Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
138 lines (113 loc) · 16 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

138 lines (113 loc) · 16 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for nextcloud/server

Mitigation Strategy: Enhanced Server Configuration and Hardening

  • Description:

    1. Run Nextcloud Security Scan: Utilize the built-in Nextcloud security scan tool (accessible via the admin interface) regularly to identify potential server configuration weaknesses.
    2. Harden Web Server (Apache/Nginx):
      • Disable unnecessary modules: Disable modules not required for Nextcloud functionality (e.g., mod_status, mod_info in Apache).
      • Restrict access to sensitive files: Configure web server to restrict access to .htaccess, .env, config.php, and other sensitive files.
      • Set appropriate timeouts: Configure timeouts for connections and requests to prevent resource exhaustion attacks.
      • Disable server signature: Prevent the web server from disclosing its version in HTTP headers.
    3. Harden PHP:
      • Disable dangerous functions: Disable potentially dangerous PHP functions like exec, shell_exec, system, passthru, eval in php.ini.
      • Enable opcache: Enable PHP opcache for performance and potentially some security benefits.
      • Set expose_php = Off in php.ini: Prevent PHP version disclosure in HTTP headers.
      • Configure secure session.cookie_httponly = 1 and session.cookie_secure = 1 in php.ini: Enhance session cookie security.
    4. Harden Database Server (MySQL/PostgreSQL):
      • Use strong database passwords: Ensure strong, unique passwords for database users.
      • Restrict database user permissions: Grant database users only the necessary permissions for Nextcloud operation.
      • Disable remote root access: Prevent remote root login to the database server.
      • Regularly update database server: Apply security updates and patches to the database server.
    5. Implement Security Headers: Configure the web server to send the following security headers:
      • Strict-Transport-Security (HSTS): Enforce HTTPS connections. Strict-Transport-Security: max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload
      • X-Frame-Options: DENY or SAMEORIGIN: Prevent clickjacking attacks.
      • X-Content-Type-Options: nosniff: Prevent MIME-sniffing vulnerabilities.
      • Referrer-Policy: no-referrer or strict-origin-when-cross-origin: Control referrer information leakage.
      • Permissions-Policy (formerly Feature-Policy): Control browser features available to the application.
    6. Disable Unnecessary Features: Disable Nextcloud server features not required, such as public link sharing at the server level if not needed.
    7. Configure File Permissions: Ensure correct file permissions for Nextcloud files and directories on the server. Web server user should have limited write access.
    8. Implement Rate Limiting/Brute-Force Protection: Enable Nextcloud's built-in brute-force protection or integrate with fail2ban or similar tools at the server level to protect login endpoints.
    9. Regular Nextcloud Updates: Apply Nextcloud server updates promptly.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Server Misconfiguration Exploitation (High Severity): Hardening reduces vulnerabilities arising from default or insecure server configurations, preventing exploitation for unauthorized access, information disclosure, or denial of service.
      • Brute-Force Attacks (Medium Severity): Rate limiting and brute-force protection mitigate password guessing attacks against user accounts at the server level.
      • Clickjacking (Medium Severity): X-Frame-Options prevents embedding Nextcloud in malicious iframes to trick users into performing actions, a server-level defense.
      • MIME-Sniffing Attacks (Medium Severity): X-Content-Type-Options prevents browsers from incorrectly interpreting file types, reducing the risk of executing malicious content, enforced by the server.
      • Information Disclosure (Medium Severity): Disabling server signatures, error reporting, and directory listing prevents leaking server version and file structure information.
      • Session Hijacking (Medium Severity): Secure session cookie settings reduce the risk of session hijacking, configured at the server level.

    • Impact: High risk reduction for server misconfiguration exploitation. Medium risk reduction for brute-force, clickjacking, MIME-sniffing, information disclosure, and session hijacking.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Nextcloud security scan is available but may not be run regularly.
      • Basic web server hardening (disabling directory listing, server signature) is often done.
      • PHP hardening is sometimes overlooked or incompletely implemented.
      • Database hardening varies depending on setup.
      • Security headers are often not fully implemented or configured correctly.
      • Brute-force protection is usually enabled by default in Nextcloud.
      • Regular Nextcloud updates are generally practiced, but timeliness can vary.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Automated Hardening Scripts/Tools: Lack of automated scripts or tools to assist with server hardening tasks and ensure consistent configuration.
      • Regular Hardening Audits: No regular audits to verify server hardening configurations and identify configuration drift over time.
      • Comprehensive Security Header Configuration: Security headers are often missing or incompletely configured, leaving vulnerabilities unaddressed.
      • Database Hardening Best Practices: Database hardening is often not prioritized or implemented to best practice standards.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure File Storage and Handling (Server-Side Focus)

  • Description:

    1. Enable Server-Side Encryption: Enable server-side encryption in Nextcloud settings (Encryption section). Choose an appropriate encryption module (e.g., default encryption module) and understand key management implications. This is a server-side feature to protect data at rest. Consider using encryption at rest for the underlying storage layer as well (server OS level).
    2. Integrate Antivirus Scanning (Server-Side): Install and configure an antivirus app (e.g., "Antivirus for Files") in Nextcloud and integrate it with an antivirus engine like ClamAV, ensuring the scanning happens on the server upon file upload. Configure scanning settings (e.g., scan on upload).
    3. Secure External Storage Configuration (Server-Side): If using external storage (e.g., S3, SMB/CIFS), ensure that the server-side connection and access to the external storage is properly secured with access controls, encryption (if supported), and strong authentication. Follow best practices for securing the specific external storage service from the server's perspective.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Data Breach at Rest (High Severity): Server-side encryption protects data at rest in case of physical server compromise or unauthorized access to storage media.
      • Malware Upload and Distribution (High Severity): Server-side antivirus scanning prevents the upload and distribution of malware through Nextcloud, protecting users and systems connected to the server.
      • Unauthorized Access to External Storage (High Severity): Secure server-side configuration of external storage prevents unauthorized access to data stored externally.

    • Impact: High risk reduction for data breaches at rest, malware distribution, and unauthorized access to external storage from the server.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Server-side encryption is available and often enabled, but key management practices may vary.
      • Antivirus integration is available via apps but may not be consistently implemented or configured for server-side scanning.
      • External storage security depends heavily on the specific external storage service and server-side configuration.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Robust Key Management for Encryption: Lack of formalized and secure key management practices for server-side encryption, including key rotation and secure storage on the server.
      • Automated Antivirus Definition Updates and Monitoring (Server-Side): Ensuring antivirus definitions are automatically updated on the server and monitoring server-side antivirus scanning effectiveness.
      • Regular Security Audits of External Storage Server-Side Connections: No regular audits to review and refine server-side configurations for external storage to ensure they remain appropriate and secure.

Mitigation Strategy: Authentication and Session Management (Server-Side Focus)

  • Description:

    1. Enforce Strong Password Policies (Server-Side): Configure Nextcloud password policy settings (Security section in admin settings) to enforce minimum password length, complexity requirements, and password expiration. This is enforced by the server.
    2. Implement Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) (Server-Side Enforcement): Enable and enforce MFA for all users at the server level. Nextcloud supports various MFA methods (e.g., TOTP, WebAuthn, U2F). Server configuration should mandate MFA.
    3. Configure Secure Session Management (Server-Side): Review and adjust session timeout settings in Nextcloud configuration (config.php or admin settings). Set appropriate session timeouts to balance security and user convenience. Ensure sessions are invalidated properly upon logout and inactivity, managed by the server.
    4. Monitor Login Attempts and User Activity (Server-Side Logging): Enable and review Nextcloud's audit logs to monitor login attempts (successful and failed) and user activity. Server-side logging is crucial for detecting suspicious activity.
    5. Integrate with Trusted Authentication Provider (SSO) (Server-Side): Integrate Nextcloud with a trusted authentication provider like LDAP/Active Directory, SAML, or OAuth 2.0. This centralizes authentication management at the server level.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Password-Based Account Compromise (High Severity): Server-enforced strong password policies and MFA significantly reduce the risk of account compromise due to weak or stolen passwords.
      • Brute-Force Password Attacks (Medium Severity): Server-side strong password policies make brute-force attacks more difficult. Server-enforced MFA adds an additional layer of protection.
      • Session Hijacking/Theft (Medium Severity): Server-configured secure session management and HTTPS reduce the risk of session hijacking.
      • Unauthorized Access due to Weak Authentication (High Severity): Server-side strong authentication mechanisms (strong passwords, MFA, SSO) are crucial to prevent unauthorized access to Nextcloud and its data.

    • Impact: High risk reduction for password-based account compromise and unauthorized access. Medium risk reduction for brute-force attacks and session hijacking.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Strong password policies are often configured at the server level, but enforcement may vary.
      • MFA is available but server-side enforcement for all users or user groups may be missing.
      • Session management settings are usually default and may not be optimally secure from a server perspective.
      • Login attempt and user activity logging is available on the server but may not be actively monitored.
      • SSO integration is often considered for larger organizations for server-level authentication management.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Enforced MFA for All Users/Groups (Server-Side): Lack of mandatory MFA for all users or specific user groups, enforced at the server level, leaving some accounts vulnerable to password-based attacks.
      • Proactive Monitoring and Alerting for Suspicious Login Activity (Server-Side): No proactive server-side monitoring and alerting systems to detect and respond to suspicious login attempts or account compromise in real-time.
      • Regular Review of Session Management Settings (Server-Side): Server-side session management settings are often set once and forgotten, without periodic review and adjustment based on evolving security needs.
      • Centralized Authentication and Authorization Policies (Server-Side): Lack of centralized server-side authentication and authorization policies when not using SSO, leading to potential inconsistencies and weaker security controls.

Mitigation Strategy: Information Disclosure Prevention (Server-Side Focus)

  • Description:

    1. Disable Directory Listing (Web Server Configuration): Configure the web server (Apache/Nginx) to disable directory listing. This is a server-level configuration.
    2. Configure Error Reporting (PHP Configuration): Set PHP error reporting in php.ini to be minimal in production environments and disable displaying errors to the browser. This is a server-level PHP configuration.
    3. Remove Unnecessary Files/Directories (Server File System): Remove any default or example files and directories from the server file system that are not required for Nextcloud to function.
    4. Secure Configuration Files (Server File System Permissions): Ensure that Nextcloud configuration files (e.g., config.php, .htaccess) are properly secured with restrictive file permissions on the server.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Information Disclosure via Directory Listing (Medium Severity): Server-side disabling of directory listing prevents attackers from easily discovering files and directory structures.
      • Information Disclosure via Error Messages (Medium Severity): Server-side proper error reporting configuration prevents exposing sensitive information in error messages.
      • Information Disclosure via Unnecessary Files (Low Severity): Removing unnecessary files from the server reduces potential information leakage.
      • Information Disclosure via Configuration Files (High Severity if misconfigured): Server-side securing of configuration files prevents unauthorized access to sensitive configuration details.

    • Impact: Medium risk reduction for information disclosure via directory listing and error messages. Low risk reduction for unnecessary files. High risk reduction for configuration file exposure.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented.

      • Directory listing is often disabled by default in common web server configurations, but should be verified on the server.
      • Error reporting configuration is sometimes overlooked or incorrectly configured on the server in production.
      • Removal of unnecessary files from the server is often not systematically performed.
      • Configuration file security is generally considered on the server, but permissions may not always be optimal.

    • Missing Implementation:

      • Automated Checks for Directory Listing and Error Reporting (Server-Side): Lack of automated server-side checks to verify directory listing is disabled and error reporting is correctly configured.
      • Automated Removal of Unnecessary Files (Server-Side): No automated scripts or processes to regularly identify and remove unnecessary files and directories from the server.
      • Regular Security Audits of Configuration Files (Server File System): Lack of regular security audits to review configuration file permissions and content on the server for potential vulnerabilities or information leakage.