Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
137 lines (108 loc) · 7.74 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

137 lines (108 loc) · 7.74 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for mochajs/mocha

Mitigation Strategy: Isolate Test Contexts with Mocha Hooks

Mitigation Strategy: Isolate Test Contexts with Mocha Hooks

  • Description:

    1. Identify Global Dependencies: Analyze each test file to identify any interactions with global objects or shared state.
    2. Implement beforeEach and afterEach Hooks:
      • Within each test file (or in a shared setup file loaded by Mocha), create beforeEach and afterEach hooks. These are Mocha-specific functions.
      • In beforeEach, set up the necessary test environment for that specific test. This might involve creating temporary data, setting up specific conditions, or initializing variables.
      • In afterEach, restore the environment to its original state. This is crucial for isolation. This involves cleaning up any temporary data, resetting variables, and ensuring no side effects persist. This prevents one test from affecting subsequent tests.
    3. Avoid Direct Global Modification (Within Mocha Tests): Within the test logic itself (the it blocks), avoid directly modifying global objects whenever possible. If modification is absolutely necessary, ensure it's undone in the afterEach hook.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Accidental Modification of Test Environment (Global Scope Pollution): Severity: High. Prevents tests from interfering with each other and the application's runtime by ensuring a clean state before and after each test.
    • Flaky Tests: Severity: Medium. Reduces the likelihood of tests passing or failing inconsistently due to shared state, making test results more reliable.

  • Impact:

    • Accidental Modification: Risk reduced significantly (80-90%). Proper use of Mocha's beforeEach and afterEach hooks is highly effective at isolating tests.
    • Flaky Tests: Risk reduced significantly (70-80%). Makes tests much more reliable and predictable.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Partially implemented in src/utils/__tests__/helper.test.js (uses beforeEach and afterEach).
    • Not implemented in src/components/__tests__/MyComponent.test.js.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Consistent and thorough implementation of beforeEach and afterEach hooks across all test files is needed. Every test should have proper setup and teardown.
    • src/components/__tests__/MyComponent.test.js requires refactoring to use these hooks.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Test Timeouts using Mocha's this.timeout()

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Test Timeouts using Mocha's this.timeout()

  • Description:

    1. Identify Potentially Slow Tests: Analyze your tests to identify those that might take longer to execute (e.g., tests involving network requests, complex calculations, or large datasets).
    2. Set Individual Test Timeouts:
      • Within individual tests (it blocks) or entire suites (describe blocks), use Mocha's this.timeout(milliseconds) function: 
        it('should complete within 2 seconds', function() {
    this.timeout(2000); // Set a 2-second timeout
    // ... test logic ...
});

describe('My Suite', function() {
    this.timeout(5000); // Set a 5-second timeout for the entire suite

    it('test 1', function() { ... });
    it('test 2', function() { ... });
});
      • Choose timeout values that are reasonable for the expected execution time of the test, but not excessively long.
    3. Set Global Timeout (Mocha Configuration):
      • Configure a global timeout for the entire test run. This can be done:
        • Via the command line: mocha --timeout 5000 (sets a 5-second global timeout).
        • In a Mocha configuration file (e.g., mocha.opts, .mocharc.js, or package.json): 
          // .mocharc.js
module.exports = {
  timeout: 5000 // 5 seconds
};
      • The global timeout acts as a safety net for tests that don't have individual timeouts set.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Slow or Resource-Intensive Tests (DoS): Severity: Medium. Prevents tests from running indefinitely and consuming excessive resources, potentially causing a denial-of-service condition for developers or build servers.

  • Impact:

    • DoS: Risk reduced significantly (70-80%). Timeouts prevent runaway tests, ensuring resources are freed up.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Some tests have individual timeouts, but it's not consistent.
    • No global timeout is configured.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Consistent use of this.timeout() in all tests, especially those that interact with external resources or perform complex operations.
    • Configuration of a global timeout via the command line or a Mocha configuration file.

Mitigation Strategy: Utilize Mocha's before, after, beforeEach, afterEach for Setup and Teardown

Mitigation Strategy: Utilize Mocha's before, after, beforeEach, afterEach for Setup and Teardown

  • Description:

    1. Understand the Hooks:
      • before: Executes once before all tests in a describe block.
      • after: Executes once after all tests in a describe block.
      • beforeEach: Executes before each test in a describe block.
      • afterEach: Executes after each test in a describe block.
    2. Strategic Use:
      • Use before for setup that is only needed once per suite (e.g., connecting to a test database).
      • Use after for cleanup that is only needed once per suite (e.g., disconnecting from a test database).
      • Use beforeEach for setup that needs to be done before every test (e.g., creating fresh mock objects, resetting state).
      • Use afterEach for cleanup that needs to be done after every test (e.g., restoring mocks, cleaning up temporary data).
    3. Example: 
      describe('My Feature', function() {
    let sharedResource;

    before(function() {
        // Run once before all tests
        sharedResource = createSharedResource();
    });

    beforeEach(function() {
        // Run before each test
        resetSharedResource(sharedResource);
    });

    it('test 1', function() { /* ... */ });
    it('test 2', function() { /* ... */ });

    afterEach(function() {
        // Run after each test
        cleanupTemporaryData();
    });

    after(function() {
        // Run once after all tests
        destroySharedResource(sharedResource);
    });
});

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Accidental Modification of Test Environment (Global Scope Pollution): Severity: High. Ensures consistent and isolated test environments.
    • Flaky Tests: Severity: Medium. Reduces test interdependencies.

  • Impact:

    • Accidental Modification: Risk significantly reduced (80-90%).
    • Flaky Tests: Risk significantly reduced (70-80%).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Partially implemented in some test files.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Consistent and strategic use across all test suites. Need to review all tests and ensure appropriate hooks are used for setup and teardown.