Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
108 lines (91 loc) · 14.6 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

108 lines (91 loc) · 14.6 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for friendsofphp/goutte

Mitigation Strategy: Whitelist Allowed Domains

  • Description:
    1. Identify Allowed Domains: Determine the specific domains your application legitimately needs to scrape using Goutte.
    2. Create Whitelist: Store this list of allowed domains in a configuration file or environment variable.
    3. Implement Validation Function: Before using Goutte to make a request, create a function that checks if the target URL's hostname is present in the whitelist.
    4. Enforce Validation Before Goutte Request: Integrate this validation function immediately before initiating a Goutte request. If the domain is not whitelisted, prevent Goutte from making the request and log the attempt.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF): High Severity. Prevents Goutte from being used to access internal resources or unintended external services by restricting target domains.
  • Impact: Significantly reduces SSRF risk by controlling the domains Goutte can access.
  • Currently Implemented: No. [Placeholder: Is domain whitelisting currently implemented? If yes, where is the whitelist defined and where is the validation performed in the codebase?]
  • Missing Implementation: [Placeholder: If not implemented, specify where this validation should be added. It should be enforced right before any Goutte client request() or similar method is called.]

Mitigation Strategy: URL Structure Validation

  • Description:
    1. Define URL Structure Rules: Determine the expected structure of valid target URLs for Goutte. This includes allowed protocols (e.g., https:// only), path patterns, and query parameter restrictions.
    2. Implement Validation Logic: Use regular expressions or URL parsing functions to create validation logic that checks if a given URL conforms to the defined structure rules.
    3. Apply Validation Before Goutte Request: Before making a Goutte request, apply this validation logic to the target URL. If the URL structure is invalid, prevent Goutte from making the request and log the invalid URL attempt.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • SSRF (Bypass of Whitelist): Medium Severity. Reduces the chance of attackers bypassing domain whitelists through URL manipulation.
    • Unexpected Goutte Behavior: Medium Severity. Prevents Goutte from processing malformed URLs that could lead to errors or unexpected behavior within the library.
  • Impact: Moderately reduces SSRF risk and improves the robustness of Goutte usage by ensuring valid URL structures.
  • Currently Implemented: No. [Placeholder: Is URL structure validation currently implemented? If yes, where is the validation logic and where is it applied before Goutte requests?]
  • Missing Implementation: [Placeholder: If not implemented, specify where this validation should be added. Similar to domain whitelisting, it should be applied immediately before Goutte requests are made.]

Mitigation Strategy: Sanitize User-Provided Input for URLs

  • Description:
    1. Identify User Input Points for URLs: Locate all places where user input is used to construct the target URL for Goutte.
    2. Apply Sanitization: For each user input point, implement sanitization techniques before constructing the URL that will be used by Goutte:
      • URL Encoding: Encode user input using URL encoding functions.
      • Input Filtering: Filter out or escape potentially harmful characters or sequences that could be used for injection attacks within the URL context.
    3. Validate Sanitized Input: After sanitization, validate the constructed URL using URL structure validation and domain whitelisting to ensure the sanitization was effective and the resulting URL is safe for Goutte to access.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Injection Attacks via URL Manipulation: Medium to High Severity (depending on application context). Prevents attackers from injecting malicious commands or paths into the URL that Goutte will process.
  • Impact: Moderately to Significantly reduces injection attack risks by sanitizing user-provided URL components before Goutte uses them.
  • Currently Implemented: No. [Placeholder: Is user input sanitization for URLs currently implemented? If yes, where and how is sanitization performed before URLs are used with Goutte?]
  • Missing Implementation: [Placeholder: If not implemented, identify all user input points that contribute to URLs used by Goutte and implement sanitization logic at these points.]

Mitigation Strategy: Avoid Executing Scraped JavaScript

  • Description:
    1. Verify Goutte Configuration: Confirm that Goutte is configured not to execute JavaScript. The default Goutte behavior is to not execute JavaScript, which is the recommended secure configuration.
    2. Disable JavaScript Execution (If Enabled): If JavaScript execution is enabled through extensions or custom configurations (which is generally discouraged for security reasons), disable it unless absolutely necessary.
    3. Document Justification (If Enabled and Unavoidable): If JavaScript execution is enabled due to a critical requirement, thoroughly document the reasons and the increased security risks. Implement compensating security controls if JavaScript execution is unavoidable.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Scraped Content: High Severity. Prevents execution of malicious JavaScript code that might be present on scraped websites, protecting your application and users from client-side attacks.
  • Impact: Significantly reduces XSS and client-side vulnerability risks by ensuring Goutte does not execute untrusted JavaScript.
  • Currently Implemented: Yes (by default Goutte configuration). [Placeholder: Confirm that JavaScript execution is indeed disabled in the project's Goutte configuration. Verify no extensions or custom configurations enable it.]
  • Missing Implementation: N/A (assuming default Goutte behavior is maintained). [Placeholder: If JavaScript execution is unexpectedly enabled, it needs to be disabled unless absolutely necessary and justified due to the significant security risks.]

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Rate Limiting for Goutte Requests

  • Description:
    1. Determine Goutte Request Rate Limits: Decide on appropriate rate limits specifically for requests made by Goutte. This should consider the target websites' terms of service and your application's needs to avoid overloading target servers.
    2. Implement Rate Limiting in Goutte Request Logic: Integrate a rate limiting mechanism directly into the code that initiates Goutte requests. This could involve using delays between requests or a more sophisticated rate limiting library.
    3. Apply Rate Limiting Before Each Goutte Request: Ensure the rate limiting mechanism is checked and enforced before each Goutte request is sent. If the rate limit is exceeded, delay the request or implement appropriate error handling and retry logic.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Denial of Service (DoS) to Target Websites (via Goutte): Low to Medium Severity. Prevents your application from unintentionally overloading target websites with excessive Goutte requests.
    • Application Resource Exhaustion (due to uncontrolled Goutte requests): Medium Severity. Prevents uncontrolled scraping from consuming excessive resources on your application server.
  • Impact: Moderately reduces the risk of DoS to target websites and application resource exhaustion caused by Goutte's scraping activity. Promotes responsible scraping.
  • Currently Implemented: No. [Placeholder: Is rate limiting specifically implemented for Goutte requests? If yes, what rate limits are in place and how is it implemented in the Goutte request flow?]
  • Missing Implementation: [Placeholder: If not implemented, rate limiting logic should be added to the code that initiates Goutte requests, ensuring it is enforced before each request.]

Mitigation Strategy: Set Request Timeouts in Goutte Client

  • Description:
    1. Configure Goutte Client Timeouts: Explicitly set timeout values within the Goutte client configuration. This includes setting connection timeouts (time to establish a connection) and response timeouts (time to receive a response) for Goutte requests.
    2. Choose Reasonable Goutte Timeouts: Select timeout values that are appropriate for typical website response times but are short enough to prevent Goutte from hanging indefinitely if a target website is slow or unresponsive.
    3. Handle Goutte Timeout Exceptions: Implement error handling to catch timeout exceptions raised by Goutte. When a timeout occurs, log the event and implement appropriate retry logic or error reporting within your application.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Denial of Service (DoS) from Target Websites (affecting Goutte): Medium Severity. Prevents slow or unresponsive websites from causing Goutte requests to hang indefinitely, consuming resources.
    • Application Resource Exhaustion (due to hanging Goutte requests): Medium Severity. Prevents hanging Goutte requests from tying up resources and impacting application performance.
  • Impact: Moderately reduces the risk of DoS from slow websites affecting Goutte and prevents application resource exhaustion due to hanging Goutte requests.
  • Currently Implemented: Yes (likely default Goutte configuration, but needs explicit verification). [Placeholder: Verify that request timeouts are explicitly configured in the project's Goutte client setup. Check the timeout values to ensure they are reasonable.]
  • Missing Implementation: N/A (assuming default timeouts are configured, but explicit configuration is recommended). [Placeholder: If timeouts are not explicitly configured in the Goutte client or are set to very high values, they need to be properly configured in the Goutte client setup for better resilience.]

Mitigation Strategy: Resource Limits for Goutte Processes (If Using Process Isolation)

  • Description:
    1. Process Isolation for Goutte (If Applicable): If your application uses process isolation (e.g., separate processes or threads) for Goutte operations, this mitigation becomes relevant.
    2. Implement Resource Limits for Goutte Processes: Use operating system or containerization features to set resource limits (e.g., memory limits, CPU time limits) specifically for the processes or threads running Goutte.
    3. Apply Limits to Goutte Processes: Ensure these resource limits are correctly applied to the processes or threads that are executing Goutte operations.
    4. Monitor Goutte Process Resource Usage: Monitor the resource usage of these Goutte processes to ensure the limits are effective and adjust limits as needed to prevent resource exhaustion.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Application Resource Exhaustion (due to runaway Goutte processes): Medium to High Severity. Prevents a single Goutte scraping process from consuming excessive resources and impacting the entire application or system.
    • Impact on Other Application Components (due to Goutte resource usage): Medium Severity. Prevents resource exhaustion by Goutte from negatively impacting the performance of other parts of the application.
  • Impact: Moderately to Significantly reduces the risk of application resource exhaustion caused by isolated Goutte processes. Improves resource management and application stability when using process isolation for scraping.
  • Currently Implemented: No. [Placeholder: Are resource limits currently implemented for Goutte processes, especially if process isolation is used? If yes, how are processes isolated and what limits are in place?]
  • Missing Implementation: [Placeholder: If not implemented and process isolation is used for Goutte, resource limits should be configured for these processes to prevent resource exhaustion. This might involve using process management tools or containerization features to enforce limits.]

Mitigation Strategy: Disable Unnecessary Goutte Features

  • Description:
    1. Review Goutte Configuration Options: Thoroughly examine all available configuration options for Goutte.
    2. Identify Unnecessary Features: Identify any Goutte features or functionalities that are not strictly required for your application's specific scraping or testing use cases.
    3. Disable Unused Goutte Features: Explicitly disable any identified unnecessary features in the Goutte client configuration. This reduces the attack surface and potential for misconfiguration or unexpected behavior.
    4. Document Disabled Features: Document which Goutte features have been disabled and the reasons for disabling them, for future reference and maintenance.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Security Risks from Unused Goutte Features: Low Severity. While unlikely to be directly exploitable, unused features can sometimes introduce unexpected vulnerabilities or increase complexity, making the system harder to secure.
    • Misconfiguration Risks in Goutte: Low Severity. Simplifying the Goutte configuration by disabling unused features reduces the potential for misconfiguration and makes the configuration easier to understand and manage.
  • Impact: Minimally reduces security risks by reducing the attack surface of Goutte and simplifying its configuration. Improves overall configuration clarity and maintainability.
  • Currently Implemented: No (likely default Goutte configuration). [Placeholder: Has the Goutte configuration been reviewed to disable unnecessary features? If yes, which features have been disabled in the Goutte client configuration?]
  • Missing Implementation: [Placeholder: Review the Goutte configuration options and explicitly disable any features that are not actively used by the application to minimize the attack surface and simplify configuration.]