Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
90 lines (65 loc) · 8.75 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

90 lines (65 loc) · 8.75 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for mutualmobile/mmdrawercontroller

Mitigation Strategy: Robust State Management for Drawer Open/Close

Description:

  1. Define a State Enum: Create a Swift enum to represent the drawer's possible states (e.g., DrawerState { case open, closed, opening, closing }). This enum should be specific to the states provided and managed by MMDrawerController.
  2. Centralized State Manager: Implement a singleton or a dedicated class (e.g., DrawerStateManager) to hold the current DrawerState. This class should directly interact with MMDrawerController's methods and properties to get and set the drawer's state. For example, use mmDrawerController.openDrawerSide(...) and mmDrawerController.closeDrawer(...) within the state manager's methods, and use mmDrawerController.openSide to query the current state. Do not manage the state independently of the library.
  3. Data Loading Based on MMDrawerController State: Within the drawer's view controllers, use MMDrawerController's delegate methods (if available) or KVO (Key-Value Observing) on MMDrawerController's properties (like openSide) to detect state changes. Only load and display sensitive data when MMDrawerController reports that the drawer is fully open.
  4. Data Clearing on MMDrawerController Closure: Similarly, use delegate methods or KVO to detect when MMDrawerController is closing the drawer. Immediately clear any sensitive data in the drawer's view controllers when the drawer begins to close, as reported by MMDrawerController.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Information Leakage (Severity: High): Prevents sensitive data from being displayed when the drawer is in an intermediate state (opening, closing) managed by MMDrawerController.
  • Unauthorized Access (Severity: High): Ensures data is only loaded when MMDrawerController indicates the drawer is fully open and accessible.

Impact:

  • Information Leakage: Risk significantly reduced. Data visibility is directly tied to MMDrawerController's reported state.
  • Unauthorized Access: Risk significantly reduced. Data loading depends on MMDrawerController's open state.

Currently Implemented:

  • State Enum: Implemented in DrawerState.swift.
  • Centralized State Manager: Partially implemented in DrawerStateManager.swift. State transitions are not fully synchronized with MMDrawerController's methods.
  • Data Loading/Clearing: Not implemented; relies on view controller lifecycle methods instead of MMDrawerController's state.

Missing Implementation:

  • DrawerStateManager.swift: Must be refactored to directly use MMDrawerController's methods and properties for state management.
  • All drawer view controllers: Must use MMDrawerController's delegate methods or KVO to trigger data loading and clearing, not standard view controller lifecycle methods.

Mitigation Strategy: Correct MMDrawerController View Controller Containment

Description:

  1. Strict Adherence to Apple's Guidelines: When initializing and setting up MMDrawerController, meticulously follow Apple's guidelines for view controller containment. This is crucial for MMDrawerController to function correctly.
  2. Correct Method Calls: Ensure that addChild, didMove(toParent:), removeFromParent, and willMove(toParent:) are called in the precise order specified by Apple's documentation when adding or removing the center view controller and the drawer view controllers to/from the MMDrawerController instance. Incorrect usage can lead to memory leaks and unexpected behavior within MMDrawerController.
  3. MMDrawerController Lifecycle Awareness: Understand how MMDrawerController manages the lifecycles of its child view controllers. Avoid making assumptions about the lifecycle events of the drawer's view controllers based solely on standard iOS behavior. Test thoroughly to ensure proper behavior.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Memory Leaks (Severity: Medium): Incorrect containment can cause MMDrawerController to retain view controllers improperly, leading to leaks.
  • Unexpected Behavior (Severity: Medium): Incorrect lifecycle management can cause MMDrawerController to behave unpredictably, potentially leading to UI glitches or crashes.

Impact:

  • Memory Leaks: Risk significantly reduced by ensuring correct containment and lifecycle management within MMDrawerController.
  • Unexpected Behavior: Risk reduced by adhering to Apple's guidelines and understanding MMDrawerController's internal workings.

Currently Implemented:

  • Containment Guidelines: Partially followed, but needs a thorough review in the code where MMDrawerController is initialized and configured.

Missing Implementation:

  • AppDelegate.swift (or wherever MMDrawerController is set up): A complete review and refactoring are needed to ensure strict adherence to Apple's containment guidelines, specifically in the context of how MMDrawerController uses them.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Deep Link Integration with MMDrawerController

Description: (Only if deep links control MMDrawerController)

  1. Indirect Drawer Control: If deep links are used to open or close the drawer, or to navigate to specific content within the drawer, do not directly manipulate the drawer's state using the deep link parameters. Instead, use the deep link to navigate to a specific view controller within your application.
  2. MMDrawerController Interaction in View Controller: Within that view controller, then use MMDrawerController's methods (e.g., openDrawerSide, closeDrawer) to control the drawer's state. This separation prevents direct manipulation of MMDrawerController from potentially malicious deep link input.
  3. Authorization Before MMDrawerController Action: Before calling any MMDrawerController methods in response to a deep link, perform an authorization check (using a centralized AuthorizationManager, as described in previous responses, but this is a general good practice, not directly related to MMDrawerController). Only interact with MMDrawerController if the user is authorized.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Unauthorized Access (Severity: High): Prevents attackers from using malicious deep links to directly control MMDrawerController and bypass authorization.
  • Unexpected State (Severity: Medium): Prevents deep links from putting MMDrawerController into an unexpected or invalid state.

Impact:

  • Unauthorized Access: Risk significantly reduced. Deep links cannot directly manipulate MMDrawerController.
  • Unexpected State: Risk reduced by controlling MMDrawerController through a dedicated view controller.

Currently Implemented:

  • Indirect Drawer Control: Not implemented. Deep links might directly call MMDrawerController methods.
  • Authorization Before Action: Not implemented in the context of deep links.

Missing Implementation:

  • Deep link handling logic: Must be refactored to navigate to a view controller first, and then interact with MMDrawerController within that view controller, after authorization checks.

Mitigation Strategy: Keep MMDrawerController Updated

Description:

  1. Dependency Management: Use a dependency manager (CocoaPods, Swift Package Manager) to include MMDrawerController in your project.
  2. Regular Updates: Regularly check for updates to the MMDrawerController library. Update to the latest version promptly, especially if the changelog mentions security fixes or bug fixes related to view controller management or state handling. This is crucial because vulnerabilities could exist within the library itself.
  3. Review Changelogs: Before updating, carefully review the changelog for the new version. Look for any changes that might affect your application's functionality or security.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Known Vulnerabilities (Severity: Variable, potentially High): Directly addresses vulnerabilities that might be discovered and patched within the MMDrawerController library itself.

Impact:

  • Known Vulnerabilities: Risk significantly reduced by applying updates that contain security fixes.

Currently Implemented:

  • Dependency Management: CocoaPods is used.
  • Regular Updates: Updates are performed occasionally, but not on a regular, proactive schedule.

Missing Implementation:

  • Establish a formal schedule for checking and applying updates to MMDrawerController (and all other dependencies).