Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
129 lines (98 loc) · 8.09 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

129 lines (98 loc) · 8.09 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for path/fastimagecache

Mitigation Strategy: Strong, Unpredictable Cache Keys (within fastimagecache)

  • Description:

    1. Modify fastimagecache Key Generation: Directly alter the library's code responsible for generating cache keys.
    2. Content Hashing (Inside Library): Integrate the calculation of a SHA-256 hash of the original image's raw byte data within the fastimagecache library, before any processing. This should be a core part of the key generation process.
    3. Parameter Hashing (Inside Library): Modify fastimagecache to concatenate all relevant image processing parameters (after validation – see separate strategy) into a consistent string representation. Hash this string using SHA-256.
    4. Combined Hashing (Inside Library): Implement the combined hashing approach: final_key = sha256(sha256(parameter_string) + image_content_hash) within the library's key generation logic.
    5. Expose Configuration (Optional): Consider exposing configuration options to allow users to choose the hashing algorithm (though SHA-256 should be the default and strongly recommended).

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Cache Poisoning: (Severity: High)
    • Cache Tampering: (Severity: High)
    • Information Disclosure (Limited): (Severity: Medium)

  • Impact:

    • Cache Poisoning: Significantly reduced, as the attacker needs the original image content and parameters.
    • Cache Tampering: Reduced (best with integrity checks).
    • Information Disclosure: Partially reduced.

  • Currently Implemented: (Example - Needs project-specific details)

    • fastimagecache currently uses a simple hash of the URL.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Hashing of original image content within the library.
    • Parameter hashing within the library.
    • Combined hashing logic within the library.

Mitigation Strategy: Input Validation and Sanitization (within fastimagecache)

  • Description:

    1. Integrate Validation: Modify fastimagecache to perform strict input validation before processing any image or generating cache keys.
    2. Allow-Lists (Within Library): Embed allow-lists for all image processing parameters (width, height, quality, format, etc.) directly within the fastimagecache code.
    3. Reject Invalid Input (Within Library): Modify fastimagecache to immediately reject any requests with parameters that don't match the allow-lists. Throw an exception or return an error code that can be handled by the calling application.
    4. Type Checking (Within Library): Ensure that fastimagecache performs type checking on all input parameters.
    5. Configuration (Optional): Consider allowing users to configure the allow-lists through a configuration file or API, but provide secure defaults.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Cache Poisoning: (Severity: High)
    • Denial of Service (Cache Exhaustion): (Severity: Medium)
    • Vulnerabilities in Image Processing Libraries: (Severity: High)

  • Impact:

    • Cache Poisoning: Significantly reduced.
    • Denial of Service: Helps mitigate.
    • Image Processing Vulnerabilities: Reduces likelihood.

  • Currently Implemented: (Example)

    • fastimagecache has minimal input validation.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Comprehensive allow-lists for all parameters within the library.
    • Early and strict validation within the library's request handling.
    • Robust error handling for invalid input within the library.

Mitigation Strategy: Digital Signatures / Integrity Checks (within fastimagecache)

  • Description:

    1. Hashing on Cache (Inside Library): Modify fastimagecache to calculate a SHA-256 hash of the original image data before storing it in the cache.
    2. Store Hash (Library Managed): Modify fastimagecache to store this hash alongside the cached image data. The library should manage the storage and retrieval of this hash.
    3. Hashing on Retrieval (Inside Library): Modify fastimagecache to, upon retrieval, calculate the SHA-256 hash of the retrieved cached image data.
    4. Compare and Handle (Inside Library): Modify fastimagecache to compare the calculated hash with the stored hash. If they don't match, the library should:
      • Discard the cached image.
      • Log the event (using a logging mechanism within fastimagecache).
      • Optionally, automatically re-fetch and re-cache the original image (and re-calculate the hash).
      • Return an error or throw an exception to indicate the cache miss/tampering.
    5. Digital Signatures (Optional, Inside Library): Implement digital signature generation and verification within fastimagecache as a more robust alternative to simple hashing.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Cache Tampering: (Severity: High)
    • Cache Poisoning (Partial): (Severity: High)

  • Impact:

    • Cache Tampering: Effectively eliminates.
    • Cache Poisoning: Fail-safe mechanism.

  • Currently Implemented: (Example)

    • Not implemented within fastimagecache.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • The entire process of hash calculation, storage, retrieval, and comparison within fastimagecache.

Mitigation Strategy: Cache Size Limits and Eviction Policy (within fastimagecache)

  • Description:

    1. Configurable Limit: Modify fastimagecache to allow users to configure a maximum cache size (e.g., in bytes or number of entries). Provide a sensible default.
    2. Eviction Policy Implementation: Implement one or more cache eviction policies (LRU, LFU, TTL) directly within fastimagecache.
    3. Policy Selection: Allow users to choose the eviction policy through configuration.
    4. Automatic Eviction: Modify fastimagecache to automatically evict entries based on the chosen policy when the cache reaches its size limit.
    5. Internal Monitoring: Add internal monitoring within fastimagecache to track cache size, hit rate, and eviction rate. Expose this data through logging or a dedicated API.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (Cache Exhaustion): (Severity: High)

  • Impact:

    • Denial of Service: Significantly reduces risk.

  • Currently Implemented: (Example)

    • fastimagecache has a hardcoded TTL.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Configurable maximum cache size.
    • Choice of eviction policies (LRU, LFU).
    • Internal monitoring of cache statistics.

Mitigation Strategy: Request Normalization (within fastimagecache)

  • Description:

    1. Normalization Rules: Embed normalization rules for image processing parameters directly within the fastimagecache code.
    2. Apply Before Key Generation: Modify fastimagecache to apply these rules before generating the cache key. This should happen after input validation.
    3. Examples:
      • Round width/height to the nearest multiple of 10.
      • Clamp quality values to a specific range.
      • Convert format strings to lowercase.
    4. Configuration (Optional): Consider allowing users to configure the normalization rules, but provide secure defaults.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (Cache Exhaustion): (Severity: Medium)

  • Impact:

    • Denial of Service: Helps mitigate.

  • Currently Implemented: (Example)

    • Not implemented within fastimagecache.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • The entire process of defining and applying normalization rules within fastimagecache.