Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
116 lines (96 loc) · 11.7 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

116 lines (96 loc) · 11.7 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for kanyun-inc/ytknetwork

Objective: To gain unauthorized access to data or functionality protected by the application's API calls managed by ytknetwork, or to disrupt the application's API communication.

Attack Tree Visualization

[Gain Unauthorized Access/Disrupt API Communication] /
/
[Exploit Request Handling] [Exploit Response Handling] / | \ / |
/ | \ / |
[1. Bypass [2. Inject [3. Tamper [4. Intercept [5. Inject [6. Tamper [7. Denial Request Malicious with Request & Modify Malicious with Response of Service] Validation] Payload] Parameters] Cached Payload] Data] Responses] | | | | | | | | | | | | | | [1a. Override [2a. Craft [3a. Modify [4b. Poison [5b. Inject [6b. Modify [7b. Trigger Base URL] Malicious Headers] Cache] XSS Response Excessive [HIGH] JSON/XML] [HIGH] [HIGH] Payload] Body] Retries] [HIGH] [HIGH] [HIGH] [HIGH] | | | [1b. Bypass [2b. Inject Argument SQL/Code Validation] into [CRITICAL] Arguments] [CRITICAL]

Attack Tree Path: [1. Bypass Request Validation]

  • [1a. Override Base URL] (HIGH):

    • Description: The attacker manipulates the base URL used by ytknetwork to send requests, redirecting them to a malicious server controlled by the attacker. This could be achieved through vulnerabilities in how the application handles user input or configuration settings related to the base URL.
    • Likelihood: Medium - Depends on how base URLs are handled; if user input is involved without proper sanitization, likelihood increases significantly.
    • Impact: High - Can redirect requests to a malicious server, leading to complete data compromise (credentials, sensitive data) or phishing attacks.
    • Effort: Low to Medium - Finding the vulnerability might be easy (e.g., exposed configuration setting); exploiting it depends on the attacker's server setup.
    • Skill Level: Intermediate - Requires understanding of HTTP requests and how URLs are constructed and used.
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Traffic analysis might reveal unusual redirects, but it could be obfuscated (e.g., using URL shorteners, compromised legitimate servers).

  • [1b. Bypass Argument Validation] (CRITICAL):

    • Description: The attacker provides crafted input to API request parameters that bypasses ytknetwork's validation (if any), allowing malicious data to be passed to the backend server. This is a classic injection vulnerability.
    • Likelihood: High - Very common vulnerability if input validation is weak or missing. Many applications fail to properly sanitize all inputs.
    • Impact: Very High - Can lead to SQL injection, command injection, cross-site scripting (XSS), or other severe exploits, potentially giving full control of the application or database.
    • Effort: Low to Medium - Many automated tools (e.g., SQLmap) exist for finding and exploiting these vulnerabilities. Manual exploitation is also possible with basic knowledge.
    • Skill Level: Novice to Intermediate - Basic SQL injection or command injection knowledge is often sufficient. More sophisticated attacks require more skill.
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium to Hard - Can be difficult to detect without proper logging, intrusion detection systems (IDS), and web application firewalls (WAFs). Attackers can obfuscate their payloads.

Attack Tree Path: [2. Inject Malicious Payload]

  • [2a. Craft Malicious JSON/XML] (HIGH):

    • Description: The attacker sends a specially crafted JSON or XML payload that exploits vulnerabilities in the server-side parsing logic. This could lead to denial of service, arbitrary code execution, or data leakage.
    • Likelihood: Medium to High - If the server doesn't properly validate or sanitize JSON/XML input, and uses a vulnerable parser.
    • Impact: High - Can lead to data breaches, code execution, or denial of service. Severity depends on the server-side vulnerability.
    • Effort: Medium - Requires understanding of JSON/XML parsing vulnerabilities and how to craft exploits.
    • Skill Level: Intermediate - Requires knowledge of common XML/JSON vulnerabilities (e.g., XXE, billion laughs attack).
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium to Hard - Requires deep inspection of request payloads and server-side behavior. May require specialized security tools.

  • [2b. Inject SQL/Code into Arguments] (CRITICAL):

    • Description: The attacker injects malicious SQL or code (e.g., shell commands, JavaScript) into API request parameters. If the server-side code doesn't properly sanitize these parameters, the injected code will be executed.
    • Likelihood: High - If the server uses unsanitized input in SQL queries or code execution, this is a very common and easily exploitable vulnerability.
    • Impact: Very High - Complete database compromise (read, modify, delete data), server takeover, potential for lateral movement within the network.
    • Effort: Low to Medium - Automated tools and well-known techniques (e.g., SQL injection cheat sheets) exist.
    • Skill Level: Novice to Intermediate - Basic SQL injection can be learned quickly. More advanced techniques require more skill.
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium to Hard - Requires database monitoring, intrusion detection, and careful analysis of SQL queries.

Attack Tree Path: [3. Tamper with Request Parameters]

  • [3a. Modify Headers] (HIGH):
    • Description: The attacker manipulates HTTP headers sent by ytknetwork. This could involve modifying authentication tokens, content types, or other headers to bypass security controls or cause unexpected behavior.
    • Likelihood: Medium - Depends on how headers are handled and whether they are exposed to modification by the client or during transit.
    • Impact: High - Can bypass authentication, authorization, inject malicious directives (e.g., Cross-Site Scripting protection bypass), or cause application errors.
    • Effort: Low to Medium - Requires understanding of HTTP headers and their purpose. Tools like Burp Suite can be used to intercept and modify requests.
    • Skill Level: Intermediate - Requires knowledge of HTTP and web application security concepts.
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires monitoring of HTTP headers for anomalies and unexpected values.

Attack Tree Path: [4. Intercept & Modify Cached Responses]

  • [4b. Poison Cache with Modified Responses] (HIGH):
    • Description: The attacker manages to inject malicious data into the cache used by ytknetwork. Subsequent requests will then receive the attacker's modified response, potentially leading to XSS, data leakage, or other attacks.
    • Likelihood: Low to Medium - Depends on the cache's vulnerability to injection attacks. Requires the attacker to be able to influence the cache content.
    • Impact: High - Can serve malicious content to users for an extended period, affecting multiple users. The impact depends on the content being cached.
    • Effort: Medium - Requires finding a way to inject malicious responses into the cache, which may involve exploiting other vulnerabilities.
    • Skill Level: Intermediate - Requires understanding of caching mechanisms and potential injection points.
    • Detection Difficulty: Hard - Requires monitoring cache content and comparing it to expected values. May require analyzing server logs and network traffic.

Attack Tree Path: [5. Inject Malicious Payload (Response)]

  • [5b. Inject XSS Payload] (HIGH):
    • Description: The attacker crafts a malicious response that includes JavaScript code. If ytknetwork or the application using it doesn't properly sanitize the response before displaying it in a web browser, the attacker's code will execute in the context of the user's browser.
    • Likelihood: Medium to High - If the response data is rendered in a web browser without proper sanitization or output encoding.
    • Impact: High - Can lead to session hijacking (stealing user cookies), data theft, defacement of the web page, and redirection to malicious sites.
    • Effort: Low to Medium - Many XSS payloads are readily available online. Crafting a targeted payload may require more effort.
    • Skill Level: Intermediate - Requires understanding of HTML, JavaScript, and how browsers handle untrusted content.
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires web application security testing (e.g., using a web vulnerability scanner) and monitoring for unusual client-side behavior.

Attack Tree Path: [6. Tamper with Response Data]

  • [6b. Modify Response Body] (HIGH):
    • Description: The attacker intercepts and modifies the response body returned by the server. This could involve injecting malicious code, altering data, or removing critical information.
    • Likelihood: Low to Medium - Depends on the ability to intercept and modify responses (e.g., through a MITM attack). HTTPS makes this more difficult.
    • Impact: High - Can alter the data displayed to the user, inject malicious content (e.g., XSS, malware), or disrupt application functionality.
    • Effort: Medium - Requires intercepting and modifying the response in transit, which can be challenging with HTTPS.
    • Skill Level: Intermediate - Requires knowledge of network protocols and potentially tools for intercepting and modifying network traffic.
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires traffic analysis, content validation, and integrity checks (e.g., comparing checksums).

Attack Tree Path: [7. Denial of Service via Response Handling]

  • [7b. Trigger Excessive Retries] (HIGH):
    • Description: The attacker crafts responses that intentionally trigger ytknetwork's retry mechanism. By repeatedly causing failures that lead to retries, the attacker can exhaust server resources and cause a denial of service.
    • Likelihood: Medium - Depends on the retry logic and error handling implemented in ytknetwork and the application. If retries are not properly limited, the likelihood is higher.
    • Impact: High - Can exhaust server resources (CPU, memory, network bandwidth) and cause denial of service, making the application unavailable to legitimate users.
    • Effort: Low to Medium - Requires understanding the retry mechanism and crafting responses that trigger retries.
    • Skill Level: Intermediate - Requires understanding of network protocols and application logic.
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires monitoring retry rates, server resource usage, and application performance. Unusually high retry rates would be a strong indicator.