Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
131 lines (94 loc) · 15.5 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

131 lines (94 loc) · 15.5 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for rikkaapps/shizuku

Mitigation Strategy: Principle of Least Privilege for Shizuku Permissions

  • Description:

    1. Developers: Carefully review all Shizuku permissions your application requests. For each permission, rigorously justify its necessity for the intended functionality specifically within the context of using Shizuku.
    2. Minimize Permissions: Request only the absolute minimum set of Shizuku permissions required for your application to function correctly when leveraging Shizuku's capabilities. Avoid requesting broad or potentially unnecessary permissions that could grant excessive access through Shizuku.
    3. User Transparency: Clearly document and explain to users why each requested Shizuku permission is necessary. This explanation should focus on how these permissions are used in conjunction with Shizuku to enable specific features of your application. This can be done in your application's permission request dialogs, documentation, or a dedicated privacy/permissions section within the app.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Over-Permissioning via Shizuku (Medium Severity): Requesting unnecessary Shizuku permissions increases the potential damage if your application or Shizuku itself is compromised. An attacker could exploit these excessive permissions granted through Shizuku to perform actions beyond the intended scope of your application's Shizuku integration.

  • Impact:

    • Over-Permissioning via Shizuku: Medium to High reduction. By adhering to the principle of least privilege specifically for Shizuku permissions, you limit the potential impact of a security breach by restricting the attacker's access to only the necessary functionalities enabled by Shizuku.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Likely partially implemented in the sense that developers might be requesting only permissions they believe are necessary. However, a formal review and documentation specifically focused on Shizuku permissions are likely missing.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Conduct a thorough review of currently requested Shizuku permissions, specifically considering their necessity for Shizuku-related features.
    • Refactor code to minimize permission requirements if possible, especially concerning Shizuku permissions.
    • Document the justification for each requested Shizuku permission for user transparency. This documentation should clearly explain how these permissions are used in conjunction with Shizuku and should be easily accessible to users within the application or its accompanying materials.

Mitigation Strategy: User Guidance for Official Shizuku Server Installation

  • Description:

    1. Documentation/Setup Guide: Create clear, step-by-step instructions for users on how to install the official Shizuku Server application. This guidance is crucial because your application relies on Shizuku Server.
    2. Official Sources: Direct users to install Shizuku Server exclusively from trusted and official sources, such as the Google Play Store or the official Shizuku GitHub repository (rikkaapps/shizuku). Provide direct links to these sources in your documentation because your application's security is partially dependent on the integrity of the Shizuku Server installation.
    3. Warning Against Unofficial Sources: Explicitly warn users against downloading Shizuku Server from untrusted or third-party websites or app stores. Emphasize the risk of downloading modified or malicious versions of Shizuku Server from unofficial sources, which could compromise their device security and directly impact the security of your application's Shizuku integration.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Malicious Shizuku Server (High Severity): If users install a compromised or malicious version of Shizuku Server, it could act as a backdoor, granting attackers broad access to their device and potentially the elevated privileges intended for your application through the Shizuku interface.

  • Impact:

    • Malicious Shizuku Server: High reduction. Guiding users to official sources significantly reduces the risk of them installing a compromised Shizuku Server application, protecting the foundation upon which your application's Shizuku functionality relies.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • No, user guidance on official Shizuku Server installation is likely missing.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Create a dedicated section in your application's documentation or setup guide that provides clear instructions and links to official Shizuku Server sources. This is essential for secure Shizuku integration.
    • Include a warning against using unofficial sources for Shizuku Server installation, highlighting the risks specifically for applications using Shizuku.

Mitigation Strategy: Encourage Users to Keep Shizuku Server Updated

  • Description:

    1. Documentation/In-App Information: Inform users about the importance of keeping their Shizuku Server application updated to the latest version. Explain that updates often include bug fixes and security patches that are crucial for maintaining system security and the secure operation of applications using Shizuku.
    2. Update Instructions/Links: Provide clear instructions on how users can update Shizuku Server. Include direct links to the official update channels, such as the Shizuku Server Play Store page or the GitHub releases page. This makes it easy for users to maintain a secure Shizuku Server installation for your application's benefit.
    3. Periodic Reminders (Optional): Consider implementing (carefully and non-intrusively) periodic reminders within your application to encourage users to check for Shizuku Server updates, especially if security vulnerabilities are publicly disclosed for older versions. This proactive approach helps ensure users are running a secure Shizuku Server for optimal application security.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Vulnerable Shizuku Server (Medium Severity): Outdated versions of Shizuku Server may contain known security vulnerabilities. Attackers could potentially exploit these vulnerabilities to gain unauthorized access or compromise the system through the Shizuku Server, impacting applications that rely on it.

  • Impact:

    • Vulnerable Shizuku Server: Medium reduction. Encouraging updates helps users benefit from security patches and reduces the likelihood of exploitation of known vulnerabilities in Shizuku Server, thereby enhancing the security of your application's Shizuku integration.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • No, user guidance on keeping Shizuku Server updated is likely missing.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Add information about Shizuku Server updates and instructions/links to update channels in your application's documentation or a "Security Tips" section. This is important for maintaining the security of your application's Shizuku dependency.
    • Consider (with caution and user experience in mind) implementing optional, non-intrusive update reminders within the application to promote secure Shizuku Server usage for your application.

Mitigation Strategy: Input Validation and Sanitization for Shizuku Commands

  • Description:

    1. Developers: Implement robust input validation and sanitization for all data that is used to construct commands sent through Shizuku. This is critical because Shizuku executes these commands with elevated privileges. This includes data originating from user input, external sources, or any other potentially untrusted origin.
    2. Validation Rules: Define strict validation rules for expected input formats, data types, and allowed values for commands intended for Shizuku. Reject any input that does not conform to these rules to prevent malicious command construction via Shizuku.
    3. Sanitization Techniques: Sanitize input data to remove or escape any characters or sequences that could be interpreted as commands or control characters by the Shizuku Server or the underlying system when processed through Shizuku.
    4. Parameterized Commands: If Shizuku's API or the underlying system allows for parameterized commands or prepared statements, utilize these mechanisms to construct commands securely when interacting with Shizuku. Parameterization separates data from commands, preventing injection attacks through the Shizuku interface.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Command Injection via Shizuku (High Severity): If input data used in Shizuku commands is not properly validated and sanitized, attackers could inject malicious commands. Due to Shizuku's elevated privileges, successful command injection through Shizuku could allow attackers to execute arbitrary code with system-level permissions, leading to complete system compromise originating from your application's Shizuku usage.

  • Impact:

    • Command Injection via Shizuku: High reduction. Thorough input validation and sanitization are critical to prevent command injection vulnerabilities when using Shizuku and protect against this severe threat introduced by Shizuku's privileged command execution.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Needs verification. Input validation for Shizuku commands might be partially implemented, but a comprehensive and rigorous approach specifically for Shizuku command construction is crucial and needs to be confirmed.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Conduct a security review of all code paths where Shizuku commands are constructed. Focus specifically on the security of Shizuku command generation.
    • Implement robust input validation and sanitization for all relevant input data used in Shizuku commands.
    • Explore and utilize parameterized command mechanisms if available in Shizuku's API or the underlying system to further enhance security against injection attacks when communicating with Shizuku.

Mitigation Strategy: Educate Users about Shizuku's Functionality and Risks

  • Description:

    1. Documentation/In-App Information: Provide clear and concise explanations of what Shizuku is, how it works, and the security implications of using it specifically in the context of your application. Use language that is accessible to non-technical users, avoiding jargon.
    2. Trust Relationship: Emphasize that using Shizuku involves granting your application elevated privileges through the Shizuku Server. Explain that users should only grant these privileges if they trust both your application and the official Shizuku project because your application is leveraging Shizuku for enhanced functionality.
    3. Risk Disclosure: Clearly outline the potential security risks associated with using Shizuku, such as the increased attack surface and the importance of using official sources and keeping Shizuku Server updated. This risk disclosure is essential because your application's security posture is now intertwined with Shizuku's.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • User Misunderstanding of Shizuku Risks (Medium Severity): Users might grant Shizuku permissions without fully understanding the implications or the level of trust involved when using your application. This lack of understanding could lead to users unknowingly exposing themselves to security risks related to your application's Shizuku usage.

  • Impact:

    • User Misunderstanding of Shizuku Risks: Medium reduction. User education empowers users to make informed decisions about using Shizuku with your application and granting permissions, leading to more responsible usage of Shizuku-dependent features.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • No, user education about Shizuku's functionality and risks is likely missing.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Create a dedicated section in your application's documentation or a "Security and Privacy" section within the app that explains Shizuku in simple terms and outlines the associated security considerations specifically for users of your application.

Mitigation Strategy: Explicit User Consent for Shizuku Usage

  • Description:

    1. Consent Dialog: Before enabling or utilizing any Shizuku-dependent functionality, display a clear and informative consent dialog to the user. This is crucial because Shizuku grants elevated privileges to your application.
    2. Information in Dialog: The consent dialog should:
      • Explain that the application is about to use Shizuku to perform actions that require elevated privileges. Clearly state this is due to Shizuku integration.
      • Briefly reiterate the purpose of Shizuku and its role in granting these privileges. Focus on Shizuku's function in enabling your application's features.
      • Link to or summarize the user education materials about Shizuku's functionality and risks (from the previous mitigation strategy). This provides context for the consent.
      • Clearly state what specific permissions or functionalities will be enabled through Shizuku. Make it transparent what the user is consenting to in relation to Shizuku.
    3. Opt-Out Option: Provide a clear and easily accessible option for users to decline or opt-out of using Shizuku-dependent features. Your application should ideally offer alternative functionality or gracefully degrade if Shizuku is not used to respect user choice regarding Shizuku usage.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Unintentional Shizuku Usage (Low Severity): Users might unknowingly enable Shizuku features without fully understanding the implications or explicitly consenting to the use of elevated privileges granted through Shizuku to your application.
    • Lack of Informed Consent (Ethical/Privacy Concern): From an ethical and privacy perspective, users should be fully informed and explicitly agree to the use of Shizuku and the associated permissions before they are granted to your application via Shizuku.

  • Impact:

    • Unintentional Shizuku Usage: Medium reduction. Explicit consent ensures that users are consciously aware and actively agree to use Shizuku features within your application.
    • Lack of Informed Consent: High reduction. Implementing explicit consent addresses ethical and privacy concerns by ensuring users are fully informed and have control over the use of Shizuku in conjunction with your application.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • No, explicit user consent for Shizuku usage is likely missing.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Implement a consent dialog that is displayed before any Shizuku functionality is activated. This is a key step for responsible Shizuku integration.
    • Ensure the dialog contains all the necessary information as described above and provides a clear opt-out option. The dialog should be comprehensive and user-friendly.
    • Modify application logic to respect user consent and gracefully handle cases where users decline Shizuku usage. Your application should be functional even without Shizuku, or offer clear alternatives.