Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
60 lines (46 loc) · 6.51 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

60 lines (46 loc) · 6.51 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for dzenbot/dznemptydataset

Objective: To cause a denial-of-service (DoS) in an application using dznemptydataset by manipulating its data handling or type conversion mechanisms through a vulnerable dependent library.

Attack Tree Visualization

Compromise Application Using dznemptydataset
└── 1. Denial of Service (DoS) (Moderate/High/Moderate/Moderate/Moderate to High)
    └── 1.2 Triggering NumPy Errors via __array_ufunc__ / __array_function__ [HIGH RISK] (Moderate/High/Moderate/Moderate/Moderate to High)
        ├── 1.2.1 Attacker controls ufunc/function arguments (Indirectly, through a vulnerable library) [CRITICAL] (Moderate/High/Moderate/Moderate/Moderate to High)
        │   ├── 1.2.1.1 Vulnerable Library Misinterprets NotImplemented [HIGH RISK] (Moderate/High/Moderate/Moderate/Moderate to High)
        │   └── 1.2.1.2 Vulnerable Library Passes Invalid Arguments to NumPy [HIGH RISK] (Moderate/High/Moderate/Moderate/Moderate to High)

Attack Tree Path: 1. Denial of Service (DoS)

  • Overall Description: The attacker aims to disrupt the normal operation of the application, making it unavailable to legitimate users. This is achieved by exploiting how a dependent library interacts with dznemptydataset.
  • Likelihood: Moderate. This depends on the existence of a vulnerable library that misuses dznemptydataset.
  • Impact: High. A successful DoS attack can render the application unusable.
  • Effort: Moderate. The attacker needs to find a vulnerable library and craft inputs to trigger the vulnerability.
  • Skill Level: Moderate. Requires understanding of NumPy, dznemptydataset, and how to exploit vulnerabilities in other libraries.
  • Detection Difficulty: Moderate to High. Requires monitoring for application crashes and analyzing the call stack to determine if dznemptydataset and a dependent library were involved.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2 Triggering NumPy Errors via __array_ufunc__ / __array_function__ [HIGH RISK]

  • Overall Description: This is the primary attack vector. The attacker leverages the interaction between dznemptydataset and NumPy's universal functions (ufuncs) and array functions. The vulnerability lies not directly in dznemptydataset, but in how a dependent library handles the NotImplemented return value from dznemptydataset's __array_ufunc__ and __array_function__ methods.
  • Likelihood: Moderate. Relies on the presence of a vulnerable dependent library.
  • Impact: High. Triggering a NumPy error can lead to an application crash (DoS).
  • Effort: Moderate. Requires finding a vulnerable library and crafting specific inputs.
  • Skill Level: Moderate. Requires understanding of NumPy, dznemptydataset, and library interaction.
  • Detection Difficulty: Moderate to High. Requires crash analysis and potentially debugging the dependent library.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1 Attacker controls ufunc/function arguments (Indirectly, through a vulnerable library) [CRITICAL]

  • Overall Description: This is the critical control point. The attacker doesn't directly interact with dznemptydataset. Instead, they provide malicious input to a vulnerable library that uses dznemptydataset. This input is crafted to cause the vulnerable library to misuse dznemptydataset in a way that triggers the vulnerability. This is the essential step for the attacker to gain influence over the interaction.
  • Likelihood: Moderate. Depends on the existence and exploitability of a vulnerable library.
  • Impact: High. This control is necessary to trigger the subsequent steps leading to DoS.
  • Effort: Moderate. Requires identifying and exploiting a vulnerability in a dependent library.
  • Skill Level: Moderate. Requires understanding of input validation and how to exploit vulnerabilities in libraries.
  • Detection Difficulty: Moderate to High. Requires analyzing the input handling of the dependent library and tracing the flow of data to dznemptydataset.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1.1 Vulnerable Library Misinterprets NotImplemented [HIGH RISK]

  • Overall Description: The vulnerable library calls __array_ufunc__ or __array_function__ on an EmptyDataset object. dznemptydataset returns NotImplemented. The vulnerable library incorrectly handles this return value, leading to unexpected behavior, potentially a crash. For example, it might try to use the NotImplemented value as if it were a valid NumPy array, leading to a TypeError or other exception within the vulnerable library's code.
  • Likelihood: Moderate. This is a plausible error in library development.
  • Impact: High. Leads to a crash (DoS).
  • Effort: Moderate. Relies on finding a library with this specific mishandling.
  • Skill Level: Moderate. Requires understanding of how libraries should handle special return values.
  • Detection Difficulty: Moderate to High. Requires analyzing the vulnerable library's code and how it handles NotImplemented.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1.2 Vulnerable Library Passes Invalid Arguments to NumPy [HIGH RISK]

  • Overall Description: The vulnerable library, after interacting with dznemptydataset (and potentially receiving NotImplemented), proceeds to call a NumPy function. However, because of the interaction with dznemptydataset, it passes incorrect or invalid arguments to the NumPy function. This leads to a crash or error within NumPy itself. The root cause is still the vulnerable library's mishandling of the EmptyDataset object, but the crash occurs in NumPy.
  • Likelihood: Moderate. This is another plausible error in library development.
  • Impact: High. Leads to a crash (DoS).
  • Effort: Moderate. Relies on finding a library that makes this mistake.
  • Skill Level: Moderate. Requires understanding of NumPy function arguments and how libraries should interact with them.
  • Detection Difficulty: Moderate to High. Requires analyzing the call stack to identify the incorrect arguments passed to NumPy.