Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
154 lines (117 loc) · 21.2 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

154 lines (117 loc) · 21.2 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for firefly-iii/firefly-iii

Mitigation Strategy: Input Validation and Sanitization on Import Files (Firefly III Specific Implementation)

Description:

  1. Utilize Firefly III's Import Functionality Securely: When using Firefly III's import features (e.g., CSV import for transactions, accounts, etc.), understand the expected data formats for each import type as defined by Firefly III's documentation.
  2. Pre-process Import Files (Outside Firefly III if possible): Before uploading files to Firefly III, pre-process them using external tools (like scripting languages or spreadsheet software) to:
    • Validate Data Types and Formats: Ensure data in each column matches the expected data type (number, date, text) and format required by Firefly III. For example, verify date formats, currency symbols, and numerical precision.
    • Sanitize Text Fields: For text fields (descriptions, notes, etc.), sanitize or escape potentially harmful characters. While Firefly III should handle basic sanitization, pre-processing adds an extra layer of defense. Consider removing or escaping special characters that could be interpreted as code in CSV or other formats.
    • Remove Unnecessary Data: Strip out any columns or data that are not strictly required for import into Firefly III. This reduces the attack surface.
  3. Review Firefly III Import Settings (If Available): Check if Firefly III offers any configuration options related to import validation or sanitization. Consult Firefly III's documentation for any such settings and enable or configure them appropriately.
  4. Test Import Process with Sample Data: Before importing large or sensitive datasets, test the import process with small sample files containing various data types, including edge cases and potentially malicious data (e.g., long strings, special characters in text fields, unusual numerical values). Observe how Firefly III handles these inputs and check for any errors or unexpected behavior.
  5. Monitor Import Logs (Firefly III Logs): After importing files, review Firefly III's logs for any warnings or errors related to the import process. This can help identify potential issues with data validation or sanitization.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • CSV Injection (Medium to High Severity): By pre-processing and validating CSV files before import, and by Firefly III's internal handling, the risk of CSV injection is reduced. However, reliance solely on Firefly III's sanitization without pre-processing increases the risk.
  • Data Integrity Issues (Medium Severity): Improperly formatted or invalid data in import files can lead to data integrity issues within Firefly III, causing incorrect financial records and potentially impacting application functionality. Validation helps prevent this.
  • Potential Exploits in Import Parsers (Low to Medium Severity): Vulnerabilities might exist in Firefly III's import parsers. While less likely, robust validation can help mitigate the impact of such vulnerabilities by rejecting malformed input that could trigger exploits.

Impact:

  • CSV Injection: Moderately reduces risk. Pre-processing and Firefly III's internal handling provide defense in depth.
  • Data Integrity Issues: Significantly reduces risk. Validation ensures data conforms to expected formats, improving data quality.
  • Potential Exploits in Import Parsers: Slightly reduces risk. Validation can act as a partial defense against certain parser exploits.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Firefly III likely has some internal validation within its import functionality.

Missing Implementation: Pre-processing of import files is not a standard practice. Formal guidelines or scripts for pre-processing and validating import files are missing. Detailed review of Firefly III's import validation and sanitization mechanisms is needed to understand its effectiveness and identify any gaps.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Granular Access Control and Permissions (Leverage Firefly III's User Roles)

Description:

  1. Understand Firefly III's User Roles and Permissions: Familiarize yourself with Firefly III's user role management system. Identify the different roles available (e.g., administrator, user, viewer, if applicable) and the permissions associated with each role. Consult Firefly III's documentation for details on user roles and permissions.
  2. Define User Roles Based on Needs: Determine the different levels of access required for users of the Firefly III application. Map user roles to specific job functions or responsibilities. For example:
    • Administrator: Full access to all features, settings, and data. Reserved for trusted administrators.
    • Accountant/Financial Manager: Access to manage accounts, transactions, reports, but potentially restricted from system settings.
    • Viewer/Auditor: Read-only access to reports and financial data for auditing or review purposes.
    • Limited User (if applicable): Access to only specific accounts or functionalities, if Firefly III allows such granular control.
  3. Assign Users to Appropriate Roles: Carefully assign users to the least privileged role that still allows them to perform their necessary tasks within Firefly III. Avoid granting administrator privileges unnecessarily.
  4. Regularly Review User Roles and Permissions: Periodically review user roles and permissions to ensure they are still appropriate and aligned with current user responsibilities. Remove or adjust permissions as needed, especially when users change roles or leave the organization.
  5. Audit User Activity (Firefly III Logs): Utilize Firefly III's logging capabilities to audit user activity, particularly actions related to data modification, access to sensitive information, and changes to system settings. This helps monitor for unauthorized access or actions.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Unauthorized Data Access (Medium to High Severity): Without granular access control, users might have access to financial data they don't need, increasing the risk of accidental or intentional data breaches. Role-based access control limits access to only necessary data.
  • Privilege Escalation (Medium Severity): If users are granted excessive privileges, they could potentially escalate their privileges or abuse their access to perform unauthorized actions, modify critical settings, or access sensitive data beyond their intended scope.
  • Insider Threats (Medium Severity): Granular access control helps mitigate insider threats by limiting the potential damage an insider can cause, even if they have malicious intent or are compromised.

Impact:

  • Unauthorized Data Access: Significantly reduces risk. Role-based access control enforces the principle of least privilege.
  • Privilege Escalation: Moderately reduces risk. Proper role assignment limits the scope of potential privilege escalation.
  • Insider Threats: Moderately reduces risk. Limits the potential damage from compromised or malicious insiders.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Firefly III has user roles (administrator, user).

Missing Implementation: More granular role definitions and permission customization might be possible within Firefly III but are not fully explored or utilized. Formal process for regularly reviewing user roles and permissions is missing. Detailed documentation and training for administrators on effectively using Firefly III's access control features are needed.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Handling of Import/Export Files (Firefly III Features)

Description:

  1. Use Firefly III's Built-in Import/Export Features: Primarily rely on Firefly III's built-in import and export functionalities instead of developing custom or external import/export scripts unless absolutely necessary. Firefly III's features are designed to handle data within its security context.
  2. Understand Supported File Formats and Options: Familiarize yourself with the file formats supported by Firefly III for import and export (e.g., CSV, JSON, OFX, QIF). Understand any configuration options available within Firefly III for import/export, such as delimiters, encoding, and data selection.
  3. Secure Temporary Storage of Uploaded Files (Firefly III Configuration): If Firefly III temporarily stores uploaded import files on the server before processing, ensure that the temporary storage location is securely configured:
    • Restrict Access: Limit access to the temporary directory to only the Firefly III application user and necessary system processes.
    • Appropriate Permissions: Set restrictive file permissions on the temporary directory and files to prevent unauthorized access.
    • Automatic Deletion: Configure Firefly III (if possible) or implement a system process to automatically delete temporary files immediately after successful import or after a short period.
  4. Secure Exported Files After Download: Educate users about the importance of securely handling exported files after they are downloaded from Firefly III.
    • Secure Storage: Advise users to store exported files in secure locations on their local machines or network drives, protected by appropriate access controls and encryption if necessary.
    • Secure Transmission: If exported files need to be transmitted, recommend using secure methods like encrypted email or secure file transfer protocols (SFTP, HTTPS).
    • Avoid Unnecessary Sharing: Discourage users from sharing exported files unnecessarily, especially via insecure channels.
  5. Review Firefly III's Export Options for Sensitive Data: Check if Firefly III offers any options to control the level of detail or sensitive data included in exported files. If possible, configure export settings to minimize the exposure of sensitive information in exported files, while still providing necessary data for reporting or backup purposes.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Data Exposure through Exported Files (Medium to High Severity): If exported files are not handled securely after download, they could be accessed by unauthorized individuals if stored insecurely, transmitted insecurely, or shared inappropriately.
  • Information Leakage through Exported Data (Medium Severity): Overly detailed exported files could inadvertently expose sensitive information that is not strictly necessary for the intended purpose of the export, increasing the risk of information leakage.
  • Potential Vulnerabilities in Import/Export Features (Low to Medium Severity): While less likely, vulnerabilities could exist in Firefly III's import/export functionalities. Using built-in features and keeping Firefly III updated reduces this risk compared to custom implementations.

Impact:

  • Data Exposure through Exported Files: Moderately reduces risk. User education and secure handling practices are crucial.
  • Information Leakage through Exported Data: Moderately reduces risk. Configuring export options to minimize sensitive data exposure helps.
  • Potential Vulnerabilities in Import/Export Features: Slightly reduces risk. Relying on Firefly III's features and updates is generally more secure than custom code.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Firefly III's built-in import/export features are used.

Missing Implementation: Formal guidelines and user education on secure handling of exported files are missing. Review of Firefly III's temporary file storage for imports and configuration hardening is needed. Exploration of Firefly III's export options for controlling data sensitivity is required.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) (Utilize Firefly III's MFA Support)

Description:

  1. Enable MFA in Firefly III Configuration: Firefly III supports MFA using TOTP (Time-based One-Time Password) and WebAuthn. Enable MFA in Firefly III's settings or configuration files. Consult Firefly III's documentation for specific instructions on enabling MFA.
  2. Encourage or Enforce MFA for All Users: Strongly encourage or, ideally, enforce MFA for all Firefly III users, especially administrators and users with access to sensitive financial data. Make MFA mandatory for high-privilege accounts.
  3. Provide User Guidance and Support for MFA Setup: Provide clear instructions and user-friendly guides on how to set up MFA in Firefly III. Offer support to users who encounter difficulties during the MFA setup process.
  4. Test MFA Functionality: Thoroughly test the MFA implementation to ensure it is working correctly and effectively. Verify that MFA is enforced for login attempts and that users can successfully authenticate using their chosen MFA method (TOTP or WebAuthn).
  5. Consider MFA Recovery Procedures: Establish procedures for MFA recovery in case users lose access to their MFA devices or recovery codes. This might involve contacting an administrator for assistance or using pre-defined recovery methods (while ensuring these recovery methods are also secure).

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Account Takeover due to Password Compromise (High Severity): If user passwords are compromised (e.g., through phishing, password reuse, or data breaches), MFA adds an extra layer of security, making it significantly harder for attackers to gain unauthorized access to accounts, even with stolen passwords.
  • Brute-Force Password Attacks (Medium Severity): MFA makes brute-force password attacks much less effective, as attackers would need to bypass both the password and the MFA factor.

Impact:

  • Account Takeover due to Password Compromise: Significantly reduces risk. MFA provides a strong second factor of authentication.
  • Brute-Force Password Attacks: Significantly reduces risk. MFA makes brute-force attacks practically infeasible.

Currently Implemented: Not implemented. MFA is not currently enabled or enforced in Firefly III.

Missing Implementation: MFA needs to be enabled in Firefly III's configuration. User guidance and support materials for MFA setup need to be created. A policy for MFA enforcement and recovery procedures needs to be defined and implemented.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update Firefly III and Dependencies (Firefly III Maintenance)

Description:

  1. Establish a Regular Update Schedule: Create a schedule for regularly checking for and applying updates to Firefly III and its dependencies (PHP, database, web server, operating system). Frequency should be based on risk assessment and release frequency of Firefly III and its components (e.g., monthly or quarterly checks).
  2. Subscribe to Firefly III Security Announcements: Subscribe to Firefly III's official channels (e.g., mailing lists, release notes, security advisories) to receive notifications about new releases, security patches, and important updates.
  3. Test Updates in a Staging Environment: Before applying updates to the production Firefly III instance, thoroughly test them in a staging or testing environment that mirrors the production setup. This helps identify potential compatibility issues or regressions before they impact the live application.
  4. Apply Updates Promptly: Once updates have been tested and verified in the staging environment, apply them promptly to the production Firefly III instance, especially security patches. Prioritize security updates and apply them as soon as possible after release and testing.
  5. Document Update Process: Document the update process, including steps for backing up data, applying updates, and verifying successful update. This ensures consistency and repeatability of the update process.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities (High Severity): Outdated software is often vulnerable to known security vulnerabilities that have been patched in newer versions. Regularly updating Firefly III and its dependencies ensures that known vulnerabilities are addressed, reducing the risk of exploitation by attackers.
  • Zero-Day Vulnerabilities (Medium Severity): While updates primarily address known vulnerabilities, staying up-to-date also helps in mitigating the risk of zero-day vulnerabilities to some extent. Newer versions might include general security improvements and hardening that can make it harder to exploit even unknown vulnerabilities.

Impact:

  • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities: Significantly reduces risk. Regular updates are crucial for patching known vulnerabilities.
  • Zero-Day Vulnerabilities: Moderately reduces risk. Updates contribute to overall security hardening.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Updates are applied, but not on a formal, scheduled basis.

Missing Implementation: Formal update schedule and process are missing. Subscription to Firefly III security announcements is not formally tracked. Staging environment for testing updates is not consistently used. Documentation of the update process is lacking.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Comprehensive Logging (Firefly III Logging Configuration)

Description:

  1. Configure Firefly III Logging Level: Review Firefly III's logging configuration settings and set the logging level to capture sufficient detail for security monitoring and incident investigation. Consider logging levels like "INFO," "WARNING," and "ERROR" to capture relevant events without excessive verbosity.
  2. Log Security-Relevant Events: Ensure that Firefly III logs security-relevant events, including:
    • Authentication Events: Successful and failed login attempts, logout events, MFA usage.
    • Authorization Events: Access control decisions, attempts to access restricted resources, permission changes.
    • Data Modification Events: Creation, modification, and deletion of sensitive financial data (transactions, accounts, etc.).
    • System Errors and Exceptions: Errors and exceptions that might indicate security issues or application malfunctions.
    • Import/Export Activity: Logs related to data import and export operations.
  3. Review Firefly III Log Files Regularly: Establish a process for regularly reviewing Firefly III log files to identify suspicious activities, security incidents, or potential vulnerabilities. Automated log analysis tools can be helpful for this purpose.
  4. Secure Log Storage (Separate from Firefly III): Ideally, configure Firefly III to send logs to a separate, secure log management system or service. This ensures that logs are protected even if the Firefly III server itself is compromised. If storing logs locally on the Firefly III server, ensure they are stored in a secure location with restricted access.
  5. Implement Log Rotation and Retention: Configure log rotation to prevent log files from growing excessively large and consuming disk space. Implement a log retention policy to define how long logs are stored, balancing security needs with storage capacity and compliance requirements.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Delayed Incident Detection (High Severity): Without comprehensive logging, security incidents might go undetected for extended periods, allowing attackers to cause more damage or exfiltrate more data. Logging enables timely detection of security breaches and suspicious activities.
  • Insufficient Forensic Information (Medium Severity): Inadequate logging can hinder incident response and forensic investigations. Detailed logs provide valuable information for understanding the scope and impact of security incidents, identifying attackers, and improving security measures.
  • Compliance Violations (Varying Severity): Many security and data privacy regulations require organizations to maintain adequate logging and audit trails. Comprehensive logging helps meet these compliance requirements.

Impact:

  • Delayed Incident Detection: Significantly reduces risk. Logging enables faster detection of security incidents.
  • Insufficient Forensic Information: Significantly reduces risk. Logs provide crucial data for incident response and forensics.
  • Compliance Violations: Moderately reduces risk. Logging helps meet regulatory requirements.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Firefly III likely has default logging enabled, but the level of detail and specific events logged might be insufficient for comprehensive security monitoring.

Missing Implementation: Detailed review and configuration of Firefly III's logging settings are needed to ensure security-relevant events are logged. Regular log review process is missing. Secure log storage and management (ideally separate log management system) are not implemented. Log rotation and retention policies need to be defined and configured.