Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
62 lines (51 loc) · 9.03 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

62 lines (51 loc) · 9.03 KB

Threat Model Analysis for grouper/flatuikit

Threat: Bootstrap 3 XSS Vulnerability Exploitation

  • Description: Flat UI Kit relies on the outdated Bootstrap 3 framework, which contains known Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) vulnerabilities. Attackers can exploit these vulnerabilities in Bootstrap 3 components styled by Flat UI Kit (like modals or tooltips) by injecting malicious scripts through various input vectors. This allows execution of arbitrary JavaScript in users' browsers when they interact with vulnerable Flat UI Kit components.
  • Impact: Full account compromise, theft of sensitive user data and session tokens, website defacement leading to reputational damage, redirection to attacker-controlled malicious websites, and potential malware distribution to users.
  • Affected Component: Bootstrap 3 core JavaScript components integrated within Flat UI Kit (e.g., modals, tooltips, popovers, dropdowns).
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Actively monitor for and research known Bootstrap 3 CVEs and assess their applicability to your application using Flat UI Kit.
    • Implement rigorous input validation and output encoding across the application to minimize the impact of potential XSS vulnerabilities, even if present in the underlying framework.
    • Enforce a strong Content Security Policy (CSP) to restrict script execution sources, significantly limiting the damage from successful XSS exploitation.
    • Strategize and plan for migration away from Flat UI Kit and Bootstrap 3 to a more actively maintained and secure framework as a long-term solution.

Threat: jQuery Vulnerability Exploitation

  • Description: Flat UI Kit includes jQuery, and older versions of jQuery are known to have security vulnerabilities, some of which can be high severity (e.g., Prototype Pollution, XSS). Attackers can exploit these jQuery vulnerabilities present in Flat UI Kit to execute arbitrary JavaScript code or manipulate the application's behavior. This can be achieved by crafting malicious inputs or interactions that trigger the jQuery vulnerability when processed by Flat UI Kit's JavaScript or application-specific JavaScript that interacts with jQuery.
  • Impact: Similar to XSS, this can lead to complete account compromise, large-scale data theft, website defacement impacting brand reputation, unauthorized redirection of users, and widespread malware distribution. Prototype Pollution vulnerabilities can also enable deeper manipulation of application logic and backend systems.
  • Affected Component: jQuery library as distributed with Flat UI Kit, potentially affecting any Flat UI Kit component relying on jQuery and application-specific JavaScript utilizing jQuery.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Identify the precise jQuery version bundled with Flat UI Kit and meticulously check for known vulnerabilities (CVEs) associated with that specific version.
    • If high severity vulnerabilities are identified, immediately investigate patching jQuery within the Flat UI Kit distribution if feasible and safe.
    • Apply any available security patches released by the jQuery team for the used version, if applicable and compatible with Flat UI Kit.
    • Strictly adhere to jQuery security best practices in all application code, especially when handling user-provided input and performing DOM manipulations.

Threat: Custom Flat UI Kit Component XSS Vulnerabilities

  • Description: If Flat UI Kit includes any custom JavaScript components beyond standard Bootstrap, or if developers extend Flat UI Kit with their own custom JavaScript, these custom components may introduce new Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) vulnerabilities. Attackers can inject malicious scripts through user-supplied data that is processed or rendered by these custom components without proper security measures, leading to arbitrary script execution in user browsers.
  • Impact: Full account takeover, extensive data breaches, severe website defacement causing significant reputational harm, widespread redirection to malicious domains, and large-scale malware infections of users.
  • Affected Component: Any custom JavaScript components included directly within Flat UI Kit's distribution or developer-created JavaScript extensions specifically designed to work with Flat UI Kit.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Conduct thorough and rigorous security audits of all custom JavaScript code within Flat UI Kit and any developer-created extensions.
    • Implement secure JavaScript coding practices, including mandatory input validation, robust output encoding, and context-aware escaping for all user-controlled data.
    • Utilize automated JavaScript security linters and static analysis tools to proactively identify potential XSS vulnerabilities in custom code components.
    • Implement a restrictive Content Security Policy (CSP) to act as a strong defense-in-depth measure, mitigating the impact even if XSS vulnerabilities exist in custom components.

Threat: Compromised Flat UI Kit Distribution (Supply Chain Attack)

  • Description: Although less probable for a GitHub-hosted project, there remains a risk that the official Flat UI Kit repository or its distribution channels could be compromised by malicious actors. If successful, attackers could inject malicious code directly into the framework files. Developers downloading and using this compromised version would unknowingly integrate malware into their applications.
  • Impact: Widespread and severe compromise of all applications utilizing the compromised Flat UI Kit version. This could result in massive data breaches across numerous applications, large-scale malware distribution affecting countless users, and complete takeover of vulnerable applications by attackers.
  • Affected Component: The entire Flat UI Kit framework distribution, encompassing all CSS, JavaScript, font files, and any other assets distributed as part of the framework.
  • Risk Severity: High (Potentially Critical Impact)
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Always download Flat UI Kit exclusively from trusted and officially recognized sources, such as the official GitHub repository.
    • Verify the integrity of all downloaded files using checksums or digital signatures if provided by the Flat UI Kit project to ensure they haven't been tampered with.
    • Strongly consider implementing Subresource Integrity (SRI) for any CDN-hosted Flat UI Kit assets to guarantee their integrity and authenticity when loaded by user browsers.
    • Continuously monitor the Flat UI Kit project and its community for any signs of potential compromise or unusual activities that might indicate a supply chain attack.

Threat: Unmaintained Flat UI Kit Leading to Accumulation of Unpatched Vulnerabilities

  • Description: Flat UI Kit is built upon outdated and unmaintained technologies (Bootstrap 3, older jQuery). If the Flat UI Kit project itself becomes unmaintained, as is likely given its age, critical security vulnerabilities discovered in its dependencies or within Flat UI Kit itself will no longer be addressed with security patches. This leads to a growing accumulation of unpatched vulnerabilities over time, making applications increasingly susceptible to exploitation.
  • Impact: Progressively increasing risk of exploitation due to unpatched vulnerabilities. Over time, this can lead to critical vulnerabilities becoming widely known and easily exploitable, resulting in data breaches, application compromise, and other severe security incidents.
  • Affected Component: The entire Flat UI Kit framework and all of its dependencies, including Bootstrap 3 and jQuery, as they become increasingly outdated and vulnerable without active maintenance.
  • Risk Severity: High (Increasing to Critical over time)
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Continuously monitor the Flat UI Kit project's activity, community engagement, and maintenance status to assess the ongoing risk of using an unmaintained framework.
    • Develop a comprehensive contingency plan to migrate away from Flat UI Kit to a more actively maintained and secure UI framework. This plan should be proactively implemented before critical unpatched vulnerabilities are discovered and exploited.
    • As a highly resource-intensive and potentially unsustainable option, consider forking the Flat UI Kit repository and undertaking the responsibility of maintaining a custom, security-patched version. This requires significant expertise and ongoing effort.
    • For all new projects, strongly prioritize the selection of actively maintained UI frameworks that receive regular security updates to minimize the long-term risk of unpatched vulnerabilities.