Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
172 lines (137 loc) · 14.8 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

172 lines (137 loc) · 14.8 KB

Okay, let's perform a deep security analysis of the pnchart project based on the provided design review and the GitHub repository (https://github.com/kevinzhow/pnchart).

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

  • Objective: The primary objective is to conduct a thorough security analysis of the pnchart library, focusing on identifying potential vulnerabilities related to its core functionality: rendering pie and donut charts from user-provided data within a React environment. We aim to assess the risks associated with data handling, rendering logic, and integration with React, and to propose specific, actionable mitigation strategies. The analysis will cover key components like data input, processing, SVG rendering, and interaction with the React lifecycle.

  • Scope: The scope of this analysis includes:

    • The pnchart library's source code (TypeScript/JavaScript).
    • The library's interaction with the React framework.
    • The handling of user-provided data and configuration options.
    • The build and deployment process as described in the design review.
    • The SECURITY.md and LICENSE files.
    • The project's dependencies (primarily React).

    The scope excludes:

    • The security of the React application using pnchart (except where pnchart directly impacts it).
    • The security of the web server or CDN hosting the application.
    • Network-level security concerns (beyond what's relevant to client-side vulnerabilities).

  • Methodology:

    1. Code Review: We will manually review the pnchart source code, focusing on areas identified as potential security risks in the design review and through our understanding of common web vulnerabilities.
    2. Dependency Analysis: We will examine the project's dependencies (primarily React) for known vulnerabilities and assess the risk of supply chain attacks.
    3. Architecture and Data Flow Inference: Based on the code and documentation, we will infer the library's architecture, component interactions, and data flow to identify potential attack vectors.
    4. Threat Modeling: We will identify potential threats based on the library's functionality and the identified risks.
    5. Mitigation Strategy Recommendation: For each identified threat, we will propose specific, actionable mitigation strategies tailored to the pnchart project.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

Let's break down the security implications of the key components, inferred from the design review and the GitHub repository:

  • Data Input (Props):

    • data (array of objects): This is the primary input, containing the data to be visualized. Each object likely has properties like label (string) and value (number).
      • Security Implication: The label property is a prime candidate for XSS attacks if not properly sanitized. The value property, if not validated, could lead to unexpected behavior or rendering errors (e.g., negative values, extremely large values, non-numeric values).
    • options (object): This likely contains configuration options for the chart's appearance (colors, sizes, etc.).
      • Security Implication: While less likely to be a direct source of XSS, options that allow arbitrary CSS or style injection could be exploited. Options affecting calculations (e.g., angles, radii) could lead to rendering issues if not validated.
    • cx, cy, innerRadius, outerRadius, cornerRadius, padAngle (numbers): These props control the geometry of the chart.
      • Security Implication: Incorrect or malicious values could lead to division by zero, infinite loops, or other logic errors that could cause a denial-of-service (DoS) condition by crashing the browser tab or making the application unresponsive.

  • Data Processing (Internal Logic):

    • Angle Calculation: The library likely calculates angles and positions for each segment of the pie/donut chart.
      • Security Implication: Mathematical errors or edge cases in angle calculations could lead to rendering issues or, in extreme cases, infinite loops or excessive resource consumption.
    • Data Transformation: The library might transform the input data into a format suitable for rendering.
      • Security Implication: If this transformation involves string concatenation or manipulation using user-provided data, it could be vulnerable to XSS.

  • SVG Rendering (React Components):

    • path elements: The core of the chart is likely rendered using SVG path elements.
      • Security Implication: The d attribute of the path element, which defines the shape, is constructed based on calculated values. Errors in these calculations could lead to malformed SVG, potentially causing rendering issues or even browser vulnerabilities (though this is less likely with modern browsers).
    • text elements (labels, tooltips): Text elements are used to display labels and potentially tooltips.
      • Security Implication: This is the most critical area for XSS vulnerabilities. If user-provided label values are directly inserted into text elements without sanitization, an attacker could inject malicious JavaScript code.
    • Event Handlers (if any): The library might include event handlers for user interaction (e.g., clicks, hovers).
      • Security Implication: If event handlers are used to manipulate the DOM or update the chart based on user input, they must be carefully implemented to prevent XSS or other injection attacks. pnchart does not appear to have interactive elements based on a quick review, which reduces this risk.

  • React Integration:

    • Component Lifecycle: The library uses React's component lifecycle methods (e.g., useEffect, useState).
      • Security Implication: Incorrect use of lifecycle methods could lead to unexpected behavior or state corruption, but this is less likely to be a direct security vulnerability. More importantly, how the component updates in response to prop changes is crucial. If updates involve re-rendering text without sanitization, XSS remains a risk.

3. Architecture, Components, and Data Flow (Inferred)

Based on the code and documentation, we can infer the following:

  • Architecture: pnchart is a single React component (likely a functional component using hooks) that takes data and options as props and renders an SVG chart. It's a relatively simple, self-contained component.

  • Components:

    • Main PNChart Component: Receives props, performs calculations, and renders the SVG structure.
    • (Likely) Internal Helper Functions: Functions to calculate angles, generate path data (d attribute), and potentially handle color generation.

  • Data Flow:

    1. Input: The React application passes data and options as props to the PNChart component.
    2. Processing: The PNChart component (and its helper functions) process the data:
      • Validate numerical inputs (value, cx, cy, radii, etc.).
      • Calculate angles and positions for each segment.
      • Generate the d attribute for each path element.
      • Prepare label text.
    3. Rendering: The component renders an SVG element containing path elements for the segments and text elements for the labels.
    4. Update (on prop change): If the data or options props change, React re-renders the component, repeating steps 2 and 3.

4. Security Considerations (Tailored to pnchart)

Here are the specific security considerations, focusing on the identified risks:

  • XSS (Cross-Site Scripting) - HIGH PRIORITY:

    • Source: User-provided label values in the data prop, and potentially any options that allow for text input.
    • Impact: An attacker could inject malicious JavaScript code that would be executed in the context of the user's browser. This could lead to data theft, session hijacking, or defacement of the application.
    • Specific to pnchart: The library directly renders the label property into SVG text elements. This is a classic XSS vector.

  • Denial of Service (DoS) - MEDIUM PRIORITY:

    • Source: Maliciously crafted numerical input values for data, cx, cy, innerRadius, outerRadius, cornerRadius, or padAngle.
    • Impact: Could cause the library to enter an infinite loop, perform excessive calculations, or generate extremely large SVG elements, leading to browser crashes or unresponsiveness.
    • Specific to pnchart: The library performs geometric calculations based on these inputs. Edge cases and invalid values could trigger vulnerabilities.

  • Rendering Errors / Unexpected Behavior - LOW PRIORITY:

    • Source: Invalid or unexpected data types in the data prop (e.g., non-numeric value, missing label).
    • Impact: Could lead to incorrect chart rendering, JavaScript errors, or component crashes.
    • Specific to pnchart: While TypeScript helps prevent some type errors, runtime validation is still necessary.

  • Dependency Vulnerabilities - LOW/MEDIUM PRIORITY:

    • Source: Vulnerabilities in the react dependency.
    • Impact: Could lead to various vulnerabilities, depending on the specific React vulnerability.
    • Specific to pnchart: pnchart relies on React for rendering. Keeping React updated is crucial.

5. Mitigation Strategies (Actionable and Tailored)

Here are the specific mitigation strategies, addressing the identified threats:

  • XSS Mitigation - HIGH PRIORITY:

    • 1. Sanitize Labels (MUST DO):
      • Technique: Use a dedicated sanitization library like DOMPurify to remove any potentially dangerous HTML tags or attributes from the label values before rendering them in the SVG text elements. Do not attempt to write your own sanitization function, as this is error-prone.
      • Implementation: 
        import DOMPurify from 'dompurify';

// ... inside the PNChart component ...

<text>
  {DOMPurify.sanitize(item.label)}
</text>
      • Why DOMPurify: It's a well-maintained, widely used, and robust sanitization library specifically designed to prevent XSS. It's much safer than relying on React's built-in escaping (which is primarily for HTML, not SVG).
    • 2. Content Security Policy (CSP) (SHOULD DO):
      • Technique: Implement a CSP in the hosting application (not directly in pnchart, as it's a library). A strict CSP can significantly reduce the impact of XSS vulnerabilities even if sanitization fails.
      • Implementation: This involves setting HTTP headers (e.g., Content-Security-Policy) on the web server. A good starting point is: 
        Content-Security-Policy: default-src 'self'; script-src 'self'; style-src 'self';
        This policy restricts the application to loading resources (scripts, styles, etc.) only from the same origin. You may need to adjust this based on your application's needs.
      • Why CSP: It's a defense-in-depth measure. Even if an attacker manages to inject malicious code, the CSP can prevent it from executing.

  • DoS Mitigation - MEDIUM PRIORITY:

    • 1. Input Validation (MUST DO):
      • Technique: Validate all numerical inputs (value, cx, cy, radii, etc.) to ensure they are within reasonable bounds and of the correct type. Use typeof checks and potentially a validation library (though simple checks are likely sufficient here).
      • Implementation: 
        // ... inside the PNChart component ...

if (typeof item.value !== 'number' || item.value < 0) {
  // Handle invalid value (e.g., log an error, set a default value, or throw an error)
  console.error("Invalid value:", item.value);
  item.value = 0; // Or some other safe default
}

if (typeof cx !== 'number' || isNaN(cx)) {
    //handle error
}
// ... similar checks for other numerical props ...
      • Why: This prevents the library from entering states that could lead to excessive resource consumption.
    • 2. Defensive Programming (SHOULD DO):
      • Technique: Add checks within the calculation logic to prevent division by zero, infinite loops, or other potential errors. For example, ensure that denominators are not zero before performing division.
      • Implementation: This involves adding if statements and other checks within the helper functions that perform calculations.

  • Rendering Errors / Unexpected Behavior Mitigation - LOW PRIORITY:

    • 1. Type Checking (with TypeScript) (ALREADY IN PLACE, BUT AUGMENT):
      • Technique: pnchart already uses TypeScript, which provides static type checking. However, ensure that the types are as specific as possible and that you handle cases where data might not conform to the expected types (e.g., using optional properties or union types).
      • Implementation: Review the type definitions for the data and options props and make them as precise as possible.
    • 2. Runtime Validation (MUST DO):
      • Technique: As shown in the DoS mitigation, add runtime checks to ensure that data is of the expected type and within reasonable bounds.

  • Dependency Vulnerabilities Mitigation - LOW/MEDIUM PRIORITY:

    • 1. Regular Updates (MUST DO):
      • Technique: Use a tool like npm audit or yarn audit to regularly check for vulnerabilities in dependencies. Update dependencies (especially React) to their latest versions promptly.
      • Implementation: Integrate npm audit into the CI/CD pipeline (as recommended in the design review).
    • 2. Dependency Management Tool (SHOULD DO):
      • Technique: Consider using a tool like Dependabot (integrated with GitHub) to automatically create pull requests when new versions of dependencies are available.

Summary of Key Recommendations (MUST DO):

  1. Sanitize all user-provided labels using DOMPurify before rendering them in SVG text elements. This is the most critical step to prevent XSS.
  2. Validate all numerical inputs to prevent unexpected values that could lead to DoS or rendering errors.
  3. Regularly update dependencies (especially React) to patch known vulnerabilities.
  4. Integrate npm audit into the CI/CD pipeline.

By implementing these recommendations, the pnchart library can be significantly hardened against common web vulnerabilities, making it safer to use in React applications. Remember that security is an ongoing process, and regular reviews and updates are essential.