Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
118 lines (96 loc) · 12.2 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

118 lines (96 loc) · 12.2 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for gatsbyjs/gatsby

Objective: To exfiltrate sensitive data or gain unauthorized control over the Gatsby-powered website's content or underlying infrastructure.

Attack Tree Visualization

[Attacker's Goal: Exfiltrate Data or Gain Unauthorized Control] | ├── [Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] │ ├── [Vulnerable Plugin] [CRITICAL] │ │ ├── [RCE via Plugin] (Likelihood: Medium, Impact: High, Effort: Medium, Skill Level: Medium, Detection Difficulty: Medium) │ │ ├── [Lack of Input Validation] (Likelihood: Medium, Impact: Medium, Effort: Low, Skill Level: Medium, Detection Difficulty: Medium) │ │ └── [Sensitive Data in GraphQL] (Likelihood: Medium, Impact: High, Effort: Medium, Skill Level: Medium, Detection Difficulty: Medium) │ └── [Outdated Plugin] (Likelihood: High, Impact: High, Effort: Low, Skill Level: Medium, Detection Difficulty: Low) │ └── [Misconfigured Plugin] (Likelihood: Medium, Impact: Medium, Effort: Low, Skill Level: Medium, Detection Difficulty: Medium) │ └── [Plugin Data Leak] (Likelihood: Medium, Impact: Medium, Effort: Medium, Skill Level: Medium, Detection Difficulty: Medium) │ └── [Plugin Supply Chain] [CRITICAL] │ ├── [Compromised 3rd Party Dependency in Plugin] (Likelihood: Low, Impact: High, Effort: High, Skill Level: High, Detection Difficulty: High) │ └── [Malicious Code Injected During Plugin Development] (Likelihood: Low, Impact: High, Effort: High, Skill Level: High, Detection Difficulty: High) | └── [Exploit Gatsby Build/Deployment Process] └── [Exposed Environment Variables] (Likelihood: Medium, Impact: High, Effort: Low, Skill Level: Low, Detection Difficulty: Low) [CRITICAL]

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 1: ***[Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] -> [Vulnerable Plugin] -> [RCE via Plugin]***

  • Description: This path represents an attacker exploiting a known or unknown (0-day) vulnerability in a Gatsby plugin to achieve Remote Code Execution (RCE). This is a high-risk path because many Gatsby sites rely heavily on plugins, and a single vulnerable plugin can compromise the entire site.
    • Vulnerable Plugin [CRITICAL]: This is a critical node because the presence of any vulnerable plugin opens the door to various attacks. The vulnerability could be in the plugin's code itself, or in one of its dependencies.
    • RCE via Plugin:
      • Likelihood: Medium: While not every plugin has an RCE vulnerability, the sheer number of plugins and the varying levels of security auditing increase the likelihood. Many plugins are community-maintained and may not undergo rigorous security reviews.
      • Impact: High: RCE allows the attacker to execute arbitrary code on the server, potentially leading to complete system compromise, data exfiltration, or website defacement.
      • Effort: Medium: Finding and exploiting an RCE vulnerability often requires some technical skill, but publicly available exploits or vulnerability details can lower the effort.
      • Skill Level: Medium: Requires understanding of web vulnerabilities and potentially some knowledge of the specific plugin's code.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium: Sophisticated RCE exploits might be difficult to detect without proper intrusion detection systems (IDS) and logging. Simpler exploits might leave traces in server logs.

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 2: ***[Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] -> [Vulnerable Plugin] -> [Lack of Input Validation]***

  • Description: This path involves exploiting a plugin that doesn't properly sanitize user inputs, leading to vulnerabilities like Cross-Site Scripting (XSS), SQL Injection (if the plugin interacts with a database), or other injection attacks.
    • Vulnerable Plugin [CRITICAL]: (Same as above)
    • Lack of Input Validation:
      • Likelihood: Medium: Common vulnerability in web applications, especially in less rigorously tested plugins.
      • Impact: Medium: Depends on the type of injection. XSS can lead to session hijacking, while SQL injection can lead to data breaches.
      • Effort: Low: Finding and exploiting input validation flaws is often relatively easy, especially with automated scanning tools.
      • Skill Level: Medium: Requires understanding of common web vulnerabilities.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium: Can be detected through careful code review, penetration testing, and web application firewalls (WAFs).

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 3: ***[Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] -> [Vulnerable Plugin] -> [Sensitive Data in GraphQL]***

  • Description: This path targets plugins that expose sensitive data through their GraphQL API endpoints without proper authorization or access controls.
    • Vulnerable Plugin [CRITICAL]: (Same as above)
    • Sensitive Data in GraphQL:
      • Likelihood: Medium: GraphQL's flexibility can lead to developers inadvertently exposing more data than intended.
      • Impact: High: Direct access to sensitive data (user information, API keys, etc.) can have severe consequences.
      • Effort: Medium: Requires understanding of GraphQL and the specific schema used by the plugin.
      • Skill Level: Medium: Requires knowledge of GraphQL query language and security best practices.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium: Requires monitoring GraphQL queries and analyzing the schema for potential over-exposure.

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 4: ***[Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] -> [Outdated Plugin]***

  • Description: This path involves exploiting known vulnerabilities in outdated versions of plugins.
    • Outdated Plugin:
      • Likelihood: High: Many websites fail to keep plugins up-to-date, making this a common attack vector.
      • Impact: High: Outdated plugins often contain known vulnerabilities with publicly available exploits.
      • Effort: Low: Exploits for known vulnerabilities are often readily available.
      • Skill Level: Medium: Requires basic understanding of vulnerability exploitation.
      • Detection Difficulty: Low: Version numbers are often publicly visible, and vulnerability databases are readily accessible.

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 5: ***[Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] -> [Misconfigured Plugin]***

  • Description: This path involves exploiting a plugin that is improperly configured, exposing sensitive data or functionality.
    • Misconfigured Plugin:
      • Likelihood: Medium: Human error is common, and plugins often have many configuration options.
      • Impact: Medium: Depends on the misconfiguration. Could expose API keys, allow unauthorized access, etc.
      • Effort: Low: Often involves simply trying default configurations or looking for exposed information.
      • Skill Level: Medium: Requires understanding of the plugin's configuration options.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium: Requires careful review of plugin configurations and security audits.

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 6: ***[Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] -> [Plugin Data Leak]***

  • Description: This path involves a plugin that inadvertently leaks sensitive data, perhaps through GraphQL queries or improper data handling.
    • Plugin Data Leak:
      • Likelihood: Medium: Developers may not fully understand the implications of their data handling practices.
      • Impact: Medium: Depends on the type of data leaked.
      • Effort: Medium: Requires analyzing the plugin's code and data flows.
      • Skill Level: Medium: Requires understanding of data security principles.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium: Requires monitoring network traffic and analyzing data exposed by the plugin.

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 7: ***[Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] -> [Plugin Supply Chain] -> [Compromised 3rd Party Dependency in Plugin]***

  • Description: This path represents a sophisticated attack where a plugin's dependency is compromised, leading to the inclusion of malicious code in the plugin itself.
    • Plugin Supply Chain [CRITICAL]: This is a critical node because it's very difficult for developers to fully audit all dependencies of their plugins.
    • Compromised 3rd Party Dependency in Plugin:
      • Likelihood: Low: Requires compromising a library used by the plugin.
      • Impact: High: Can lead to complete system compromise, as the malicious code runs with the plugin's privileges.
      • Effort: High: Requires significant resources and expertise to compromise a widely used library.
      • Skill Level: High: Requires advanced knowledge of software supply chain security.
      • Detection Difficulty: High: Difficult to detect without sophisticated software composition analysis (SCA) tools and threat intelligence.

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 8: ***[Exploit Gatsby Plugin Vulnerabilities] -> [Plugin Supply Chain] -> [Malicious Code Injected During Plugin Development]***

  • Description: This path involves an attacker compromising the development environment of a plugin author and injecting malicious code directly into the plugin's source code.
    • Plugin Supply Chain [CRITICAL]: (Same as above)
    • Malicious Code Injected During Plugin Development:
      • Likelihood: Low: Requires targeting a specific plugin developer.
      • Impact: High: Can lead to complete system compromise, as the malicious code runs with the plugin's privileges.
      • Effort: High: Requires significant resources and expertise to compromise a developer's environment.
      • Skill Level: High: Requires advanced social engineering or technical skills.
      • Detection Difficulty: High: Very difficult to detect without rigorous code reviews and supply chain security measures.

Attack Tree Path: High-Risk Path 9: ***[Exploit Gatsby Build/Deployment Process] -> [Exposed Environment Variables]***

  • Description: This path involves an attacker gaining access to sensitive environment variables (e.g., API keys, database credentials) that are improperly exposed during the build or deployment process.
    • Exposed Environment Variables [CRITICAL]: This is a critical node because it can provide direct access to sensitive resources.
    • Likelihood: Medium: Misconfigurations in CI/CD pipelines or build scripts are common.
    • Impact: High: Can lead to unauthorized access to databases, APIs, and other critical systems.
    • Effort: Low: Often involves simply inspecting build logs or environment configurations.
    • Skill Level: Low: Requires basic understanding of CI/CD and environment variables.
    • Detection Difficulty: Low: Can be detected through regular security audits and code reviews.