Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
195 lines (146 loc) · 25.9 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

195 lines (146 loc) · 25.9 KB

Deep Security Analysis of FreshRSS Application

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

Objective:

This deep security analysis aims to provide a comprehensive evaluation of the security posture of FreshRSS, a self-hosted RSS feed aggregator, based on the provided security design review and inferred architecture. The objective is to identify potential security vulnerabilities and weaknesses within the application's key components and recommend specific, actionable mitigation strategies to enhance its overall security. This analysis will focus on the unique security challenges associated with self-hosted applications and the specific functionalities of FreshRSS.

Scope:

The scope of this analysis encompasses the following key components and aspects of FreshRSS, as outlined in the security design review and C4 diagrams:

  • FreshRSS Web Application (PHP Codebase): Analyzing the application logic, input handling, data processing, authentication, authorization, and session management.
  • Web Server (Nginx/Apache): Examining the web server configuration, HTTPS enforcement, header security, and access control.
  • PHP Runtime Environment: Considering the security of the PHP runtime, enabled extensions, and configuration.
  • Database System (MySQL/PostgreSQL/SQLite): Assessing database access controls, data storage security, and potential SQL injection vulnerabilities.
  • User Browser Interaction: Analyzing client-side security aspects, including XSS risks and CSP implementation.
  • RSS/Atom Feed Handling: Evaluating the security implications of fetching and parsing external RSS/Atom feeds.
  • Deployment Architecture (Docker Compose): Considering the security aspects of containerization, network isolation, and host system security.
  • Build Process (CI/CD Pipeline): Analyzing the security of the build pipeline, dependency management, and artifact security.

The analysis will primarily focus on the security considerations directly related to FreshRSS and its immediate dependencies, excluding a detailed infrastructure security audit of the user's self-hosting environment beyond the Docker Compose setup.

Methodology:

This deep security analysis will employ the following methodology:

  1. Document Review: Thoroughly review the provided security design review document, including business posture, security posture, C4 diagrams, deployment options, build process, risk assessment, questions, and assumptions.
  2. Architecture Inference: Based on the design review, C4 diagrams, and general knowledge of web applications and RSS aggregators, infer the architecture, components, and data flow of FreshRSS.
  3. Component-Based Security Analysis: Break down the application into key components identified in the scope and analyze the security implications for each component. This will involve:
    • Threat Modeling: Identify potential threats and vulnerabilities relevant to each component, considering common web application security risks (OWASP Top 10) and self-hosting specific concerns.
    • Control Evaluation: Assess the existing and recommended security controls outlined in the design review against the identified threats.
    • Gap Analysis: Identify gaps between the existing controls and the recommended controls, and areas where further security enhancements are needed.
  4. Tailored Recommendation Generation: Develop specific, actionable, and tailored security recommendations for FreshRSS, addressing the identified vulnerabilities and gaps. Recommendations will be practical and feasible for a self-hosted, open-source project.
  5. Mitigation Strategy Development: For each identified threat and recommendation, propose concrete and actionable mitigation strategies applicable to FreshRSS. These strategies will be focused on improving the security of the application and reducing the identified risks.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

Based on the design review and inferred architecture, the following are the security implications for each key component of FreshRSS:

2.1. FreshRSS Web Application (PHP Codebase):

  • Security Implications:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS): As a web application handling user input and displaying external content from RSS feeds, XSS is a significant risk. Insufficient input sanitization and output encoding in the PHP codebase could allow attackers to inject malicious scripts into the application, potentially stealing user sessions, defacing the application, or redirecting users to malicious sites.
    • SQL Injection: If the application directly constructs SQL queries without proper parameterization or uses an outdated ORM with vulnerabilities, it could be susceptible to SQL injection attacks. Attackers could manipulate database queries to gain unauthorized access to data, modify data, or even execute arbitrary commands on the database server.
    • Authentication and Authorization Vulnerabilities: Weak password policies, insecure session management, or flaws in the role-based access control implementation could lead to unauthorized access to user accounts and application features. Brute-force attacks and credential stuffing are also relevant threats.
    • Insecure Deserialization: If FreshRSS uses PHP object serialization and deserialization without proper safeguards, it could be vulnerable to insecure deserialization attacks. Attackers could craft malicious serialized objects to execute arbitrary code on the server.
    • File Inclusion Vulnerabilities: If the application dynamically includes files based on user input without proper validation, it could be vulnerable to local or remote file inclusion attacks, potentially allowing attackers to execute arbitrary code or access sensitive files.
    • Logic Flaws and Business Logic Vulnerabilities: Flaws in the application's logic, such as feed parsing, update mechanisms, or user management, could be exploited to bypass security controls or cause unintended behavior.

2.2. Web Server (Nginx/Apache):

  • Security Implications:
    • Misconfiguration: Improper web server configuration can introduce vulnerabilities. Examples include:
      • Exposing sensitive files or directories: Accidental exposure of .git directory, configuration files, or backups.
      • Default configurations: Using default credentials or insecure default settings.
      • Lack of HTTPS enforcement: Not properly enforcing HTTPS and allowing insecure HTTP connections.
      • Missing security headers: Not implementing security headers like HSTS, CSP, X-Frame-Options, X-XSS-Protection, and X-Content-Type-Options.
    • Vulnerabilities in Web Server Software: Outdated web server software may contain known vulnerabilities that attackers can exploit.
    • Denial of Service (DoS) and Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS): Web servers can be targets of DoS/DDoS attacks. Lack of rate limiting and other protective measures can lead to service unavailability.

2.3. PHP Runtime Environment:

  • Security Implications:
    • Vulnerabilities in PHP itself: Outdated PHP versions may contain known vulnerabilities.
    • Insecure PHP Configuration: Default PHP configurations may have insecure settings. For example, allowing dangerous functions, exposing error details, or not properly configuring security extensions.
    • Vulnerabilities in PHP Extensions: Enabled PHP extensions may contain vulnerabilities.
    • Resource Exhaustion: PHP scripts can be exploited to consume excessive server resources, leading to DoS.

2.4. Database System (MySQL/PostgreSQL/SQLite):

  • Security Implications:
    • SQL Injection (as mentioned in 2.1): Database is the target of SQL injection attacks originating from the web application.
    • Weak Database Credentials: Using default or weak database passwords.
    • Insufficient Access Control: Granting excessive privileges to the database user used by FreshRSS.
    • Unencrypted Database Connections: Communication between the web application and the database might not be encrypted, especially if they are on the same host, potentially exposing database credentials and data in transit within the server.
    • Data Breaches due to Database Vulnerabilities: Vulnerabilities in the database software itself could be exploited to gain unauthorized access to data.
    • Lack of Encryption at Rest: Sensitive data in the database (user credentials, subscriptions) might not be encrypted at rest, increasing the risk of data exposure if the database storage is compromised.

2.5. User Browser Interaction:

  • Security Implications:
    • XSS (Client-Side): Even with server-side XSS prevention, client-side JavaScript vulnerabilities or misconfigurations could introduce XSS risks.
    • Session Hijacking: If session management is not secure (e.g., using insecure cookies, not using HTTPS properly), attackers could potentially hijack user sessions.
    • Clickjacking: Without proper frame protection (X-Frame-Options or CSP frame-ancestors), the FreshRSS interface could be embedded in a malicious website to trick users into performing unintended actions.
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks: If HTTPS is not properly enforced or if users access FreshRSS over insecure networks, MitM attacks could be possible, allowing attackers to intercept communication and potentially steal credentials or session tokens.

2.6. RSS/Atom Feed Handling:

  • Security Implications:
    • Malicious Feed Content: RSS/Atom feeds are external and potentially untrusted sources. Malicious feeds could contain:
      • XSS payloads: Scripts embedded in feed titles, descriptions, or content.
      • Links to malicious websites: Phishing or malware distribution sites.
      • Exploits targeting feed parsers: Vulnerabilities in the feed parsing library used by FreshRSS.
      • Denial of Service (DoS) through large or complex feeds: Overloading the server with excessively large or computationally expensive feeds.
    • Feed Fetching Vulnerabilities: Vulnerabilities in the feed fetching mechanism could be exploited to perform Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF) attacks, potentially allowing attackers to access internal resources or interact with other systems.

2.7. Deployment Architecture (Docker Compose):

  • Security Implications:
    • Container Image Vulnerabilities: Using outdated or vulnerable base images for Docker containers.
    • Container Escape: Vulnerabilities in the container runtime or container configuration could potentially allow attackers to escape the container and gain access to the host system.
    • Docker Daemon Security: Insecure Docker daemon configuration or vulnerabilities in the Docker daemon itself.
    • Network Exposure: Improperly configured Docker networks or port mappings could expose services to unintended networks or the public internet.
    • Volume Security: Insecurely configured Docker volumes could lead to data breaches or unauthorized access to persistent data.

2.8. Build Process (CI/CD Pipeline):

  • Security Implications:
    • Compromised Dependencies (Supply Chain Attacks): Using vulnerable or malicious dependencies in the application.
    • Insecure Build Environment: Compromised build environment could lead to the injection of malicious code into the build artifacts.
    • Vulnerabilities in Build Tools: Outdated or vulnerable build tools used in the CI/CD pipeline.
    • Insecure Secrets Management: Exposing sensitive credentials (API keys, database passwords) in the CI/CD pipeline configuration or logs.
    • Unauthorized Access to CI/CD Pipeline: Attackers gaining access to the CI/CD pipeline could modify the build process, inject malicious code, or steal secrets.

3. Actionable and Tailored Mitigation Strategies

Based on the identified security implications, here are actionable and tailored mitigation strategies for FreshRSS:

3.1. FreshRSS Web Application (PHP Codebase):

  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Implement a robust Content Security Policy (CSP): As recommended in the security review, implement a strict CSP to mitigate XSS risks. Configure CSP headers in the web server or application to restrict the sources from which the browser is allowed to load resources. Specific Action: Define a CSP that whitelists trusted sources for scripts, styles, images, and other resources. Regularly review and update the CSP as needed.
    • Strengthen Input Sanitization and Output Encoding: Thoroughly review and enhance input sanitization and output encoding throughout the PHP codebase. Use context-aware output encoding functions (e.g., htmlspecialchars() for HTML, json_encode() for JSON) to prevent XSS. Specific Action: Conduct a code audit focusing on all user input points (GET/POST parameters, cookies, headers) and ensure proper sanitization and encoding before processing and displaying data.
    • Utilize Parameterized Queries or ORM: Ensure all database interactions are performed using parameterized queries or a secure ORM (like Doctrine or Eloquent if applicable) to prevent SQL injection vulnerabilities. Specific Action: Audit database query construction throughout the codebase and replace any direct string concatenation for SQL queries with parameterized queries or ORM methods.
    • Implement Strong Password Policies and Consider Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Enforce strong password policies (minimum length, complexity requirements) and consider adding support for MFA (e.g., TOTP) to enhance authentication security. Specific Action: Implement password complexity checks during user registration and password changes. Explore and implement a plugin or built-in functionality for MFA.
    • Secure Session Management: Use secure session cookies (HTTP-only, Secure flags), implement session timeouts, and regenerate session IDs after successful login to prevent session hijacking. Specific Action: Review session management code and ensure secure cookie flags are set, session timeouts are configured, and session ID regeneration is implemented.
    • Regular Static Application Security Testing (SAST): Integrate SAST tools into the CI/CD pipeline to automatically detect potential vulnerabilities in the PHP codebase. Specific Action: Integrate a SAST tool like SonarQube, PHPStan, or Psalm into the GitHub Actions workflow. Configure the tool to scan the codebase on each commit and pull request and address identified vulnerabilities.
    • Address Insecure Deserialization Risks: If object serialization is used, carefully review its usage and consider alternatives or implement robust safeguards to prevent insecure deserialization attacks. Specific Action: Audit the codebase for unserialize() function usage and assess the risk. If necessary, refactor to avoid deserialization of user-controlled data or implement signature-based integrity checks.
    • Prevent File Inclusion Vulnerabilities: Avoid dynamic file inclusion based on user input. If necessary, implement strict input validation and use a whitelist approach to control allowed files. Specific Action: Audit the codebase for include, require, include_once, require_once functions and ensure file paths are not directly derived from user input without validation.

3.2. Web Server (Nginx/Apache):

  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Harden Web Server Configuration: Follow web server hardening best practices. Disable unnecessary modules, restrict access to sensitive files, and configure appropriate permissions. Specific Action: Review web server configuration files (e.g., Nginx nginx.conf, Apache httpd.conf or .htaccess) and apply hardening guidelines.
    • Enforce HTTPS and HSTS: Strictly enforce HTTPS for all web traffic and implement HTTP Strict Transport Security (HSTS) to instruct browsers to always use HTTPS. Specific Action: Configure web server to redirect all HTTP requests to HTTPS. Set the Strict-Transport-Security header with max-age, includeSubDomains, and preload directives.
    • Implement Security Headers: Configure the web server to send security-related HTTP headers like X-Frame-Options, X-XSS-Protection, X-Content-Type-Options, and Referrer-Policy. Specific Action: Configure web server to add these headers to all responses.
    • Implement Rate Limiting and Brute-Force Protection: As recommended, implement rate limiting and brute-force protection at the web server level (e.g., using Nginx's limit_req_zone and limit_req directives or Apache's mod_evasive). Focus on login endpoints and API endpoints. Specific Action: Configure rate limiting rules in the web server configuration to limit the number of requests from a single IP address within a specific time frame for login and API endpoints.
    • Regularly Update Web Server Software: Keep the web server software updated to the latest stable version to patch known vulnerabilities. Specific Action: Implement a process for regularly updating web server packages on the server.

3.3. PHP Runtime Environment:

  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Use the Latest Stable PHP Version: Use the latest stable and actively supported PHP version to benefit from security patches and improvements. Specific Action: Ensure the Docker image or server environment uses the latest stable PHP version.
    • Harden PHP Configuration: Harden the PHP configuration (php.ini). Disable dangerous functions (e.g., exec, system, passthru, eval), enable security extensions (e.g., sodium, openssl), and configure appropriate error reporting levels. Specific Action: Review and modify php.ini to disable dangerous functions, enable security extensions, and set display_errors = Off in production.
    • Regularly Update PHP: Keep the PHP runtime environment updated to the latest version to patch known vulnerabilities. Specific Action: Implement a process for regularly updating PHP packages on the server.

3.4. Database System (MySQL/PostgreSQL/SQLite):

  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Use Strong Database Credentials: Generate strong, unique passwords for database users. Specific Action: Use a password manager to generate and store strong database passwords.
    • Implement Least Privilege Access Control: Grant only the necessary privileges to the database user used by FreshRSS. Avoid using the root or administrator database user. Specific Action: Create a dedicated database user for FreshRSS with only the necessary permissions (e.g., SELECT, INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE, CREATE, DROP on the FreshRSS database).
    • Secure Database Connections: If possible, encrypt the connection between the web application and the database (e.g., using TLS/SSL for MySQL or PostgreSQL). Specific Action: Configure database server and client to use encrypted connections.
    • Regularly Update Database Software: Keep the database software updated to the latest stable version to patch known vulnerabilities. Specific Action: Implement a process for regularly updating database packages on the server.
    • Consider Encryption at Rest: For highly sensitive deployments, consider encrypting the database at rest using database-level encryption features or disk encryption. Specific Action: Evaluate the need for encryption at rest based on data sensitivity and compliance requirements. If needed, configure database encryption or disk encryption.

3.5. User Browser Interaction:

  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Strict CSP (as mentioned in 3.1): CSP is crucial for client-side security.
    • Secure Cookie Configuration (as mentioned in 3.1): Use secure cookie flags.
    • Implement Frame Protection: Use X-Frame-Options or CSP frame-ancestors directive to prevent clickjacking attacks. Specific Action: Ensure X-Frame-Options header is set to SAMEORIGIN or DENY or configure CSP frame-ancestors directive.
    • Educate Users on Browser Security: Encourage users to use modern browsers with security features enabled and to be aware of phishing and social engineering attacks. Specific Action: Provide documentation or tips for users on browser security best practices.

3.6. RSS/Atom Feed Handling:

  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Sanitize and Validate Feed Content: Thoroughly sanitize and validate content from RSS/Atom feeds before displaying it to users. Use HTML sanitization libraries to remove potentially malicious scripts and HTML tags. Specific Action: Implement a robust HTML sanitization library (e.g., HTMLPurifier) to process feed content before displaying it.
    • Limit Feed Resource Consumption: Implement measures to limit the resources consumed by fetching and parsing feeds. Set timeouts for feed requests and limit the size of feeds processed. Specific Action: Configure timeouts for HTTP requests when fetching feeds. Implement checks to limit the size of feeds processed to prevent DoS.
    • Regularly Update Feed Parsing Libraries: Keep the feed parsing libraries used by FreshRSS updated to the latest versions to patch known vulnerabilities. Specific Action: Monitor for updates to feed parsing libraries and update them regularly.
    • Consider Content Security Policy for Feed Content (iframes): If FreshRSS uses iframes to display feed content, apply CSP to iframes to further restrict their capabilities and mitigate risks from malicious feed content. Specific Action: If iframes are used for feed content, configure CSP frame-src directive to restrict the sources allowed within iframes.

3.7. Deployment Architecture (Docker Compose):

  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Use Minimal and Regularly Scanned Base Images: Use minimal base images for Docker containers and regularly scan container images for vulnerabilities using container image scanning tools. Specific Action: Use minimal base images (e.g., Alpine Linux based images). Integrate container image scanning tools (e.g., Trivy, Clair) into the CI/CD pipeline to scan Docker images for vulnerabilities before deployment.
    • Apply Container Runtime Security: Configure container runtime security features like resource limits, security profiles (e.g., AppArmor, SELinux), and namespaces to isolate containers and limit their capabilities. Specific Action: Configure Docker Compose to use resource limits (CPU, memory) for containers. Explore and implement security profiles for containers.
    • Secure Docker Daemon: Follow Docker daemon security best practices. Restrict access to the Docker daemon socket and avoid running containers with --privileged flag unless absolutely necessary. Specific Action: Restrict access to the Docker daemon socket. Avoid using --privileged flag for containers.
    • Network Isolation: Utilize Docker networks to isolate containers and restrict network access. Only expose necessary ports. Specific Action: Ensure FreshRSS and database containers are on separate Docker networks and only expose necessary ports (e.g., 443 for web access) to the host network.
    • Secure Volume Mounts: Configure volume mounts with appropriate permissions to restrict access to data volumes. Consider using Docker volumes instead of bind mounts for better security. Specific Action: Review volume mounts in Docker Compose configuration and ensure appropriate permissions are set. Consider using Docker volumes for data persistence.

3.8. Build Process (CI/CD Pipeline):

  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Software Composition Analysis (SCA): Integrate SCA tools into the CI/CD pipeline to automatically identify vulnerable dependencies. Specific Action: Integrate an SCA tool like Snyk, OWASP Dependency-Check, or RetireJS into the GitHub Actions workflow. Configure the tool to scan dependencies on each commit and pull request and address identified vulnerabilities.
    • Secure Build Environment: Harden the build environment and ensure it is regularly updated and patched. Isolate build processes to prevent cross-contamination. Specific Action: Use secure and updated build environments in GitHub Actions.
    • Secure Secrets Management: Use secure secrets management mechanisms provided by CI/CD platforms (e.g., GitHub Secrets) to store and manage sensitive credentials. Avoid hardcoding secrets in code or configuration files. Specific Action: Use GitHub Secrets to store database credentials, API keys, and other sensitive information. Ensure secrets are not exposed in CI/CD logs.
    • Pipeline Code Review and Version Control: Treat the CI/CD pipeline configuration as code and apply code review and version control practices. Specific Action: Review and version control GitHub Actions workflow files.
    • Regularly Update Build Tools: Keep build tools and dependencies used in the CI/CD pipeline updated to the latest versions. Specific Action: Regularly update build tools and dependencies used in GitHub Actions workflows.

4. Conclusion

This deep security analysis of FreshRSS has identified several potential security implications across its key components, ranging from web application vulnerabilities to deployment and build process security. By implementing the tailored mitigation strategies outlined above, the FreshRSS project can significantly enhance its security posture and better protect user data and privacy.

It is crucial to prioritize the recommended security controls, especially those addressing XSS, SQL injection, authentication, and dependency vulnerabilities, as these are common and critical web application risks. Regular security testing, including SAST, SCA, and penetration testing, as recommended in the security design review, should be conducted to continuously assess and improve the security of FreshRSS. Furthermore, fostering a security-conscious development culture and actively engaging with the community for security audits and vulnerability reporting are essential for the long-term security of this self-hosted open-source project.