Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
48 lines (41 loc) · 5.88 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

48 lines (41 loc) · 5.88 KB

Threat Model Analysis for alibaba/p3c

Threat: Ruleset Tampering

  • Description: An attacker with access to the p3c ruleset configuration files (e.g., rulesets/p3c-ruleset.xml or custom rules) modifies them. The attacker disables critical security checks (e.g., those preventing SQL injection, XSS, or insecure deserialization), adds rules that permit insecure coding, or weakens existing rules by changing parameters. The attacker could be an insider or an external actor who gained unauthorized access.
  • Impact: Critical security vulnerabilities are missed, leading to the deployment of insecure code. p3c's effectiveness as a security tool is severely compromised or nullified. False negatives create a dangerous illusion of security.
  • Affected p3c Component: Ruleset configuration files (XML files), custom rule implementations (if used).
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Strict Access Control: Enforce strict access control on ruleset configuration files, limiting access to authorized personnel only (e.g., security team, designated senior developers). Use OS-level permissions and version control system access controls.
    • Version Control and Auditing: Mandatory version control (e.g., Git) for the ruleset, with detailed tracking of all changes. Regularly audit the commit history for unauthorized modifications.
    • Integrity Checks (Hashing): Calculate a cryptographic hash (e.g., SHA-256) of the ruleset file and store it securely. Automatically verify the hash during the build process to detect tampering.
    • Centralized, Read-Only Ruleset: Implement a centralized, read-only repository for the ruleset, preventing direct modification by individual developers.
    • Mandatory Change Review: Require a formal review and approval process (including security experts) for any changes to the ruleset.
    • Digital Signatures (if feasible): Digitally sign the ruleset file to guarantee its authenticity and integrity.

Threat: Malicious Plugin/Tool Distribution

  • Description: An attacker distributes a compromised version of the p3c IDE plugin (e.g., for IntelliJ IDEA or Eclipse) or the command-line tool. This malicious version could be hosted on a fake website, distributed via compromised update mechanisms, or bundled with other malware. The compromised plugin/tool might: * Silently disable security checks. * Inject malicious code into the developer's project. * Steal sensitive data (credentials, API keys) from the IDE or system. * Report false positives to obscure real vulnerabilities. * Manipulate output to hide violations.
  • Impact: Deployment of vulnerable code, compromise of developer workstations, data breaches, and potential for lateral movement within the organization's network.
  • Affected p3c Component: IDE plugin (IntelliJ IDEA plugin, Eclipse plugin, etc.), command-line tool (p3c-pmd).
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Official Sources Exclusively: Download the p3c plugin only from the official IDE marketplace (e.g., JetBrains Marketplace) or the official Alibaba p3c GitHub repository. Never use third-party sources.
    • Checksum Verification: If provided, verify the checksum (e.g., SHA-256) of the downloaded plugin/tool against the official checksum.
    • Digital Signature Verification: Ensure the plugin has a valid digital signature from Alibaba or a trusted provider. IDEs usually handle this automatically.
    • Software Composition Analysis (SCA): Use an SCA tool to scan the plugin for known vulnerabilities before installation.
    • Automatic Updates: Enable automatic updates for the plugin through the IDE's built-in update mechanism to receive security patches promptly.
    • Sandboxing (if supported): If the IDE offers sandboxing for plugins, enable it to limit the plugin's access to the system.

Threat: Exploitable Vulnerability in p3c's Code

  • Description: The p3c codebase (plugin or command-line tool) contains a vulnerability like a buffer overflow, format string vulnerability, XML External Entity (XXE) vulnerability, or insecure deserialization vulnerability. This could be in the code responsible for parsing source code, evaluating rules, or generating reports. An attacker could craft malicious code or input to trigger the vulnerability.
  • Impact: Arbitrary code execution on the developer's machine or build server, potentially leading to a complete system compromise. The attacker could gain access to sensitive data, source code, or other resources.
  • Affected p3c Component: Core parsing logic (PMD, AST parsing), rule evaluation engine, reporting module, components handling external input (especially XML parsing).
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Regular Updates: Keep the p3c plugin and command-line tool updated to the latest versions. Alibaba will likely release patches for discovered vulnerabilities.
    • Monitor Security Advisories: Actively monitor the p3c project's GitHub repository and any related security mailing lists for vulnerability announcements and patches.
    • Vulnerability Scanning (of p3c itself): If you have access to the p3c source code, consider using static analysis tools to scan it for potential vulnerabilities.
    • Input Validation (for p3c developers): (Applies to those developing or maintaining p3c) Implement rigorous input validation and sanitization in all parts of the p3c codebase that handle external input, particularly XML parsing.
    • Least Privilege: Run the p3c tool with the minimum necessary privileges. Avoid running it as an administrator or root user.