Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
129 lines (110 loc) · 9.1 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

129 lines (110 loc) · 9.1 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for octobercms/october

Objective: Compromise OctoberCMS Application

Attack Tree Visualization

Root Goal: Compromise OctoberCMS Application
├───[OR]─ 2. Exploit OctoberCMS Plugin Vulnerabilities **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   ├───[OR]─ 2.1. Identify and Exploit Known Plugin Vulnerabilities **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │   ├───[AND]─ 2.1.4. Vulnerability Exploitation **[CRITICAL NODE]**
├───[OR]─ 3. Exploit OctoberCMS Theme Vulnerabilities **[MEDIUM RISK PATH]**
│   ├───[OR]─ 3.1. Identify and Exploit Theme-Based XSS **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │   ├───[AND]─ 3.1.3. XSS Exploitation **[CRITICAL NODE]**
├───[OR]─ 4. Exploit OctoberCMS Configuration Weaknesses **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   ├───[OR]─ 4.1. Default or Weak Admin Credentials **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │   ├───[AND]─ 4.1.3. Admin Panel Access **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   ├───[OR]─ 4.3. Insecure File Permissions **[MEDIUM-HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │   ├───[AND]─ 4.3.2. File Manipulation/Code Injection **[CRITICAL NODE]**
└───[OR]─ 6. Social Engineering Targeting OctoberCMS Administrators **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
    ├───[OR]─ 6.1. Phishing for Admin Credentials **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   ├───[AND]─ 6.1.4. Admin Panel Access **[CRITICAL NODE]**

Attack Tree Path: Exploit OctoberCMS Plugin Vulnerabilities (High-Risk Path)

1. Exploit OctoberCMS Plugin Vulnerabilities (High-Risk Path)

  • Attack Vector:
    • OctoberCMS relies heavily on plugins for extending functionality.
    • Plugins are often developed by third-party developers with varying levels of security expertise.
    • Known vulnerabilities in popular or outdated plugins are frequently discovered and publicly disclosed.
    • Attackers can easily identify installed plugins and their versions on a target OctoberCMS site.
    • Exploits for known plugin vulnerabilities are often readily available or easy to develop.
  • Critical Node: 2.1.4. Vulnerability Exploitation
    • This is the point where the attacker executes an exploit against a vulnerable plugin.
    • Successful exploitation can lead to various outcomes, including:
      • Remote Code Execution (RCE) - allowing the attacker to run arbitrary code on the server.
      • SQL Injection - allowing the attacker to access or modify the database.
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) - allowing the attacker to inject malicious scripts into the website.
      • Local File Inclusion (LFI) - allowing the attacker to read sensitive files on the server.
    • Why High-Risk:
      • High likelihood due to the prevalence of plugin vulnerabilities.
      • Critical impact as plugin vulnerabilities often lead to full system compromise.
      • Relatively low effort and skill level to exploit known vulnerabilities.
      • Detection can be challenging if the exploit is sophisticated or zero-day.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Theme-Based XSS (High-Risk Path)

2. Exploit Theme-Based XSS (High-Risk Path)

  • Attack Vector:
    • OctoberCMS themes control the presentation layer and often handle user-generated content.
    • If theme developers do not properly sanitize and escape user inputs before displaying them in templates, XSS vulnerabilities can arise.
    • Attackers can inject malicious JavaScript code through various input points (e.g., search forms, comments, URL parameters).
    • When a user visits a page containing the injected script, the script executes in their browser within the context of the website.
  • Critical Node: 3.1.3. XSS Exploitation
    • This is the point where the attacker leverages a confirmed XSS vulnerability to perform malicious actions.
    • Common XSS exploitation techniques include:
      • Session Hijacking - stealing user session cookies to impersonate users, including administrators.
      • Website Defacement - altering the visual appearance of the website.
      • Redirection to Malicious Sites - redirecting users to phishing pages or malware distribution sites.
      • Keylogging - capturing user keystrokes.
    • Why High-Risk:
      • High likelihood due to common mistakes in theme development regarding input handling.
      • Medium impact, can escalate to high if admin sessions are hijacked.
      • Low effort and skill level to exploit basic XSS vulnerabilities.
      • Detection can be challenging for reflected XSS if not properly logged and monitored.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Default or Weak Admin Credentials (High-Risk Path)

3. Exploit Default or Weak Admin Credentials (High-Risk Path)

  • Attack Vector:
    • If administrators choose weak passwords or fail to change default credentials (though default credentials are not typically set by OctoberCMS itself, weak passwords are common).
    • Attackers can use brute-force or dictionary attacks to guess admin credentials.
    • Once valid credentials are obtained, attackers can directly log in to the OctoberCMS admin panel.
  • Critical Node: 4.1.3. Admin Panel Access
    • Gaining access to the OctoberCMS admin panel is a critical node as it grants extensive control over the application.
    • With admin access, attackers can:
      • Install and modify plugins and themes, leading to code execution.
      • Modify website content and configuration.
      • Access sensitive data stored in the database.
      • Create new admin accounts for persistent access.
    • Why High-Risk:
      • Medium likelihood due to the persistent issue of weak passwords and password reuse.
      • Critical impact as admin access grants full control.
      • Low effort and skill level for basic brute-force or dictionary attacks.
      • Detection can be improved with account lockout and login attempt monitoring.

Attack Tree Path: Insecure File Permissions leading to File Manipulation/Code Injection (Medium-High Risk Path)

4. Insecure File Permissions leading to File Manipulation/Code Injection (Medium-High Risk Path)

  • Attack Vector:
    • Incorrectly configured file permissions on the server can allow unauthorized users (including web server processes) to write to sensitive directories.
    • Commonly misconfigured directories include storage/, uploads/, and theme directories.
    • If attackers can write to these directories, they can upload malicious files (e.g., PHP scripts) or modify existing application files.
    • Uploaded or modified files can then be executed by the web server, leading to code execution.
  • Critical Node: 4.3.2. File Manipulation/Code Injection
    • This is the point where the attacker successfully uploads or modifies files to inject malicious code.
    • Successful code injection can lead to:
      • Remote Code Execution (RCE) - allowing the attacker to run arbitrary code on the server.
      • Website Defacement - altering website files.
      • Data Exfiltration - accessing and stealing sensitive data.
    • Why Medium-High Risk:
      • Medium likelihood as misconfigurations are common, but require some server-side access or vulnerability to exploit.
      • High impact as code injection often leads to RCE.
      • Medium effort and skill level to exploit writable directories and inject code.
      • Detection can be improved with file integrity monitoring and proper permission audits.

Attack Tree Path: Phishing for Admin Credentials (High-Risk Path)

5. Phishing for Admin Credentials (High-Risk Path)

  • Attack Vector:
    • Attackers use social engineering techniques, primarily phishing emails, to trick OctoberCMS administrators into revealing their login credentials.
    • Phishing emails often mimic legitimate OctoberCMS login pages or system notifications.
    • Emails may contain links to fake login pages designed to steal credentials when entered.
    • Attackers may also use other social engineering tactics to gain trust and extract credentials.
  • Critical Node: 6.1.4. Admin Panel Access
    • Similar to weak credentials, gaining admin panel access via stolen credentials is a critical node.
    • The consequences of admin panel access are the same as described in point 3 (plugin/theme modification, data access, etc.).
    • Why High-Risk:
      • High likelihood due to the effectiveness of phishing attacks against human targets.
      • Critical impact as admin access grants full control.
      • Low effort and skill level to launch phishing campaigns (tools are readily available).
      • Detection relies heavily on user awareness and email security measures.