Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
360 lines (250 loc) · 29.1 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

360 lines (250 loc) · 29.1 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for bcit-ci/codeigniter

Mitigation Strategy: Secure encryption_key

  • Description:

    1. Locate Configuration File: Open the config/config.php file within your CodeIgniter application (usually in application/config/).
    2. Identify encryption_key: Find the line defining the encryption key: $config['encryption_key'] = 'your_key'; (or similar).
    3. Generate Strong Key: Create a cryptographically strong, unique, and random key. Use a secure random string generator. Avoid predictable keys.
    4. Replace Default Key: Replace the placeholder 'your_key' with your generated strong key.
    5. Configuration Storage: Ensure config/config.php is securely stored and not publicly accessible. Consider using environment variables for production environments to keep the key out of the codebase.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Session Hijacking (High Severity): Weak encryption_key compromises session encryption, enabling session hijacking.
    • Cookie Manipulation (Medium Severity): CodeIgniter uses this key for cookie signing; a weak key allows forging signed cookies.
    • Data Decryption (Medium Severity): If used for other encryption, a weak key risks data decryption.

  • Impact:

    • Session Hijacking: High - Significantly reduces risk by making session decryption infeasible.
    • Cookie Manipulation: Medium - Substantially reduces cookie forgery risk.
    • Data Decryption: Medium - Substantially reduces unauthorized data decryption risk.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Yes, implemented in application/config/config.php.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No missing implementation. Key is rotated annually.]

Mitigation Strategy: Remove index.php from URLs (CodeIgniter Routing)

  • Description:

    1. Configure config.php: In application/config/config.php, set $config['index_page'] = ''; (empty string). This tells CodeIgniter to expect URLs without index.php.
    2. Web Server Configuration (Apache Example): Use .htaccess in the application root with mod_rewrite enabled:
    <IfModule mod_rewrite.c>
    RewriteEngine On
    RewriteBase /
    RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-f
    RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-d
    RewriteRule ^(.*)$ index.php/$1 [L]
</IfModule>

    (Nginx configuration will be different, consult Nginx documentation for URL rewriting).

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Information Disclosure (Low Severity): Slightly obscures framework usage by hiding index.php, making reconnaissance marginally harder.
    • Obfuscation (Low Severity): Cleaner URLs improve aesthetics and subtly reduce predictability.

  • Impact:

    • Information Disclosure: Low - Minimally reduces framework identification.
    • Obfuscation: Low - Minor improvement in URL clarity and slight obfuscation.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Yes, implemented using .htaccess.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No missing implementation.]

Mitigation Strategy: Disable display_errors in Production (CodeIgniter Environment)

  • Description:

    1. Set ENVIRONMENT: In your main index.php file, ensure ENVIRONMENT is set to 'production' for live environments.
    2. CodeIgniter Configuration: CodeIgniter automatically handles error display based on the ENVIRONMENT setting. Verify that in application/config/config.php (or environment-specific config), $config['show_error_display'] is effectively set to FALSE in production (this is often the default for 'production' environment).

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Information Disclosure (Medium Severity): Production error messages can reveal sensitive application details to attackers.

  • Impact:

    • Information Disclosure: Medium - Significantly reduces information leakage via error messages.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Yes, ENVIRONMENT is 'production' and error display is disabled.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No missing implementation. Error logging is configured.]

Mitigation Strategy: Leverage CodeIgniter's Input Class for Validation and Sanitization

  • Description:

    1. Use $this->input: Consistently use CodeIgniter's Input class ($this->input) to access all user inputs (POST, GET, COOKIE, etc.).
    2. Form Validation Library: Load CodeIgniter's Form Validation library ($this->load->library('form_validation');).
    3. Define Validation Rules: Use $this->form_validation->set_rules() to define validation rules for each input field. Specify data types, required fields, constraints, etc.
    4. Run Validation: Execute validation with $this->form_validation->run(). Handle validation failures appropriately (display errors to the user).
    5. Sanitize Input: Use Input class sanitization functions like $this->input->xss_clean(), $this->input->strip_tags(), $this->input->escape() as needed after validation and before using or storing input. Choose sanitization appropriate for the context.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • SQL Injection (High Severity): Prevents injection by validating and sanitizing input before database queries.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (High Severity): Sanitization using xss_clean() and strip_tags() mitigates XSS risks.
    • Command Injection (Medium Severity): Reduces risk if input is used in system commands (though avoid this pattern).
    • Path Traversal (Medium Severity): Validation helps prevent malicious path manipulation.

  • Impact:

    • SQL Injection: High - Significantly reduces SQL injection vulnerability.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): High - Significantly reduces XSS vulnerability.
    • Command Injection: Medium - Reduces command injection risk.
    • Path Traversal: Medium - Reduces path traversal risk.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Partially implemented. Input validation used in key controllers.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Extend input validation to all controllers and models handling user input.]

Mitigation Strategy: Use Query Builder and Prepared Statements (CodeIgniter Database)

  • Description:

    1. Prefer Query Builder: Utilize CodeIgniter's Query Builder ($this->db) for database interactions. It automatically escapes values.
    2. Prepared Statements (Advanced): For complex queries or stored procedures, use prepared statements with parameter binding supported by CodeIgniter's database library.
    3. Avoid Raw Queries with Concatenation: Do not construct raw SQL queries by directly concatenating user input strings. This is a primary SQL injection risk.
    4. Review and Refactor: Audit existing code for raw SQL queries and refactor them to use Query Builder or prepared statements.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • SQL Injection (High Severity): Query Builder and prepared statements are the primary defense against SQL injection.

  • Impact:

    • SQL Injection: High - Significantly reduces SQL injection vulnerability.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Mostly implemented. Query Builder is standard practice.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Refactor legacy raw SQL queries to Query Builder.]

Mitigation Strategy: Employ Output Encoding Functions (CodeIgniter Helpers)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Output Points in Views: Find all locations in your CodeIgniter views where dynamic data (from database or user input) is displayed.
    2. Use esc() Function: Use CodeIgniter's esc() function (or html_escape() for HTML context) to encode output before displaying it in views.
    3. Context-Aware Encoding: Use appropriate encoding functions based on the output context (HTML, JavaScript, URL, CSS). esc() is context-aware and generally recommended.
    4. Consistent Application: Apply output encoding consistently to all dynamic output in views to prevent XSS.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (High Severity): Output encoding prevents XSS by rendering potentially malicious scripts as plain text.

  • Impact:

    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): High - Significantly reduces XSS vulnerability.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Partially implemented. esc() used in newer views.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Retroactively apply esc() to all dynamic output in existing views.]

Mitigation Strategy: Configure Secure Session Settings (CodeIgniter Session Library)

  • Description:

    1. config/config.php Settings: Review and configure session settings in application/config/config.php:
      • sess_cookie_secure: Set to TRUE for HTTPS only cookies.
      • sess_http_only: Set to TRUE to prevent JavaScript access to session cookies.
      • sess_time_to_update: Adjust session regeneration frequency.
      • sess_driver: Consider database or Redis (database, redis) for session storage instead of files (files) for better security and scalability.
    2. Session Driver Choice: If using database or Redis, configure the necessary database/Redis connection settings in database.php or appropriate configuration files.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Session Hijacking (High Severity): Secure session settings reduce risks of session hijacking and session fixation.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (Medium Severity): sess_http_only mitigates some XSS-related session cookie theft.

  • Impact:

    • Session Hijacking: High - Significantly reduces session hijacking and fixation risks.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): Medium - Provides some mitigation against XSS-related cookie theft.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Partially implemented. sess_cookie_secure and sess_http_only are TRUE, but using file-based sessions.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Migrate session storage to database or Redis for enhanced security and scalability.]

Mitigation Strategy: Enable CSRF Protection (CodeIgniter CSRF Feature)

  • Description:

    1. Enable in config.php: Set $config['csrf_protection'] = TRUE; in application/config/config.php.
    2. Form Helper Usage: Use CodeIgniter's form helpers (e.g., form_open()) to automatically include CSRF tokens in forms.
    3. AJAX Handling: For AJAX requests, retrieve the CSRF token (e.g., from meta tag or cookie - CodeIgniter provides csrf_token() and csrf_header() helpers) and include it in AJAX request headers or data.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) (Medium Severity): CSRF protection prevents attackers from performing unauthorized actions on behalf of authenticated users.

  • Impact:

    • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF): Medium - Significantly reduces CSRF vulnerability.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Yes, CSRF protection is enabled and form helpers are used.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Implement AJAX CSRF token handling for all AJAX endpoints.]

Mitigation Strategy: Use Form Helpers for CSRF Tokens (CodeIgniter Form Helper)

  • Description:

    1. Use form_open(): When creating HTML forms in your views, consistently use CodeIgniter's form_open() helper function to generate the opening <form> tag. This function automatically injects the CSRF token as a hidden field.
    2. Avoid Manual Form Creation: Minimize or eliminate manually written <form> tags. Rely on form_open() to ensure CSRF tokens are always included.
    3. Verify Token on Submission: CodeIgniter automatically verifies the CSRF token on form submissions when CSRF protection is enabled in config.php.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) (Medium Severity): Ensures CSRF tokens are present in forms, preventing CSRF attacks.

  • Impact:

    • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF): Medium - Strengthens CSRF protection by ensuring token inclusion in forms.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Yes, form_open() is used for all forms.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No missing implementation.]

Mitigation Strategy: Handle AJAX CSRF Tokens (CodeIgniter CSRF Feature)

  • Description:

    1. Retrieve CSRF Token: In your JavaScript code, retrieve the CSRF token. CodeIgniter provides csrf_token() and csrf_header() helpers to access the token value and header name. You can render these in a meta tag in your layout or access them via server-side code.
    2. Include in AJAX Requests: For every AJAX request that modifies data (POST, PUT, DELETE), include the CSRF token. You can include it as:
      • Request Header: Set a custom header with the token (e.g., X-CSRF-TOKEN: <token_value>). Use csrf_header() to get the header name.
      • Request Data: Include the token as part of the POST data. Use csrf_token() to get the token name and value.
    3. Server-Side Verification: CodeIgniter automatically verifies CSRF tokens in headers or POST data when CSRF protection is enabled.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) (Medium Severity): Extends CSRF protection to AJAX requests, securing AJAX-driven actions.

  • Impact:

    • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF): Medium - Extends CSRF protection to AJAX, crucial for modern web applications.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No, AJAX CSRF handling is not implemented.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Implement AJAX CSRF token handling for all AJAX endpoints. Update JavaScript code to include tokens in requests.]

Mitigation Strategy: Validate File Types and Extensions (CodeIgniter Upload Library)

  • Description:

    1. Use CodeIgniter Upload Library: Utilize CodeIgniter's Upload library ($this->load->library('upload');) for handling file uploads.
    2. Configure Allowed Types: Set the allowed_types configuration option in the Upload library configuration ($config['upload_path'], $config['allowed_types'], etc.). Specify only the file types that are genuinely required for your application. Be restrictive.
    3. Validate Upload: Use $this->upload->do_upload() to perform the upload and validation. Check for upload errors using $this->upload->display_errors().
    4. Extension Validation: CodeIgniter's Upload library validates file extensions based on MIME types. Ensure your allowed types are correctly configured.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Malicious File Upload (High Severity): Prevents users from uploading executable files or other malicious file types that could be exploited.
    • Information Disclosure (Low Severity): Prevents upload of unexpected file types that might reveal information if publicly accessible.

  • Impact:

    • Malicious File Upload: High - Significantly reduces the risk of malicious file uploads.
    • Information Disclosure: Low - Reduces risk of unintended information disclosure via file uploads.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Partially implemented. File type validation is used for image uploads, but not for all file upload functionalities.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Implement file type validation using CodeIgniter's Upload library for all file upload features in the application.]

Mitigation Strategy: Sanitize Filenames (CodeIgniter Upload Library & General Practices)

  • Description:

    1. CodeIgniter Filename Sanitization (Limited): CodeIgniter's Upload library provides basic filename sanitization. Review its behavior and ensure it's sufficient for your needs.
    2. Manual Sanitization (Recommended): Implement more robust filename sanitization. Before saving uploaded files, sanitize filenames to:
      • Remove or replace special characters, spaces, and non-alphanumeric characters.
      • Convert to lowercase.
      • Limit filename length.
      • Generate unique and unpredictable filenames (e.g., using UUIDs or timestamps combined with random strings).
    3. Avoid Original Filenames: Do not directly use user-provided filenames for storing files. Generate new, sanitized filenames.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • File Path Manipulation (Medium Severity): Sanitized filenames prevent attackers from crafting filenames that could be used for path traversal or other file system exploits.
    • Operating System Command Injection (Low Severity): Reduces risk if filenames are used in system commands (though avoid this pattern).
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (Low Severity): Sanitizing filenames can prevent some XSS risks if filenames are displayed directly in the browser (though output encoding is the primary defense).

  • Impact:

    • File Path Manipulation: Medium - Reduces file path manipulation risks.
    • Operating System Command Injection: Low - Minor reduction in command injection risk.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): Low - Minor contribution to XSS prevention.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No, filenames are not sanitized beyond CodeIgniter's default.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Implement robust filename sanitization logic before saving uploaded files. Refactor file upload handling to generate sanitized filenames.]

Mitigation Strategy: Restrict Route Access (CodeIgniter Routing & Authorization)

  • Description:

    1. Define Routes Carefully: Plan your CodeIgniter routes to reflect the application's structure and access control requirements.
    2. Controller-Based Authorization: Implement authorization logic within your controllers. Use CodeIgniter's session management or authentication libraries to check user roles and permissions before granting access to controller methods.
    3. Route-Level Middleware/Filters (CodeIgniter 4+): If using CodeIgniter 4 or later, leverage route-level middleware or filters to enforce authorization rules before controllers are executed. This is a more centralized and efficient approach.
    4. Avoid Publicly Accessible Admin Panels: Ensure administrative or sensitive routes are protected by authentication and authorization. Do not rely on obscurity for security.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Unauthorized Access (High Severity): Restricting route access prevents unauthorized users from accessing sensitive parts of the application or performing actions they are not permitted to.
    • Privilege Escalation (Medium Severity): Proper route access control helps prevent privilege escalation attacks.

  • Impact:

    • Unauthorized Access: High - Significantly reduces unauthorized access to sensitive application areas.
    • Privilege Escalation: Medium - Reduces privilege escalation risks.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Partially implemented. Basic controller-level authorization is in place for some admin routes.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Implement comprehensive route access control for all sensitive areas. Consider using middleware/filters for centralized authorization (if using CodeIgniter 4+).]

Mitigation Strategy: Avoid Exposing Internal Structure in Routes (CodeIgniter Routing Design)

  • Description:

    1. Abstract Route Patterns: Design routes that are user-friendly and abstract away the internal controller and method names. Avoid routes that directly map to controller/method structures (e.g., /users/editUser/123).
    2. Use RESTful Routing (Where Applicable): Adopt RESTful routing principles where appropriate. This often leads to more abstract and less revealing route patterns (e.g., /api/users/123 with HTTP methods like GET, PUT, DELETE).
    3. Custom Route Definitions: Use CodeIgniter's routing configuration (application/config/routes.php) to define custom routes that are decoupled from the physical controller/method structure.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Information Disclosure (Low Severity): Obscuring internal structure in routes makes it slightly harder for attackers to guess controller and method names, reducing reconnaissance opportunities.
    • Obfuscation (Low Severity): More abstract routes improve aesthetics and reduce predictability.

  • Impact:

    • Information Disclosure: Low - Minimally reduces information disclosure about internal structure.
    • Obfuscation: Low - Minor improvement in URL clarity and slight obfuscation.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Partially implemented. Some routes are abstract, but others still reveal controller/method names.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Review and refactor routes to be more abstract and less revealing of internal structure. Define custom routes in routes.php.]

Mitigation Strategy: Keep CodeIgniter Updated

  • Description:

    1. Monitor Updates: Regularly check for new CodeIgniter releases and security announcements on the official CodeIgniter website and security channels.
    2. Update Framework: When updates are available, especially security updates, update your CodeIgniter framework to the latest stable version. Follow the official CodeIgniter update guide for your version.
    3. Test After Update: After updating, thoroughly test your application to ensure compatibility and that no regressions have been introduced.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Known Framework Vulnerabilities (High Severity): Outdated frameworks are vulnerable to known security flaws that are patched in newer versions. Updating mitigates these known vulnerabilities.

  • Impact:

    • Known Framework Vulnerabilities: High - Significantly reduces vulnerability to known CodeIgniter flaws.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Yes, CodeIgniter is updated regularly.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No missing implementation. Update process is documented and followed.]

Mitigation Strategy: Monitor Security Announcements (CodeIgniter Community)

  • Description:

    1. Subscribe to Mailing Lists/Forums: Subscribe to official CodeIgniter security mailing lists, forums, or community channels where security announcements are posted.
    2. Follow Official Channels: Monitor the official CodeIgniter website, blog, and social media for security-related news.
    3. Stay Informed: Proactively seek out and stay informed about potential security vulnerabilities and best practices related to CodeIgniter development.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Unknown Framework Vulnerabilities (Medium Severity): Staying informed allows for quicker response and patching when new vulnerabilities are discovered in CodeIgniter.

  • Impact:

    • Unknown Framework Vulnerabilities: Medium - Improves responsiveness to newly discovered vulnerabilities.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Yes, team monitors CodeIgniter announcements.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No missing implementation. Security monitoring is part of the development process.]

Mitigation Strategy: Audit Third-Party Code (CodeIgniter Extensions & Libraries)

  • Description:

    1. Inventory Third-Party Components: Create an inventory of all third-party libraries, helpers, extensions, and plugins used in your CodeIgniter application.
    2. Source Review: For each third-party component, review its source code for potential security vulnerabilities. Focus on code that handles user input, database interactions, file operations, and authentication/authorization.
    3. Reputation and Maintenance: Assess the reputation and maintenance status of each third-party component. Prefer components from reputable sources that are actively maintained and have a history of security awareness.
    4. Vulnerability Scanning (If Possible): If feasible, use vulnerability scanning tools to scan third-party components for known vulnerabilities.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Third-Party Component Vulnerabilities (Variable Severity): Vulnerabilities in third-party code can introduce security risks into your application.

  • Impact:

    • Third-Party Component Vulnerabilities: Variable - Reduces risk depending on the severity of vulnerabilities found and addressed in third-party code.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: No, third-party code is not regularly audited.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Implement a process for regularly auditing third-party libraries used in the project. Start with a security review of all currently used third-party components.]

Mitigation Strategy: Keep Third-Party Libraries Updated (CodeIgniter Dependencies)

  • Description:

    1. Dependency Management: Use a dependency management tool (e.g., Composer if applicable to your CodeIgniter setup) to manage third-party libraries.
    2. Regular Updates: Regularly update all third-party libraries to their latest stable versions. Security vulnerabilities are often fixed in updates.
    3. Update Monitoring: Monitor for updates to third-party libraries and security advisories related to them.
    4. Testing After Updates: After updating third-party libraries, thoroughly test your application to ensure compatibility and that no regressions have been introduced.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Third-Party Component Vulnerabilities (Variable Severity): Outdated third-party libraries are vulnerable to known security flaws. Updating mitigates these vulnerabilities.

  • Impact:

    • Third-Party Component Vulnerabilities: Variable - Reduces risk depending on the severity of vulnerabilities in outdated libraries.

  • Currently Implemented: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Yes, third-party libraries are updated periodically.]

  • Missing Implementation: [Project Specific - Replace with actual status. Example: Missing implementation: Implement automated dependency update checks and integrate them into the development workflow.]