Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
90 lines (65 loc) · 9.49 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

90 lines (65 loc) · 9.49 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for laravel-backpack/crud

Mitigation Strategy: Granular Permission Management within Backpack CRUD

Description:

  1. Utilize Backpack's Permission Features: Leverage Backpack's built-in integration with permission management packages (like spatie/laravel-permission).
  2. Define CRUD-Specific Permissions: Define permissions that are specific to each CRUD panel and operation. For example, instead of just "admin access", define permissions like user_crud_access, user_create, user_edit, blog_post_crud_access, blog_post_delete, etc.
  3. Apply Permissions in CRUD Controllers: Use Backpack's access() and allowAccess() methods within CRUD controllers to enforce these granular permissions. Control access to list, create, update, delete, show, and bulk actions based on user permissions.
  4. Implement Field-Level Permissions (If Needed): For sensitive data, consider implementing field-level permissions using Backpack's field attributes or custom logic to control which users can view or edit specific fields within a CRUD entry.
  5. Regularly Review and Adjust: Periodically audit and adjust CRUD-specific permissions as roles and application requirements evolve. Ensure that permissions are aligned with the principle of least privilege within the context of data managed by Backpack CRUD.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Unauthorized CRUD Access (High Severity): Prevents users from accessing or manipulating CRUD panels and data they are not authorized to manage through the Backpack interface.
  • Unauthorized Data Modification via CRUD (High Severity): Restricts unauthorized creation, editing, or deletion of data through the CRUD interface.
  • Privilege Escalation within CRUD (High Severity): Reduces the risk of users gaining elevated privileges within the CRUD system to manage data beyond their intended scope.
  • Data Breaches via CRUD Interface (High Severity): Limits potential data breaches by controlling access to sensitive data exposed and managed through CRUD panels.

Impact:

Significantly Reduces risk for threats related to unauthorized access and manipulation of data specifically through the Backpack CRUD interface.

Currently Implemented:

Partially implemented. Basic role-based access control for accessing the admin panel exists, but granular permissions within CRUD panels (operations, fields) are not fully defined for all entities.

Missing Implementation:

Need to define granular permissions for each CRUD entity and operation (create, read, update, delete, list, etc.). Implement these permission checks within Backpack CRUD controllers using access() and allowAccess() methods. Consider field-level permissions for sensitive data displayed or edited via CRUD.

Mitigation Strategy: Input Validation in Backpack CRUD Form Requests

Description:

  1. Create Form Requests for Backpack CRUD: Generate Laravel Form Request classes specifically for Create and Update operations within your Backpack CRUD controllers.
  2. Define Validation Rules for CRUD Fields: In these Form Requests, define comprehensive validation rules that directly correspond to the fields defined in your Backpack CRUD setup. Ensure rules match data types, required status, formats, lengths, and any custom validation needs for each CRUD field.
  3. Utilize Backpack Field Types for Implicit Validation: Leverage Backpack's field types (e.g., email, number, select) as they provide some inherent client-side and server-side validation. However, always supplement with explicit server-side validation in Form Requests.
  4. Apply Form Requests in Backpack Controllers: Ensure your Backpack CRUD controllers are type-hinting and using these Form Requests in their store() (create) and update() methods. Backpack automatically handles validation when Form Requests are used.
  5. Focus on Server-Side Validation: Prioritize server-side validation in Form Requests as the primary security measure. Client-side validation in Backpack forms is for user experience and should not be relied upon for security.

Threats Mitigated:

  • SQL Injection via CRUD Forms (High Severity): Reduces SQL injection risks by validating data submitted through CRUD forms before database interaction.
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via CRUD Fields (High Severity): Helps prevent XSS attacks by validating input in CRUD fields and ensuring only expected data types and formats are processed.
  • Data Integrity Issues from CRUD Input (Medium Severity): Prevents invalid or malformed data from being entered and stored through CRUD forms, maintaining data integrity.
  • Business Logic Errors due to Invalid CRUD Input (Medium Severity): Catches invalid input from CRUD forms that could lead to errors in application logic.

Impact:

Significantly Reduces risk of injection attacks and data integrity problems originating from user input through Backpack CRUD forms.

Currently Implemented:

Partially implemented. Form Requests are used for some CRUD operations, but validation rules are not consistently comprehensive for all fields across all CRUD entities.

Missing Implementation:

Create and implement Form Requests with comprehensive validation rules for all Create and Update operations in all Backpack CRUD entities. Ensure validation rules are specifically tailored to each CRUD field's requirements and data type. Review and enhance existing Form Requests for Backpack CRUD to ensure complete coverage.

Mitigation Strategy: HTML Sanitization for Rich Text Fields in Backpack CRUD

Description:

  1. Identify Rich Text Fields in Backpack CRUD: Locate all Backpack CRUD fields that use WYSIWYG editors (like CKEditor or TinyMCE) for rich text input.
  2. Integrate Sanitization in Backpack CRUD Logic: Implement HTML sanitization specifically when saving data from these rich text fields in your Backpack CRUD controllers (in store() and update() methods).
  3. Sanitize Before Database Storage: Ensure HTML sanitization occurs on the server-side before the rich text content is stored in the database.
  4. Configure Sanitization Rules for Backpack Context: Configure the HTML sanitization library to allow necessary HTML tags and attributes required for rich text formatting within your application, while strictly removing potentially harmful tags, attributes, and JavaScript.
  5. Apply Sanitization to Backpack Field Output (Optional): Consider sanitizing again when displaying rich text content from Backpack fields in the frontend views for an extra layer of defense, although sanitization on input is the primary requirement.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Backpack Rich Text Fields (High Severity): Significantly reduces the risk of stored XSS attacks originating from malicious HTML code injected through rich text fields managed by Backpack CRUD.

Impact:

Significantly Reduces risk of XSS attacks specifically related to user-provided rich text content within Backpack CRUD.

Currently Implemented:

No HTML sanitization is currently implemented for rich text fields in Backpack CRUD. Raw HTML from WYSIWYG editors is stored directly in the database via CRUD operations.

Missing Implementation:

Integrate an HTML sanitization library and apply it to all Backpack CRUD fields that use WYSIWYG editors within the CRUD controller's store() and update() methods, before saving data to the database. Configure the sanitizer to allow safe formatting tags while removing potentially malicious elements.

Mitigation Strategy: CSRF Protection for Backpack CRUD Forms

Description:

  1. Verify @csrf in Backpack Form Views: Double-check that the @csrf Blade directive is present within all <form> tags in your Backpack CRUD views (Create, Update, Delete forms, and any custom forms you've added within Backpack panels). Backpack's default views should include this, but verify customizations.
  2. AJAX CSRF Token for Custom Backpack Interactions: If you have implemented custom AJAX interactions within your Backpack admin panel (e.g., custom buttons, inline editing), ensure you are correctly sending the CSRF token with these AJAX requests.
  3. Test Backpack CRUD Forms for CSRF: Test submitting forms in your Backpack CRUD panels (Create, Update, Delete) both with and without the CSRF token. Verify that Laravel correctly rejects requests without a valid CSRF token with a 419 error.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) Attacks Targeting CRUD Operations (Medium Severity): Prevents CSRF attacks that could trick authenticated administrators into performing unintended CRUD operations (creating, updating, deleting data) through malicious websites or emails.

Impact:

Moderately Reduces risk of CSRF attacks specifically targeting actions performed through Backpack CRUD forms.

Currently Implemented:

Yes, globally implemented for default Backpack CRUD forms as Laravel's CSRF protection is enabled and @csrf is used in default views.

Missing Implementation:

Ensure @csrf is included in all custom forms or AJAX interactions you might have added within the Backpack admin panel. Regularly verify that CSRF protection remains active and functional for all CRUD-related forms.