Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
79 lines (70 loc) · 6.75 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

79 lines (70 loc) · 6.75 KB

Threat Model Analysis for square/picasso

Threat: Insecure Image Loading from Untrusted Sources

  • Description:
    • An attacker provides a malicious URL that the application uses with Picasso.load().
    • This URL can point to:
      • Malicious Image: Crafted to exploit vulnerabilities in image processing libraries, potentially leading to remote code execution.
      • Phishing Image: Designed to deceive users into clicking malicious links or revealing sensitive information.
      • Denial of Service Image: An extremely large image that consumes excessive resources, causing application slowdown or crashes.
    • Picasso attempts to download and process the image from this attacker-controlled URL.
  • Impact:
    • Critical: Remote code execution on the user's device if an image processing vulnerability is exploited.
    • High: Application crash or instability due to image processing errors or resource exhaustion.
    • High: User exposure to phishing or social engineering attacks, potentially leading to data theft or account compromise.
  • Picasso Component Affected:
    • Picasso.load() function, RequestCreator, Network downloader, Image decoding pipeline.
  • Risk Severity: Critical to High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Strict URL Validation and Sanitization: Implement robust checks to validate and sanitize image URLs before passing them to Picasso.load(). Use allowlists of trusted domains or URL patterns.
    • Content Security Policy (CSP): If using Picasso in a WebView context, implement a strong CSP to restrict allowed image sources.
    • Input Validation: Thoroughly validate any user-provided input that influences image URLs to prevent injection of malicious URLs.
    • Regular Picasso Updates: Keep Picasso updated to the latest version to benefit from security patches and bug fixes.

Threat: Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks on Image Downloads

  • Description:
    • If the application loads images over insecure HTTP connections using Picasso, an attacker on the network can intercept the traffic.
    • The attacker can:
      • Replace Images: Substitute legitimate images with malicious images containing malware, phishing content, or misleading information.
      • Inject Malicious Content: While less common with image formats, theoretically, an attacker might attempt to inject malicious code into the image data stream.
  • Impact:
    • High: Display of malicious or inappropriate content to users, potentially leading to user device compromise or phishing attacks.
    • High: User deception and manipulation through the display of altered or misleading images.
  • Picasso Component Affected:
    • Network downloader (when used with HTTP URLs).
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Enforce HTTPS: Always use HTTPS for image URLs loaded by Picasso. Configure your application and server infrastructure to serve images exclusively over HTTPS.
    • HSTS (HTTP Strict Transport Security): Implement HSTS on your image servers to ensure clients always connect over HTTPS.
    • Certificate Pinning (Advanced): For highly sensitive applications, consider certificate pinning to further protect against MitM attacks by validating the server's SSL/TLS certificate against a known, trusted certificate.

Threat: Image Processing Vulnerabilities (Indirectly through Picasso's Dependencies)

  • Description:
    • Picasso relies on underlying image decoding and processing libraries provided by the Android platform or potentially other libraries.
    • These libraries might contain vulnerabilities such as buffer overflows, integer overflows, or other memory corruption issues when processing malformed or specially crafted images.
    • When Picasso loads and processes an attacker-crafted image, it could trigger these vulnerabilities in the underlying libraries.
  • Impact:
    • Critical: Potential for remote code execution on the user's device if a vulnerability in an image processing library is exploited.
    • High: Application crash or instability due to image processing errors.
    • High: Denial of service if image processing consumes excessive resources or leads to crashes.
  • Picasso Component Affected:
    • Image decoding pipeline (indirectly affected through underlying libraries used by Picasso).
  • Risk Severity: Critical to High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Keep Android System Updated: Ensure the underlying Android system and its image processing libraries are regularly updated with security patches provided by Google.
    • Monitor Security Advisories: Stay informed about security advisories related to image processing libraries used by Android and indirectly by Picasso.
    • Consider Image Format Restrictions (If Applicable and Practical): If feasible, limit the supported image formats to reduce the attack surface, although this might not be practical for many applications.

Threat: Denial of Service through Resource Exhaustion

  • Description:
    • An attacker can attempt to overload the application by forcing it to load a large number of images or extremely large images using Picasso.
    • This can be achieved by providing numerous image URLs or URLs pointing to very large files.
    • Picasso, in attempting to fulfill these requests, can exhaust device resources such as memory, bandwidth, and CPU.
  • Impact:
    • High: Application slowdown or unresponsiveness, leading to a degraded user experience.
    • High: Application crashes due to out-of-memory errors or excessive resource consumption.
    • High: Device battery drain due to prolonged resource utilization.
  • Picasso Component Affected:
    • Picasso.load() function, Network downloader, Memory cache, Disk cache, Image resizing and transformation pipeline.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Image Size Limits: Implement limits on the maximum size (both dimensions and file size) of images that can be loaded by Picasso.
    • Rate Limiting: Implement rate limiting on image loading requests, especially from untrusted or external sources, to prevent abuse.
    • Efficient Image Handling: Utilize Picasso's features for resizing and transformations to ensure only necessary image resolutions are loaded and processed.
    • Lazy Loading: Implement lazy loading of images, particularly in lists or grids, to load images only when they are about to become visible, reducing initial resource consumption.