Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
44 lines (39 loc) · 4.1 KB

attack-surface.md

File metadata and controls

44 lines (39 loc) · 4.1 KB

Attack Surface Analysis for jakewharton/timber

Attack Surface: 1. Log Injection/Manipulation

  • Description: Attackers inject malicious content into log entries by exploiting insufficient input validation or encoding when user-supplied data is used in logging statements.
    • How Timber Contributes: Timber is the direct mechanism through which the injected data is written to the logs. While the root cause is improper input handling, Timber is the point of execution for the malicious input.
    • Example: 
      String userInput = request.getParameter("comment"); // Untrusted input
Timber.e("Failed to process comment: " + userInput); // Vulnerable!
//If userInput contains:  "; DROP TABLE users; --" or javascript code
    • Impact:
      • Log Forgery (creating false entries, potentially to cover tracks)
      • Log Poisoning (disrupting log analysis, potentially leading to DoS of analysis tools)
      • Indirect Data Exfiltration (revealing sensitive data if it's already present in memory due to other vulnerabilities)
      • Indirect Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) if logs are displayed in a web UI without proper escaping (vulnerability in the viewer, but Timber is the conduit).
    • Risk Severity: High (Potentially Critical if it leads to data exfiltration or XSS in a sensitive context).
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Input Validation: Rigorously validate all user-supplied data before using it anywhere, including logging. Use whitelisting where possible. This is the most important mitigation.
      • Output Encoding: Encode data appropriately for the logging context (e.g., escaping special characters).
      • Parameterized Logging: Always use Timber's parameterized logging: Timber.e("Failed to process comment: %s", userInput); This prevents the direct concatenation of untrusted input.
      • Avoid Logging Sensitive Data: Minimize logging of sensitive information to reduce the impact of any potential exposure.

Attack Surface: 2. Information Disclosure via Overly Verbose Logging

  • Description: Sensitive information (PII, credentials, internal system details) is inadvertently exposed in log files due to excessive or careless logging.
    • How Timber Contributes: Timber is the direct tool used to write the sensitive information to the logs. The vulnerability is in the decision of what to log, but Timber executes that decision.
    • Example: 
      Timber.d("User object: " + user.toString()); // If user object contains sensitive data (PII, etc.).
Timber.e("Database connection error", exception); // If exception contains a connection string with a password.
    • Impact:
      • Exposure of PII (leading to privacy breaches and potential legal consequences)
      • Exposure of Internal System Details (aiding attackers in understanding the system and finding further vulnerabilities)
      • Exposure of Credentials (passwords, API keys – a critical security risk)
    • Risk Severity: High (Potentially Critical depending on the specific data exposed; credential exposure is always critical).
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Data Minimization: Log only the information that is absolutely essential for debugging and operational needs. Err on the side of logging less.
      • Data Masking/Redaction: Implement mechanisms to mask or redact sensitive data before it is passed to Timber. This might involve custom formatters or pre-processing steps. This is a crucial mitigation.
      • Code Review: Thoroughly review code (and any libraries used) to identify and prevent the logging of sensitive data. Make this a standard part of the code review process.
      • Security Audits: Regularly audit logging practices and log content to ensure compliance with security policies and to detect any accidental exposure.