Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
79 lines (60 loc) · 7.58 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

79 lines (60 loc) · 7.58 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for codermjlee/mjrefresh

Mitigation Strategy: Client-Side Rate Limiting (MJRefresh Specific)

  • Description:

    1. Initialization: When the view containing the MJRefresh control is loaded, initialize a lastRefreshTimestamp variable (e.g., using Date()) to the current time. Also, initialize a refreshAttemptCount to 0.
    2. Refresh Request: Before MJRefresh initiates a refresh (either user-triggered via beginRefreshing() or programmatically), check the lastRefreshTimestamp.
    3. Time Check: Calculate the time elapsed since lastRefreshTimestamp.
    4. Threshold: If the elapsed time is less than a predefined threshold (e.g., minimumRefreshInterval = 2.0 seconds), prevent the refresh. You might achieve this by:
      • Temporarily disabling the MJRefresh control: refreshControl.isEnabled = false. Re-enable it after the minimumRefreshInterval using a Timer.
      • Overriding or intercepting the beginRefreshing() method (if possible and safe within the library's design) to add the time check. This is more complex but avoids disabling the control visually.
      • Not calling beginRefreshing() if the time check fails. This is the simplest approach if you control all refresh triggers.
    5. Successful Refresh: If the elapsed time is greater than or equal to the threshold, allow the refresh. Update lastRefreshTimestamp to the current time after beginRefreshing() is called. Reset refreshAttemptCount to 0.
    6. Failed Refresh: If the refresh fails (and you have a way to detect this within the MJRefresh callbacks or completion handlers), increment refreshAttemptCount.
    7. Backoff: If refreshAttemptCount exceeds a threshold (e.g., 3), implement a backoff. Increase minimumRefreshInterval temporarily (e.g., double it). Consider a maximum backoff interval.
    8. Disable Control: If refreshAttemptCount exceeds a higher threshold (e.g., 5), temporarily disable the MJRefresh control entirely (refreshControl.isEnabled = false) for a longer period. Use a Timer to re-enable it.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) / Resource Exhaustion (Client & Server): (Severity: High) - Prevents rapid, repeated refresh requests initiated through the MJRefresh control.
    • Logic Errors / Unexpected Behavior: (Severity: Medium) - Reduces the likelihood of unexpected behavior caused by rapid refreshes.

  • Impact:

    • DoS/Resource Exhaustion: Significantly reduces the risk from the UI.
    • Logic Errors: Moderately reduces the risk.

  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented in ProductListViewController.swift. Basic time check is present (likely by not calling beginRefreshing() too often), but no backoff or disabling logic.

  • Missing Implementation: Backoff logic and disabling of the MJRefresh control after repeated failures are missing. Needs consistent application across all view controllers using MJRefresh: ProductListViewController.swift, UserProfileViewController.swift, and OrderHistoryViewController.swift.

Mitigation Strategy: Timeout Handling (MJRefresh Specific)

  • Description:

    1. Identify MJRefresh Triggers: Identify all places where MJRefresh's beginRefreshing() is called, and where its completion handlers are used.
    2. Network Request Association: Within the code triggered by MJRefresh (usually in the completion handler or a separate function called by it), identify the specific network requests that are initiated.
    3. Set Timeouts (Network Layer): Ensure that the underlying network requests (using URLSession, Alamofire, etc.) have appropriate timeouts set. This is not directly within MJRefresh itself, but it's critically linked to the refresh action.
    4. Handle Timeouts and Stop MJRefresh: In the network request's error handling, specifically check for timeout errors. If a timeout occurs:
      • Crucially: Call refreshControl.endRefreshing() to stop the MJRefresh animation. This is the direct link back to MJRefresh.
      • Display a user-friendly error message.
      • Optionally, implement a retry (with backoff, as per the rate limiting strategy).

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) / Resource Exhaustion (Client): (Severity: Medium) - Prevents the client (and the MJRefresh control) from being stuck indefinitely.
    • Logic Errors / Unexpected Behavior: (Severity: Low) - Avoids UI hangs due to long-running network requests triggered by the refresh.

  • Impact:

    • DoS/Resource Exhaustion: Moderately reduces the risk.
    • Logic Errors: Slightly reduces the risk.

  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Timeouts are set in the network layer (NetworkManager.swift), but the crucial step of calling refreshControl.endRefreshing() on timeout is inconsistent.

  • Missing Implementation: Consistent handling of timeouts and stopping the MJRefresh animation (refreshControl.endRefreshing()) in all completion handlers or associated functions triggered by MJRefresh across all relevant view controllers.

Mitigation Strategy: Error Handling (MJRefresh Specific)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Completion Handlers: Locate all uses of MJRefresh's completion handlers or callbacks (the code that executes after a refresh attempt, successful or not).
    2. Comprehensive Error Checks: Within these handlers, implement robust error checking. Check for all possible error conditions:
      • Network errors (no connection, timeout, DNS resolution failure, etc.).
      • Server errors (HTTP status codes 4xx, 5xx).
      • Data parsing errors (if the response data is invalid).
      • Application-specific errors.
    3. Stop Refreshing: In all error cases, call refreshControl.endRefreshing() to stop the MJRefresh animation. This is the key MJRefresh-specific action.
    4. User Feedback: Display appropriate, user-friendly error messages. Avoid technical jargon or error codes.
    5. Logging: Log the errors (including details like the error type, URL, and any relevant data) for debugging and monitoring.
    6. Retry Logic (Optional): Consider implementing a retry mechanism for transient errors (e.g., network glitches), but always combine this with the rate limiting and backoff strategy to prevent hammering the server.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Logic Errors / Unexpected Behavior: (Severity: Medium) - Prevents the application from entering an inconsistent or undefined state due to unhandled errors during refresh.
    • User Experience Issues: (Severity: Medium) - Avoids displaying confusing or unhelpful UI states to the user.
    • Resource Exhaustion (minor): By stopping the refresh animation, you prevent minor resource usage.

  • Impact:

    • Logic Errors: Moderately reduces the risk.
    • User Experience: Significantly improves the user experience.

  • Currently Implemented: Inconsistently implemented. Some error handling exists, but it's not comprehensive, and refreshControl.endRefreshing() is not always called.

  • Missing Implementation: Consistent and comprehensive error handling, always including refreshControl.endRefreshing(), in all MJRefresh completion handlers across all relevant view controllers.