Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
234 lines (213 loc) · 20.8 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

234 lines (213 loc) · 20.8 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for vercel/next.js

Mitigation Strategy: Input Sanitization and Validation in Server Components and API Routes (Next.js Context)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Input Sanitization and Validation (Next.js Server-Side)
  • Description:
    1. Focus on Next.js Entry Points: Specifically target Server Components and Next.js API routes as primary entry points for user input.
    2. Utilize Next.js Context: Within Server Components and API route handlers, implement validation and sanitization logic for all request parameters, body data, and headers.
    3. Leverage Server-Side Libraries: Use server-side validation libraries compatible with Next.js environment (Node.js) like zod, joi, or built-in Node.js modules for input validation.
    4. Parameterized Queries in API Routes: When API routes interact with databases, strictly use parameterized queries or ORMs (like Prisma, often used with Next.js) to prevent SQL injection.
    5. Sanitization in Server Rendering: In Server Components, sanitize user inputs before rendering them into HTML to prevent XSS vulnerabilities during server-side rendering.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) - Severity: High
    • SQL Injection - Severity: High
    • Command Injection - Severity: High
    • LDAP Injection - Severity: Medium
    • XML Injection - Severity: Medium
    • Data Integrity Issues - Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • XSS: High reduction - Prevents malicious scripts from being injected and executed, especially during server rendering in Next.js.
    • SQL Injection: High reduction - Prevents database manipulation via API routes in Next.js.
    • Command/LDAP/XML Injection: Medium to High reduction - Mitigates injection attacks through server-side input handling in Next.js.
    • Data Integrity Issues: Medium reduction - Ensures data processed by Next.js server components and API routes is valid.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • Partially implemented in API routes using basic input validation in route handlers for user registration and login forms within Next.js API routes. Parameterized queries are used with Prisma ORM in API routes.
    • Basic sanitization is applied to user comments in blog posts rendered server-side using Next.js Server Components.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Comprehensive validation is missing in Server Components that handle form submissions (contact forms, profile updates) within Next.js application.
    • Sanitization is not consistently applied across all Server Components rendering user-generated content in Next.js.
    • No validation is implemented for file uploads in Next.js API routes.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Handling of Server-Side Data and Secrets (Next.js Context)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Secure Secret Management using Next.js Configuration
  • Description:
    1. Utilize Next.js Environment Variables: Store secrets as environment variables, leveraging Next.js's environment variable handling.
    2. Differentiate Server-Side and Client-Side Variables (Next.js Convention): Strictly adhere to Next.js convention of prefixing client-side variables with NEXT_PUBLIC_ to ensure server-side secrets are not exposed client-side.
    3. Leverage serverRuntimeConfig and publicRuntimeConfig (Next.js Feature): Utilize Next.js's serverRuntimeConfig for storing sensitive secrets accessible only server-side and publicRuntimeConfig for public configuration.
    4. Secure Deployment Platform Configuration: In production, use secure secret management features provided by your Next.js hosting platform (e.g., Vercel, Netlify environment variables or secret management).
    5. Minimize Client-Side Data Exposure (Next.js Rendering): When using Server Components and API routes, carefully control data passed to Client Components to avoid unintentional exposure of server-side secrets or sensitive data in the client-side bundle.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exposure of Secrets - Severity: High
    • Unauthorized Access to Backend Systems - Severity: High
    • Data Breaches - Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • Exposure of Secrets: High reduction - Prevents secrets from being included in client-side JavaScript bundles in Next.js applications.
    • Unauthorized Access: High reduction - Protects backend systems by keeping credentials server-side within Next.js environment.
    • Data Breaches: Medium reduction - Reduces risk by securing access to sensitive resources via properly managed secrets in Next.js.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • API keys for third-party services are stored as environment variables, following Next.js conventions.
    • Database credentials are managed through environment variables and accessed by Prisma within Next.js API routes.
    • NEXT_PUBLIC_ prefix is used for client-side accessible variables as per Next.js guidelines.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • serverRuntimeConfig and publicRuntimeConfig are not fully utilized for managing different configuration types in Next.js.
    • No dedicated secret management solution beyond platform environment variables is used in production for Next.js application.
    • Review needed to ensure no sensitive server-side data is inadvertently passed to Client Components during Next.js rendering.

Mitigation Strategy: Robust Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) Prevention in Client Components (Next.js Context)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Client-Side XSS Prevention with Next.js Features
  • Description:
    1. Implement Content Security Policy (CSP) in next.config.js: Configure CSP headers directly within next.config.js to control resource loading for the entire Next.js application.
    2. Escape User-Generated Content in React/JSX (Next.js Rendering): Utilize React's JSX escaping mechanisms within Client Components, which are the primary client-side rendering units in Next.js. Avoid dangerouslySetInnerHTML.
    3. Leverage Next.js Ecosystem Libraries: Consider using libraries within the Next.js ecosystem that aid in sanitization, like DOMPurify integrated into Client Components.
    4. Regular Next.js and Dependency Updates: Keep Next.js itself and all dependencies updated to benefit from security patches and best practices within the Next.js ecosystem.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) - Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • XSS: High reduction - CSP, configured via next.config.js, provides a strong layer of defense. React/JSX escaping and ecosystem libraries further minimize XSS risks in Next.js Client Components.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • Basic escaping of user-generated content is used in Client Components displaying comments and forum posts within Next.js application.
    • React's JSX is used throughout Next.js application for rendering.
    • npm audit is run occasionally, but Next.js and dependency updates are not consistently prioritized.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • CSP headers are not configured in next.config.js for the Next.js application.
    • DOMPurify or similar advanced sanitization library is not used in Client Components for handling potentially rich user-generated content in Next.js.
    • Dependency update process for Next.js and related libraries needs to be formalized and made more regular.

Mitigation Strategy: Authentication and Authorization for API Routes (Next.js Context)

  • Mitigation Strategy: API Route Authentication and Authorization in Next.js
  • Description:
    1. Utilize Next.js API Routes for Backend Logic: Leverage Next.js API routes as the primary backend endpoints requiring authentication and authorization.
    2. Implement Middleware in API Routes (Next.js Feature): Create Next.js middleware functions to handle authentication logic for API routes. This middleware can verify JWTs, session cookies, etc.
    3. Authorization Logic in API Route Handlers: Implement authorization checks within Next.js API route handlers to control access based on user roles or permissions.
    4. Secure Credential Storage (Backend for Next.js): If using session-based auth or storing credentials, ensure secure backend storage practices are followed for the Next.js application's authentication system.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Access - Severity: High
    • Data Breaches - Severity: High
    • Privilege Escalation - Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Access: High reduction - Protects Next.js API routes from unauthorized access.
    • Data Breaches: High reduction - Limits access to sensitive data exposed through Next.js API routes.
    • Privilege Escalation: Medium reduction - Authorization in API routes helps prevent unauthorized actions within Next.js backend.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • JWT-based authentication is implemented for user login and API access to Next.js API routes.
    • Authentication middleware is used to protect API routes related to user profiles and settings in Next.js.
    • Basic role-based authorization is implemented for admin functionalities within Next.js API routes.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • More granular authorization logic is needed for different resources and actions within Next.js API routes.
    • Authorization checks are not consistently applied across all protected Next.js API routes.
    • No formal audit of authentication and authorization logic in Next.js API routes has been conducted recently.

Mitigation Strategy: Rate Limiting and Request Throttling for API Routes (Next.js Context)

  • Mitigation Strategy: API Route Rate Limiting in Next.js
  • Description:
    1. Target Next.js API Routes: Implement rate limiting specifically for Next.js API routes to protect them from abuse.
    2. Utilize Middleware for Rate Limiting (Next.js Feature): Create Next.js middleware to apply rate limiting logic to API routes. Libraries like express-rate-limit can be adapted for Next.js custom servers, or platform-specific rate limiting (e.g., Vercel Edge Functions).
    3. Configure Rate Limits for API Endpoints: Define rate limits tailored to different Next.js API routes based on their criticality and expected traffic.
    4. Handle Rate Limit Responses in API Routes: Ensure Next.js API routes return appropriate 429 status codes and informative messages when rate limits are exceeded.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Denial of Service (DoS) - Severity: High
    • Brute-Force Attacks - Severity: Medium
    • API Abuse - Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • DoS: High reduction - Protects Next.js API routes from DoS attacks.
    • Brute-Force Attacks: Medium reduction - Slows down brute-force attempts against login or other sensitive Next.js API endpoints.
    • API Abuse: Medium reduction - Limits abuse of Next.js API resources.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • Basic rate limiting is implemented on the login API route using middleware in Next.js, based on IP address.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Rate limiting is not implemented for other critical Next.js API routes (registration, password reset, data retrieval).
    • Rate limiting is not differentiated for authenticated/unauthenticated users in Next.js API routes.
    • More sophisticated rate limiting strategies are not implemented for Next.js API routes.
    • Monitoring of rate limiting effectiveness for Next.js API routes is not in place.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Image Optimization Configuration (Next.js Feature)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Secure Next.js Image Optimization Configuration
  • Description:
    1. Configure next.config.js Image Settings: Harden image optimization settings within the images section of next.config.js.
    2. Restrict formats in next.config.js: Limit allowed image formats using the formats option in next.config.js to reduce potential attack surface.
    3. Consider minimumCacheTTL in next.config.js: Configure minimumCacheTTL in next.config.js to manage caching behavior related to image optimization.
    4. dangerouslyAllowSVG in next.config.js (Avoid if possible): If SVG support is needed, use dangerouslyAllowSVG: true in next.config.js with extreme caution and implement server-side SVG sanitization. Ideally, avoid user-uploaded SVGs.
    5. Utilize Image CDN with Next.js Image Optimization: Integrate a trusted Image CDN with Next.js Image Optimization for enhanced security and offload image processing.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Image Processing Vulnerabilities - Severity: Medium
    • Denial of Service (Resource Exhaustion) - Severity: Medium
    • SVG-based XSS (if SVG allowed) - Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Image Processing Vulnerabilities: Medium reduction - Restricting formats and using CDN reduces risks associated with Next.js image optimization.
    • DoS (Resource Exhaustion): Medium reduction - Limiting formats helps prevent resource exhaustion during Next.js image processing.
    • SVG-based XSS: Medium reduction (if SVG allowed, otherwise High reduction by disallowing) - Secure SVG handling in Next.js mitigates XSS risks. Disallowing SVGs eliminates this risk.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • Default Next.js image optimization configuration is used in next.config.js.
    • Allowed image formats are not explicitly restricted in next.config.js.
    • dangerouslyAllowSVG is set to false (default) in next.config.js.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • next.config.js image configuration needs to be reviewed and hardened for Next.js application.
    • Allowed image formats should be restricted in next.config.js.
    • Consideration should be given to using a dedicated image CDN with Next.js Image Optimization.

Mitigation Strategy: Middleware Specific Mitigations (Next.js Feature)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Secure Next.js Middleware Implementation
  • Description:
    1. Thoroughly Review Next.js Middleware Logic: Carefully review the code in all Next.js middleware functions for potential vulnerabilities, especially in authentication, authorization, and request manipulation.
    2. Implement Robust Error Handling in Middleware: Ensure Next.js middleware functions have proper error handling to prevent information leakage or unexpected behavior.
    3. Minimize Middleware Complexity (Next.js Best Practice): Keep Next.js middleware functions concise and focused to reduce the attack surface and potential for errors.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Logic Errors in Middleware - Severity: Medium
    • Information Disclosure - Severity: Medium
    • Bypass of Security Controls - Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Logic Errors: Medium reduction - Careful review and testing of Next.js middleware reduces logic errors.
    • Information Disclosure: Medium reduction - Robust error handling in middleware prevents information leaks.
    • Bypass of Security Controls: Medium reduction - Well-designed and tested middleware ensures security controls are consistently applied in Next.js.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • Middleware is used for authentication in Next.js application.
    • Basic error handling is present in middleware functions.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Formal security review of Next.js middleware logic is needed.
    • More comprehensive error handling should be implemented in middleware.
    • Complexity of existing middleware should be reviewed and simplified where possible.

Mitigation Strategy: _next/data Endpoint Security (Next.js Feature)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Secure Data Exposure via _next/data in Next.js
  • Description:
    1. Understand Data Exposed via _next/data (Next.js Endpoint): Analyze what data is being served through the _next/data endpoint, which is used by Next.js for data fetching and revalidation.
    2. Prevent Unintentional Data Exposure: Ensure sensitive data is not unintentionally exposed through the _next/data endpoint in Next.js.
    3. Implement Access Control for Data Fetching: Implement appropriate access control and authorization logic in your Next.js application's data fetching mechanisms to prevent unauthorized access to data via _next/data.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Data Access - Severity: Medium
    • Information Disclosure - Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Data Access: Medium reduction - Prevents unauthorized access to data via Next.js _next/data endpoint.
    • Information Disclosure: Medium reduction - Reduces risk of sensitive information being unintentionally exposed through _next/data.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • Basic understanding of _next/data endpoint exists within the team.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Formal review of data exposed via _next/data endpoint is needed.
    • Explicit access control measures for data fetched and exposed via _next/data are not implemented.

Mitigation Strategy: Environment Variable Security (Next.js Context)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Secure Next.js Environment Variable Management
  • Description:
    1. Reinforce Secure Environment Variable Practices (Next.js Context): Follow secure environment variable management practices specifically within the Next.js project.
    2. Avoid Committing .env.local to Version Control (Next.js Best Practice): Strictly avoid committing .env.local or .env.production files to version control in Next.js projects.
    3. Secure Secret Management for Production (Next.js Deployment): Use secure secret management solutions provided by your Next.js hosting platform for production environment variables.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exposure of Secrets - Severity: High
    • Unauthorized Access - Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • Exposure of Secrets: High reduction - Prevents accidental exposure of secrets in version control for Next.js project.
    • Unauthorized Access: High reduction - Protects access to backend systems by securely managing credentials in Next.js deployments.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • .env.local is included in .gitignore for Next.js project.
    • Environment variables are used for configuration in development and production.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Formal process for secure secret management in production for Next.js application needs to be established beyond basic platform environment variables.

Mitigation Strategy: Routing Security (Next.js Context)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Secure Next.js Route Definition and Access Control
  • Description:
    1. Careful Route Definition in Next.js: Define routes in your Next.js application carefully, ensuring they align with intended application structure and access control requirements.
    2. Implement Access Control per Route (Next.js Middleware/Handlers): Implement access control mechanisms (authentication, authorization) for different Next.js routes using middleware or within route handlers.
    3. Avoid Overly Permissive Routing (Next.js Best Practice): Avoid overly broad or permissive routing configurations in Next.js that could expose unintended functionalities or data.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Access - Severity: Medium
    • Exposure of Unintended Functionality - Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Access: Medium reduction - Route-level access control in Next.js prevents unauthorized access to specific application sections.
    • Exposure of Unintended Functionality: Medium reduction - Careful route definition in Next.js minimizes exposure of unintended features.
  • Currently Implemented:
    • Basic route structure is defined in Next.js application.
    • Authentication middleware is applied to certain route groups.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Formal review of Next.js route definitions for security implications is needed.
    • More granular access control should be implemented for different routes and route segments in Next.js.