Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
112 lines (89 loc) · 19.2 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

112 lines (89 loc) · 19.2 KB

Threat Model Analysis for bookstackapp/bookstack

Threat: Insufficient Access Control Enforcement

  • Description: An attacker, potentially a low-privileged user or an external attacker exploiting a vulnerability, could bypass Bookstack's permission checks. This allows unauthorized access to view, edit, or delete books, chapters, or pages beyond their intended permissions. Attackers might manipulate API requests or exploit logic flaws within Bookstack's permission system.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach (unauthorized access to sensitive content), Integrity breach (unauthorized modification or deletion of content), potential disruption of knowledge base.
    • Affected Component: Access Control Module, Permission Check Functions, API endpoints related to content manipulation.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Implement robust and granular role-based access control (RBAC) within Bookstack. Thoroughly audit and test all permission checks, especially for API endpoints and content manipulation functions. Enforce permissions consistently at every level of content hierarchy. Utilize attribute-based access control (ABAC) for finer-grained permissions if necessary. Implement comprehensive automated tests for access control logic.
      • Users/Administrators: Regularly review user roles and permissions within Bookstack. Adhere to the principle of least privilege when assigning roles. Monitor access logs for any suspicious or unauthorized activity.

Threat: Session Hijacking

  • Description: An attacker could compromise a valid user session in Bookstack. This could be achieved through network sniffing (if HTTPS is not strictly enforced), cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerabilities within Bookstack, or brute-forcing weak session identifiers. Once a session is hijacked, the attacker can impersonate the legitimate user, gaining access to their account and performing actions on their behalf within Bookstack.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach (access to user's account and data within Bookstack), Integrity breach (unauthorized actions performed as the user, including content modification), potential account takeover within Bookstack.
    • Affected Component: Session Management Module, Authentication Handlers, Cookie Handling within Bookstack.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Employ strong and unpredictable session ID generation within Bookstack. Implement HttpOnly and Secure flags for session cookies to enhance security. Enforce HTTPS for all Bookstack communication to prevent network sniffing. Implement session timeouts and inactivity timeouts within Bookstack. Provide secure logout functionality that properly invalidates sessions. Consider anti-CSRF tokens to further protect session integrity within Bookstack.
      • Users/Administrators: Enforce HTTPS for the Bookstack application deployment. Educate users about session hijacking risks and best practices for secure browsing. Regularly review session management configurations within Bookstack.

Threat: Authentication Bypass via Misconfiguration

  • Description: Incorrect or insecure configuration of Bookstack's authentication mechanisms, particularly external authentication providers (LDAP, SAML, OIDC), can lead to authentication bypass vulnerabilities. Attackers might exploit these misconfigurations to circumvent authentication checks entirely, potentially gaining administrative access to Bookstack. This could involve manipulating authentication requests or exploiting flaws in Bookstack's configuration parsing logic.
    • Impact: Complete bypass of Bookstack authentication, unauthorized access to the entire Bookstack instance and all content, potential administrative access and full control over the knowledge base.
    • Affected Component: Authentication Module, Configuration Parsing, External Authentication Integrations (LDAP, SAML, OIDC) within Bookstack.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Provide clear, comprehensive, and security-focused documentation for configuring Bookstack's authentication methods, especially external providers. Implement robust configuration validation checks within Bookstack to prevent common misconfigurations. Provide secure default authentication configurations and guide users to customize them securely. Implement thorough error handling and logging for authentication processes within Bookstack.
      • Users/Administrators: Meticulously follow official documentation when configuring Bookstack's authentication. Thoroughly test authentication configurations after setup to ensure they function as expected and are secure. Regularly review authentication configurations for errors or misconfigurations. Disable or remove any unused authentication methods. Change any default credentials immediately upon installation.

Threat: Cross-Site Scripting (XSS)

  • Description: An attacker injects malicious JavaScript code into Bookstack content, such as page content, titles, or comments, through vulnerabilities in Bookstack's input handling or content rendering. When other users view this content, the injected script executes in their browsers within the context of the Bookstack application. This can be exploited to steal session cookies, redirect users to malicious sites, deface the Bookstack instance, or perform actions on behalf of the victim user.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach (session cookie theft, data exfiltration from Bookstack), Integrity breach (defacement of Bookstack content, unauthorized actions within Bookstack), Availability breach (redirection to malicious sites, client-side denial of service).
    • Affected Component: Content Editor, Markdown Rendering Engine, Input Handling Functions, Output Encoding Functions within Bookstack.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Implement robust input sanitization and output encoding for all user-supplied content within Bookstack. Utilize a well-vetted and actively maintained HTML sanitization library to sanitize user input before storing it in the database and when rendering it to the browser. Implement Content Security Policy (CSP) to further mitigate XSS risks within Bookstack. Conduct regular XSS vulnerability scanning and penetration testing of Bookstack.
      • Users/Administrators: Keep Bookstack updated to the latest version to benefit from security patches addressing XSS vulnerabilities. Educate users about the risks of XSS and encourage them to report any suspicious content within Bookstack.

Threat: Markdown Parsing Vulnerabilities

  • Description: Attackers exploit security vulnerabilities present in the Markdown parsing library used by Bookstack. By crafting malicious Markdown input, they can trigger various attacks. These may include Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) if the parser incorrectly handles HTML within Markdown, Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF) if the parser allows embedding external resources without proper validation, or Denial of Service (DoS) if the parser is vulnerable to processing complex or malformed Markdown input.
    • Impact: XSS (as described above), SSRF (potential access to internal resources or external systems from the Bookstack server), DoS (application crash or performance degradation), potentially Remote Code Execution (depending on the specific vulnerability in the Markdown parser).
    • Affected Component: Markdown Parsing Library, Content Rendering Engine within Bookstack.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Utilize a reputable, actively maintained, and security-focused Markdown parsing library in Bookstack. Keep the Markdown parsing library updated to the latest version to patch known vulnerabilities. Implement security hardening measures for Markdown parsing, such as disabling or carefully controlling potentially dangerous features like raw HTML embedding or external resource loading. Regularly test Markdown parsing functionality for vulnerabilities.
      • Users/Administrators: Keep Bookstack updated to the latest version to ensure the Markdown parsing library is patched. Monitor security advisories related to the Markdown parsing library used by Bookstack and apply updates promptly.

Threat: Unrestricted File Upload

  • Description: Bookstack's file upload functionality might lack sufficient restrictions on file types or content. An attacker could upload malicious files, such as executable scripts (e.g., PHP, Python, JavaScript) or malware, through Bookstack's upload mechanisms. If these files are stored in web-accessible directories and the web server is misconfigured or vulnerable, the attacker could execute these scripts directly on the server or distribute malware to other Bookstack users.
    • Impact: Remote Code Execution (if executable files are uploaded and executed on the Bookstack server), Malware distribution to Bookstack users, Server compromise, Denial of Service (if large files are uploaded to exhaust server storage).
    • Affected Component: File Upload Module, File Storage Module within Bookstack, potentially Web Server Configuration if misconfigured.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Implement strict file type validation within Bookstack based on both content type (MIME type) and file extension. Use a whitelist approach for allowed file types. Store uploaded files outside of the web root or in a dedicated, isolated storage service inaccessible for direct web execution. Implement robust file scanning for malware upon upload to Bookstack. Generate unique and unpredictable filenames for uploaded files within Bookstack.
      • Users/Administrators: Configure the web server hosting Bookstack to prevent execution of scripts within upload directories (e.g., using .htaccess in Apache or equivalent configurations in other web servers). Regularly review file upload settings in Bookstack and ensure they are properly configured and restrictive.

Threat: Path Traversal in File Upload/Retrieval

  • Description: Vulnerabilities in Bookstack's file path handling during file upload or retrieval could allow path traversal attacks. An attacker could craft malicious filenames or paths to bypass directory restrictions within Bookstack and potentially access or overwrite files outside of the intended upload directory on the server. This could lead to reading sensitive files or overwriting critical system files.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach (access to sensitive files on the Bookstack server), Integrity breach (overwriting system files, data corruption within Bookstack's storage), potentially Remote Code Execution (if system files are overwritten).
    • Affected Component: File Upload Module, File Retrieval Module, File Path Handling Functions within Bookstack.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Sanitize and validate filenames and file paths rigorously within Bookstack's file handling logic. Use absolute paths or relative paths anchored to a secure base directory when performing file operations. Avoid directly using user-supplied input in file paths. Implement robust input validation and encoding to prevent path traversal attempts within Bookstack.
      • Users/Administrators: Regularly review file storage configurations for Bookstack and ensure proper directory permissions are in place on the server.

Threat: Search Injection

  • Description: If Bookstack's search functionality is not properly secured, an attacker could inject malicious code into search queries. Depending on the search backend (SQL database, NoSQL database, or search engine) used by Bookstack, this could lead to SQL injection, NoSQL injection, or operating system command injection vulnerabilities. Successful injection could allow attackers to bypass access controls within Bookstack, extract sensitive data from the underlying database, or even execute arbitrary commands on the Bookstack server.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach (data exfiltration from Bookstack's database), Integrity breach (data modification in Bookstack's database), Availability breach (Denial of Service against the database), potentially Remote Code Execution on the Bookstack server.
    • Affected Component: Search Module, Search Query Construction, Database Interaction (if applicable), Search Engine Integration (if applicable) within Bookstack.
    • Risk Severity: High to Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Utilize parameterized queries or an ORM (Object-Relational Mapper) to interact with the database when constructing search queries in Bookstack. Sanitize and validate all user input used in search queries. If using a dedicated search engine, ensure proper input sanitization and security configurations for the search engine integration with Bookstack. Regularly test search functionality for injection vulnerabilities using automated tools and manual penetration testing.
      • Users/Administrators: Keep Bookstack and its search backend updated to the latest versions to benefit from security patches. Monitor logs for suspicious search queries that might indicate injection attempts.

Threat: Insecure Default Configurations

  • Description: Bookstack might be distributed with insecure default configurations, such as default administrative credentials, overly permissive file permissions, or insecure default settings for various services. If administrators fail to properly harden the Bookstack installation after deployment, attackers could exploit these insecure defaults to gain unauthorized access or compromise the entire system hosting Bookstack.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach, Integrity breach, Availability breach, potentially complete system compromise and takeover of the Bookstack instance and underlying server.
    • Affected Component: Installation Scripts, Default Configuration Files, Service Configuration within Bookstack distribution.
    • Risk Severity: High to Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Ensure no default administrative credentials are included in the Bookstack distribution. Provide secure default configurations for all components where possible. Provide clear, prominent, and easy-to-follow documentation and guidance on secure configuration practices and essential hardening steps for Bookstack. Develop and provide security hardening checklists and tools to assist administrators in securing their Bookstack instances effectively.
      • Users/Administrators: Carefully review and diligently follow security hardening documentation immediately after Bookstack installation. Change all default credentials to strong, unique passwords upon initial setup. Regularly review and update Bookstack configurations based on security best practices and security advisories.

Threat: Exposure of Sensitive Configuration Files

  • Description: Improper web server configuration or insufficient file permissions on the server hosting Bookstack could lead to the exposure of sensitive configuration files (e.g., .env files, database configuration files) through direct web access. These files often contain critical secrets such as database credentials, API keys, and other sensitive information required for Bookstack to function. Attackers gaining access to these files could obtain credentials to compromise Bookstack and potentially related systems.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach (disclosure of sensitive credentials and configuration information for Bookstack), potentially leading to full system compromise, unauthorized database access, and wider infrastructure compromise.
    • Affected Component: Web Server Configuration, File Permissions on the server hosting Bookstack, Configuration File Storage.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Provide clear and strong warnings to users to store sensitive Bookstack configuration files outside of the web root directory, making them inaccessible via direct web requests.
      • Users/Administrators: Ensure sensitive Bookstack configuration files are stored completely outside of the web root and are not directly accessible via the web server. Configure the web server to explicitly deny access to sensitive file types (e.g., .env, .config, .ini) to prevent accidental exposure. Implement strict file permissions to restrict access to configuration files to only the necessary users and processes on the server. Regularly audit web server configurations and file permissions to prevent unintended exposure.

Threat: Vulnerabilities in Dependencies

  • Description: Bookstack relies on various third-party libraries and frameworks for its functionality. Security vulnerabilities discovered in these dependencies can indirectly affect Bookstack. Attackers can exploit known vulnerabilities in outdated or unpatched dependencies to compromise Bookstack instances. This could include vulnerabilities in PHP libraries, JavaScript frameworks, or other components used by Bookstack.
    • Impact: Wide range of impacts depending on the specific vulnerability in the dependency, potentially including Remote Code Execution, XSS, SQL Injection, Denial of Service, or other forms of compromise affecting Bookstack.
    • Affected Component: All components of Bookstack that rely on vulnerable dependencies, Dependency Management System used by Bookstack.
    • Risk Severity: Varies, but potential for High to Critical impact on Bookstack depending on the severity of the dependency vulnerability.
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers: Maintain a comprehensive inventory of all dependencies used by Bookstack. Implement a system for regularly monitoring for security vulnerabilities in these dependencies using vulnerability databases and security scanning tools. Establish a robust process for promptly patching and updating dependencies when vulnerabilities are identified. Utilize dependency management tools to streamline tracking and updating dependencies for Bookstack.
      • Users/Administrators: Keep Bookstack updated to the latest version releases, as updates often include patched dependencies. Regularly check for security advisories related to Bookstack and its dependencies. Subscribe to security mailing lists and monitor security news sources to stay informed about potential vulnerabilities affecting Bookstack and its components. Apply updates and patches promptly when they are released.