Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
83 lines (72 loc) · 9.04 KB

attack-surface.md

File metadata and controls

83 lines (72 loc) · 9.04 KB

Attack Surface Analysis for element-hq/element-android

Attack Surface: 1. Matrix Protocol Implementation Vulnerabilities

Description: Critical bugs or flaws in Element Android's implementation of the Matrix protocol. Exploitation can lead to severe security breaches, including unauthorized access and denial of service.

  • Element-Android Contribution: Element Android's codebase directly implements the Matrix protocol client logic. Vulnerabilities within this implementation are direct attack vectors.
  • Example: A buffer overflow vulnerability in Element Android's event parsing logic could be triggered by a malicious homeserver sending a specially crafted Matrix event, leading to remote code execution on the user's device.
  • Impact: Remote Code Execution, Denial of Service, Unauthorized Access, Bypassing Security Features, Information Disclosure.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Mandatory: Keep Element Android SDK updated to the latest version. Security patches for protocol implementation flaws are crucial and released in SDK updates.
      • Implement robust input validation on data received from the Matrix homeserver, even if the SDK is expected to handle it. Assume untrusted input.
      • Conduct regular security code reviews focusing on Matrix protocol handling logic within the application and SDK integration points.
    • Users:
      • Mandatory: Keep the application using Element Android updated to the latest version from trusted sources (official app stores).

Attack Surface: 2. End-to-End Encryption (E2EE) Vulnerabilities (Olm/Megolm)

Description: Critical cryptographic weaknesses or implementation flaws in how Element Android utilizes Olm and Megolm for end-to-end encryption. Exploitation can break message confidentiality.

  • Element-Android Contribution: Element Android is responsible for the correct integration and usage of Olm and Megolm libraries for encrypting and decrypting Matrix messages. Flaws in this integration directly compromise E2EE.
  • Example: A vulnerability in Element Android's Megolm session key derivation or handling could allow an attacker to recover session keys, enabling decryption of past and future messages in encrypted rooms.
  • Impact: Complete Loss of Message Confidentiality, Decryption of Encrypted Communications, Potential Mass Surveillance if widely exploited.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Mandatory: Keep Element Android SDK and underlying Olm/Megolm libraries updated. Security updates for cryptographic libraries are paramount.
      • Thoroughly audit the integration of cryptographic libraries, focusing on key management, session handling, and cryptographic operations. Consult with cryptography experts if necessary.
      • Implement robust testing and validation of E2EE functionality to ensure correct cryptographic behavior.
    • Users:
      • Mandatory: Keep the application using Element Android updated.
      • Enable and actively use end-to-end encryption for all sensitive conversations.
      • Be aware that device compromise can lead to key compromise, regardless of E2EE implementation.

Attack Surface: 3. Insecure Key Storage

Description: High risk vulnerabilities related to insecure storage of encryption keys by Element Android on the Android device. Compromised key storage allows attackers to bypass E2EE and decrypt messages.

  • Element-Android Contribution: Element Android manages and persists encryption keys locally. Insecure storage mechanisms within the SDK directly expose keys to potential compromise.
  • Example: Element Android might store encryption keys in shared preferences without proper encryption, or use weak encryption for local key storage. Malware with read access to application data could then extract these keys.
  • Impact: Compromise of Encryption Keys, Loss of Message Confidentiality, Unauthorized Access to Encrypted Communications, Potential Impersonation.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Mandatory: Utilize the Android Keystore system for secure hardware-backed key storage. This is the recommended and most secure method on Android.
      • If Android Keystore cannot be used for all key types, implement strong encryption at rest for any locally stored key material. Use robust encryption algorithms and proper key derivation techniques.
      • Enforce device security best practices by recommending users to enable strong device locks (PIN, password, biometric).
    • Users:
      • Mandatory: Enable a strong device lock (PIN, password, or biometric) on your Android device. This is crucial for protecting locally stored keys.
      • Avoid rooting or jailbreaking your Android device, as this weakens the Android security model and can compromise key storage security.
      • Be cautious about installing applications from untrusted sources, as malware can target insecure key storage.

Attack Surface: 4. Malicious Media Processing

Description: High risk vulnerabilities in Element Android's handling of media files. Processing malicious media can lead to code execution or denial of service, potentially allowing attackers to compromise the client.

  • Element-Android Contribution: Element Android is responsible for displaying and processing media received through Matrix. Vulnerabilities in its media handling libraries or processing logic are direct attack vectors.
  • Example: A specially crafted video file sent through Matrix could exploit a heap buffer overflow in the video decoding library used by Element Android. Upon rendering the video, this could lead to arbitrary code execution within the application's context.
  • Impact: Remote Code Execution, Denial of Service, Potential Data Exfiltration if code execution is achieved, Client-Side Application Compromise.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Mandatory: Keep Element Android SDK and all underlying media processing libraries updated. Security patches for media codecs are frequently released.
      • Implement robust input validation and sanitization for all media files before processing. Validate file formats, sizes, and metadata.
      • Consider using sandboxed or isolated processes for media decoding to limit the impact of potential vulnerabilities. Implement Content Security Policy (CSP) if applicable to UI rendering of media.
    • Users:
      • Recommended: Be cautious about opening media files from unknown or untrusted senders, especially if unexpected or suspicious.
      • Keep the application using Element Android updated to benefit from security fixes in media handling libraries.

Attack Surface: 5. Third-Party Library Vulnerabilities (High Impact Dependencies)

Description: High risk vulnerabilities in critical third-party libraries directly used by Element Android that could lead to significant security compromises if exploited.

  • Element-Android Contribution: Element Android depends on numerous third-party libraries for core functionalities. Vulnerabilities in these direct dependencies create attack surface within Element Android's operational context.
  • Example: A critical vulnerability (e.g., remote code execution) in a widely used networking library (like OkHttp or similar) that Element Android directly depends on could be exploited by sending malicious network traffic to the Element Android client.
  • Impact: Remote Code Execution, Denial of Service, Information Disclosure, Bypassing Security Features, depending on the nature and impact of the third-party library vulnerability.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Mandatory: Maintain a comprehensive Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) for Element Android and its direct dependencies.
      • Mandatory: Regularly scan direct dependencies for known vulnerabilities using automated vulnerability scanning tools integrated into the development pipeline.
      • Mandatory: Prioritize updating direct dependencies to the latest versions, especially when security patches are released. Implement a robust dependency management strategy.
      • Implement security code reviews focusing on the integration points with critical third-party libraries to identify potential misuse or vulnerabilities arising from library interactions.
    • Users:
      • Mandatory: Keep the application using Element Android updated. Updates often include fixes for vulnerabilities in third-party libraries.