Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
127 lines (102 loc) · 11.4 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

127 lines (102 loc) · 11.4 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for robbiehanson/cocoaasyncsocket

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Delegate Method Implementation

Description:

  1. Implement All Delegates: Ensure every delegate method provided by GCDAsyncSocket and GCDAsyncUdpSocket is implemented. This includes error-handling delegates.
  2. Robust Error Handling: Within each delegate method, especially error-related ones (e.g., socketDidDisconnect:withError:, socket:didNotConnect:, etc.), check for errors returned by CocoaAsyncSocket. Log these errors and take appropriate action based on the error (reconnect, close socket, inform user). Never silently ignore errors from CocoaAsyncSocket.
  3. Input Re-Validation: Inside data-receiving delegate methods (socket:didReadData:withTag:, udpSocket:didReceiveData:fromAddress:withFilterContext:), re-validate all data received through the CocoaAsyncSocket APIs. Assume the data is potentially malicious. Check length, type, and content.
  4. Thread-Safe State (Related to CocoaAsyncSocket): If delegate methods access shared resources that are also used in conjunction with CocoaAsyncSocket calls (e.g., checking a flag to see if a write should be performed), use synchronization mechanisms (locks, @synchronized, dispatch queues) to prevent race conditions. Understand that CocoaAsyncSocket handles its internal threading, but your interaction with it and shared data needs to be thread-safe.
  5. Non-Blocking Delegates: Keep delegate methods short and fast. Avoid blocking operations. If a long operation is needed as a result of a CocoaAsyncSocket event, dispatch it to a background queue using GCD.
  6. Tag Validation: If using tags to identify asynchronous CocoaAsyncSocket operations, validate the tag within the delegate method to ensure it matches the expected tag. This prevents misinterpreting responses.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Code Injection (Severity: Critical): Improper input validation in delegate methods can allow attackers to inject malicious code through the socket.
  • Denial of Service (DoS) (Severity: High): Blocking operations in delegate methods can make the application unresponsive, especially the socket handling. Unhandled CocoaAsyncSocket errors can lead to resource leaks.
  • Data Corruption (Severity: High): Race conditions related to shared state used with CocoaAsyncSocket can corrupt data.
  • Information Disclosure (Severity: Medium): Exposing internal CocoaAsyncSocket error details can aid attackers.
  • Logic Errors (Severity: Variable): Incorrect state or tag handling related to CocoaAsyncSocket calls can lead to unexpected behavior.

Impact:

  • Code Injection: Risk significantly reduced by re-validating all input within delegate methods that receive data from CocoaAsyncSocket.
  • DoS: Risk significantly reduced by avoiding blocking operations and handling CocoaAsyncSocket errors properly.
  • Data Corruption: Risk eliminated by using appropriate synchronization for shared state accessed in conjunction with CocoaAsyncSocket.
  • Information Disclosure: Risk reduced by logging CocoaAsyncSocket errors securely.
  • Logic Errors: Risk reduced by careful state and tag management within CocoaAsyncSocket delegate methods.

Currently Implemented:

  • Basic delegate methods are implemented.
  • Error logging is present but may not be comprehensive for all CocoaAsyncSocket errors.
  • Input validation is present but needs review for re-validation within CocoaAsyncSocket delegate methods.
  • Thread safety is partially implemented, but a full audit related to CocoaAsyncSocket interactions is needed.

Missing Implementation:

  • Comprehensive error handling for all CocoaAsyncSocket delegate methods.
  • Re-validation of input within socket:didReadData:withTag: and similar methods.
  • Thorough thread-safety audit of code interacting with CocoaAsyncSocket.
  • Consistent tag validation in all relevant CocoaAsyncSocket delegate methods.

Mitigation Strategy: Robust TLS/SSL Configuration and Verification (Using CocoaAsyncSocket APIs)

Description:

  1. Enable TLS: Always use startTLS: to initiate a secure connection using CocoaAsyncSocket.
  2. kCFStreamSSLValidatesCertificateChain: In the dictionary passed to startTLS:, ensure kCFStreamSSLValidatesCertificateChain is set to @YES.
  3. kCFStreamSSLCertificates (Optional): If you have specific trusted root certificates, provide them using the kCFStreamSSLCertificates key in the startTLS: dictionary.
  4. Implement socket:didReceiveTrust:completionHandler:: Implement this crucial CocoaAsyncSocket delegate method for fine-grained control over certificate validation. This is essential for certificate pinning and handling self-signed certificates (if absolutely necessary and with extreme caution). Within this method, you must evaluate the provided SecTrustRef and call the completionHandler with YES to trust the connection or NO to reject it.
  5. Set Strong Cipher Suites: Use kCFStreamSSLCipherSuites in the startTLS: dictionary to specify an array of allowed cipher suites. Prioritize strong, modern ciphers.
  6. Enforce TLS Version: Use kCFStreamSSLMinimumProtocolVersion and kCFStreamSSLMaximumProtocolVersion in the startTLS: dictionary to restrict the allowed TLS versions (at least TLS 1.2, ideally TLS 1.3).

Threats Mitigated:

  • Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks (Severity: Critical): Incorrect TLS configuration in CocoaAsyncSocket allows attackers to intercept communication.
  • Eavesdropping (Severity: Critical): Without startTLS:, communication is in plain text.
  • Data Tampering (Severity: Critical): Attackers can modify data in transit without proper TLS configuration in CocoaAsyncSocket.
  • Impersonation (Severity: Critical): Attackers can impersonate the server if certificate validation within CocoaAsyncSocket is weak.

Impact:

  • MitM Attacks: Risk virtually eliminated with proper certificate validation (including pinning) within the socket:didReceiveTrust:completionHandler: delegate method.
  • Eavesdropping: Risk eliminated by using startTLS:.
  • Data Tampering: Risk eliminated by using startTLS: with a secure configuration.
  • Impersonation: Risk significantly reduced by proper certificate validation within CocoaAsyncSocket.

Currently Implemented:

  • startTLS: is used.
  • kCFStreamSSLValidatesCertificateChain is set to @YES.
  • A basic implementation of socket:didReceiveTrust:completionHandler: exists but lacks certificate pinning.

Missing Implementation:

  • Certificate pinning within socket:didReceiveTrust:completionHandler:.
  • Explicit strong cipher suite restrictions using kCFStreamSSLCipherSuites.
  • Explicit TLS version restrictions using kCFStreamSSLMinimumProtocolVersion and kCFStreamSSLMaximumProtocolVersion.
  • Enhanced checks (expiration, revocation) within socket:didReceiveTrust:completionHandler:.

Mitigation Strategy: Safe Data Handling and Buffer Management (Using CocoaAsyncSocket Reads)

Description:

  1. Bounded Buffers: When reading data using CocoaAsyncSocket methods, use appropriately sized buffers.
  2. Length Checks: Always check the length of data received from CocoaAsyncSocket before processing.
  3. Progressive Reading: For potentially large data, use CocoaAsyncSocket's readDataToData:withTimeout:tag: or readDataToLength:withTimeout:tag: methods to read data in chunks. Process each chunk as it arrives, rather than attempting to read everything at once using a single, large buffer. This is a direct use of CocoaAsyncSocket's API for safer reading.
  4. Data Framing (with CocoaAsyncSocket): Implement a data framing protocol and use CocoaAsyncSocket's read methods to enforce it. For example:
    • Length Prefixing: Use readDataToLength:withTimeout:tag: to read the length prefix, then use readDataToLength:withTimeout:tag: again to read the message data.
    • Delimiters: Use readDataToData:withTimeout:tag: to read until the delimiter is found.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Buffer Overflow (Severity: Critical): Unbounded reads from CocoaAsyncSocket can overwrite memory.
  • Denial of Service (DoS) (Severity: High): Reading excessively large amounts of data from CocoaAsyncSocket can exhaust memory.
  • Data Corruption (Severity: High): Incorrectly handling partial reads or message boundaries from CocoaAsyncSocket can lead to data corruption.

Impact:

  • Buffer Overflow: Risk virtually eliminated by using bounded buffers and length checks with data read from CocoaAsyncSocket.
  • DoS: Risk significantly reduced by using CocoaAsyncSocket's progressive reading methods.
  • Data Corruption: Risk significantly reduced by implementing data framing using CocoaAsyncSocket's read methods.

Currently Implemented:

  • Fixed-size buffers are used in some places.
  • Basic length checks are present after reading from CocoaAsyncSocket.
  • A rudimentary delimiter-based framing protocol is used, but not robustly implemented with CocoaAsyncSocket's methods.

Missing Implementation:

  • Consistent use of bounded buffers with all CocoaAsyncSocket reads.
  • Progressive reading using readDataToData: or readDataToLength: is not consistently implemented.
  • The data framing protocol needs to be redesigned and implemented using the appropriate CocoaAsyncSocket read methods.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Connection Management (Using CocoaAsyncSocket APIs)

Description:

  1. Connection Timeouts: Use connectToHost:onPort:withTimeout:error: and specify a reasonable timeout.
  2. Read/Write Timeouts: In all CocoaAsyncSocket read and write operations (e.g., readDataToData:withTimeout:tag:, writeData:withTimeout:tag:), set appropriate timeouts.
  3. Graceful Disconnection: When a socket is no longer needed, call CocoaAsyncSocket's disconnect method.
  4. Handle Disconnections: Implement the socketDidDisconnect:withError: delegate method to handle disconnections reported by CocoaAsyncSocket.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Denial of Service (DoS) (Severity: High): Lack of timeouts in CocoaAsyncSocket calls can lead to the application hanging.
  • Resource Leaks (Severity: Medium): Failing to call disconnect on CocoaAsyncSocket can lead to leaks.

Impact:

  • DoS: Risk significantly reduced by setting timeouts in all relevant CocoaAsyncSocket methods.
  • Resource Leaks: Risk eliminated by calling disconnect on CocoaAsyncSocket.

Currently Implemented:

  • Connection timeouts are used.
  • Read/write timeouts are partially implemented, but not consistently in all CocoaAsyncSocket calls.
  • disconnect is called in some cases.

Missing Implementation:

  • Consistent use of read/write timeouts in all CocoaAsyncSocket read/write operations.
  • Ensure disconnect is always called when a CocoaAsyncSocket instance is no longer needed.
  • Robust handling of disconnections in the socketDidDisconnect:withError: delegate method.