Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
126 lines (97 loc) · 7.26 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

126 lines (97 loc) · 7.26 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for kif-framework/kif

Mitigation Strategy: Strict Build Configuration Separation

  1. Create separate build configurations in Xcode: "Debug," "Release," and "UITests."

  2. In the "UITests" configuration, add KIF as a linked framework and library. This is typically done in the "Build Phases" section of the target settings.

  3. In the "Release" configuration, ensure KIF is not listed as a linked framework or library. Double-check all build phases.

  4. Use preprocessor macros (e.g., #if DEBUG || UITESTS) to conditionally include KIF-related code:

    #if DEBUG || UITESTS
#import <KIF/KIF.h>
#endif

// ... later in your code ...

#if DEBUG || UITESTS
// KIF test code here
[tester tapViewWithAccessibilityLabel:@"My Button"];
#endif

  5. In the "Build Settings," ensure that the "Other Linker Flags" for the "Release" configuration do not include any references to KIF.

  6. After building for "Release," use Xcode's "Analyze" feature (Product -> Analyze) and inspect the generated binary (using tools like otool or Hopper Disassembler) to confirm the absence of KIF symbols.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Accidental Inclusion of KIF in Production: (Severity: Critical) - The entire KIF framework and test code are present in the released app, allowing attackers to manipulate the UI, bypass security, and potentially access sensitive data.
    • Exposure of Test Code: (Severity: High) - Even if KIF itself is removed, remnants of test code (e.g., accessibility identifiers used only in tests) might leak information about the app's internal structure.

  • Impact:

    • Accidental Inclusion of KIF in Production: Risk reduced from Critical to Negligible (if implemented correctly).
    • Exposure of Test Code: Risk reduced from High to Low (some minor information leakage might still be possible, but the main attack surface is removed).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Separate build configurations ("Debug," "Release," "UITests") exist.
    • KIF is linked only in the "UITests" configuration.
    • Preprocessor macros are used in AppDelegate.m and ViewController.m to exclude KIF imports.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Preprocessor macros are not consistently used throughout all view controllers and helper classes. Some test code might still be included in the Release build.
    • No automated checks (e.g., scripts in a CI/CD pipeline) verify the absence of KIF in the Release build artifact.
    • Binary analysis after Release build is not a standard part of the workflow.

Mitigation Strategy: Test Code Isolation and Review

  1. Ensure all KIF test code resides in a separate Xcode target (e.g., "MyAppUITests").
  2. This target should be completely independent of the main application target.
  3. Within the test target, organize test code into logical groups (e.g., by feature or screen).
  4. Conduct regular code reviews of the KIF test code, focusing on:
    • Hardcoded credentials or sensitive data.
    • Insecure data handling (e.g., storing test data in insecure locations).
    • Potential bypasses of application security controls.
    • Use of mock data and test accounts instead of production data.
  5. Establish coding standards for KIF tests, emphasizing security best practices.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Exposure of Sensitive Data in Test Code: (Severity: High) - Hardcoded credentials or test data could be leaked if the test code is compromised.
    • Insecure Test Code Practices: (Severity: Medium) - Vulnerabilities in the test code itself could be exploited.
    • Accidental Use of Production Data: (Severity: High) - Using production data in tests could lead to data breaches or unintended modifications.

  • Impact:

    • Exposure of Sensitive Data in Test Code: Risk reduced from High to Low.
    • Insecure Test Code Practices: Risk reduced from Medium to Low.
    • Accidental Use of Production Data: Risk reduced from High to Negligible.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • KIF tests are in a separate "MyAppUITests" target.
    • Basic code organization within the test target.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No formal code review process specifically for KIF test code security.
    • No established coding standards for secure KIF test development.
    • No automated checks for hardcoded credentials or insecure practices in test code.

Mitigation Strategy: Runtime Checks (Use with Extreme Caution)

  1. (Only if absolutely necessary) Add code to the application's startup sequence (e.g., in AppDelegate.m) to check for the presence of KIF classes.

  2. This can be done using Objective-C runtime functions like objc_getClass.

  3. Example:

    #if !DEBUG && !UITESTS // Only in Release builds
Class kifClass = NSClassFromString(@"KIFTestActor");
if (kifClass != nil) {
    // KIF is present! Take drastic action.
    NSLog(@"ERROR: KIF detected in Release build!");
    exit(1); // Terminate the app
    // Or: disable sensitive features, display an error, etc.
}
#endif

  4. Thoroughly test this check to ensure it doesn't cause false positives or performance issues.

  5. Document this check clearly and explain its purpose (as a last resort).

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Accidental Inclusion of KIF in Production (Last Resort): (Severity: Critical) - Provides a final, albeit fragile, defense against KIF being present in a released build.

  • Impact:

    • Accidental Inclusion of KIF in Production (Last Resort): Risk reduced from Critical to Very Low (but relies on the check not being bypassed). This is a fallback mechanism, not a primary defense.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Not implemented.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No runtime checks for KIF are present. (This is acceptable, as the other mitigation strategies should be sufficient.)

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Updates

  1. Establish a process for regularly checking for updates to the KIF framework.
  2. Subscribe to the KIF project's release notifications (e.g., on GitHub).
  3. When a new version is released, review the release notes for any security-related fixes or improvements.
  4. Update the KIF framework in your project to the latest stable version, following the project's instructions.
  5. Thoroughly test the application after updating KIF to ensure no regressions were introduced.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Known Vulnerabilities in KIF: (Severity: Variable, depends on the vulnerability) - Exploiting known vulnerabilities in older versions of the framework.

  • Impact:

    • Known Vulnerabilities in KIF: Risk reduced from Variable to Low (assuming timely updates).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • The project uses a specific version of KIF (e.g., 3.8.0).

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No formal process for monitoring KIF updates.
    • No automated checks to ensure the project is using the latest stable version of KIF.