Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
74 lines (65 loc) · 8.24 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

74 lines (65 loc) · 8.24 KB

Threat Model Analysis for googleapis/google-api-php-client

Threat: Credential Theft and Abuse (Direct Library Impact)

  • Description: An attacker gains access to the application's Google API credentials due to vulnerabilities or misconfigurations directly related to how the library handles or stores credentials. This is distinct from general credential theft (e.g., from a compromised server) and focuses on library-specific issues. Examples include:
    • Library Bug: A hypothetical vulnerability in the google-api-php-client that leaks credentials during processing or storage.
    • Misconfiguration of Library-Specific Storage: If the library were to offer a built-in (but insecure) credential storage mechanism, and the developer used it incorrectly. (Note: The library generally doesn't do this, relying on external secure storage, but this highlights the direct involvement).
    • Dependency Vulnerability Affecting Credential Handling: A vulnerability in a direct dependency of google-api-php-client that impacts how credentials are processed or transmitted.
  • Impact:
    • Data Breach: Unauthorized access to sensitive data in Google services.
    • Data Modification/Deletion: Attacker can modify or delete data.
    • Service Disruption: Attacker can consume API quotas.
    • Financial Loss: Potential for significant charges if API usage is billed.
    • Reputational Damage: Loss of user trust and legal consequences.
  • Affected Component: Google\Client (credential handling mechanisms, setAuthConfig(), setAccessToken(), and related methods). Any part of the library involved in processing or storing credentials, including its direct dependencies.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Never Rely on Library for Primary Credential Storage: The library is not a secrets management solution. Always use external, secure storage (secrets manager, environment variables with extreme caution, encrypted config files).
    • Keep Library Updated: Immediately apply updates to google-api-php-client and its dependencies to patch any discovered vulnerabilities.
    • composer audit: Regularly run composer audit to identify vulnerable dependencies.
    • Follow Best Practices for External Storage: Regardless of the storage method chosen (secrets manager, etc.), follow all security best practices for that method. This is the primary defense.
    • Least Privilege: Grant the service account or OAuth 2.0 client ID only the minimum necessary permissions.
    • Regular Key Rotation: Rotate service account keys and API keys.
    • Monitor for Library Vulnerability Announcements: Stay informed about security advisories related to the library and its dependencies.

Threat: Library Tampering (Supply Chain Attack)

  • Description: An attacker compromises the google-api-php-client library itself or one of its direct dependencies before it's installed in the application. This is a classic supply chain attack. The attacker could:
    • Compromise Packagist: Publish a malicious version of the library or a direct dependency to Packagist.
    • Compromise a Git Repository: If the library or a dependency is pulled directly from a Git repository (less common, but possible), the attacker could compromise that repository.
  • Impact:
    • Credential Theft: The modified library could intercept and steal API credentials.
    • Data Exfiltration: The library could send sensitive data to the attacker.
    • Arbitrary Code Execution: The attacker could execute arbitrary code on the application server.
    • Backdoor Installation: The attacker could install a backdoor.
  • Affected Component: The entire google-api-php-client library and its direct dependencies (as managed by Composer). Any function or class could be affected.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Dependency Management (Composer):
      • Use composer.lock: Always commit composer.lock to version control. This ensures that the exact same versions of dependencies are installed on every deployment.
      • composer audit: Regularly run composer audit to check for known vulnerabilities.
      • Verify Package Sources: Be extremely cautious about using unofficial or untrusted package sources. Stick to the official Packagist repository.
    • Regular Updates: Keep the google-api-php-client and all its dependencies up-to-date.
    • File Integrity Monitoring (FIM): Implement FIM to detect unauthorized changes to library files after installation (this helps detect modifications after the initial install, which is a separate threat).
    • Vendor Directory Protection: Ensure the vendor directory is protected from unauthorized write access after installation.

Threat: Information Disclosure through Library Errors (Direct Leakage)

  • Description: A vulnerability in the google-api-php-client itself causes it to leak sensitive information (e.g., parts of API keys, internal state) through error messages or logging without the application's intervention. This is distinct from the application mishandling errors; this is about the library generating the sensitive information in the error.
  • Impact:
    • Partial Credential Exposure: Attackers might gain partial information about API keys or other secrets.
    • System Information Disclosure: Attackers gain information about the library's internal workings, potentially aiding in further attacks.
  • Affected Component: Error handling and logging mechanisms within the google-api-php-client itself. Specifically, any code that generates error messages or log output.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Keep Library Updated: This is the primary defense against library-specific vulnerabilities.
    • Monitor for Library Vulnerability Announcements: Stay informed about security advisories.
    • Review Library Code (if feasible): While not always practical, reviewing the library's error handling code (if open source) can help identify potential issues. This is a more advanced mitigation.
    • Application-Level Error Handling (as a secondary defense): Even though this threat focuses on the library, robust application-level error handling can still help mitigate the impact by preventing the library's raw errors from being exposed directly to users or logged unsafely. This is a secondary defense, as the primary issue is the library's behavior.

Threat: Overly Permissive Scopes (Configuration within the Library)

  • Description: The application, through its configuration of the google-api-php-client, requests overly broad OAuth 2.0 scopes. While this is primarily an application configuration issue, it's directly tied to how the library is used. The threat is that the library is configured to request excessive permissions.
  • Impact:
    • Increased Data Breach Scope: If credentials are compromised, the attacker has access to a wider range of data.
    • Wider Range of Actions: The attacker can perform more actions within Google services.
  • Affected Component: The OAuth 2.0 authorization flow and the configuration of scopes within the Google\Client object (e.g., when using setScopes()). This is about how the application uses the library's API.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Principle of Least Privilege: Request only the minimum necessary scopes. This is the most important mitigation.
    • Scope Justification: Document the justification for each requested scope.
    • Regular Scope Review: Periodically review and refine the requested scopes.
    • User Consent: Ensure users are clearly informed about the requested scopes during the authorization flow (this is more about user experience and transparency, but it's related).