Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
66 lines (59 loc) · 12.5 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

66 lines (59 loc) · 12.5 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for sortablejs/sortable

Mitigation Strategy: Server-Side Validation and Authorization of Order Changes Initiated by SortableJS

  • Description:
    1. Capture SortableJS Order Output: When a user reorders items using SortableJS, utilize SortableJS's events (like onSort, onUpdate, or onChange) to capture the new order of items as determined by the client-side drag-and-drop interaction. This will typically be an array of item IDs in their new sequence.
    2. Transmit Order to Server Post-SortableJS Interaction: After SortableJS has updated the client-side order, send this new order to the server via an API request. This request is triggered specifically because of the user's interaction with the SortableJS interface.
    3. Server-Side Re-Verification of SortableJS Order: On the server, upon receiving the order data resulting from the SortableJS interaction, critically re-validate this order. Do not assume the order from SortableJS is inherently secure or authorized.
      • Fetch the original item data from the server's authoritative source (database, etc.).
      • Compare the received order against the server-side data to confirm integrity and consistency.
      • Perform authorization checks to ensure the user is permitted to reorder these specific items in this manner, regardless of the client-side SortableJS manipulation.
      • Apply any relevant business logic validation based on the new order, ensuring the server-side logic aligns with the intended consequences of the reordering action.
    4. Persist Server-Validated Order: Only after successful server-side validation and authorization should the new order be persisted in the application's data storage. This ensures the final order is determined and controlled server-side, not solely by the client-side SortableJS interaction.
    5. Inform Client of Server Outcome: Send a response back to the client indicating the success or failure of the order update based on server-side validation. Handle potential errors from the server (e.g., validation failures, authorization issues) gracefully in the client-side application, potentially reverting the SortableJS list to its previous state or displaying informative error messages.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Client-Side Order Manipulation via SortableJS Leading to Privilege Escalation or Data Integrity Issues (Severity: High): This directly addresses the threat of users exploiting SortableJS's client-side reordering to bypass security checks or corrupt data by ensuring server-side control over the final order.
  • Impact:
    • Client-Side Order Manipulation via SortableJS Leading to Privilege Escalation or Data Integrity Issues: High Reduction. This strategy effectively neutralizes the risk of unauthorized or invalid order changes originating from client-side SortableJS actions impacting critical server-side operations.
  • Currently Implemented: [Describe where this is currently implemented in your project, specifically mentioning SortableJS interactions. For example: "Implemented for 'task list reordering' feature where SortableJS onSort event triggers an API call to validate and persist the order." If not implemented, state "Not currently implemented."]
    • Example: Implemented for 'task list reordering' feature where SortableJS onSort event triggers an API call to validate and persist the order.
  • Missing Implementation: [Describe where this mitigation is missing, specifically in areas using SortableJS for order manipulation. For example: "Missing in 'dashboard widget arrangement' feature which uses SortableJS but directly trusts the client-side order without server validation." If fully implemented, state "No missing implementation."]
    • Example: Missing in 'dashboard widget arrangement' feature which uses SortableJS but directly trusts the client-side order without server validation.

Mitigation Strategy: Strict Sanitization and Encoding of Data Rendered in SortableJS Lists

  • Description:
    1. Identify Data Displayed by SortableJS: Pinpoint all data sources that are rendered as items within SortableJS sortable lists. This includes any dynamic content, user-provided text, or data fetched from external sources that are displayed within the draggable elements managed by SortableJS.
    2. Server-Side Sanitization Before SortableJS Rendering: Critical: Sanitize all data on the server-side before it is sent to the client to be rendered by SortableJS.
      • Employ a robust server-side sanitization library suitable for your backend language.
      • Sanitize data to neutralize any potentially malicious code, focusing on HTML, JavaScript, and URL injection vectors that could be exploited when rendered by SortableJS in the browser.
      • Apply context-aware sanitization, considering the intended use of the data within the SortableJS list (e.g., sanitizing differently for plain text display versus potentially rich text elements within list items).
    3. Client-Side Output Encoding During SortableJS Rendering: When the client-side application receives data intended for display in SortableJS lists:
      • Utilize frontend frameworks or templating engines that automatically perform output encoding when rendering dynamic content within SortableJS managed elements.
      • If directly manipulating the DOM to render SortableJS list items, use browser APIs that inherently provide output encoding (e.g., textContent for text content, DOM element creation APIs instead of innerHTML for structured content) to prevent the interpretation of data as code by the browser when SortableJS updates or manipulates the DOM.
      • Specifically, for HTML content intended to be displayed within SortableJS items, ensure proper HTML encoding of special characters (<, >, &, ", ') to prevent them from being interpreted as HTML tags or attributes when rendered or manipulated by SortableJS.
    4. Regularly Review Data Handling in SortableJS Context: Periodically review the data flow and sanitization/encoding practices around SortableJS list rendering. Update sanitization libraries and encoding methods as needed to address emerging XSS vulnerabilities and ensure ongoing protection for data displayed within SortableJS interfaces.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) Vulnerabilities via Unsanitized Data Displayed in SortableJS Lists (Severity: High): This directly prevents XSS attacks by ensuring that data rendered and manipulated by SortableJS cannot be used to inject and execute malicious scripts within the application context.
  • Impact:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) Vulnerabilities via Unsanitized Data Displayed in SortableJS Lists: High Reduction. Rigorous sanitization and encoding are fundamental to preventing XSS when displaying dynamic content, especially within interactive components like SortableJS lists that manipulate the DOM.
  • Currently Implemented: [Describe where this is currently implemented, specifically for data used in SortableJS lists. For example: "Implemented for all data rendered in SortableJS task lists, using [Sanitization Library Name] on the backend and React's automatic output encoding on the frontend." If not fully implemented, specify areas related to SortableJS.]
    • Example: Implemented for all data rendered in SortableJS task lists, using OWASP Java Encoder on the backend and React's automatic output encoding on the frontend.
  • Missing Implementation: [Describe areas where sanitization or encoding might be missing for data used in SortableJS lists. For example: "Potentially missing in 'admin dashboard widgets' feature where data displayed in SortableJS lists might not be consistently sanitized." If fully implemented for all SortableJS data, state "No missing implementation."]
    • Example: Potentially missing in 'admin dashboard widgets' feature where data displayed in SortableJS lists might not be consistently sanitized. Ensure all data sources for SortableJS lists are subject to strict sanitization and encoding.

Mitigation Strategy: Client-Side List Size Management for SortableJS Performance

  • Description:
    1. Establish Practical List Size Limits for SortableJS: Determine reasonable limits for the number of items that should be rendered and made sortable within a single SortableJS list instance. Consider client-side performance implications, browser limitations, and the user experience when manipulating very long lists with drag-and-drop.
    2. Implement Client-Side List Item Virtualization or Pagination for SortableJS: For scenarios where large datasets are involved and need to be presented in a sortable manner:
      • Virtual Scrolling: Implement virtual scrolling techniques within the SortableJS list. This involves rendering only the visible portion of the list items within the SortableJS container, dynamically loading and unloading items as the user scrolls. This significantly reduces the DOM overhead and improves performance for large lists.
      • Client-Side Pagination: If virtual scrolling is not feasible, implement client-side pagination. Divide large datasets into smaller pages and render only the items for the current page within the SortableJS list. Provide pagination controls to navigate between pages. Note that sorting across pages might require additional server-side logic or client-side data management.
    3. Limit Initial Data Load for SortableJS: When initializing SortableJS lists, especially if they can potentially contain a large number of items, limit the initial data load to a manageable subset. Use pagination or virtual scrolling to load additional items on demand as the user interacts with the list.
    4. Optimize SortableJS Configuration for Performance: Review SortableJS configuration options to optimize performance, especially when dealing with potentially larger lists. Consider:
      • handle option: Use a specific drag handle within list items instead of making the entire item draggable if appropriate, potentially improving drag performance.
      • animation option: Use subtle or minimal animations for drag-and-drop feedback, as complex animations can impact performance with large lists.
      • ghostClass and chosenClass options: Ensure the CSS styles for ghost and chosen elements are performant and avoid overly complex styles that could degrade performance during drag operations.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Denial of Service (DoS) or Performance Degradation due to Excessive Client-Side Manipulation of Large SortableJS Lists (Severity: Medium): Managing list size and optimizing SortableJS usage reduces the risk of client-side performance issues or browser crashes caused by manipulating extremely large sortable lists, which could be exploited for localized DoS.
  • Impact:
    • Denial of Service (DoS) or Performance Degradation due to Excessive Client-Side Manipulation of Large SortableJS Lists: Medium Reduction. By limiting list size and optimizing rendering, this strategy mitigates the risk of performance-related issues when using SortableJS with large datasets, improving overall application responsiveness and user experience.
  • Currently Implemented: [Describe if list size management is implemented for SortableJS lists. For example: "Virtual scrolling is implemented for SortableJS 'user list' component to handle potentially large user datasets." If not implemented, state "Not currently implemented for large SortableJS lists."]
    • Example: Virtual scrolling is implemented for SortableJS 'user list' component to handle potentially large user datasets.
  • Missing Implementation: [Describe areas where list size management is missing for SortableJS lists that could become large. For example: "Client-side pagination or virtual scrolling needs to be implemented for the 'admin log list' which uses SortableJS and can grow very large." If implemented where needed, state "No missing implementation."]
    • Example: Client-side pagination or virtual scrolling needs to be implemented for the 'admin log list' which uses SortableJS and can grow very large. Consider implementing virtual scrolling for smoother user experience.