Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
58 lines (49 loc) · 5.92 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

58 lines (49 loc) · 5.92 KB

Threat Model Analysis for element-hq/element-android

Threat: Malicious User Impersonation via Session Hijacking

  • Description: An attacker intercepts or steals a user's session token (e.g., through a compromised network, XSS on a related web service if Element session tokens are exposed there, or malware on the device) and uses it to impersonate the user within Element. The attacker could then send messages, join rooms, and access data as if they were the legitimate user. This focuses on vulnerabilities within Element's handling of the token.
  • Impact: High - Loss of confidentiality, integrity, and account control within the Element ecosystem. The attacker can read private messages, impersonate the user in conversations, and potentially damage the user's reputation.
  • Affected Component: SessionStore (and related classes handling session persistence), network communication modules (handling of access tokens). Specifically, vulnerabilities in how the session token is stored, transmitted, or validated within Element-Android could be exploited.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Ensure SessionStore uses secure storage mechanisms provided by Android (e.g., EncryptedSharedPreferences).
      • Verify that all network communication involving session tokens uses HTTPS with proper certificate validation. Crucially, ensure Element-Android itself does not leak tokens through improper logging or error handling.
      • Implement robust session management, including short-lived tokens and refresh token mechanisms.
      • Regularly audit the session handling code for vulnerabilities.
      • Monitor for and apply security updates to Element Android promptly.

Threat: Message Tampering via Cryptographic Vulnerability

  • Description: An attacker exploits a vulnerability in the Olm/Megolm cryptographic implementation within Element Android to modify the content of encrypted messages in transit or at rest (on the device). This could involve breaking the encryption, forging signatures, or manipulating key exchange due to a flaw in Element's code.
  • Impact: High - Loss of confidentiality and integrity of messages. The attacker could read, modify, or inject messages without the sender or recipient's knowledge.
  • Affected Component: OlmMachine (and related cryptographic libraries), CryptoService, RoomEventDecryption. Specifically, vulnerabilities in the implementation of the Olm and Megolm protocols, key management, or signature verification within the Element-Android codebase.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Rely on well-vetted cryptographic libraries (e.g., libolm).
      • Regularly audit the cryptographic code for vulnerabilities.
      • Monitor for and apply security updates to Element Android and its cryptographic dependencies promptly.
      • Ensure proper implementation of key verification procedures (cross-signing).
      • Consider using formal verification techniques for critical cryptographic components.

Threat: Privilege Escalation via Intent Redirection

  • Description: An attacker crafts a malicious intent that targets a vulnerable component within Element Android. If the component doesn't properly validate the intent's data, the attacker could gain elevated privileges within the Element app or potentially within the broader Android system (if Element has excessive permissions).
  • Impact: High - Potential for complete device compromise if Element-Android has vulnerabilities that allow escalation beyond its intended sandbox.
  • Affected Component: Any Activity, Service, or BroadcastReceiver within Element-Android that handles external intents without proper validation. Specifically, vulnerabilities in how intents are received, parsed, and processed by Element's code.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Implement strict input validation for all data received via intents within Element-Android.
      • Use explicit intents whenever possible to avoid unintended redirection.
      • Set the exported attribute to false for components that don't need to be accessible from other applications.
      • Regularly audit the intent handling code for vulnerabilities.
      • Follow Android's security best practices for inter-process communication. Ensure Element-Android does not request unnecessary permissions.

Threat: Compromised Dependency Attack

  • Description: A malicious actor compromises a third-party library that Element-Android depends on. This could be achieved through various means, such as submitting malicious code to an open-source repository or compromising a package manager. This is a direct threat to Element-Android's integrity.
  • Impact: High to Critical - The impact depends on the compromised dependency, but could range from data leakage to complete application compromise through the compromised Element-Android component.
  • Affected Component: Potentially any component within Element-Android that relies on the compromised dependency.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Use a dependency management system that supports vulnerability scanning (e.g., Dependabot, Snyk).
      • Pin dependencies to specific versions to prevent automatic updates to potentially compromised versions.
      • Regularly audit dependencies for known vulnerabilities.
      • Consider using a private repository for critical dependencies.
      • Implement Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) practices.