Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
105 lines (92 loc) · 16.9 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

105 lines (92 loc) · 16.9 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for twbs/bootstrap

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Bootstrap Updates

  • Description:
    1. Utilize Dependency Management for Bootstrap: Employ tools like npm, yarn, or Composer to manage Bootstrap as a project dependency.
    2. Monitor Bootstrap Security Advisories: Subscribe to Bootstrap's official security channels (website, GitHub releases, security mailing lists) to receive notifications about new releases and security patches.
    3. Test Bootstrap Updates: Before deploying updates, thoroughly test them in a non-production environment to ensure compatibility with your application and identify any regressions introduced by the Bootstrap update.
    4. Apply Bootstrap Updates Promptly: Once tested, apply Bootstrap updates, especially security patches, to your production environment as soon as possible to remediate known vulnerabilities within the framework itself.
    5. Document Bootstrap Update History: Maintain a record of Bootstrap versions used and update history for audit trails and to track applied security fixes.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Bootstrap Framework Vulnerabilities (High Severity): Outdated Bootstrap versions may contain known security vulnerabilities within Bootstrap's CSS or JavaScript code that attackers can exploit in client-side attacks. Regular updates patch these framework-specific vulnerabilities.
    • Exposure to Unpatched Bootstrap Issues (Medium Severity): Delaying updates increases the time window where your application is vulnerable to publicly disclosed Bootstrap security flaws before a patch is applied.
  • Impact:
    • Bootstrap Framework Vulnerabilities: High Impact - Directly eliminates known vulnerabilities within the Bootstrap framework, significantly reducing the risk of exploits targeting Bootstrap itself.
    • Exposure to Unpatched Bootstrap Issues: Medium Impact - Minimizes the period of vulnerability to newly discovered Bootstrap flaws, reducing the likelihood of exploitation in the immediate term.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Dependency management using npm for Bootstrap is in place. Manual quarterly checks for Bootstrap updates are performed.
    • Location: package.json file, project deployment guide.
  • Missing Implementation: Automated Bootstrap update checks and security vulnerability scanning for Bootstrap dependencies are missing. Update frequency should be increased to monthly for security patches.

Mitigation Strategy: Specific Bootstrap Version Pinning

  • Description:
    1. Define Exact Bootstrap Version: In your project's dependency file (e.g., package.json), specify the precise Bootstrap version number (e.g., "bootstrap": "5.3.0") instead of using version ranges or wildcards.
    2. Control Bootstrap Updates: Avoid automatic minor or patch updates of Bootstrap by using exact versioning. Updates should be a deliberate and tested process.
    3. Explicitly Update Bootstrap Version: When a Bootstrap update is desired, manually change the version number in the dependency file to the target version.
    4. Test After Bootstrap Version Changes: After any Bootstrap version modification, conduct thorough testing to ensure compatibility and identify any issues arising from the Bootstrap version change.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unexpected Bootstrap Behavior Changes (Medium Severity): Automatic minor or patch updates in Bootstrap (when using version ranges) could introduce subtle changes in Bootstrap's CSS or JavaScript behavior that might unintentionally impact application functionality or introduce unforeseen security issues due to changed framework behavior. Pinning prevents these unexpected framework-level changes.
    • Inconsistent Bootstrap Versions Across Environments (Low Severity): Version ranges can lead to different Bootstrap versions being used in development, staging, and production environments, potentially causing inconsistencies and making it harder to reproduce and debug issues related to Bootstrap's behavior.
  • Impact:
    • Unexpected Bootstrap Behavior Changes: Medium Impact - Prevents unexpected changes in Bootstrap's behavior that could indirectly lead to security vulnerabilities or application instability due to framework-level modifications.
    • Inconsistent Bootstrap Versions Across Environments: Low Impact - Ensures consistent Bootstrap framework behavior across all environments, simplifying development, testing, and deployment, and reducing potential environment-specific issues related to Bootstrap.
  • Currently Implemented: Implemented. package.json specifies an exact Bootstrap version.
    • Location: package.json file.
  • Missing Implementation: No missing implementation. This strategy is currently well implemented for Bootstrap version control.

Mitigation Strategy: Customized Bootstrap Build

  • Description:
    1. Analyze Bootstrap Component Usage: Determine precisely which Bootstrap CSS and JavaScript components are actively used within your application's front-end.
    2. Configure Bootstrap Customization: Utilize Bootstrap's customization features (Sass variables, _custom.scss, JavaScript build configuration) to selectively include only the necessary Bootstrap modules and exclude unused components.
    3. Generate Optimized Bootstrap Assets: Employ a build process (e.g., using Sass compilation, Webpack, or Parcel) to create a tailored Bootstrap CSS and JavaScript bundle containing only the selected components.
    4. Deploy Customized Bootstrap Build: Integrate and deploy the optimized, customized Bootstrap build with your application, replacing the full default Bootstrap distribution.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Reduced Bootstrap Attack Surface (Low Severity): By excluding unused Bootstrap CSS and JavaScript components, you minimize the amount of Bootstrap code included in your application. This reduces the potential attack surface by removing code that is not actively required and could theoretically contain vulnerabilities, even if those components are not directly used.
    • Improved Performance of Bootstrap Assets (Low Severity): Smaller, customized Bootstrap CSS and JavaScript files result in faster download and parsing times in the browser, leading to improved page load performance. While primarily a performance benefit, faster loading can indirectly reduce the impact of some denial-of-service attempts.
  • Impact:
    • Reduced Bootstrap Attack Surface: Low Impact - While beneficial as a defense-in-depth measure, the direct security impact of unused Bootstrap code is typically low unless a vulnerability exists in an unused component and is somehow indirectly triggered.
    • Improved Performance of Bootstrap Assets: Low Impact - Primarily improves performance, with a minor indirect security benefit from reduced asset size.
  • Currently Implemented: Not implemented. The application currently uses the full, default Bootstrap CSS and JavaScript bundles from a CDN.
    • Location: N/A
  • Missing Implementation: Implementation of a customized Bootstrap build process is needed. This requires setting up a build pipeline and configuring Bootstrap customization, likely using Sass variables or selective imports within a build tool configuration.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure CDN Usage with SRI for Bootstrap

  • Description:
    1. Select a Reputable Bootstrap CDN: Choose a well-established and trustworthy CDN provider specifically for hosting Bootstrap files (e.g., jsDelivr, cdnjs).
    2. Enforce HTTPS for Bootstrap CDN URLs: Always use HTTPS URLs when referencing Bootstrap CSS and JavaScript files from the CDN to ensure encrypted communication and prevent man-in-the-middle attacks during Bootstrap asset delivery.
    3. Generate SRI Hashes for Bootstrap Files: For each Bootstrap CSS and JavaScript file loaded from the CDN, generate its Subresource Integrity (SRI) hash. Tools are available online and via command-line for SRI hash generation.
    4. Implement SRI Attributes in HTML for Bootstrap: Add the integrity attribute along with the generated SRI hash and crossorigin="anonymous" attribute to the <link> and <script> tags in your HTML that load Bootstrap files from the CDN.
    5. Periodically Verify Bootstrap SRI Hashes (Optional): Regularly re-calculate and compare the SRI hashes against the CDN-hosted Bootstrap files to ensure file integrity and detect any potential unauthorized modifications on the CDN.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Compromised Bootstrap CDN (Medium Severity): If the CDN hosting Bootstrap files is compromised by an attacker, they could replace legitimate Bootstrap files with malicious versions. SRI ensures that the browser only executes Bootstrap files if their content matches the expected SRI hash, preventing execution of tampered Bootstrap code from a compromised CDN.
    • Man-in-the-Middle Attacks on Bootstrap Delivery (Low Severity): While HTTPS protects against MITM attacks on the network path, SRI provides an additional layer of defense specifically for Bootstrap assets by verifying the integrity of the Bootstrap files received by the browser, even if HTTPS is bypassed or compromised.
  • Impact:
    • Compromised Bootstrap CDN: Medium Impact - Effectively mitigates the risk of executing malicious or altered Bootstrap code originating from a compromised CDN, ensuring the integrity of the Bootstrap framework used by the application.
    • Man-in-the-Middle Attacks on Bootstrap Delivery: Low Impact - Provides defense-in-depth against MITM attacks specifically targeting the delivery of Bootstrap assets, adding an extra layer of security beyond HTTPS for Bootstrap framework integrity.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Bootstrap is loaded from a reputable CDN (jsDelivr) using HTTPS.
    • Location: HTML templates.
  • Missing Implementation: SRI hashes are not currently implemented in the <link> and <script> tags for Bootstrap CDN resources. SRI attributes need to be added to the HTML templates to enable integrity verification for Bootstrap files.

Mitigation Strategy: Input Sanitization for Bootstrap Components Displaying Dynamic Content

  • Description:
    1. Identify Bootstrap Components with Dynamic Content: Pinpoint all instances where Bootstrap components (e.g., modals, tooltips, popovers, alerts, cards, lists) are used to display user-provided data or any dynamically generated content.
    2. Choose Bootstrap-Contextual Sanitization: Select a sanitization method appropriate for the type of content being displayed within Bootstrap components. This might involve HTML encoding for simple text display or a more robust HTML sanitization library if HTML content is allowed within Bootstrap components.
    3. Sanitize Before Rendering in Bootstrap Components: Implement sanitization logic to process user inputs or dynamic content before it is inserted into Bootstrap components for display. Sanitize data on the server-side whenever feasible. If client-side sanitization is necessary, use a well-vetted sanitization library.
    4. Context-Specific Sanitization for Bootstrap: Apply different sanitization rules depending on how the content is used within the Bootstrap component. For example, sanitization for text within a Bootstrap button might differ from sanitization for HTML content within a Bootstrap modal body.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Bootstrap Components (High Severity): Improper handling of user input displayed within Bootstrap components can lead to XSS vulnerabilities. Attackers can inject malicious scripts that are then rendered within Bootstrap elements, potentially compromising user sessions or data.
  • Impact:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Bootstrap Components: High Impact - Effectively prevents XSS vulnerabilities that could arise from displaying unsanitized user input within Bootstrap components, protecting users from script injection attacks targeting Bootstrap-rendered content.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Basic output encoding is used in some areas, but consistent sanitization specifically for dynamic content within Bootstrap components is lacking.
    • Location: Scattered throughout codebase, server-side templating, some client-side JavaScript.
  • Missing Implementation: Consistent and comprehensive input sanitization is missing, particularly for dynamic content rendered within Bootstrap components like modals, tooltips, and popovers. Dedicated HTML sanitization libraries are not consistently used for Bootstrap-related dynamic content. A systematic review and implementation of sanitization for all Bootstrap components displaying dynamic data is required.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure JavaScript Interactions with Bootstrap JavaScript Components

  • Description:
    1. Review Custom JavaScript Interacting with Bootstrap: Thoroughly examine all custom JavaScript code that interacts with Bootstrap's JavaScript components (e.g., event handlers attached to Bootstrap elements, JavaScript code manipulating Bootstrap components programmatically).
    2. Avoid Insecure JavaScript Practices with Bootstrap: Minimize or eliminate inline JavaScript event handlers directly attached to Bootstrap elements in HTML. Prefer attaching event listeners in separate JavaScript files for better security management and auditability.
    3. Validate Data Passed to Bootstrap JavaScript: If programmatically providing data to Bootstrap JavaScript components (e.g., via JavaScript options or data attributes), rigorously validate and sanitize this data to prevent injection vulnerabilities that could be triggered through Bootstrap's JavaScript functionality.
    4. Secure Event Handlers for Bootstrap Events: Ensure that event handlers attached to Bootstrap JavaScript events are secure and do not introduce vulnerabilities. Avoid directly executing user-provided data or dynamically constructing code within Bootstrap event handlers.
    5. Security Audits of Bootstrap JavaScript Interactions: Include JavaScript code that interacts with Bootstrap's JavaScript components in regular security code reviews and audits, specifically looking for potential vulnerabilities arising from these interactions.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • DOM-based XSS through Bootstrap JavaScript (Medium Severity): Insecure JavaScript interactions with Bootstrap's JavaScript components can create DOM-based XSS vulnerabilities. Attackers might manipulate Bootstrap's JavaScript APIs or events to inject and execute malicious scripts within the client-side DOM, exploiting vulnerabilities in how custom JavaScript interacts with the Bootstrap framework's JavaScript.
    • Logic Flaws in Bootstrap-Related JavaScript (Low to Medium Severity): Poorly written custom JavaScript that interacts with Bootstrap components can introduce logic flaws that might be exploitable or lead to unexpected behavior, potentially creating security loopholes or usability issues related to Bootstrap's functionality.
  • Impact:
    • DOM-based XSS through Bootstrap JavaScript: Medium Impact - Significantly reduces the risk of DOM-based XSS vulnerabilities originating from insecure custom JavaScript interactions with Bootstrap's JavaScript components, protecting against client-side script injection attacks targeting Bootstrap's JavaScript functionality.
    • Logic Flaws in Bootstrap-Related JavaScript: Low to Medium Impact - Improves the overall robustness and security of the application by reducing the likelihood of exploitable logic flaws in custom JavaScript code that interacts with Bootstrap, enhancing the security and reliability of Bootstrap-enhanced features.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Code reviews are conducted, but specific focus on secure JavaScript interactions with Bootstrap components is not consistently emphasized. Inline JavaScript is generally avoided.
    • Location: JavaScript files, code review process documentation.
  • Missing Implementation: Specific guidelines and developer training on secure JavaScript coding practices when interacting with Bootstrap JavaScript components are needed. Automated static analysis tools to detect potential DOM-based XSS vulnerabilities in JavaScript code interacting with Bootstrap are not currently used. Dedicated security reviews focusing on these interactions are recommended.