Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
162 lines (131 loc) · 11 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

162 lines (131 loc) · 11 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for kanyun-inc/ytknetwork

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Underlying Library Configuration (Direct ytknetwork Modification)

Description:

  1. Code Review of ytknetwork: Thoroughly analyze ytknetwork's source code, specifically focusing on how it initializes and configures AFNetworking (iOS) and OkHttp (Android). Identify all security-relevant settings, including:
    • SSL/TLS configuration (protocol versions, cipher suites).
    • Certificate pinning implementation (if any).
    • Hostname verification logic.
    • Timeout settings.
    • HTTP/2 and HTTP/3 settings.
  2. Identify Hardcoded Settings: Pinpoint any instances where security settings are hardcoded within ytknetwork and assess their security implications.
  3. Expose Configuration Options: If ytknetwork doesn't expose sufficient configuration options for security settings, modify the library's code to:
    • Add public APIs (methods, properties, configuration objects) to allow developers to control these settings.
    • Ensure these new APIs are well-documented.
  4. Enforce Secure Defaults: If possible, modify ytknetwork to use secure defaults for all security-related settings. For example, default to TLS 1.3, enable strict hostname verification, and provide a mechanism for easy certificate pinning.
  5. Fork/Patch and Pull Request: Create a fork of the ytknetwork repository to implement these changes. Submit a pull request to the original project to contribute your improvements back to the community.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) Attacks (High Severity): By allowing proper configuration of SSL/TLS (certificate pinning, hostname verification), we directly prevent ytknetwork from being vulnerable to MITM attacks.
  • Weak Cipher Suite Usage (Medium Severity): Exposing and enforcing strong cipher suites within ytknetwork prevents the library from using vulnerable cryptographic algorithms.
  • Cleartext Traffic (High Severity): Ensuring ytknetwork defaults to HTTPS and allows configuration to prevent cleartext communication eliminates this risk within the library.

Impact:

  • MITM Attacks: Risk significantly reduced (potentially eliminated with proper pinning implemented within ytknetwork).
  • Weak Cipher Suite Usage: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Cleartext Traffic: Risk eliminated (within the scope of ytknetwork).

Currently Implemented:

  • None (This strategy requires direct modification of ytknetwork).

Missing Implementation:

  • All aspects of this strategy are missing, as it requires code changes to ytknetwork.

Mitigation Strategy: Request Signing within ytknetwork

Description:

  1. Integrate Signing Logic: Modify ytknetwork's code to include request signing logic directly within its request-sending methods.
  2. Choose a Signing Algorithm: Select a secure signing algorithm (e.g., HMAC-SHA256).
  3. Define Signing Parameters: Determine which parts of the request (body, URL, headers) will be included in the signature calculation.
  4. Key Management: Implement a secure way for ytknetwork to access the shared secret key used for signing. This might involve:
    • Configuration options.
    • Secure storage mechanisms (e.g., Keychain on iOS, Keystore on Android).
    • Avoid hardcoding the key.
  5. Automatic Signature Generation: Modify ytknetwork's request methods to automatically:
    • Calculate the signature before sending each request.
    • Add the signature as a custom header to the request.
  6. Optional Verification: Consider adding optional server-side signature verification logic within ytknetwork (this is less common, as verification is usually handled server-side). This could be useful for testing or in specific client-to-client communication scenarios.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Request Tampering (High Severity): By embedding signing directly within ytknetwork, we ensure that all requests made through the library are protected against tampering.
  • Replay Attacks (Medium Severity): Can be mitigated by including a timestamp and/or nonce in the signed data within ytknetwork's implementation.

Impact:

  • Request Tampering: Risk significantly reduced for all requests made through ytknetwork.
  • Replay Attacks: Risk significantly reduced (if timestamp/nonce is implemented within ytknetwork).

Currently Implemented:

  • None (This strategy requires direct modification of ytknetwork).

Missing Implementation:

  • All aspects of this strategy are missing.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Response Handling within ytknetwork

Description:

  1. Code Review: Thoroughly review ytknetwork's code responsible for handling responses, paying close attention to:
    • Deserialization of response data (JSON, XML, etc.).
    • Parsing of headers.
    • Error handling logic.
  2. Safe Deserialization:
    • JSON: Ensure ytknetwork uses a secure and up-to-date JSON parsing library. If not, replace it or modify the code to use a safe alternative.
    • XML: If ytknetwork handles XML responses, modify the code to explicitly disable external entity resolution in the XML parser it uses. This is crucial to prevent XXE attacks.
  3. Content-Type Handling: Modify ytknetwork to strictly validate the Content-Type header of responses before processing them. Reject responses with unexpected or missing content types.
  4. Error Handling Hardening: Review and modify ytknetwork's error handling to:
    • Prevent leaking sensitive information in error messages.
    • Ensure robust handling of various HTTP status codes and network errors.
    • Avoid any logic that could be exploited based on error conditions.

Threats Mitigated:

  • XXE Attacks (High Severity): Prevented by modifying ytknetwork to disable external entity resolution in its XML parsing.
  • Deserialization Vulnerabilities (High Severity): Mitigated by ensuring ytknetwork uses safe deserialization libraries and practices.
  • Content Type Confusion Attacks (Medium Severity): Prevented by ytknetwork strictly validating Content-Type headers.
  • Information Disclosure (Medium Severity): Reduced by hardening ytknetwork's error handling to avoid leaking sensitive information.

Impact:

  • XXE Attacks: Risk eliminated (within the scope of ytknetwork).
  • Deserialization Vulnerabilities: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Content Type Confusion Attacks: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Information Disclosure: Risk reduced.

Currently Implemented:

  • None (This strategy requires direct modification of ytknetwork).

Missing Implementation:

  • All aspects of this strategy are missing.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Caching Implementation within ytknetwork

Description:

  1. Code Review: Thoroughly examine ytknetwork's caching implementation. Identify:
    • Where cached data is stored (file paths, database names, etc.).
    • How caching is configured (expiration times, cache size limits).
    • What data is cached.
    • How cache invalidation is handled (if at all).
  2. Secure Storage: Modify ytknetwork to ensure that cached data is stored in a secure location, appropriate for the sensitivity of the data. This might involve:
    • Using platform-specific secure storage mechanisms (e.g., Keychain on iOS, encrypted SharedPreferences on Android).
    • Avoiding caching sensitive data in easily accessible locations.
  3. Cache Expiration Control: Enhance ytknetwork's caching configuration to allow fine-grained control over cache expiration times. Provide options to:
    • Set different expiration times for different types of data.
    • Disable caching for specific requests or responses.
    • Respect Cache-Control headers from the server.
  4. Cache Invalidation: Implement or improve ytknetwork's cache invalidation mechanisms. Add support for:
    • Invalidating the cache based on events (e.g., user logout, data updates).
    • Programmatic cache clearing.
  5. Encryption (Optional): If ytknetwork caches sensitive data, modify it to encrypt the cached data at rest using a strong encryption algorithm and securely manage the encryption keys.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Data Leakage from Cache (Medium Severity): Reduced by modifying ytknetwork to store cached data securely and implement proper invalidation.
  • Stale Data (Low Severity): Mitigated by enhancing ytknetwork's cache expiration and invalidation mechanisms.

Impact:

  • Data Leakage from Cache: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Stale Data: Risk reduced.

Currently Implemented:

  • None (This strategy requires direct modification of ytknetwork).

Missing Implementation:

  • All aspects of this strategy are missing.

Mitigation Strategy: Enhanced Logging within ytknetwork

Description:

  1. Add Logging Statements: Modify ytknetwork's code to include detailed logging statements throughout its request and response handling process. Log information such as:
    • Request URLs and methods.
    • Request headers (selectively, redacting sensitive data).
    • Request bodies (only if necessary and with careful redaction of sensitive data).
    • Response status codes.
    • Response headers (selectively).
    • Response bodies (only if necessary and with careful redaction).
    • Error messages and stack traces.
    • Timestamps.
    • Cache hits and misses.
  2. Configurable Logging Levels: Implement different logging levels (e.g., DEBUG, INFO, WARN, ERROR) within ytknetwork and allow developers to configure the logging level at runtime.
  3. Log Formatting: Use a consistent and structured log format (e.g., JSON) to make it easier to parse and analyze the logs.
  4. Redaction: Ensure that sensitive data (passwords, API keys, tokens) is never logged directly. Implement redaction mechanisms within ytknetwork's logging to replace sensitive data with placeholders.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Difficult Security Auditing (Medium Severity): Comprehensive logging within ytknetwork provides a detailed audit trail of all network activity handled by the library.
  • Undetected Attacks (High to Low Severity): Detailed logs can help identify unusual patterns or errors that might indicate an attack.

Impact:

  • Difficult Security Auditing: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Undetected Attacks: Risk reduced (by providing more information for analysis).

Currently Implemented:

  • None (This strategy requires direct modification of ytknetwork).

Missing Implementation:

  • All aspects of this strategy are missing.