Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
207 lines (172 loc) · 16.8 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

207 lines (172 loc) · 16.8 KB

Okay, let's perform a deep security analysis of the Three20 library based on the provided design review.

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

Objective:

The primary objective is to conduct a thorough security analysis of the Three20 library's key components, identifying potential vulnerabilities and weaknesses that could be exploited in applications using the library. This analysis will focus on the historical context of Three20, considering its age and archived status, while also providing recommendations that would be relevant if it were to be used (though strongly discouraged) or revived today. We aim to understand how the design and implementation choices within Three20 could impact the security of an application.

Scope:

The scope of this analysis includes the following:

  • Key Components: We'll focus on the major components identified within the Three20 library, as inferred from the codebase structure and documentation. This includes, but is not limited to:
    • UI elements (buttons, text fields, tables, etc.)
    • Networking components (if any)
    • Data handling and persistence mechanisms (if any, though ideally minimal)
    • Navigation and view controller management
    • Utilities and helper functions
  • Codebase Analysis: We'll examine the Objective-C code for common security vulnerabilities.
  • Dependency Analysis: We'll consider the potential impact of outdated dependencies.
  • Historical Context: We'll acknowledge the limitations of security practices at the time of Three20's development.
  • Exclusions: We will not analyze the security of a specific application using Three20, but rather the library itself. We will also not perform a full penetration test or source code audit.

Methodology:

  1. Component Identification: Based on the provided design review and a review of the GitHub repository structure, we'll identify the key functional components of Three20.
  2. Architecture and Data Flow Inference: We'll infer the architectural patterns and data flow within each component based on the code and any available documentation. This will involve understanding how data enters the component, how it's processed, and how it's output.
  3. Threat Modeling: For each component, we'll perform threat modeling, considering potential attack vectors and vulnerabilities. We'll use a combination of:
    • STRIDE: Spoofing, Tampering, Repudiation, Information Disclosure, Denial of Service, Elevation of Privilege.
    • OWASP Mobile Top 10: Focusing on relevant risks for a client-side library.
  4. Vulnerability Analysis: We'll look for specific code patterns and practices known to be associated with vulnerabilities, including:
    • Input validation issues (or lack thereof)
    • Use of deprecated APIs
    • Potential memory management issues (retain cycles, buffer overflows)
    • Insecure data handling (if any)
    • Hardcoded secrets (if any)
  5. Mitigation Strategy Recommendation: For each identified vulnerability, we'll provide specific, actionable mitigation strategies tailored to Three20 and Objective-C development.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

Based on the GitHub repository structure and common patterns in Three20, we can identify the following key areas and their potential security implications:

  • TTNavigator (Navigation):

    • Architecture: Manages the navigation stack and transitions between view controllers. Likely uses URL schemes for mapping URLs to view controllers.
    • Data Flow: Receives URLs (potentially from external sources), instantiates and displays view controllers based on those URLs.
    • Threats:
      • URL Scheme Hijacking: If the application registers custom URL schemes, a malicious application could potentially hijack those schemes and pass malicious URLs to TTNavigator, leading to unexpected behavior or the display of attacker-controlled content.
      • Open Redirects: If TTNavigator allows redirection to arbitrary URLs based on user input, it could be vulnerable to open redirect attacks.
      • Denial of Service: Maliciously crafted URLs could potentially cause crashes or resource exhaustion.
    • Mitigation:
      • Strict URL Validation: Implement rigorous validation of all URLs passed to TTNavigator, ensuring they conform to expected patterns and do not contain unexpected characters or parameters. Use a whitelist approach, allowing only known-good URL structures.
      • Avoid External URL Handling: If possible, avoid handling URLs from external sources (e.g., other apps). If necessary, treat them as untrusted and perform thorough validation.
      • Safe URL Scheme Handling: If custom URL schemes are used, follow best practices for secure URL scheme handling, including validating the source of the URL and the data it contains.

  • TTTableViewController and related classes (Table Views):

    • Architecture: Provides a framework for displaying data in table views. Handles data sources, delegates, and cell rendering.
    • Data Flow: Receives data from a data source (often an array or other collection), renders it into table view cells, and handles user interactions (taps, swipes, etc.).
    • Threats:
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): If the table view displays user-provided data without proper escaping, it could be vulnerable to XSS attacks, especially if the data is rendered in a TTStyledTextLabel or similar component that supports HTML-like formatting.
      • Data Leakage: If sensitive data is displayed in the table view, it could be leaked to unauthorized users or applications if proper access controls are not in place.
      • Denial of Service: Large or maliciously crafted data sets could potentially cause performance issues or crashes.
    • Mitigation:
      • Output Encoding: Always encode or escape user-provided data before displaying it in the table view. Use appropriate encoding methods based on the context (e.g., HTML encoding for TTStyledTextLabel).
      • Data Sanitization: Sanitize user-provided data to remove any potentially harmful characters or tags.
      • Secure Data Handling: Ensure that sensitive data is only displayed to authorized users and is not exposed to other applications.
      • Limit Data Size: Implement limits on the size of data that can be displayed in the table view to prevent performance issues.

  • TTTextEditor and TTTextField (Text Input):

    • Architecture: Provides text input fields for user input.
    • Data Flow: Receives user input, potentially stores it, and passes it to other parts of the application.
    • Threats:
      • Input Validation Bypass: Lack of proper input validation could allow attackers to inject malicious data, leading to various vulnerabilities (XSS, SQL injection, command injection) depending on how the input is used.
      • Sensitive Data Exposure: If the text field is used to enter sensitive data (e.g., passwords), it should be configured to mask the input and prevent it from being copied or pasted.
    • Mitigation:
      • Robust Input Validation: Implement thorough input validation on all text fields, checking for data type, length, format, and allowed characters. Use a whitelist approach whenever possible.
      • Secure Text Field Configuration: For sensitive data, use the appropriate secure text field settings (e.g., secureTextEntry in UIKit) to mask input and prevent unauthorized access.
      • Avoid Storing Sensitive Data in UI Components: Do not store sensitive data directly in UI components. Pass it to secure storage mechanisms (e.g., Keychain) as soon as possible.

  • TTImageView and TTPhotoViewController (Image Handling):

    • Architecture: Displays images, potentially loaded from remote URLs or local storage.
    • Data Flow: Receives image data (from a URL or file), decodes it, and displays it.
    • Threats:
      • Image Decoding Vulnerabilities: Vulnerabilities in image decoding libraries (historically common) could be exploited by providing maliciously crafted image files, leading to crashes or potentially arbitrary code execution.
      • Path Traversal: If images are loaded from local storage based on user input, a path traversal vulnerability could allow attackers to access arbitrary files on the device.
      • Denial of Service: Large or maliciously crafted images could cause performance issues or crashes.
    • Mitigation:
      • Use System Image Libraries: Rely on the system-provided image decoding libraries (e.g., UIImage) as they are generally more secure and regularly updated.
      • Validate Image URLs: If loading images from remote URLs, validate the URLs to ensure they are legitimate and do not point to malicious servers.
      • Sanitize File Paths: If loading images from local storage, sanitize file paths to prevent path traversal attacks. Avoid using user-provided data directly in file paths.
      • Limit Image Size: Implement limits on the size of images that can be loaded to prevent performance issues.

  • Networking Components (e.g., TTURLRequest - if used):

    • Architecture: Handles network requests, potentially fetching data from remote servers.
    • Data Flow: Sends requests to remote servers, receives responses, and processes the data.
    • Threats:
      • Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks: If network requests are not made over HTTPS, they could be intercepted and modified by attackers.
      • Data Leakage: Sensitive data transmitted over the network could be intercepted if not properly encrypted.
      • Server-Side Vulnerabilities: Vulnerabilities on the server-side could be exploited through the networking components.
    • Mitigation:
      • HTTPS Only: Enforce the use of HTTPS for all network requests. This is crucial for protecting data in transit.
      • Certificate Pinning: Consider implementing certificate pinning to further protect against MitM attacks.
      • Secure Data Handling: Encrypt any sensitive data transmitted over the network.
      • Regularly Update Dependencies: Keep any networking libraries up-to-date to address known vulnerabilities.

3. Actionable Mitigation Strategies (Tailored to Three20)

The following are specific, actionable mitigation strategies, considering the context of Three20 and Objective-C:

  1. Comprehensive Input Validation (Priority):

    • Strategy: Create a centralized input validation library or utility class within the Three20 project. This library should provide functions for validating different data types (strings, numbers, URLs, etc.) based on specific criteria (length, format, allowed characters).

    • Implementation:

      • Use regular expressions (with caution, avoiding overly complex expressions that could lead to ReDoS) to define allowed patterns for strings and URLs.
      • Use NSPredicate for more complex validation rules.
      • Provide clear error messages when validation fails.
      • Apply these validation functions consistently to all UI components that accept user input.

    • Example (Objective-C):

      // In a utility class (e.g., TTInputValidator)

+ (BOOL)isValidURL:(NSString *)url {
    // Use a regular expression or NSPredicate to validate the URL
    NSString *urlRegex = @"^(https?://)?[a-zA-Z0-9\\-\\.]+\\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}(/\\S*)?$";
    NSPredicate *urlTest = [NSPredicate predicateWithFormat:@"SELF MATCHES %@", urlRegex];
    return [urlTest evaluateWithObject:url];
}

+ (BOOL)isValidEmail:(NSString *)email {
  //Similar validation for email
}

// ... other validation methods ...

// In a TTTextField subclass:

- (void)setText:(NSString *)text {
    if ([TTInputValidator isValidInput:text forType:TTInputTypeEmail]) { //Assuming an enum for input types
        [super setText:text];
    } else {
        // Handle invalid input (e.g., display an error message)
    }
}

  2. Output Encoding (Priority):

    • Strategy: Ensure that all user-provided data is properly encoded before being displayed in UI components, especially in TTStyledTextLabel and other components that might interpret HTML-like formatting.

    • Implementation:

      • Create helper functions for HTML encoding and other relevant encoding types.
      • Apply these functions consistently whenever displaying user-provided data.

    • Example (Objective-C):

      // In a utility class (e.g., TTOutputEncoder)

+ (NSString *)htmlEncode:(NSString *)string {
    NSMutableString *encodedString = [string mutableCopy];
    [encodedString replaceOccurrencesOfString:@"&" withString:@"&" options:NSLiteralSearch range:NSMakeRange(0, [encodedString length])];
    [encodedString replaceOccurrencesOfString:@"<" withString:@"&lt;" options:NSLiteralSearch range:NSMakeRange(0, [encodedString length])];
    [encodedString replaceOccurrencesOfString:@">" withString:@"&gt;" options:NSLiteralSearch range:NSMakeRange(0, [encodedString length])];
    [encodedString replaceOccurrencesOfString:@"\"" withString:@"&quot;" options:NSLiteralSearch range:NSMakeRange(0, [encodedString length])];
    [encodedString replaceOccurrencesOfString:@"'" withString:@"&#x27;" options:NSLiteralSearch range:NSMakeRange(0, [encodedString length])];
    [encodedString replaceOccurrencesOfString:@"/" withString:@"&#x2F;" options:NSLiteralSearch range:NSMakeRange(0, [encodedString length])];
    return encodedString;
}

// In a TTStyledTextLabel subclass:

- (void)setText:(NSString *)text {
    [super setText:[TTOutputEncoder htmlEncode:text]];
}

  3. Secure URL Handling (for TTNavigator):

    • Strategy: Implement a strict whitelist of allowed URL schemes and URL patterns for TTNavigator.
    • Implementation:
      • Define a configuration file (e.g., a plist) or a set of constants that specify the allowed URL schemes and patterns.
      • Before navigating to a URL, check if it matches the allowed patterns.
      • Reject any URLs that do not match the whitelist.

  4. Dependency Management (Critical, but difficult for an archived project):

    • Strategy: Identify all dependencies of Three20 and assess their security status. This is challenging for an archived project, but crucial if it were to be revived.
    • Implementation:
      • Manually inspect the codebase for any external libraries or frameworks used.
      • Research the security status of each dependency, looking for known vulnerabilities and available updates.
      • If possible, update dependencies to the latest secure versions. If updates are not available, consider replacing the dependency with a more modern alternative or removing the functionality that relies on it.

  5. Memory Management Review:

    • Strategy: Carefully review the code for potential memory management issues, such as retain cycles and buffer overflows. This is particularly important for Objective-C code that predates Automatic Reference Counting (ARC).
    • Implementation:
      • Use Xcode's static analyzer and Instruments to identify potential memory leaks and other issues.
      • Manually inspect the code for retain cycles, especially in delegate relationships and block usage.
      • Ensure that buffers are properly sized and that there are no out-of-bounds writes.

  6. Avoid Deprecated APIs:

    • Strategy: Identify and replace any use of deprecated iOS APIs.
    • Implementation:
      • Use Xcode's warnings and documentation to identify deprecated APIs.
      • Replace deprecated APIs with their modern equivalents.

  7. Data Handling Review (if applicable):

    • Strategy: If Three20 handles any data persistence, ensure that it is done securely.
    • Implementation:
      • Use appropriate encryption for sensitive data.
      • Store data in secure locations (e.g., Keychain for sensitive data, app-specific containers for other data).
      • Avoid storing sensitive data in UI components.

This deep analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the security considerations for the Three20 library, along with actionable mitigation strategies. Given the archived nature of the project, the most important recommendation is to avoid using it in new projects. However, if it must be used or revived, the strategies outlined above are essential for minimizing the security risks.