Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
144 lines (114 loc) · 14.9 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

144 lines (114 loc) · 14.9 KB

Deep Analysis of Realm Kotlin Security Considerations

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

Objective: To conduct a thorough security analysis of the key components of the realm-kotlin library, identifying potential vulnerabilities, assessing their impact, and proposing actionable mitigation strategies. This analysis focuses on the library's design, implementation, and interaction with the underlying operating system and potential external services (like Realm Cloud, if used).

Scope:

  • Core Realm Kotlin Library: This includes the API, Object Store, Query Engine, Kotlin Native/JVM Bindings, and the interaction with the underlying C++ Core Database.
  • Data at Rest: Security of data stored locally on the device.
  • Data in Transit: Security of data during synchronization (if Realm Sync is used – this will be a secondary focus, as the primary focus is the local database).
  • Build Process: Security of the build pipeline and generated artifacts.
  • Dependencies: Analysis of the security implications of third-party libraries.
  • Deployment: Focus on the embedded deployment model within mobile applications (Android/iOS).

Methodology:

  1. Code Review (Inferred): While direct access to the entire codebase isn't available, we'll infer security practices based on the provided design document, GitHub repository structure, contribution guidelines, and publicly available information. We'll assume best practices are followed unless evidence suggests otherwise.
  2. Architecture Analysis: We'll analyze the C4 diagrams and element lists to understand the data flow, component interactions, and potential attack surfaces.
  3. Threat Modeling: We'll identify potential threats based on the identified components, data flows, and known vulnerabilities in similar database systems.
  4. Vulnerability Assessment: We'll assess the likelihood and impact of identified threats, considering existing security controls.
  5. Mitigation Recommendations: We'll propose specific, actionable mitigation strategies tailored to realm-kotlin to address identified vulnerabilities.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

  • API:

    • Threats: Injection attacks (if query language is not properly sanitized), unauthorized access to data (if API methods are not properly secured), denial-of-service (DoS) attacks (if API calls are not rate-limited).
    • Implications: Data breaches, data corruption, application instability.
    • Mitigation:
      • Strict Input Validation: Rigorously validate all inputs to the API, including data types, lengths, and formats. Use parameterized queries or a type-safe query API to prevent injection vulnerabilities. This is crucial for any query building functionality.
      • Secure by Default: Design the API to be secure by default, requiring explicit configuration to enable potentially risky features.
      • Rate Limiting: Implement rate limiting on API calls to prevent DoS attacks.

  • Object Store:

    • Threats: Data corruption (due to bugs in serialization/deserialization), unauthorized access to data (if encryption is not properly implemented or keys are compromised), data tampering (if integrity checks are insufficient).
    • Implications: Data loss, data breaches, application instability.
    • Mitigation:
      • Robust Serialization/Deserialization: Use a secure and well-tested serialization/deserialization mechanism to prevent data corruption. Consider using a format that is resistant to injection vulnerabilities.
      • Comprehensive Encryption at Rest: Implement strong encryption at rest using industry-standard algorithms (e.g., AES-256 with a secure key derivation function). Ensure that encryption keys are securely managed and protected. This is a critical area for Realm Kotlin.
      • Data Integrity Checks: Implement data integrity checks (e.g., checksums, MACs) to detect and prevent data tampering.

  • Query Engine:

    • Threats: Injection attacks (if the query language is not properly sanitized), denial-of-service (DoS) attacks (through resource exhaustion with complex queries).
    • Implications: Data breaches, data corruption, application instability.
    • Mitigation:
      • Prevent Query Injection: The most critical mitigation here. Use parameterized queries or a type-safe query API (like Kotlin's type-safe builders) to completely eliminate the possibility of injection attacks. Avoid any string concatenation or interpolation when building queries.
      • Query Optimization and Resource Limits: Optimize query execution to minimize resource consumption. Implement limits on query complexity and execution time to prevent DoS attacks.

  • Core Database (C++):

    • Threats: Buffer overflows, memory corruption vulnerabilities, logic errors, vulnerabilities inherited from underlying libraries. This is a high-risk area due to the use of C++.
    • Implications: Code execution, data breaches, data corruption, application crashes.
    • Mitigation:
      • Rigorous Code Review and Testing: Conduct thorough code reviews and extensive testing (including fuzz testing, static analysis, and dynamic analysis) of the C++ code.
      • Memory Safety: Use memory-safe techniques and tools (e.g., AddressSanitizer, MemorySanitizer) to detect and prevent memory corruption vulnerabilities.
      • Regular Audits: Conduct regular security audits of the C++ codebase.
      • Vulnerability Scanning: Use static and dynamic analysis tools to scan for known vulnerabilities.

  • Kotlin Native/JVM Bindings:

    • Threats: Data type confusion, memory corruption vulnerabilities during data marshalling, vulnerabilities in the JNI (Java Native Interface) or Kotlin/Native interop layer.
    • Implications: Code execution, data breaches, data corruption, application crashes.
    • Mitigation:
      • Careful Data Marshalling: Implement careful data marshalling between Kotlin and C++ to prevent data type confusion and memory corruption. Use well-defined data structures and avoid manual memory management.
      • Secure Interop Practices: Follow secure coding practices for JNI and Kotlin/Native interop. Validate all data passed between Kotlin and C++.
      • Testing: Thoroughly test the bindings to ensure data integrity and security.

  • File System (Deployment):

    • Threats: Unauthorized access to Realm files (if file system permissions are not properly configured), data tampering (if the file system is compromised).
    • Implications: Data breaches, data corruption.
    • Mitigation:
      • Secure File System Permissions: Use the most restrictive file system permissions possible. On Android, store Realm files in the application's private storage directory. On iOS, use appropriate data protection APIs.
      • OS-Level Encryption: Leverage OS-level encryption (e.g., FileVault on macOS, device encryption on Android and iOS) to provide an additional layer of protection. This is crucial, as it protects the data even if the device is compromised.
      • Realm Encryption: Even with OS-level encryption, Realm's own encryption is essential to protect against application-level attacks.

  • Remote Sync Service (If Used):

    • Threats: Man-in-the-middle (MITM) attacks, unauthorized access to data in transit, data breaches on the server, denial-of-service (DoS) attacks.
    • Implications: Data breaches, data corruption, service disruption.
    • Mitigation:
      • TLS/SSL: Use TLS/SSL with strong ciphers and certificate pinning to encrypt all data in transit.
      • Robust Authentication and Authorization: Implement strong authentication and authorization mechanisms on the server.
      • Server-Side Security: Follow best practices for securing the server-side infrastructure, including regular security updates, intrusion detection, and prevention systems.
      • Encryption at Rest (Server-Side): Encrypt data stored on the server.

  • Build Process:

    • Threats: Compromised build tools, malicious dependencies, insertion of malicious code during the build process.
    • Implications: Distribution of compromised software, supply chain attacks.
    • Mitigation:
      • Dependency Management: Use a dependency management system (like Gradle) to track and update dependencies. Regularly scan for known vulnerabilities in dependencies. Use tools like dependencyCheck to identify vulnerable components.
      • Software Bill of Materials (SBOM): Generate an SBOM to provide a comprehensive list of all components and dependencies.
      • Code Signing: Digitally sign all release artifacts to ensure authenticity and integrity. Verify signatures before deployment.
      • Secure Build Environment: Use a secure and isolated build environment (like GitHub Actions) to prevent tampering with the build process.
      • Reproducible Builds: Aim for reproducible builds to ensure that the same source code always produces the same binary output.

3. Architecture, Components, and Data Flow (Inferences)

Based on the C4 diagrams and element lists, we can infer the following:

  • Data Flow: User data flows from the application through the Realm Kotlin API, to the Object Store, and then to the Core Database (C++) via the Kotlin Native/JVM Bindings. The Query Engine interacts with the Object Store and Bindings to retrieve data. Data is ultimately stored in the device's file system.
  • Components: The key components are the API, Object Store, Query Engine, Core Database (C++), and Kotlin Native/JVM Bindings.
  • Attack Surfaces: The primary attack surfaces are the API (exposed to the application), the Query Engine (potential for injection attacks), the Bindings (potential for memory corruption), and the File System (potential for unauthorized access). If Realm Sync is used, the network connection and the remote server become additional attack surfaces.

4. Tailored Security Considerations and Mitigation Strategies

Given the focus on realm-kotlin as a local, embedded database, the following are critical security considerations and mitigation strategies:

  • Encryption at Rest (Highest Priority):

    • Consideration: Without robust encryption at rest, any data stored in Realm is vulnerable if the device is lost, stolen, or compromised. OS-level encryption is not sufficient, as it doesn't protect against application-level attacks.
    • Mitigation: Implement strong, transparent encryption at rest using AES-256 or a comparable algorithm. Use a secure key derivation function (e.g., PBKDF2, Argon2) to derive encryption keys from a user-provided password or a securely generated random key. Store encryption keys securely, ideally using the platform's secure storage mechanisms (e.g., Android Keystore, iOS Keychain). Ensure that encryption is enabled by default or very easy to enable. Provide clear documentation and examples for developers.

  • Query Injection Prevention (Highest Priority):

    • Consideration: If the query language allows for string concatenation or interpolation, it is highly vulnerable to injection attacks.
    • Mitigation: Absolutely prohibit string concatenation or interpolation when building queries. Use a type-safe query API (e.g., Kotlin's type-safe builders) or parameterized queries. This is non-negotiable for security. Provide clear documentation and examples to developers, emphasizing the importance of avoiding string-based query construction.

  • Secure Bindings (High Priority):

    • Consideration: The Kotlin Native/JVM bindings are a critical security boundary. Vulnerabilities here can lead to code execution.
    • Mitigation: Use memory-safe techniques and tools (e.g., AddressSanitizer, MemorySanitizer) during development and testing of the bindings. Conduct thorough code reviews and fuzz testing. Validate all data passed between Kotlin and C++.

  • Dependency Management (High Priority):

    • Consideration: Vulnerabilities in third-party libraries can be exploited to compromise Realm Kotlin.
    • Mitigation: Regularly scan for known vulnerabilities in dependencies using tools like OWASP Dependency-Check. Keep dependencies up-to-date. Consider using a software bill of materials (SBOM) to track dependencies.

  • File System Security (Medium Priority):

    • Consideration: Realm files should be protected from unauthorized access.
    • Mitigation: Store Realm files in the application's private storage directory. Use the most restrictive file system permissions possible. Encourage users to enable device-level encryption.

  • Regular Security Audits (Medium Priority):

    • Consideration: Regular security audits are essential to identify and address potential vulnerabilities.
    • Mitigation: Conduct periodic security audits (both internal and external) of the Realm Kotlin codebase, including the C++ core.

  • Fuzz Testing (Medium Priority):

    • Consideration: Fuzz testing can help identify unexpected vulnerabilities.
    • Mitigation: Expand fuzz testing to cover a wider range of inputs and edge cases, particularly for the API, Query Engine, and Bindings.

  • Security Training (Low Priority, but Recommended):

    • Consideration: Contributors should be aware of secure coding practices.
    • Mitigation: Provide security training and guidelines for all contributors.

  • Addressing the Questions:

    • Encryption Status: This needs immediate clarification. The documentation must be explicit about which platforms support encryption, which algorithms are used, and how to enable and configure encryption.
    • Security Certifications: While not always necessary, clarifying any compliance goals (HIPAA, GDPR) helps guide development and provides assurance to users.
    • Vulnerability Handling Process: A clear, publicly documented process for reporting and handling security vulnerabilities is essential for building trust. This should include a security contact (e.g., a [email protected] email address) and a defined response timeline.
    • Code Signing: Code signing must be consistently used for all release artifacts. This is a fundamental security practice.
    • Threat Models: Documenting the threat models considered during development helps ensure that security is considered proactively.

This deep analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the security considerations for realm-kotlin. The most critical areas are encryption at rest and query injection prevention. By implementing the recommended mitigation strategies, the Realm Kotlin project can significantly enhance its security posture and protect user data.