Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
78 lines (59 loc) · 9 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

78 lines (59 loc) · 9 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for forkingdog/uitableview-fdtemplatelayoutcell

Mitigation Strategy: Timeout Mechanism (Direct Library Interaction)

  1. Understand Library's Calculation Process: Deeply analyze UITableView-FDTemplateLayoutCell's source code, specifically the methods involved in calculating cell heights (e.g., methods related to systemLayoutSizeFitting and Auto Layout). Pinpoint the exact locations where the calculations begin and end.

  2. Strategic Timer Placement: Insert timer logic around the library's core layout calculation calls. This might involve:

    • Subclassing: Create a custom subclass of UITableViewCell (or the specific cell class you're using) and override the relevant methods (e.g., systemLayoutSizeFitting, or methods that call it). Start the timer before calling super and stop it after.
    • Method Swizzling (with extreme caution): As a last resort, and only if subclassing is not feasible, consider method swizzling to intercept the library's layout calculation methods. This is a very advanced technique and should be used with extreme care, as it can lead to unexpected behavior and instability if not done correctly.

  3. Abort Calculation (Library-Specific): The most challenging part is aborting the ongoing layout calculation if the timeout is reached. This likely requires:

    • Library Modification (Ideal): The ideal solution would be to modify the library itself to support a cancellation mechanism. This could involve adding a cancelLayoutCalculation method or using a flag that the library checks periodically during the calculation. This would require submitting a pull request to the library's maintainers.
    • Workarounds (Less Ideal): If modifying the library is not possible, you might need to explore less ideal workarounds, such as:
      • Setting a Flag: Set a flag in your custom cell subclass that the library's calculation methods can check periodically. If the flag is set (due to the timeout), the calculation methods could return immediately with a default or estimated height. This requires deep understanding of the library's internal logic.
      • Interrupting Auto Layout (Very Difficult): Attempting to directly interrupt the Auto Layout engine is extremely difficult and likely unreliable. Avoid this approach unless you have a very deep understanding of Auto Layout internals.

  4. Handle Completion and Timeout: Implement logic to handle both successful completion of the layout calculation (within the timeout) and the timeout case. This includes:

    • Stopping the Timer: Stop the timer when the calculation completes successfully.
    • Invalidating Cache (Timeout): If the timeout is reached, invalidate the corresponding cache entry in UITableView-FDTemplateLayoutCell's caching mechanism. This prevents the use of potentially incorrect cached heights. You'll need to access the library's cache (likely a dictionary or similar data structure) and remove the entry associated with the cell.
    • Returning a Default Height (Timeout): If the timeout is reached, return a reasonable default height for the cell (e.g., an estimated height or the height of a placeholder cell).

  5. Thread Safety: Ensure that all interactions with the library's caching mechanism and any UI updates are performed on the main thread using DispatchQueue.main.async.

    Threats Mitigated: * Denial of Service (DoS) via Extremely Complex Layouts: (Severity: High) - Prevents the application from hanging indefinitely due to long layout calculations initiated by the library.

    Impact: * DoS via Extremely Complex Layouts: Significantly reduces the risk by providing a hard limit on the time the library spends calculating layout.

    Currently Implemented: * None.

    Missing Implementation: * This strategy is not currently implemented. It requires significant effort and potentially modifications to the library itself. The feasibility depends on the library's internal structure and the ability to interrupt the layout calculation process.

Mitigation Strategy: Review and Potentially Modify Caching Key Generation (Library-Specific)

  1. Locate Key Generation Code: Examine the UITableView-FDTemplateLayoutCell source code to find the exact code responsible for generating the caching keys used to store calculated cell heights. This is likely within a method like fd_cacheKeyForCellWithIdentifier:configuration:.

  2. Analyze Key Components: Carefully analyze the components that make up the caching key. Identify all data sources and variables used in the key generation process.

  3. Identify Sensitive Data: Determine if any sensitive data (e.g., user IDs, personal information, API keys, or any data that should not be exposed) is directly included as part of the caching key.

  4. Modify Key Generation (If Necessary): If sensitive data is found to be part of the key, modify the library's code to remove or replace it:

    • Removal: If the sensitive data is not essential for uniquely identifying the layout configuration, remove it from the key generation process entirely.
    • Hashing/Obfuscation: If the sensitive data is essential for uniqueness, replace it with a secure, one-way hash (e.g., SHA-256) of the data. This ensures that the key remains unique but does not directly expose the sensitive information. Ensure you use a cryptographically secure hashing algorithm.
    • Proxy Value: Another option is to replace the sensitive data with a non-sensitive proxy value that still uniquely identifies the layout configuration. This might involve creating a mapping between the sensitive data and a unique, non-sensitive identifier.

  5. Library Modification (Likely Required): This mitigation almost certainly requires modifying the UITableView-FDTemplateLayoutCell library's source code directly. You would then need to use a local copy of the modified library or submit a pull request to the original project.

  6. Thorough Testing: After modifying the key generation logic, extremely thorough testing is crucial. You need to ensure that:

    • Caching still works correctly (cells are correctly cached and retrieved).
    • There are no collisions (different layouts do not accidentally get the same key).
    • There are no performance regressions.

    Threats Mitigated: * Data Leakage (Indirect, via Caching): (Severity: Low) - Prevents sensitive data from being inadvertently exposed through the library's caching mechanism.

    Impact: * Data Leakage: Reduces the (already low) risk of indirect data leakage by ensuring that caching keys do not contain sensitive information.

    Currently Implemented: * Needs Review: The library's default key generation logic has not yet been reviewed for potential inclusion of sensitive data.

    Missing Implementation: * A thorough review and potential modification of the library's caching key generation logic are required. This is a lower priority unless the application handles highly sensitive data that directly influences cell layout.

Mitigation Strategy: Stay Updated (Library Updates)

  1. Monitor for Updates: Regularly check the UITableView-FDTemplateLayoutCell GitHub repository (or other relevant channels) for new releases, bug fixes, and security advisories.

  2. Use a Dependency Manager: Use a dependency manager (e.g., CocoaPods, Carthage, Swift Package Manager) to manage the library and its dependencies. This makes it easier to update to new versions.

  3. Review Changelogs: Before updating, carefully review the changelog or release notes to understand the changes and identify any potential breaking changes or security fixes.

  4. Test After Updating: After updating the library, thoroughly test your application to ensure that everything still works as expected and that the update has not introduced any new issues.

  5. Establish a schedule: Create a schedule to check for updates.

    Threats Mitigated: * Unexpected behavior due to library bugs: (Severity: Variable, depends on the bug) - Fixes bugs that could lead to crashes, incorrect behavior, or potential vulnerabilities within the library itself.

    Impact: * Unexpected behavior due to library bugs: Reduces the risk by applying bug fixes and security patches released by the library maintainers.

    Currently Implemented: * The project uses CocoaPods to manage dependencies, and the Podfile specifies the library version.

    Missing Implementation: * There is no established schedule for checking for library updates. This should be implemented to ensure that the project is using the latest, most secure version.