Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
96 lines (84 loc) · 11.9 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

96 lines (84 loc) · 11.9 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for facebookarchive/three20

Objective: Compromise Application Using Three20

Attack Tree Visualization

Root: **[CRITICAL NODE]** Compromise Application Using Three20
├── 1. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Exploit UI Component Vulnerabilities
│   └── 1.1. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Malicious Content Injection via UI Components **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│       └── 1.1.1. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Inject Malicious HTML/JavaScript via TTStyledText/TTAttributedLabel **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│           └── Exploit: Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) like vulnerabilities in rendering **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
├── 2. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Exploit Networking and Data Loading Vulnerabilities
│   └── 2.1. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) Attacks due to Insecure HTTP Usage **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│       └── 2.1.1. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Force application to use HTTP instead of HTTPS for data retrieval **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│           └── Exploit: Intercept sensitive data transmitted over network **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
├── 4. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Exploit OAuth Implementation Vulnerabilities (TTOAuthController)
│   └── 4.1. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Insecure Storage of OAuth Tokens **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│       └── 4.1.1. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Store OAuth tokens in plaintext or weakly encrypted storage **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│           └── Exploit: Steal OAuth tokens, gain unauthorized access to user accounts **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
└── 5. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Exploit Code Quality Issues and Bugs in Three20 (General Software Vulnerabilities)
    └── 5.3. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Information Disclosure via Error Messages or Debug Logs (if exposed in production) **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
        └── 5.3.1. **[CRITICAL NODE]** Leak sensitive information through verbose error messages or debug logs **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
            └── Exploit: Gather information about application internals, potential vulnerabilities **[HIGH RISK PATH]**

Attack Tree Path: Exploit UI Component Vulnerabilities - Critical Node

  • 1.1. Malicious Content Injection via UI Components - Critical Node & High-Risk Path
    • Attack Vector: Applications using Three20's UI components like TTStyledText and TTAttributedLabel to display dynamic content (e.g., user-generated content, data from external sources) without proper sanitization are vulnerable to malicious content injection.
    • 1.1.1. Inject Malicious HTML/JavaScript via TTStyledText/TTAttributedLabel - Critical Node & High-Risk Path
      • Exploit: Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) like vulnerabilities in rendering - High-Risk Path
        • Description: Attackers can inject malicious HTML or JavaScript code into the content displayed by TTStyledText or TTAttributedLabel. If these components render this content in a way that allows script execution (especially if used within WebViews or if vulnerabilities exist in the rendering logic), it can lead to XSS-like vulnerabilities.
        • Impact: Successful exploitation can lead to:
          • Account Compromise: Stealing user session cookies or credentials.
          • Data Theft: Accessing sensitive data displayed within the application or making unauthorized API calls.
          • Malicious Actions: Performing actions on behalf of the user without their consent, such as posting content, making purchases, or modifying account settings.
          • Redirection to Malicious Sites: Redirecting users to phishing websites or sites hosting malware.
        • Mitigation:
          • Input Sanitization: Thoroughly sanitize and validate all dynamic content before displaying it using TTStyledText or TTAttributedLabel. Use appropriate encoding and escaping techniques to neutralize potentially harmful HTML and JavaScript.
          • Content Security Policy (CSP): If these components are used in conjunction with WebViews, implement a strict Content Security Policy to prevent the execution of inline scripts and restrict the loading of external resources from untrusted origins.
          • Regular Security Audits: Regularly review the usage of these UI components and ensure that dynamic content is handled securely.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Networking and Data Loading Vulnerabilities - Critical Node

  • 2.1. Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) Attacks due to Insecure HTTP Usage - Critical Node & High-Risk Path
    • Attack Vector: Applications that still rely on HTTP for network communication, especially for sensitive data, are vulnerable to Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) attacks. Even applications primarily using HTTPS might be vulnerable if they can be forced to downgrade to HTTP or if mixed HTTP/HTTPS usage exists.
    • 2.1.1. Force application to use HTTP instead of HTTPS for data retrieval - Critical Node & High-Risk Path
      • Exploit: Intercept sensitive data transmitted over network - High-Risk Path
        • Description: Attackers positioned on the network path between the application and the server can intercept network traffic if HTTP is used. This allows them to eavesdrop on communication, steal sensitive data, and potentially modify data in transit.
        • Impact: Successful MITM attacks can result in:
          • Data Breach: Interception of sensitive data like usernames, passwords, personal information, financial details, and application-specific data.
          • Credential Theft: Stealing user credentials for unauthorized access to accounts.
          • Session Hijacking: Stealing session tokens to impersonate users and gain unauthorized access.
          • Data Manipulation: Modifying data in transit, potentially leading to application malfunction or malicious actions.
        • Mitigation:
          • Enforce HTTPS: Strictly enforce HTTPS for all network communication, especially when transmitting sensitive data. Disable HTTP entirely if possible.
          • HTTP Strict Transport Security (HSTS): Implement HSTS to instruct browsers and applications to always use HTTPS for communication with the server, preventing downgrade attacks.
          • SSL/TLS Certificate Pinning: Implement certificate pinning to validate the server's SSL/TLS certificate against a known, trusted certificate, preventing MITM attacks even if the attacker has a valid certificate from a compromised Certificate Authority.
          • Network Monitoring: Implement network monitoring to detect suspicious network traffic patterns that might indicate MITM attacks.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit OAuth Implementation Vulnerabilities (TTOAuthController) - Critical Node

  • 4.1. Insecure Storage of OAuth Tokens - Critical Node & High-Risk Path
    • Attack Vector: If applications using Three20's TTOAuthController or their own OAuth implementation store OAuth access tokens and refresh tokens insecurely on the device, attackers can potentially gain access to these tokens.
    • 4.1.1. Store OAuth tokens in plaintext or weakly encrypted storage - Critical Node & High-Risk Path
      • Exploit: Steal OAuth tokens, gain unauthorized access to user accounts - High-Risk Path
        • Description: Storing OAuth tokens in plaintext or using weak encryption methods (easily reversible or using hardcoded keys) makes them vulnerable to theft. Attackers with physical access to the device, or through other vulnerabilities allowing file system access, can retrieve these tokens.
        • Impact: Stealing OAuth tokens can lead to:
          • Account Takeover: Attackers can use the stolen access tokens to impersonate the user and gain full unauthorized access to their account and data.
          • Data Access: Accessing all data and resources associated with the user's account.
          • Unauthorized Actions: Performing actions on behalf of the user, potentially causing financial loss, reputational damage, or privacy violations.
        • Mitigation:
          • Secure Token Storage: Utilize platform-provided secure storage mechanisms like Keychain on iOS to store OAuth tokens. Keychain provides hardware-backed encryption and secure access control.
          • Encryption at Rest: If Keychain is not used directly, encrypt OAuth tokens at rest using strong, industry-standard encryption algorithms. Ensure that encryption keys are securely managed and not hardcoded in the application.
          • Access Control to Token Storage: Implement strict access control to the storage location of OAuth tokens to prevent unauthorized access by other applications or processes on the device.
          • Regular Security Audits: Regularly audit the token storage mechanism to ensure it remains secure and adheres to best practices.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Code Quality Issues and Bugs in Three20 (General Software Vulnerabilities) - Critical Node

  • 5.3. Information Disclosure via Error Messages or Debug Logs (if exposed in production) - Critical Node & High-Risk Path
    • Attack Vector: Applications that expose verbose error messages or leave debug logs enabled in production builds can inadvertently leak sensitive information to attackers.
    • 5.3.1. Leak sensitive information through verbose error messages or debug logs - Critical Node & High-Risk Path
      • Exploit: Gather information about application internals, potential vulnerabilities - High-Risk Path
        • Description: Verbose error messages and debug logs can reveal details about the application's internal workings, code structure, database queries, API endpoints, configuration details, and even potentially sensitive data. Attackers can use this information to understand the application's architecture, identify potential vulnerabilities, and plan further attacks.
        • Impact: Information disclosure can lead to:
          • Exposure of Sensitive Data: Leaking API keys, database credentials, internal paths, or other sensitive configuration information.
          • Vulnerability Discovery: Providing attackers with insights into application vulnerabilities, making it easier to exploit them.
          • Bypass of Security Measures: Revealing details about security mechanisms, allowing attackers to find ways to circumvent them.
          • Increased Attack Surface: Expanding the attack surface by providing attackers with more information to target.
        • Mitigation:
          • Disable Debug Logs in Production: Ensure that debug logging is completely disabled in production builds of the application. Use different logging levels for development and production environments.
          • Minimize Verbose Error Messages: Minimize the verbosity of error messages displayed to users in production. Provide generic error messages to users while logging detailed error information securely for debugging purposes.
          • Secure Error Logging: If error logging is necessary in production, ensure that logs are stored securely, access is restricted to authorized personnel, and sensitive information is redacted or masked before logging.
          • Regular Code Reviews: Conduct code reviews to identify and remove any accidental logging of sensitive information or overly verbose error handling in production code.