Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
190 lines (147 loc) · 22.4 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

190 lines (147 loc) · 22.4 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for kong/insomnia

Mitigation Strategy: Avoid Hardcoding Sensitive Credentials

  • Mitigation Strategy: Avoid Hardcoding Sensitive Credentials

    • Description:

      1. Identify Sensitive Data in Insomnia: Locate all instances where sensitive credentials (API keys, passwords, tokens, etc.) are used within your Insomnia requests, environment variables, or collections.
      2. Replace with Environment Variables: Substitute any hardcoded sensitive values in request URLs, headers, bodies, or query parameters with references to Insomnia environment variables. Use a consistent naming convention for these variables (e.g., API_KEY, AUTH_TOKEN).
      3. Populate Variables Securely (External to Insomnia Editor): Instead of directly typing sensitive values into Insomnia's environment variable editor, establish a secure method to populate these variables outside of the Insomnia UI. This could involve:
        • Using a script that retrieves credentials from a secure vault (like HashiCorp Vault or AWS Secrets Manager) and sets them as environment variables before launching Insomnia.
        • Leveraging operating system-level environment variables that are securely managed and then accessed by Insomnia.
        • Employing a configuration management system to inject these values into the environment where Insomnia runs.
      4. Document Secure Variable Population: Create clear documentation outlining the chosen secure method for populating Insomnia environment variables and ensure all developers adhere to this process.

    • List of Threats Mitigated:

      • Exposure of Credentials in Workspace Files (High Severity): Hardcoding credentials directly into .insomnia files makes them vulnerable to accidental exposure if these files are shared, committed to version control, or accessed by unauthorized users.
      • Credential Leakage through Shared Workspaces (Medium Severity): Sharing Insomnia workspaces containing hardcoded credentials with collaborators or external parties can directly expose sensitive information.
      • Accidental Credential Disclosure during Screen Sharing (Low Severity): Hardcoded credentials visible in the Insomnia UI during screen sharing or recording for debugging or demonstrations can be inadvertently exposed.

    • Impact:

      • Exposure of Credentials in Workspace Files: High reduction in risk. Eliminates the primary source of static credential exposure within Insomnia workspace files.
      • Credential Leakage through Shared Workspaces: Medium reduction in risk. Significantly reduces the risk, but effectiveness depends on the robustness of the external secure variable population method.
      • Accidental Credential Disclosure during Screen Sharing: Low reduction in risk. Minimizes the chance of static credential exposure within the Insomnia UI itself, but developers still need to be cautious during screen sharing.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Developers are generally aware of using environment variables for configuration, but not consistently for sensitive credentials.
      • No enforced policy or automated mechanism to prevent hardcoding sensitive credentials within Insomnia.
      • Basic environment variable usage is mentioned in internal documentation, but secure population methods are not standardized.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Enforcement and Detection: Lack of automated checks or linters within Insomnia workflows to detect hardcoded credentials in requests or environment variables before they are saved in workspaces.
      • Standardized Secure Variable Population: No project-wide, enforced, and documented method for secure external population of sensitive environment variables specifically for Insomnia.
      • Developer Training (Insomnia-Specific): Need for targeted training for developers focusing on secure credential management within the context of using Insomnia.

Mitigation Strategy: Encrypt Sensitive Environment Variables within Insomnia

  • Mitigation Strategy: Encrypt Sensitive Environment Variables within Insomnia

    • Description:

      1. Identify Sensitive Variables in Insomnia: Determine which Insomnia environment variables contain sensitive data (API keys, tokens, passwords, etc.).
      2. Enable Insomnia Encryption: Utilize Insomnia's built-in encryption feature specifically for these identified sensitive environment variables. This is typically done by marking the variable as "sensitive" within Insomnia's environment editor.
      3. Understand Encryption Limitations: Be aware that Insomnia's encryption primarily protects data at rest within the workspace file. It does not encrypt data in memory while Insomnia is running or during network transmission.
      4. Promote Encryption Usage: Actively encourage and guide developers to use Insomnia's environment variable encryption for all sensitive data stored within Insomnia environments.

    • List of Threats Mitigated:

      • Exposure of Credentials in Stored Workspace Files (Medium Severity): If .insomnia workspace files are compromised (e.g., stolen device, unauthorized file system access), encrypted variables are significantly harder to extract in plaintext compared to unencrypted ones.
      • Accidental Exposure of Workspace Files (Low Severity): If workspace files are accidentally shared or backed up insecurely, encryption provides an additional layer of protection against casual observation of sensitive data.

    • Impact:

      • Exposure of Credentials in Stored Workspace Files: Medium reduction in risk. Makes it considerably more difficult for attackers to extract credentials from static workspace files, although it's not a foolproof solution if encryption keys or Insomnia itself are compromised.
      • Accidental Exposure of Workspace Files: Low reduction in risk. Offers a basic defense against accidental exposure, but is not a robust security measure against determined attackers.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Insomnia's encryption feature is available and documented in official Insomnia documentation.
      • Some developers may be aware of and use this feature on their own initiative.
      • No project-wide policy or enforcement to mandate encryption of sensitive environment variables within Insomnia.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Mandatory Encryption Policy (Insomnia-Specific): Establish a project policy specifically requiring the use of Insomnia's encryption for all environment variables containing sensitive data.
      • Guidance and Training (Insomnia-Focused): Provide clear, Insomnia-specific guidance and training to developers on how to correctly use the environment variable encryption feature and when it is mandatory.
      • Workspace Review Process (for Encryption): Implement a process to periodically review Insomnia workspaces to ensure that sensitive environment variables are indeed encrypted as per policy.

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Workspace Sanitization within Insomnia

  • Mitigation Strategy: Regular Workspace Sanitization within Insomnia

    • Description:

      1. Establish a Sanitization Schedule: Define a regular schedule for developers to sanitize their Insomnia workspaces (e.g., weekly, bi-weekly, or before sharing or archiving workspaces).
      2. Identify Sensitive Data Locations in Insomnia: Understand where sensitive data might be stored within Insomnia workspaces:
        • Request History: Past requests stored by Insomnia might contain sensitive data in URLs, headers, bodies, or responses.
        • Environment Variables: Review environment variables, even encrypted ones, for any accidentally stored sensitive values or outdated credentials.
        • Collections: Inspect collection descriptions, request names, and example requests for any inadvertently included sensitive information.
      3. Manual Sanitization Steps within Insomnia:
        • Clear Request History: Use Insomnia's built-in option to clear the request history.
        • Review and Sanitize Environment Variables: Manually review environment variables within Insomnia's environment editor and remove or update any outdated or accidentally stored sensitive values.
        • Inspect and Sanitize Collections: Examine collections within Insomnia and remove or redact any sensitive data from descriptions, request names, or example requests.
      4. Document Sanitization Procedure (Insomnia-Specific): Document the workspace sanitization procedure, focusing on steps within Insomnia, and communicate it clearly to all developers.

    • List of Threats Mitigated:

      • Data Leakage from Insomnia Request History (Medium Severity): Stored request history in Insomnia can contain sensitive data that could be exposed if workspace files are compromised or shared.
      • Accidental Exposure of Sensitive Data in Shared Insomnia Workspaces (Low Severity): Sanitization reduces the risk of inadvertently sharing sensitive data embedded in request history or collection details when Insomnia workspaces are shared.
      • Compliance Violations due to Data Retention in Insomnia (Varying Severity): Depending on the type of sensitive data, unnecessarily retaining it in Insomnia's request history or workspace files might violate data retention policies or compliance regulations.

    • Impact:

      • Data Leakage from Insomnia Request History: Medium reduction in risk. Significantly reduces the window of opportunity for data leakage from request history by regularly clearing it within Insomnia.
      • Accidental Exposure of Sensitive Data in Shared Insomnia Workspaces: Low to Medium reduction in risk. Reduces the likelihood of accidental sharing of sensitive data embedded in Insomnia workspaces, but relies on consistent sanitization practices.
      • Compliance Violations due to Data Retention in Insomnia: Medium reduction in risk. Helps in adhering to data retention policies by removing potentially sensitive data from Insomnia workspaces on a regular basis.

    • Currently Implemented: Not implemented.

      • No formal workspace sanitization process for Insomnia is in place.
      • Developers are not explicitly instructed or reminded to sanitize their Insomnia workspaces.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Sanitization Policy and Schedule (Insomnia-Focused): Establish a clear policy and schedule for regular workspace sanitization specifically for Insomnia.
      • Sanitization Procedure Documentation (Insomnia-Specific): Create and document a step-by-step procedure for Insomnia for developers to follow during workspace sanitization.
      • Reminders and Tools (Insomnia Context): Implement reminders for developers to perform Insomnia workspace sanitization and explore if Insomnia offers any features or plugins to assist with or automate parts of the sanitization process.

Mitigation Strategy: Exercise Caution When Sharing Insomnia Workspaces or Collections

  • Mitigation Strategy: Exercise Caution When Sharing Insomnia Workspaces or Collections

    • Description:

      1. Educate Developers on Sharing Risks: Train developers about the potential security risks associated with sharing Insomnia workspaces or collections, especially with external parties or untrusted individuals.
      2. Sanitize Before Sharing (Mandatory): Establish a mandatory policy to sanitize Insomnia workspaces or collections before sharing them. This includes:
        • Clearing request history.
        • Reviewing and removing any sensitive data from environment variables (even encrypted ones, if possible, or advise recipients to re-configure securely).
        • Inspecting collections and removing or redacting any sensitive data from descriptions, request names, or example requests.
      3. Verify Recipient Trustworthiness: When sharing Insomnia configurations, verify the trustworthiness and security posture of the recipient, especially if sharing outside of the organization.
      4. Use Secure Sharing Methods: Utilize secure collaboration platforms or methods for sharing Insomnia workspace configurations instead of relying on insecure methods like email or public file sharing.

    • List of Threats Mitigated:

      • Exposure of Credentials through Shared Workspaces (Medium to High Severity): Sharing unsanitized workspaces can inadvertently expose sensitive credentials if they are present in environment variables, request history, or collections.
      • Exposure of API Endpoints and Configurations (Medium Severity): Shared workspaces can reveal internal API endpoints, configurations, and potentially sensitive details about the application's architecture to unintended recipients.
      • Data Leakage through Shared Request History (Low to Medium Severity): Request history in shared workspaces might contain sensitive data from past testing or development activities.

    • Impact:

      • Exposure of Credentials through Shared Workspaces: Medium to High reduction in risk. Mandatory sanitization and cautious sharing significantly reduce the risk of accidental credential exposure through shared Insomnia configurations.
      • Exposure of API Endpoints and Configurations: Medium reduction in risk. Reduces the risk of exposing API details to unintended parties, but relies on diligent sanitization and careful recipient selection.
      • Data Leakage through Shared Request History: Low to Medium reduction in risk. Sanitization helps minimize data leakage from request history in shared workspaces.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Developers are generally advised to be careful when sharing sensitive information, but no specific policy or procedure exists for sharing Insomnia workspaces.
      • Sanitization before sharing is not a mandatory or enforced step.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Mandatory Sanitization Policy for Sharing Insomnia Configurations: Establish a clear policy requiring mandatory sanitization of Insomnia workspaces or collections before sharing.
      • Sanitization Checklist/Procedure for Sharing: Create a checklist or step-by-step procedure for developers to follow when sanitizing Insomnia configurations before sharing.
      • Training on Secure Sharing of Insomnia Configurations: Provide specific training to developers on the risks of sharing Insomnia workspaces and best practices for secure sharing, including mandatory sanitization.

Mitigation Strategy: Verify the Source of Imported Insomnia Workspaces/Collections

  • Mitigation Strategy: Verify the Source of Imported Insomnia Workspaces/Collections

    • Description:

      1. Educate Developers on Import Risks: Train developers about the potential security risks of importing Insomnia workspaces or collections from untrusted or unknown sources.
      2. Verify Source Trustworthiness (Mandatory): Establish a mandatory policy to verify the trustworthiness and reputation of the source before importing any Insomnia workspaces or collections.
      3. Review Imported Content Carefully: Always review the contents of imported workspaces or collections within Insomnia before using them. Pay close attention to:
        • URLs and base URLs: Ensure they point to expected and trusted endpoints.
        • Environment variables: Check for any unexpected or suspicious variables or pre-filled values.
        • Request bodies and headers: Examine for any potentially malicious or unexpected content.
      4. Isolate and Test Imported Configurations (Initially): Consider initially importing and testing workspaces/collections in an isolated or non-production environment to assess their safety before using them in production-related activities.

    • List of Threats Mitigated:

      • Malicious Configurations in Imported Workspaces (Medium to High Severity): Imported workspaces from untrusted sources could contain malicious configurations, such as requests targeting unintended endpoints, injecting malicious payloads, or exfiltrating data.
      • Misconfigurations Leading to Security Vulnerabilities (Medium Severity): Imported workspaces might contain misconfigurations that could inadvertently introduce security vulnerabilities in your testing or development environment.
      • Exposure to Unintended API Endpoints (Low to Medium Severity): Imported workspaces might be configured to interact with unintended or unknown API endpoints, potentially leading to unexpected data exposure or security risks.

    • Impact:

      • Malicious Configurations in Imported Workspaces: Medium to High reduction in risk. Mandatory source verification and content review significantly reduce the risk of importing and using malicious Insomnia configurations.
      • Misconfigurations Leading to Security Vulnerabilities: Medium reduction in risk. Careful review helps identify and mitigate potential misconfigurations in imported workspaces.
      • Exposure to Unintended API Endpoints: Low to Medium reduction in risk. Reviewing URLs and base URLs helps prevent accidental interaction with unintended API endpoints.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Developers are generally advised to be cautious about downloading files from untrusted sources, but no specific policy exists for importing Insomnia workspaces.
      • Reviewing imported content is not a mandatory or enforced step.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Mandatory Source Verification Policy for Insomnia Imports: Establish a clear policy requiring mandatory verification of the source's trustworthiness before importing Insomnia workspaces or collections.
      • Import Review Checklist/Procedure (Insomnia-Specific): Create a checklist or step-by-step procedure for developers to follow when reviewing imported Insomnia configurations.
      • Training on Securely Importing Insomnia Configurations: Provide specific training to developers on the risks of importing Insomnia workspaces from untrusted sources and best practices for secure import and review.

Mitigation Strategy: Clearly Delineate Environments within Insomnia

  • Mitigation Strategy: Clearly Delineate Environments within Insomnia

    • Description:

      1. Utilize Insomnia Environments Feature: Mandate the use of Insomnia's environment feature to clearly separate configurations for different environments (development, staging, production, etc.).
      2. Distinct Naming Conventions: Use clear and distinct naming conventions for Insomnia environments to easily differentiate them (e.g., "Development - API v1", "Staging - API v1", "PRODUCTION - API v1").
      3. Visual Cues (If Available): If Insomnia offers visual cues or color-coding for environments, utilize them to further enhance visual differentiation between environments within the Insomnia UI.
      4. Environment-Specific Configurations: Configure environment variables and base URLs within Insomnia environments to be environment-specific. This ensures that requests are directed to the correct environment based on the selected Insomnia environment.
      5. Default to Non-Production Environment: Encourage or configure Insomnia (if possible) to default to a non-production environment (e.g., development) when starting or creating new requests to minimize the risk of accidental production actions.

    • List of Threats Mitigated:

      • Accidental Actions Against Production Environments (High Severity): Without clear environment delineation, developers might accidentally execute requests against production environments when intending to target development or staging, leading to unintended data modification or service disruption.
      • Configuration Errors Targeting Production (Medium Severity): Lack of environment separation can lead to configuration errors where development or staging configurations are mistakenly applied to production, potentially causing security vulnerabilities or operational issues.

    • Impact:

      • Accidental Actions Against Production Environments: High reduction in risk. Clear environment delineation and visual cues significantly reduce the risk of developers accidentally targeting production environments from Insomnia.
      • Configuration Errors Targeting Production: Medium reduction in risk. Environment-specific configurations within Insomnia minimize the chance of configuration errors propagating to production.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Developers are generally aware of using Insomnia environments, but consistent and enforced usage across all projects might be lacking.
      • Naming conventions and visual cues for environments might not be standardized or consistently applied.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Mandatory Environment Usage Policy (Insomnia-Specific): Establish a clear policy mandating the use of Insomnia environments for all projects and development activities.
      • Standardized Naming Conventions for Insomnia Environments: Define and enforce standardized naming conventions for Insomnia environments to ensure clear and consistent environment identification.
      • Training on Effective Insomnia Environment Management: Provide specific training to developers on how to effectively use Insomnia's environment features to manage different environments and prevent accidental production actions.