Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
249 lines (220 loc) · 23.1 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

249 lines (220 loc) · 23.1 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for nodejs/readable-stream

Objective: Compromise application using readable-stream by exploiting vulnerabilities within the stream processing logic or the library itself.

Attack Tree Visualization

Compromise Application via Readable-Stream
├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Exploit Input Data Vulnerabilities
│   ├───[OR] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Malicious Data Injection
│   │   ├───[AND] Overflow Buffers
│   │   │   ├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Craft input data exceeding expected buffer size
│   │   │   └── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Trigger stream processing that writes beyond buffer bounds
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Inject Malicious Payloads
│   │   │   ├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Embed code within stream data (e.g., if data is later interpreted)
│   │   │   └── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Exploit parsing logic vulnerabilities in downstream components
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Trigger Unexpected Stream Behavior
│   │   │   ├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Send data that violates expected stream format
│   │   │   └── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Cause errors or exceptions in stream processing logic
│   ├───[OR] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Data Flooding/DoS
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Send Excessive Data
│   │   │   ├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Overwhelm stream processing pipeline with large volume of data
│   │   │   └── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Exhaust server resources (CPU, Memory, Network)
│   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Exploit Vulnerabilities in Application's Stream Handling Logic
│   │   ├───[OR] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Incorrect Error Handling
│   │   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Trigger errors in stream processing
│   │   │   │   ├── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Send malformed data or unexpected input
│   │   │   │   └── **[CRITICAL NODE]** Observe application's error handling behavior for weaknesses (e.g., information disclosure, crashes)

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Input Data Vulnerabilities

  • Description: Attackers target vulnerabilities arising from processing untrusted input data within the readable-stream pipeline. This path encompasses injecting malicious data, causing unexpected stream behavior, and exploiting buffer handling issues.

    • [HIGH-RISK PATH] Malicious Data Injection

      • Description: Injecting crafted data into the stream to cause harm when processed by the application.

        • [AND] Overflow Buffers
          • [CRITICAL NODE] Craft input data exceeding expected buffer size
            • Attack Vector: Crafting input data that is larger than the buffers allocated by the application for stream processing.
            • Likelihood: Medium
            • Impact: Moderate (Denial of Service, potential memory corruption in poorly managed native addons, unexpected application behavior)
            • Effort: Low
            • Skill Level: Beginner
            • Detection Difficulty: Moderate (Requires monitoring memory usage, application crashes, and error logs)
          • [CRITICAL NODE] Trigger stream processing that writes beyond buffer bounds
            • Attack Vector: Exploiting logic flaws in stream processing to cause writes beyond allocated buffer boundaries, even if the input data size itself isn't excessively large initially.
            • Likelihood: Medium
            • Impact: Moderate (Denial of Service, potential memory corruption in poorly managed native addons, unexpected application behavior)
            • Effort: Low
            • Skill Level: Beginner
            • Detection Difficulty: Moderate (Requires monitoring memory usage, application crashes, and error logs)
        • [AND] [HIGH-RISK PATH] Inject Malicious Payloads
          • [CRITICAL NODE] Embed code within stream data (e.g., if data is later interpreted)
            • Attack Vector: Embedding malicious code or scripts within the stream data, hoping that the application will later interpret and execute this code. This is relevant if the application processes stream data in a dynamic or unsafe manner (e.g., evaluating data as code).
            • Likelihood: Medium (Depends heavily on application logic and how stream data is processed)
            • Impact: Significant (Code execution, data manipulation, information disclosure, depending on the context of execution)
            • Effort: Medium
            • Skill Level: Intermediate
            • Detection Difficulty: Moderate (Requires robust input validation, content security policies, and anomaly detection)
          • [CRITICAL NODE] Exploit parsing logic vulnerabilities in downstream components
            • Attack Vector: Injecting data that exploits vulnerabilities in parsers or downstream components that process the stream data. This could involve format string bugs, injection flaws in data deserialization, or other parser-specific vulnerabilities.
            • Likelihood: Medium (Depends on the presence of vulnerabilities in downstream parsing logic)
            • Impact: Significant (Code execution, data manipulation, information disclosure, depending on the parser vulnerability)
            • Effort: Medium
            • Skill Level: Intermediate
            • Detection Difficulty: Moderate (Requires vulnerability scanning of downstream components, secure coding practices in parsing logic)
        • [AND] [HIGH-RISK PATH] Trigger Unexpected Stream Behavior
          • [CRITICAL NODE] Send data that violates expected stream format
            • Attack Vector: Sending data that deviates from the expected format or structure of the stream. This can trigger errors, exceptions, or unexpected behavior in the stream processing logic.
            • Likelihood: High
            • Impact: Minor to Moderate (Denial of Service, application errors, unexpected application behavior, potential for information disclosure through error messages)
            • Effort: Minimal
            • Skill Level: Novice
            • Detection Difficulty: Easy (Easily logged as errors, invalid input, format violations)
          • [CRITICAL NODE] Cause errors or exceptions in stream processing logic
            • Attack Vector: Intentionally sending data designed to trigger errors or exceptions within the stream processing pipeline. This can be used to probe for weaknesses in error handling, cause application instability, or potentially lead to denial of service.
            • Likelihood: High
            • Impact: Minor to Moderate (Denial of Service, application errors, unexpected application behavior, potential for information disclosure through error messages or stack traces)
            • Effort: Minimal
            • Skill Level: Novice
            • Detection Difficulty: Easy (Easily logged as errors, exceptions, application instability)

Attack Tree Path: Malicious Data Injection

  • Description: Injecting crafted data into the stream to cause harm when processed by the application.

        *   **[AND] Overflow Buffers**
        *   **[CRITICAL NODE] Craft input data exceeding expected buffer size**
            *   **Attack Vector:**  Crafting input data that is larger than the buffers allocated by the application for stream processing.
            *   **Likelihood:** Medium
            *   **Impact:** Moderate (Denial of Service, potential memory corruption in poorly managed native addons, unexpected application behavior)
            *   **Effort:** Low
            *   **Skill Level:** Beginner
            *   **Detection Difficulty:** Moderate (Requires monitoring memory usage, application crashes, and error logs)
        *   **[CRITICAL NODE] Trigger stream processing that writes beyond buffer bounds**
            *   **Attack Vector:**  Exploiting logic flaws in stream processing to cause writes beyond allocated buffer boundaries, even if the input data size itself isn't excessively large initially.
            *   **Likelihood:** Medium
            *   **Impact:** Moderate (Denial of Service, potential memory corruption in poorly managed native addons, unexpected application behavior)
            *   **Effort:** Low
            *   **Skill Level:** Beginner
            *   **Detection Difficulty:** Moderate (Requires monitoring memory usage, application crashes, and error logs)
    *   **[AND] [HIGH-RISK PATH] Inject Malicious Payloads**
        *   **[CRITICAL NODE] Embed code within stream data (e.g., if data is later interpreted)**
            *   **Attack Vector:** Embedding malicious code or scripts within the stream data, hoping that the application will later interpret and execute this code. This is relevant if the application processes stream data in a dynamic or unsafe manner (e.g., evaluating data as code).
            *   **Likelihood:** Medium (Depends heavily on application logic and how stream data is processed)
            *   **Impact:** Significant (Code execution, data manipulation, information disclosure, depending on the context of execution)
            *   **Effort:** Medium
            *   **Skill Level:** Intermediate
            *   **Detection Difficulty:** Moderate (Requires robust input validation, content security policies, and anomaly detection)
        *   **[CRITICAL NODE] Exploit parsing logic vulnerabilities in downstream components**
            *   **Attack Vector:** Injecting data that exploits vulnerabilities in parsers or downstream components that process the stream data. This could involve format string bugs, injection flaws in data deserialization, or other parser-specific vulnerabilities.
            *   **Likelihood:** Medium (Depends on the presence of vulnerabilities in downstream parsing logic)
            *   **Impact:** Significant (Code execution, data manipulation, information disclosure, depending on the parser vulnerability)
            *   **Effort:** Medium
            *   **Skill Level:** Intermediate
            *   **Detection Difficulty:** Moderate (Requires vulnerability scanning of downstream components, secure coding practices in parsing logic)

Attack Tree Path: Inject Malicious Payloads

  • [CRITICAL NODE] Embed code within stream data (e.g., if data is later interpreted) * Attack Vector: Embedding malicious code or scripts within the stream data, hoping that the application will later interpret and execute this code. This is relevant if the application processes stream data in a dynamic or unsafe manner (e.g., evaluating data as code). * Likelihood: Medium (Depends heavily on application logic and how stream data is processed) * Impact: Significant (Code execution, data manipulation, information disclosure, depending on the context of execution) * Effort: Medium * Skill Level: Intermediate * Detection Difficulty: Moderate (Requires robust input validation, content security policies, and anomaly detection) * [CRITICAL NODE] Exploit parsing logic vulnerabilities in downstream components * Attack Vector: Injecting data that exploits vulnerabilities in parsers or downstream components that process the stream data. This could involve format string bugs, injection flaws in data deserialization, or other parser-specific vulnerabilities. * Likelihood: Medium (Depends on the presence of vulnerabilities in downstream parsing logic) * Impact: Significant (Code execution, data manipulation, information disclosure, depending on the parser vulnerability) * Effort: Medium * Skill Level: Intermediate * Detection Difficulty: Moderate (Requires vulnerability scanning of downstream components, secure coding practices in parsing logic)

Attack Tree Path: Trigger Unexpected Stream Behavior

  • [CRITICAL NODE] Send data that violates expected stream format * Attack Vector: Sending data that deviates from the expected format or structure of the stream. This can trigger errors, exceptions, or unexpected behavior in the stream processing logic. * Likelihood: High * Impact: Minor to Moderate (Denial of Service, application errors, unexpected application behavior, potential for information disclosure through error messages) * Effort: Minimal * Skill Level: Novice * Detection Difficulty: Easy (Easily logged as errors, invalid input, format violations) * [CRITICAL NODE] Cause errors or exceptions in stream processing logic * Attack Vector: Intentionally sending data designed to trigger errors or exceptions within the stream processing pipeline. This can be used to probe for weaknesses in error handling, cause application instability, or potentially lead to denial of service. * Likelihood: High * Impact: Minor to Moderate (Denial of Service, application errors, unexpected application behavior, potential for information disclosure through error messages or stack traces) * Effort: Minimal * Skill Level: Novice * Detection Difficulty: Easy (Easily logged as errors, exceptions, application instability)

Attack Tree Path: Data Flooding/DoS

  • Description: Overwhelming the application with a large volume of data to cause denial of service.

        *   **[AND] [HIGH-RISK PATH] Send Excessive Data**
        *   **[CRITICAL NODE] Overwhelm stream processing pipeline with large volume of data**
            *   **Attack Vector:** Flooding the stream processing pipeline with an excessive amount of data, exceeding the application's capacity to handle it efficiently.
            *   **Likelihood:** High
            *   **Impact:** Moderate to Significant (Denial of Service, resource exhaustion, service disruption, making the application unresponsive to legitimate requests)
            *   **Effort:** Minimal
            *   **Skill Level:** Novice
            *   **Detection Difficulty:** Easy (High resource usage, slow response times, network traffic anomalies, system monitoring alerts)
        *   **[CRITICAL NODE] Exhaust server resources (CPU, Memory, Network)**
            *   **Attack Vector:** The ultimate goal of sending excessive data is to exhaust server resources (CPU, memory, network bandwidth), leading to denial of service.
            *   **Likelihood:** High
            *   **Impact:** Moderate to Significant (Denial of Service, resource exhaustion, service disruption, complete service unavailability)
            *   **Effort:** Minimal
            *   **Skill Level:** Novice
            *   **Detection Difficulty:** Easy (High resource usage, slow response times, system monitoring alerts, service unavailability)

Attack Tree Path: Send Excessive Data

  • [CRITICAL NODE] Overwhelm stream processing pipeline with large volume of data * Attack Vector: Flooding the stream processing pipeline with an excessive amount of data, exceeding the application's capacity to handle it efficiently. * Likelihood: High * Impact: Moderate to Significant (Denial of Service, resource exhaustion, service disruption, making the application unresponsive to legitimate requests) * Effort: Minimal * Skill Level: Novice * Detection Difficulty: Easy (High resource usage, slow response times, network traffic anomalies, system monitoring alerts) * [CRITICAL NODE] Exhaust server resources (CPU, Memory, Network) * Attack Vector: The ultimate goal of sending excessive data is to exhaust server resources (CPU, memory, network bandwidth), leading to denial of service. * Likelihood: High * Impact: Moderate to Significant (Denial of Service, resource exhaustion, service disruption, complete service unavailability) * Effort: Minimal * Skill Level: Novice * Detection Difficulty: Easy (High resource usage, slow response times, system monitoring alerts, service unavailability)

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Vulnerabilities in Application's Stream Handling Logic

  • Description: Attackers target weaknesses in how the application itself handles streams, particularly focusing on error handling.

    • [OR] [HIGH-RISK PATH] Incorrect Error Handling

      • Description: Exploiting flaws in the application's error handling mechanisms within the stream processing logic.

        • [AND] [HIGH-RISK PATH] Trigger errors in stream processing
          • [CRITICAL NODE] Send malformed data or unexpected input
            • Attack Vector: Sending malformed or unexpected input data specifically designed to trigger error conditions within the stream processing pipeline.
            • Likelihood: High
            • Impact: Minor (Information disclosure via error messages, application instability, potential for probing application behavior)
            • Effort: Minimal
            • Skill Level: Novice
            • Detection Difficulty: Easy (Error logs, monitoring application stability, increased error rates)
          • [CRITICAL NODE] Observe application's error handling behavior for weaknesses (e.g., information disclosure, crashes)
            • Attack Vector: After triggering errors, attackers observe the application's response and error handling behavior to identify weaknesses. This could include information disclosure through verbose error messages, stack traces, or application crashes that reveal internal state or vulnerabilities.
            • Likelihood: Medium
            • Impact: Minor to Moderate (Information disclosure, application instability, potential for further exploitation based on revealed information)
            • Effort: Low
            • Skill Level: Beginner
            • Detection Difficulty: Easy (Error logs, security testing, analysis of error responses)

Attack Tree Path: Incorrect Error Handling

  • Description: Exploiting flaws in the application's error handling mechanisms within the stream processing logic.

        *   **[AND] [HIGH-RISK PATH] Trigger errors in stream processing**
        *   **[CRITICAL NODE] Send malformed data or unexpected input**
            *   **Attack Vector:** Sending malformed or unexpected input data specifically designed to trigger error conditions within the stream processing pipeline.
            *   **Likelihood:** High
            *   **Impact:** Minor (Information disclosure via error messages, application instability, potential for probing application behavior)
            *   **Effort:** Minimal
            *   **Skill Level:** Novice
            *   **Detection Difficulty:** Easy (Error logs, monitoring application stability, increased error rates)
        *   **[CRITICAL NODE] Observe application's error handling behavior for weaknesses (e.g., information disclosure, crashes)**
            *   **Attack Vector:** After triggering errors, attackers observe the application's response and error handling behavior to identify weaknesses. This could include information disclosure through verbose error messages, stack traces, or application crashes that reveal internal state or vulnerabilities.
            *   **Likelihood:** Medium
            *   **Impact:** Minor to Moderate (Information disclosure, application instability, potential for further exploitation based on revealed information)
            *   **Effort:** Low
            *   **Skill Level:** Beginner
            *   **Detection Difficulty:** Easy (Error logs, security testing, analysis of error responses)

Attack Tree Path: Trigger errors in stream processing

  • [CRITICAL NODE] Send malformed data or unexpected input * Attack Vector: Sending malformed or unexpected input data specifically designed to trigger error conditions within the stream processing pipeline. * Likelihood: High * Impact: Minor (Information disclosure via error messages, application instability, potential for probing application behavior) * Effort: Minimal * Skill Level: Novice * Detection Difficulty: Easy (Error logs, monitoring application stability, increased error rates) * [CRITICAL NODE] Observe application's error handling behavior for weaknesses (e.g., information disclosure, crashes) * Attack Vector: After triggering errors, attackers observe the application's response and error handling behavior to identify weaknesses. This could include information disclosure through verbose error messages, stack traces, or application crashes that reveal internal state or vulnerabilities. * Likelihood: Medium * Impact: Minor to Moderate (Information disclosure, application instability, potential for further exploitation based on revealed information) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Beginner * Detection Difficulty: Easy (Error logs, security testing, analysis of error responses)