.
      • Data Integrity Issues: Medium Risk Reduction - Improves data quality and reduces data corruption within your Express application.
      • Application Logic Errors: Medium Risk Reduction - Makes Express application behavior more predictable and robust against unexpected input.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • Basic input validation is performed within individual Express route handlers for critical endpoints.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • No centralized input validation middleware is implemented in the Express application. Validation logic is scattered and inconsistent across Express routes. No sanitization is consistently applied via Express middleware.

Mitigation Strategy: Rate Limiting Middleware (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Install Rate Limiting Middleware for Express: Install a rate limiting middleware package like express-rate-limit for your Express application. 2. Configure Rate Limiting Options for Express: Configure the middleware with appropriate options specifically for your Express application's needs: * windowMs: Set the time window for rate limiting (e.g., 15 minutes in milliseconds) relevant to your Express application's traffic patterns. * max: Define the maximum number of requests allowed within the windowMs from a single IP address that is appropriate for your Express application's expected usage. * message: Customize the error message returned when the rate limit is exceeded in your Express application's responses. * statusCode: Set the HTTP status code for rate limit exceeded responses (usually 429 Too Many Requests) within your Express application's response codes. * keyGenerator (Optional): Customize how to identify clients (e.g., based on IP address, user ID, etc.) based on your Express application's authentication and user identification mechanisms. * store (Optional): Use a persistent store (e.g., Redis, Memcached) for rate limiting in distributed Express environments. 3. Apply Rate Limiting Middleware in Express: Apply the rate limiting middleware globally to all routes or selectively to specific routes that are more vulnerable to abuse (e.g., login endpoints, API endpoints) within your Express application's routing structure. 4. Monitor Rate Limiting in Express: Monitor your Express application logs and metrics to ensure rate limiting is working as expected and adjust configurations if needed for your Express application's traffic.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Brute-Force Attacks (High Severity): Rate limiting in Express makes brute-force attacks (e.g., password guessing) significantly slower and less effective against your Express application's authentication endpoints.
      • Denial-of-Service (DoS) Attacks (Medium Severity): Rate limiting in Express can mitigate some forms of DoS attacks by limiting the impact of a large number of requests from a single source targeting your Express application.
      • Resource Exhaustion (Medium Severity): Prevents excessive requests from overwhelming server resources serving your Express application.
    • Impact:
      • Brute-Force Attacks: High Risk Reduction - Makes brute-force attacks much harder to succeed against your Express application.
      • Denial-of-Service (DoS) Attacks: Medium Risk Reduction - Reduces the impact of some DoS attacks on your Express application, but might not fully protect against distributed DoS (DDoS).
      • Resource Exhaustion: Medium Risk Reduction - Helps prevent resource exhaustion due to excessive requests to your Express application.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • Rate limiting is implemented on the login endpoint of the Express application using express-rate-limit.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • Rate limiting is not applied globally or to other API endpoints in the Express application. Configuration is basic and not tuned for optimal protection for the Express application. No persistent store is used for rate limiting in a multi-instance Express environment.

Mitigation Strategy: Helmet for Security Headers (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Install Helmet Middleware for Express: Install the helmet middleware package for your Express application. 2. Apply Helmet Middleware in Express: Apply helmet() middleware early in your Express.js application's middleware stack (ideally as the first middleware) to ensure headers are set for all Express responses. 3. Customize Helmet Configuration (Optional) for Express: By default, helmet() enables a set of recommended security headers. You can customize its behavior by disabling or configuring individual headers if needed (e.g., helmet.contentSecurityPolicy(), helmet.frameguard(), etc.) to fine-tune security headers for your specific Express application. However, for most Express applications, the default configuration is a good starting point. 4. Test Security Headers in Express: Use browser developer tools or online header checking tools to verify that the security headers are being set correctly in your Express application's responses after implementing Helmet middleware.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (Medium to High Severity): X-XSS-Protection, Content-Security-Policy headers help mitigate XSS attacks in user browsers interacting with your Express application.
      • Clickjacking (Medium Severity): X-Frame-Options header prevents clickjacking attacks against your Express application's UI.
      • MIME-Sniffing Attacks (Low Severity): X-Content-Type-Options header prevents MIME-sniffing vulnerabilities when browsers process responses from your Express application.
      • HTTP Strict Transport Security (HSTS) Bypass (Medium Severity): Strict-Transport-Security header enforces HTTPS and prevents downgrade attacks when users connect to your Express application.
      • Information Leakage via Referrer (Low Severity): Referrer-Policy header controls referrer information sent in requests originating from your Express application.
    • Impact:
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): Medium Risk Reduction - Provides a significant layer of defense against many common XSS attacks targeting your Express application.
      • Clickjacking: Medium Risk Reduction - Effectively prevents clickjacking attacks against your Express application.
      • MIME-Sniffing Attacks: Low Risk Reduction - Prevents MIME-sniffing vulnerabilities in browsers interacting with your Express application.
      • HTTP Strict Transport Security (HSTS) Bypass: Medium Risk Reduction - Enforces HTTPS and reduces the risk of downgrade attacks when accessing your Express application.
      • Information Leakage via Referrer: Low Risk Reduction - Controls referrer information from your Express application.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • helmet() middleware is implemented in the Express application.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • No custom configuration of Helmet is performed in the Express application. Default settings are used, which might not be optimal for all scenarios. No regular review of Helmet configuration is in place for the Express application.

Mitigation Strategy: Custom Error Handling (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Create Custom Error Handling Middleware in Express: Define a custom error handling middleware function in your Express application. This middleware should accept four arguments: err, req, res, next. 2. Implement Error Logging in Custom Middleware: Within your custom error handling middleware, implement secure error logging. Log detailed error information (error object, stack trace) server-side using a secure logging mechanism. Avoid logging sensitive data in production logs. 3. Return Generic Error Responses in Custom Middleware: In your custom error handling middleware, construct generic, user-friendly error responses to send back to clients. Do not expose detailed error messages or stack traces to clients in production. Use HTTP status codes appropriately to indicate the type of error (e.g., 500 Internal Server Error, 400 Bad Request). 4. Replace Default Express Error Handler: Ensure your custom error handling middleware is placed after all other route handlers and middleware in your Express application's middleware stack. This will effectively replace Express's default error handler. 5. Test Error Handling: Thoroughly test your custom error handling in Express by triggering various error scenarios (e.g., invalid routes, database errors, input validation failures) to ensure it behaves as expected and doesn't leak sensitive information.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Information Leakage via Error Stack Traces (Medium Severity): Default Express error handler can expose stack traces and internal paths to attackers.
      • Generic Error Messages (Low Severity): While not directly a vulnerability, overly generic error messages can hinder debugging and user experience.
    • Impact:
      • Information Leakage via Error Stack Traces: Medium Risk Reduction - Prevents exposure of sensitive server-side details through error messages in Express.
      • Generic Error Messages: Low Risk Reduction - Improves user experience and debugging by providing more controlled and informative error responses (while still being secure).
    • Currently Implemented:
      • A basic custom error handler is implemented in Express to catch unhandled exceptions.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • Custom error handler does not consistently log errors securely. Error responses are not always generic and user-friendly. Error handling logic is not thoroughly tested for all error scenarios in the Express application.

Mitigation Strategy: Prevent Error Stack Traces in Production (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Configure NODE_ENV Environment Variable: Ensure the NODE_ENV environment variable is set to production in your production environment. Express.js uses this variable to determine the environment. 2. Conditional Error Handling in Custom Middleware (Express): Within your custom error handling middleware in Express, use conditional logic based on NODE_ENV. In production (NODE_ENV === 'production'), only log detailed errors server-side and return generic error messages to clients. In development or staging (NODE_ENV !== 'production'), you can optionally expose more detailed error information for debugging purposes. 3. Avoid Using Default Express Error Handler in Production: Explicitly ensure you are not relying on Express's default error handler in production. Your custom error handling middleware should always be active and handle errors in production.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Information Leakage via Error Stack Traces (Medium Severity): Exposing stack traces in production can reveal internal application details to attackers, aiding in reconnaissance and potential exploitation.
    • Impact:
      • Information Leakage via Error Stack Traces: Medium Risk Reduction - Prevents the leakage of sensitive information through error stack traces in production Express environments.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • NODE_ENV is set to production in production environments.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • Custom error handling middleware does not fully leverage NODE_ENV to conditionally control error response details. Stack traces might still be inadvertently exposed in some error scenarios in production Express application.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Session Middleware Configuration (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Choose Secure Session Middleware for Express: Select a reputable session middleware package for Express, such as express-session. 2. Configure express-session Securely: When configuring express-session in your Express application: * Use secret option securely: Store the secret used to sign session IDs in a secure environment variable, not directly in your Express code. Access it via process.env.SESSION_SECRET or similar. * Set cookie.secure: true in production: Ensure cookie.secure: true is set in your express-session configuration for production environments. This ensures session cookies are only transmitted over HTTPS, preventing session hijacking via man-in-the-middle attacks against your Express application. * Set cookie.httpOnly: true: Set cookie.httpOnly: true in your express-session configuration. This prevents client-side JavaScript from accessing session cookies, mitigating cross-site scripting (XSS) attacks that could steal session IDs from your Express application. * Consider cookie.sameSite attribute: Use sameSite: 'strict' or sameSite: 'lax' in your express-session configuration to mitigate Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) attacks by controlling when cookies are sent with cross-site requests to your Express application. 3. Test Session Security: Thoroughly test your session configuration in Express to ensure session cookies are secure, properly handled over HTTPS, and protected from client-side access.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Session Hijacking (High Severity): Insecure session cookie handling can allow attackers to steal session IDs and impersonate users in your Express application.
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) based Session Theft (High Severity): XSS vulnerabilities can be exploited to steal session cookies if httpOnly is not set.
      • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) (Medium Severity): Inadequate sameSite configuration can increase the risk of CSRF attacks against your Express application.
    • Impact:
      • Session Hijacking: High Risk Reduction - Secure session configuration significantly reduces the risk of session hijacking in your Express application.
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) based Session Theft: High Risk Reduction - httpOnly flag effectively prevents client-side session cookie theft.
      • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF): Medium Risk Reduction - sameSite attribute provides a good layer of defense against CSRF attacks.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • express-session is used in the Express application. secret is stored in environment variables.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • cookie.secure: true, cookie.httpOnly: true, and cookie.sameSite are not explicitly configured in the express-session setup. Default settings are used, which are less secure for production Express environments.

Mitigation Strategy: Principle of Least Privilege for Routes (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Design Express Routes with Least Privilege: When designing your Express application's routes, adhere to the principle of least privilege. Only expose necessary endpoints and restrict access to sensitive routes based on user roles and permissions within your Express application's routing structure. 2. Implement Authentication Middleware in Express: Use authentication middleware in Express to verify the identity of users accessing your application. This middleware should run before protected routes to ensure only authenticated users can access them. 3. Implement Authorization Middleware in Express: Implement authorization middleware in Express to enforce access control based on user roles and permissions. This middleware should run after authentication middleware and before protected routes to ensure users have the necessary privileges to access specific resources or functionalities in your Express application. 4. Define Route-Specific Access Control: For each route in your Express application, clearly define the required authentication and authorization levels. Use middleware to enforce these access controls at the route level. 5. Regularly Review Route Access Control: Periodically review your Express application's routes and access control configurations to ensure they are still appropriate and aligned with the principle of least privilege.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Unauthorized Access (High Severity): Lack of proper access control can allow unauthorized users to access sensitive data or functionalities in your Express application.
      • Privilege Escalation (Medium Severity): Vulnerabilities in authorization logic can allow users to gain higher privileges than intended in your Express application.
    • Impact:
      • Unauthorized Access: High Risk Reduction - Effectively prevents unauthorized access to sensitive parts of your Express application.
      • Privilege Escalation: Medium Risk Reduction - Reduces the risk of privilege escalation by enforcing role-based access control in Express routes.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • Basic authentication middleware is implemented for user login in the Express application.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • Authorization middleware is not fully implemented. Access control is not consistently enforced across all routes. Route-specific access control definitions are not clearly documented or implemented in the Express application.

Mitigation Strategy: Sanitize User Input in Route Handlers (Express Specific)

  • Description: 1. Identify Input Points in Express Route Handlers: Within each Express route handler, identify all points where user input is received (e.g., req.body, req.query, req.params, req.headers). 2. Sanitize Input Before Processing in Express Routes: Before using user input in database queries, system commands, rendering output, or any other processing within your Express route handlers, apply appropriate sanitization techniques. This might involve encoding, escaping, or removing potentially harmful characters or formatting input to a safe format. 3. Context-Specific Sanitization: Apply sanitization techniques that are appropriate for the context in which the input will be used. For example, sanitize for HTML output to prevent XSS, sanitize for database queries to prevent SQL injection, etc. within your Express route handlers. 4. Combine with Input Validation: Input sanitization should be used as a complement to input validation middleware, not as a replacement. Validation should reject invalid input, while sanitization should neutralize potentially harmful input that is otherwise valid but needs to be processed safely within your Express application.
    • Threats Mitigated:
      • Injection Attacks (SQL Injection, NoSQL Injection, Command Injection, XSS) (High Severity): Insufficient sanitization in Express route handlers can allow injection attacks even if basic input validation is in place.
    • Impact:
      • Injection Attacks: Medium Risk Reduction - Provides an additional layer of defense against injection attacks in Express by sanitizing input within route handlers, even after validation.
    • Currently Implemented:
      • Some basic sanitization is performed ad-hoc in certain Express route handlers, but it's inconsistent and not systematically applied.
    • Missing Implementation:
      • No consistent or systematic input sanitization is implemented within Express route handlers. Sanitization logic is not centralized or reusable. Developers are not consistently trained on proper sanitization techniques within Express routes.