Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
82 lines (71 loc) · 8.31 KB

attack-surface.md

File metadata and controls

82 lines (71 loc) · 8.31 KB

Attack Surface Analysis for nextcloud/server

Attack Surface: 1. File Storage and Synchronization (Core)

  • Description: Vulnerabilities related to how Nextcloud stores, retrieves, and synchronizes files, including interactions with underlying storage backends. This is the core server-side functionality.
  • Server Contribution: Nextcloud's core server code handles all file operations, including access control, versioning, encryption (if enabled), and communication with storage backends (local filesystem, object storage, etc.).
  • Example: A path traversal vulnerability in Nextcloud's server-side code allows an attacker to access files outside a user's authorized directory, potentially reaching system files or other users' data. This is a server-side vulnerability.
  • Impact: Data breach, data loss, system compromise, unauthorized access to sensitive information.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Implement robust input validation and sanitization for all file paths and user-supplied data related to file operations on the server-side.
      • Use secure coding practices to prevent path traversal, injection vulnerabilities, and other file-related vulnerabilities in the server code.
      • Regularly audit and test file handling code (server-side), including interactions with external storage providers.
      • Implement secure handling of symbolic links on the server.
      • Ensure proper error handling to prevent information leakage from server responses.
      • Implement and maintain robust server-side encryption mechanisms, including key management.

Attack Surface: 2. App Ecosystem (Server-Side Aspects)

  • Description: Vulnerabilities introduced by third-party apps installed within Nextcloud, specifically focusing on the server-side components of these apps.
    • Server Contribution: Nextcloud's server provides the runtime environment for apps. Apps can execute server-side code, interact with the database, and access core server functions. The server is responsible for enforcing app permissions (though this can be bypassed by vulnerabilities).
    • Example: A malicious or poorly coded app could contain a server-side SQL injection vulnerability, allowing an attacker to execute arbitrary SQL queries on the Nextcloud database server. Or, a server-side remote code execution vulnerability.
    • Impact: Data breach, data loss, system compromise, denial of service, complete control of the Nextcloud instance (all server-side consequences).
    • Risk Severity: High to Critical (depending on the app and its permissions)
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Follow secure coding guidelines when developing apps, paying critical attention to server-side code.
        • Use Nextcloud's provided APIs securely and avoid direct database access where possible. Use parameterized queries to prevent SQL injection.
        • Implement robust input validation and output encoding on the server-side.
        • Submit apps for review in the Nextcloud app store.
        • Provide timely security updates for apps, especially addressing server-side vulnerabilities.
      • Server Administrators:
        • Implement strict server-side controls to limit the capabilities of apps (e.g., using containerization or other isolation techniques). This is a server-level mitigation.
        • Monitor server logs for suspicious activity originating from apps.

Attack Surface: 3. User and Group Management (Server-Side)

  • Description: Flaws in Nextcloud's server-side authentication, authorization, and user/group management features.
    • Server Contribution: Nextcloud's server manages user accounts, groups, permissions, and authentication (including handling interactions with external authentication providers like LDAP on the server-side). All authentication and authorization logic is executed on the server.
    • Example: A vulnerability in the server-side group management logic could allow a user to gain unauthorized access to files shared with a group they shouldn't belong to. Or, a bypass of Nextcloud's server-side 2FA implementation. These are flaws in the server's logic.
    • Impact: Unauthorized access to data, privilege escalation, account takeover (all impacting the server and its data).
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Implement robust authentication and authorization checks throughout the server-side codebase.
        • Use secure session management techniques on the server.
        • Regularly audit and test user and group management features (server-side), including integrations with external authentication providers.
        • Ensure proper handling of password resets and account recovery on the server.
        • Implement secure handling of authentication tokens and secrets on the server.

Attack Surface: 4. Sharing and Collaboration (Server-Side)

  • Description: Vulnerabilities in Nextcloud's server-side file sharing and collaborative editing features. * Server Contribution: The Nextcloud server manages all aspects of sharing: generating links, enforcing permissions, and handling requests for shared resources. For collaborative editing, the server interacts with the collaborative editing backend (e.g., Collabora Online or OnlyOffice). * Example: A flaw in the server-side link generation or permission checking logic could allow unauthorized access to a shared file. Or, a server-side vulnerability in the integration with a collaborative editing suite could allow an attacker to compromise the Nextcloud server. * Impact: Data breach, unauthorized access to shared resources, potential for server compromise (depending on the vulnerability). * Risk Severity: High * Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers: * Implement robust access control checks on the server-side for all sharing mechanisms. * Ensure proper validation and sanitization of user input related to sharing and collaboration on the server. * Regularly audit and test sharing and collaboration features, including the server-side integration with external services. * Securely handle communication between the Nextcloud server and collaborative editing backends.

Attack Surface: 5. Preview and Thumbnail Generation

  • Description: Vulnerabilities in the server-side libraries used by Nextcloud to generate previews and thumbnails of files.
    • Server Contribution: Nextcloud's server uses external libraries (e.g., ImageMagick, FFmpeg) to process images, videos, and other file types for preview generation. This processing happens entirely on the server.
    • Example: A specially crafted image file uploaded to the server could exploit a vulnerability in ImageMagick, leading to remote code execution on the Nextcloud server.
    • Impact: Remote code execution on the server, denial of service, information leakage.
    • Risk Severity: High to Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Keep image and video processing libraries (used on the server) updated to the latest versions.
        • Use secure configurations for these libraries on the server.
        • Implement sandboxing or other isolation techniques on the server to limit the impact of vulnerabilities in these libraries.
        • Regularly audit and test preview generation functionality (server-side).
        • Consider disabling preview generation for certain file types if it's not essential, reducing the server's attack surface.
      • Server Administrators:
        • Ensure that the server environment is configured to limit the privileges of the Nextcloud process, reducing the impact of a successful exploit.