Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
303 lines (268 loc) · 41.7 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

303 lines (268 loc) · 41.7 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for octobercms/october

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update Plugins and Themes

  • Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update Plugins and Themes
  • Description:
    1. Access the OctoberCMS Backend: Log in to the OctoberCMS backend as an administrator.
    2. Navigate to Updates: Go to "Settings" -> "Updates".
    3. Check for Updates: Click the "Check for updates" button. OctoberCMS will check for available updates for the core, plugins, and themes.
    4. Review Updates: Examine the list of available updates. Pay attention to any security-related updates mentioned in the update descriptions.
    5. Apply Updates: Click the "Update" button to apply the updates. It's recommended to back up your application before applying updates, especially major ones.
    6. Test Application: After updating, thoroughly test the application to ensure everything is working as expected and that no regressions have been introduced.
    7. Schedule Regular Checks: Set a reminder to regularly check for updates (e.g., weekly or bi-weekly) to ensure timely patching of vulnerabilities.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Plugin/Theme Vulnerabilities (High Severity): Exploits in outdated plugin or theme code can lead to Remote Code Execution (RCE), Cross-Site Scripting (XSS), SQL Injection, and other serious vulnerabilities within the OctoberCMS context.
  • Impact: High Reduction of risk associated with known plugin and theme vulnerabilities within OctoberCMS. Updates often directly patch these vulnerabilities.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. We have a process for checking updates monthly, but it's not automated and sometimes updates are delayed due to testing requirements. Implemented in the OctoberCMS backend update interface.
  • Missing Implementation: Automation of update checks and potentially automated testing after updates in a staging environment before production deployment within the OctoberCMS workflow.

Mitigation Strategy: Install Plugins and Themes from Trusted Sources

  • Mitigation Strategy: Install Plugins and Themes from Trusted Sources
  • Description:
    1. Prioritize Official Marketplace: When searching for plugins or themes, primarily use the official OctoberCMS Marketplace (https://octobercms.com/marketplace).
    2. Evaluate Developer Reputation: For plugins/themes from the marketplace or other sources within the OctoberCMS ecosystem, research the developer or organization. Look for established developers with positive reviews and a history of maintaining their plugins/themes in the OctoberCMS community.
    3. Check Reviews and Ratings: Read reviews and ratings from other users on the marketplace or community forums specific to OctoberCMS plugins/themes to gauge the quality and reliability of the plugin/theme.
    4. Review Plugin/Theme Permissions: Before installing, check the permissions requested by the plugin/theme within the OctoberCMS permission system. Be wary of plugins/themes requesting excessive or unnecessary permissions.
    5. Code Review (Advanced): For critical plugins/themes or those from less trusted sources within the OctoberCMS ecosystem, consider performing a code review or security audit of the plugin/theme code before installation, especially if source code is available.
    6. Avoid Nullified/Pirated Plugins/Themes: Never use nulled or pirated plugins/themes designed for OctoberCMS. These often contain malware or backdoors and are a significant security risk specifically within the OctoberCMS platform.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Malicious Plugins/Themes (High Severity): Installation of plugins/themes designed for OctoberCMS containing malware, backdoors, or intentionally vulnerable code can lead to complete system compromise within the OctoberCMS application.
    • Vulnerable Plugins/Themes from Untrusted Developers (Medium to High Severity): Plugins/themes developed for OctoberCMS from less reputable developers may be poorly coded and contain unintentional vulnerabilities exploitable within the OctoberCMS environment.
  • Impact: Medium to High Reduction of risk. Significantly reduces the likelihood of installing intentionally malicious or poorly maintained components within the OctoberCMS plugin/theme ecosystem.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Developers are generally instructed to use the official marketplace, but there isn't a formal process for vetting plugins beyond that. Implemented as a guideline in development practices.
  • Missing Implementation: Formal plugin/theme vetting process, potentially including automated checks or a curated list of approved plugins/themes specifically for OctoberCMS.

Mitigation Strategy: Minimize Plugin and Theme Usage

  • Mitigation Strategy: Minimize Plugin and Theme Usage
  • Description:
    1. Requirement Review: Before installing any new plugin or theme in OctoberCMS, critically evaluate if it's absolutely necessary for the application's functionality within the OctoberCMS context.
    2. Functionality Consolidation: Explore if existing plugins or custom code within OctoberCMS can provide the required functionality instead of adding a new plugin.
    3. Regular Audit of Installed Components: Periodically review the list of installed plugins and themes in the OctoberCMS backend. Identify and remove any plugins or themes that are no longer actively used or whose functionality is no longer required.
    4. Disable Unused Plugins/Themes (If Removal Not Possible): If a plugin or theme cannot be removed immediately but is not currently in use, disable it in the OctoberCMS backend to reduce the attack surface of the OctoberCMS application.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Increased Attack Surface (Medium Severity): Each installed plugin and theme in OctoberCMS adds to the overall codebase and potential attack surface of the application within the OctoberCMS environment.
  • Impact: Medium Reduction of risk. Reduces the number of potential entry points for attackers within the OctoberCMS plugin/theme ecosystem and simplifies maintenance.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Developers are generally mindful of not over-installing plugins, but there's no regular audit process. Implemented as a general development principle.
  • Missing Implementation: Regular scheduled audits of installed plugins and themes within OctoberCMS, and a formal policy on plugin/theme justification and removal.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Plugin and Theme Vulnerability Scanning

  • Mitigation Strategy: Implement Plugin and Theme Vulnerability Scanning
  • Description:
    1. Choose a Scanning Tool: Select a vulnerability scanning tool that is capable of scanning OctoberCMS plugins and themes. This could be a dedicated OctoberCMS security scanner or a more general web application scanner with plugin/theme detection capabilities specifically for OctoberCMS.
    2. Integrate into Development Pipeline: Integrate the chosen scanning tool into the development and deployment pipeline for OctoberCMS projects. Ideally, scans should be performed:
      • During development (e.g., before committing code related to OctoberCMS plugins/themes).
      • During build/deployment processes of the OctoberCMS application.
      • Regularly on the production environment (scheduled scans of the live OctoberCMS application).
    3. Configure and Run Scans: Configure the scanning tool to target the OctoberCMS application and its plugins/themes. Run scans regularly as part of the security process for OctoberCMS.
    4. Analyze Scan Results: Review the scan results to identify any reported vulnerabilities in plugins or themes within the OctoberCMS application.
    5. Remediate Vulnerabilities: Prioritize and remediate identified vulnerabilities in OctoberCMS plugins/themes. This may involve updating plugins/themes, applying patches, or replacing vulnerable components.
    6. Automate Reporting and Alerts: Set up automated reporting and alerts to notify the security and development teams of new vulnerabilities detected by the scanning tool in OctoberCMS plugins/themes.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Known Plugin/Theme Vulnerabilities (High Severity): Proactively identifies known vulnerabilities in installed plugins and themes within OctoberCMS before they can be exploited.
  • Impact: High Reduction of risk. Provides early detection of known vulnerabilities in OctoberCMS plugins/themes, allowing for timely remediation and preventing exploitation.
  • Currently Implemented: Not implemented. We are not currently using any automated plugin/theme vulnerability scanning tools specifically for OctoberCMS.
  • Missing Implementation: Selection and integration of a suitable vulnerability scanning tool into the development and deployment pipeline for OctoberCMS plugin/theme security.

Mitigation Strategy: Develop Custom Plugins and Themes Securely

  • Mitigation Strategy: Develop Custom Plugins and Themes Securely
  • Description:
    1. Secure Coding Training: Ensure developers receive training on secure coding practices for PHP and JavaScript, specifically focusing on web application security and common vulnerabilities like OWASP Top 10 in the context of OctoberCMS plugin and theme development.
    2. Security Requirements in Design: Incorporate security considerations into the design phase of custom plugin and theme development for OctoberCMS. Identify potential security risks early on.
    3. Input Validation and Output Encoding: Implement robust input validation for all user inputs within custom OctoberCMS plugins and themes to prevent injection attacks (SQL Injection, XSS, etc.). Properly encode outputs to prevent XSS vulnerabilities.
    4. Authorization and Authentication: Implement proper authentication and authorization mechanisms within custom OctoberCMS plugins and themes, utilizing OctoberCMS's built-in features where possible, to control access to sensitive functionalities.
    5. CSRF Protection: Implement CSRF protection mechanisms for forms and actions within custom plugins and themes in OctoberCMS to prevent Cross-Site Request Forgery attacks. OctoberCMS provides built-in CSRF protection mechanisms that should be utilized.
    6. Regular Code Reviews: Conduct regular code reviews of custom plugin and theme code for OctoberCMS, focusing on security aspects. Involve security experts in code reviews if possible.
    7. Security Testing: Perform thorough security testing of custom plugins and themes developed for OctoberCMS before deployment. This should include vulnerability scanning, penetration testing, and manual security assessments.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Vulnerabilities in Custom Code (High Severity): Poorly written custom plugins and themes for OctoberCMS can introduce vulnerabilities such as SQL Injection, XSS, CSRF, and Remote Code Execution within the OctoberCMS application.
  • Impact: High Reduction of risk. Prevents the introduction of new vulnerabilities through custom code in OctoberCMS plugins and themes by implementing secure development practices.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Developers follow general secure coding practices, and code reviews are conducted, but security is not always the primary focus in reviews. Implemented as part of the development process, but not formally enforced for security.
  • Missing Implementation: Formalized secure coding guidelines for OctoberCMS plugin/theme development, mandatory security-focused code reviews, and dedicated security testing for custom plugins and themes within the OctoberCMS context.

Mitigation Strategy: Keep OctoberCMS Core Updated

  • Mitigation Strategy: Keep OctoberCMS Core Updated
  • Description:
    1. Access the OctoberCMS Backend: Log in to the OctoberCMS backend as an administrator.
    2. Navigate to Updates: Go to "Settings" -> "Updates".
    3. Check for Updates: Click the "Check for updates" button. OctoberCMS will check for core updates.
    4. Review Updates: Examine the update details. Pay close attention to security-related updates mentioned in the release notes for OctoberCMS core.
    5. Apply Updates: Click the "Update" button to update the OctoberCMS core. Back up the application before performing core updates.
    6. Test Application: After updating, thoroughly test the entire application to ensure compatibility and functionality within the OctoberCMS environment.
    7. Monitor Release Notes: Regularly monitor OctoberCMS release notes and security advisories for announcements of core updates and security patches.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • OctoberCMS Core Vulnerabilities (Critical Severity): Exploits in the OctoberCMS core can have widespread and severe consequences, potentially affecting the entire application and server running OctoberCMS.
  • Impact: High Reduction of risk. Core updates directly patch known vulnerabilities in the OctoberCMS platform, preventing exploitation.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Core updates are generally applied, but sometimes delayed due to testing and release cycles. Implemented in the OctoberCMS backend update interface.
  • Missing Implementation: More proactive monitoring of OctoberCMS security advisories and a faster process for testing and deploying core updates, potentially including automated testing within the OctoberCMS update workflow.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Configuration Files

  • Mitigation Strategy: Secure Configuration Files
  • Description:
    1. Restrict Web Access: Configure the web server (e.g., Apache, Nginx) to prevent direct web access to the config directory and its files of the OctoberCMS application. This can be done using .htaccess rules (for Apache) or server block configurations (for Nginx).
    2. Set File Permissions: Set strict file permissions on configuration files (e.g., config/cms.php, config/database.php, config/app.php) within the OctoberCMS application to restrict access to only the web server user and the application owner. Typically, permissions like 640 or 600 are recommended.
    3. Use Environment Variables: Avoid storing sensitive information directly in configuration files of OctoberCMS (e.g., database passwords, API keys). Utilize environment variables to store sensitive data and access them in the configuration files using env() function within OctoberCMS configuration.
    4. Configuration File Backup: Regularly back up configuration files of the OctoberCMS application as part of the overall application backup strategy.
    5. Version Control Considerations: If configuration files of OctoberCMS are version controlled, ensure that sensitive information is not committed directly. Use environment variables or configuration management tools to handle sensitive data separately.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exposure of Sensitive Information (High Severity): Publicly accessible or improperly secured configuration files of OctoberCMS can expose sensitive information like database credentials, API keys, and application secrets related to the OctoberCMS application.
  • Impact: High Reduction of risk. Prevents unauthorized access to and modification of sensitive configuration data within the OctoberCMS application.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Web access to the config directory is restricted via .htaccess. File permissions are generally set, but not consistently audited. Environment variables are used for some sensitive data, but not comprehensively.
  • Missing Implementation: Comprehensive use of environment variables for all sensitive configuration in OctoberCMS, automated auditing of file permissions for OctoberCMS configuration files, and more rigorous configuration management practices for OctoberCMS configuration.

Mitigation Strategy: Disable Debug Mode in Production

  • Mitigation Strategy: Disable Debug Mode in Production
  • Description:
    1. Edit config/app.php: Open the config/app.php file in the application's config directory of OctoberCMS.
    2. Set debug to false: Locate the 'debug' configuration option and ensure its value is set to false: 'debug' => false,.
    3. Deploy Configuration: Deploy the updated config/app.php file to the production environment for the OctoberCMS application.
    4. Verify Debug Mode is Disabled: After deployment, verify that debug mode is indeed disabled in the production environment of OctoberCMS. Attempting to trigger errors should not display detailed debug information to users.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Information Disclosure (Medium Severity): Debug mode in OctoberCMS can expose sensitive information like application paths, database queries, and internal errors to users, including potential attackers.
  • Impact: Medium Reduction of risk. Prevents information disclosure and reduces potential attack surface by disabling debug features in production OctoberCMS environments.
  • Currently Implemented: Implemented. Debug mode is disabled in the production environment configuration for OctoberCMS.
  • Missing Implementation: No missing implementation. This is currently enforced in production deployments of OctoberCMS applications.

Mitigation Strategy: Review and Harden .htaccess (or Web Server Configuration)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Review and Harden .htaccess (or Web Server Configuration)
  • Description:
    1. Access .htaccess or Server Configuration: Locate the .htaccess file in the OctoberCMS root directory (for Apache) or access the server block configuration file (for Nginx or other web servers).
    2. Disable Directory Listing: Add or ensure the presence of Options -Indexes to disable directory listing for the OctoberCMS application.
    3. Restrict Access to Sensitive Directories: Use directives to restrict access to sensitive directories like config, vendor, and backend assets (/modules/backend/assets) of OctoberCMS. For example, using Deny from all or Require all denied within <Directory> blocks.
    4. Implement Security Headers: Add directives to set security headers such as:
      • Header set X-Frame-Options "SAMEORIGIN"
      • Header set X-XSS-Protection "1; mode=block"
      • Header set X-Content-Type-Options "nosniff"
      • Header set Content-Security-Policy "default-src 'self'; script-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline'; style-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline'; img-src 'self' data:;" (Adjust CSP as needed for your application)
      • Header set Referrer-Policy "strict-origin-when-cross-origin"
      • Header set Permissions-Policy "geolocation=(), microphone=()" (Adjust Permissions-Policy as needed)
    5. Restrict Backend Access by IP (Optional): If applicable, restrict access to the backend directory (/backend) of OctoberCMS to specific IP address ranges using Allow from and Deny from (for Apache) or allow and deny (for Nginx).
    6. Regular Review: Regularly review and update the .htaccess or server configuration to ensure it aligns with current security best practices and application needs for the OctoberCMS application.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Directory Listing Information Disclosure (Low Severity): Directory listing can expose application structure and potentially sensitive file names of the OctoberCMS application.
    • Unauthorized Access to Sensitive Files/Directories (Medium Severity): Improperly configured web server can allow direct access to sensitive files and directories of the OctoberCMS application.
    • Clickjacking (Medium Severity): Lack of X-Frame-Options header can make the application vulnerable to clickjacking attacks targeting the OctoberCMS frontend or backend.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Browser Exploits (Medium Severity): X-XSS-Protection and Content-Security-Policy headers can mitigate certain types of XSS attacks within the OctoberCMS application.
    • MIME-Sniffing Vulnerabilities (Low Severity): X-Content-Type-Options header prevents MIME-sniffing attacks within the OctoberCMS application.
  • Impact: Medium Reduction of risk. Hardening web server configuration adds layers of defense against various common web attacks and information disclosure for the OctoberCMS application.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. .htaccess includes basic directives to disable directory listing and restrict access to some sensitive directories. Security headers are not fully implemented.
  • Missing Implementation: Full implementation of recommended security headers, more granular access control for sensitive directories of OctoberCMS, and a regular review process for web server configuration related to OctoberCMS.

Mitigation Strategy: Strong Admin Passwords and Account Management

  • Mitigation Strategy: Strong Admin Passwords and Account Management
  • Description:
    1. Enforce Strong Password Policy: Implement a strong password policy for all backend users of OctoberCMS. This should include requirements for password length, complexity (uppercase, lowercase, numbers, symbols), and password expiration. OctoberCMS's backend user settings can be configured to enforce password complexity.
    2. Regular Password Changes: Encourage or enforce regular password changes for backend users of OctoberCMS.
    3. Account Audits: Regularly audit backend user accounts in OctoberCMS. Review the list of users and their roles. Remove or disable accounts that are no longer needed or associated with former employees/personnel.
    4. Principle of Least Privilege: Assign backend user roles in OctoberCMS based on the principle of least privilege. Grant users only the minimum permissions necessary for their job functions. OctoberCMS's backend user roles and permissions system should be utilized effectively.
    5. Monitor Account Activity: Monitor backend user activity logs in OctoberCMS for suspicious login attempts, account modifications, or unusual actions.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Brute-Force Attacks (Medium to High Severity): Weak passwords for OctoberCMS backend accounts are easily cracked through brute-force or dictionary attacks, leading to unauthorized backend access.
    • Credential Stuffing (Medium to High Severity): Reused passwords for OctoberCMS backend accounts can be compromised if user credentials are leaked from other services.
    • Unauthorized Access (High Severity): Compromised admin accounts in OctoberCMS grant attackers full control over the OctoberCMS application.
  • Impact: Medium to High Reduction of risk. Strong passwords and proper account management significantly reduce the likelihood of unauthorized backend access to OctoberCMS due to compromised credentials.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Password complexity requirements are enforced in OctoberCMS. Account audits are performed ad-hoc, but not regularly scheduled. Principle of least privilege is generally followed, but not strictly enforced.
  • Missing Implementation: Regularly scheduled account audits in OctoberCMS, enforced password expiration for OctoberCMS backend accounts, and more rigorous enforcement of the principle of least privilege through role-based access control within OctoberCMS.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Implement Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)
  • Description:
    1. Choose MFA Plugin: Select and install an OctoberCMS plugin that provides Multi-Factor Authentication for the backend. Several MFA plugins are available in the OctoberCMS Marketplace.
    2. Configure MFA Plugin: Configure the chosen MFA plugin for OctoberCMS. This typically involves selecting MFA methods (e.g., Time-Based One-Time Passwords (TOTP), SMS codes, email codes), and configuring settings for user enrollment and enforcement within OctoberCMS.
    3. Enable MFA for Backend Users: Enable MFA for all backend user accounts in OctoberCMS, especially administrator accounts. Encourage or require users to enroll in MFA.
    4. Test MFA Implementation: Thoroughly test the MFA implementation in OctoberCMS to ensure it is working correctly and that users can successfully log in with MFA enabled.
    5. User Training: Provide training to backend users of OctoberCMS on how to use MFA and the importance of securing their MFA devices/methods.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Credential Compromise (High Severity): Even if passwords for OctoberCMS backend accounts are compromised (e.g., through phishing, keylogging, or database breaches), MFA adds an extra layer of security, making it much harder for attackers to gain unauthorized access to the OctoberCMS backend.
    • Brute-Force Attacks (High Severity): MFA significantly increases the difficulty of brute-force attacks against OctoberCMS backend logins, as attackers need to bypass not only the password but also the second factor.
  • Impact: High Reduction of risk. MFA is one of the most effective measures to prevent unauthorized access to the OctoberCMS backend due to compromised credentials.
  • Currently Implemented: Not implemented. MFA is not currently enabled for the OctoberCMS backend.
  • Missing Implementation: Selection, installation, and configuration of an MFA plugin for OctoberCMS, and user enrollment in MFA.

Mitigation Strategy: Restrict Backend Access by IP Address (If Feasible)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Restrict Backend Access by IP Address
  • Description:
    1. Identify Allowed IP Ranges: Determine the IP address ranges from which administrators and authorized backend users will be accessing the OctoberCMS backend.
    2. Configure Web Server or Firewall: Configure the web server (e.g., Apache, Nginx) or a firewall to restrict access to the /backend path (or custom backend URL if changed) of OctoberCMS to only the identified allowed IP address ranges.
      • Apache .htaccess: Use Allow from and Deny from directives within a <Directory /path/to/backend> block.
      • Nginx Server Block: Use allow and deny directives within a location /backend { ... } block.
      • Firewall: Configure firewall rules to block traffic to the web server on the backend path from all IP addresses except the allowed ranges.
    3. Test Access Restrictions: Thoroughly test the IP address restrictions to ensure that access is allowed from the intended IP ranges and blocked from all others for the OctoberCMS backend.
    4. Maintain IP Address List: Regularly review and update the list of allowed IP address ranges as needed for OctoberCMS backend access.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Backend Access from External Networks (Medium to High Severity): Restricting access by IP address limits the potential attack surface by preventing unauthorized access attempts to the OctoberCMS backend from outside the trusted network.
    • Brute-Force Attacks (Medium Severity): Reduces the effectiveness of brute-force attacks originating from outside the allowed IP ranges targeting the OctoberCMS backend.
  • Impact: Medium Reduction of risk. Effective in limiting backend access to OctoberCMS to trusted networks, but less effective if attackers can compromise systems within the allowed IP ranges.
  • Currently Implemented: Not implemented. Backend access to OctoberCMS is not currently restricted by IP address.
  • Missing Implementation: Configuration of web server or firewall rules to restrict backend access to OctoberCMS to specific IP address ranges.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Audit Backend Logs

  • Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Audit Backend Logs
  • Description:
    1. Enable Backend Logging: Ensure that backend activity logging is enabled in OctoberCMS. OctoberCMS logs backend user actions and events.
    2. Centralize Logs (Optional but Recommended): Consider centralizing backend logs from OctoberCMS with other application and system logs in a centralized logging system (e.g., ELK stack, Graylog, Splunk). This facilitates analysis and correlation of events.
    3. Define Audit Log Review Schedule: Establish a regular schedule for reviewing backend logs of OctoberCMS (e.g., daily, weekly).
    4. Identify Key Events to Monitor: Define specific events to monitor in the logs of OctoberCMS backend, such as:
      • Failed login attempts to OctoberCMS backend.
      • Successful logins from unusual locations or at unusual times to OctoberCMS backend.
      • Account creation and modification in OctoberCMS backend.
      • Changes to sensitive settings or configurations in OctoberCMS backend.
      • Plugin/theme installations and removals in OctoberCMS backend.
    5. Automate Log Analysis (Optional): Consider using log analysis tools or Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) systems to automate the analysis of backend logs from OctoberCMS and detect suspicious patterns or anomalies.
    6. Set Up Alerts: Configure alerts for critical security events detected in the logs of OctoberCMS backend (e.g., multiple failed login attempts, unauthorized account modifications).
    7. Incident Response Plan: Have an incident response plan in place to address security incidents identified through log auditing of OctoberCMS backend.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Backend Access (High Severity): Log auditing of OctoberCMS backend logs can detect successful or attempted unauthorized access to the backend.
    • Malicious Activity by Compromised Accounts (High Severity): Logs from OctoberCMS backend can help identify malicious actions performed by compromised backend accounts.
    • Insider Threats (Medium to High Severity): Log auditing of OctoberCMS backend activity can detect suspicious activity by internal users.
  • Impact: Medium Reduction of risk. Log auditing provides visibility into backend activity within OctoberCMS and enables detection of security incidents, but it is reactive rather than preventative.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Backend logs are generated by OctoberCMS, but there is no regular, systematic audit process in place. Logs are reviewed reactively in case of suspected issues.
  • Missing Implementation: Establishment of a regular backend log audit schedule for OctoberCMS, definition of key events to monitor in OctoberCMS backend logs, and potentially implementation of automated log analysis and alerting for OctoberCMS backend logs.

Mitigation Strategy: Consider Custom Backend URL (Security by Obscurity - Secondary Measure)

  • Mitigation Strategy: Consider Custom Backend URL
  • Description:
    1. Modify Backend URL: Change the default backend URL (/backend) of OctoberCMS to a custom, less predictable URL. This can typically be configured in OctoberCMS's configuration files (e.g., config/cms.php or backend settings).
    2. Update Web Server Configuration (If Necessary): If the custom backend URL requires web server configuration changes (e.g., for URL rewriting), update the web server configuration accordingly for OctoberCMS.
    3. Inform Authorized Users: Communicate the new custom backend URL to all authorized backend users of OctoberCMS.
    4. Regularly Review: Periodically review if the custom backend URL is still sufficiently obscure and consider changing it again if necessary (though frequent changes can be disruptive).
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Automated Brute-Force Attacks (Low Severity): Changing the default backend URL of OctoberCMS can deter some automated brute-force attacks that target the common /backend path.
    • Casual Unauthorized Access Attempts (Low Severity): Makes it slightly harder for casual attackers or script kiddies to find the backend login page of OctoberCMS.
  • Impact: Low Reduction of risk. Security by obscurity is not a strong security measure. It should only be considered as a secondary, supplementary measure in conjunction with robust security practices for OctoberCMS. It does not protect against targeted attacks or determined attackers.
  • Currently Implemented: Not implemented. The default /backend URL is currently used for OctoberCMS.
  • Missing Implementation: Configuration change to set a custom, less predictable backend URL for OctoberCMS.

Mitigation Strategy: Validate File Uploads Thoroughly

  • Mitigation Strategy: Validate File Uploads Thoroughly
  • Description:
    1. Server-Side Validation (Mandatory): Implement robust server-side validation for all file uploads within OctoberCMS functionalities (e.g., Media Manager, Forms, Plugins). Do not rely solely on client-side validation, as it can be easily bypassed.
    2. File Type Validation: Validate the file type based on the file extension and MIME type in OctoberCMS file uploads. Use an allowlist of permitted file extensions (e.g., .jpg, .png, .pdf, .doc) rather than a denylist. Verify MIME type against expected types.
    3. File Size Validation: Enforce limits on file sizes in OctoberCMS file uploads to prevent denial-of-service attacks and resource exhaustion.
    4. File Content Validation: For certain file types (e.g., images, documents), perform content validation to ensure the file is not corrupted or malicious in OctoberCMS file uploads. This could involve using libraries to parse and analyze file content.
    5. Filename Sanitization: Sanitize uploaded filenames in OctoberCMS file uploads to remove or replace special characters, spaces, and potentially dangerous characters. Ensure filenames are safe for the operating system and file system.
    6. Error Handling: Implement proper error handling for file upload validation failures in OctoberCMS. Provide informative error messages to users without revealing sensitive information.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Malicious File Upload (High Severity): Uploading malicious files (e.g., web shells, malware) via OctoberCMS upload mechanisms can lead to Remote Code Execution and system compromise.
    • Directory Traversal Attacks (Medium Severity): Improper filename sanitization in OctoberCMS file uploads can allow directory traversal attacks, potentially overwriting or accessing sensitive files.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via File Upload (Medium Severity): Uploading files with malicious content (e.g., SVG images with embedded JavaScript) via OctoberCMS upload mechanisms can lead to XSS vulnerabilities.
    • Denial of Service (DoS) (Medium Severity): Uploading excessively large files via OctoberCMS upload mechanisms can lead to resource exhaustion and DoS.
  • Impact: High Reduction of risk. Thorough file upload validation is crucial to prevent various file-based attacks and ensure the integrity of uploaded data within OctoberCMS.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Basic file type and size validation is implemented in some file upload functionalities within OctoberCMS, but not consistently across all upload points. Filename sanitization is performed in some areas, but not comprehensively.
  • Missing Implementation: Consistent and comprehensive server-side validation for all file uploads across the application within OctoberCMS functionalities, including file type, size, content validation, and robust filename sanitization.

Mitigation Strategy: Sanitize Filenames

  • Mitigation Strategy: Sanitize Filenames
  • Description:
    1. Define Sanitization Rules: Establish clear rules for sanitizing filenames in OctoberCMS. This typically involves:
      • Removing or replacing special characters (e.g., ../, \, :, ;, <, >, &, $, #, *, ?, !, (, ), [, ], {, }, ', ", |).
      • Replacing spaces with underscores or hyphens.
      • Converting filenames to lowercase (or consistently using a case convention).
      • Limiting filename length.
    2. Implement Sanitization Function: Create a reusable function or method in your application code or within OctoberCMS plugins/themes to sanitize filenames according to the defined rules.
    3. Apply Sanitization on Upload: Apply the filename sanitization function to all uploaded filenames in OctoberCMS immediately after they are received by the server, before storing them.
    4. Test Sanitization: Thoroughly test the filename sanitization function with various malicious and edge-case filenames to ensure it effectively removes or replaces dangerous characters and produces safe filenames within the OctoberCMS context.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Directory Traversal Attacks (Medium Severity): Prevents attackers from crafting filenames that can traverse directories and access or overwrite files outside the intended upload directory within OctoberCMS file handling.
    • File System Issues (Low Severity): Sanitization helps prevent issues related to incompatible characters or filenames that could cause problems with the operating system or file system when used within OctoberCMS.
  • Impact: Medium Reduction of risk. Sanitizing filenames is a key step in preventing directory traversal attacks and ensuring file system compatibility within OctoberCMS file operations.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Filename sanitization is performed in some file upload functionalities within OctoberCMS, but not consistently across all upload points.
  • Missing Implementation: Consistent application of filename sanitization across all file upload functionalities in OctoberCMS and a clearly defined and documented filename sanitization policy for OctoberCMS.

Mitigation Strategy: Store Uploaded Files Securely

  • Mitigation Strategy: Store Uploaded Files Securely
  • Description:
    1. Store Outside Webroot (Recommended): Ideally, store uploaded files managed by OctoberCMS outside of the webroot (the publicly accessible directory of the web server). This prevents direct execution of uploaded files as scripts.
    2. If Stored Within Webroot, Prevent Execution: If files managed by OctoberCMS must be stored within the webroot, configure the web server to prevent execution of scripts in the upload directories. This can be achieved using:
      • .htaccess (Apache): Add directives like RemoveHandler .php .phtml .phps, RemoveType .php .phtml .phps, and AddType text/plain .php .phtml .phps within a .htaccess file in the upload directory to prevent PHP execution.
      • Nginx Configuration: Use location blocks in the Nginx configuration to deny execution of PHP and other script files in the upload directory.
    3. Randomize Filenames (Optional but Recommended): Consider randomizing uploaded filenames managed by OctoberCMS (e.g., using UUIDs or hashes) to make it harder for attackers to guess file paths and directly access uploaded files.
    4. Restrict Directory Permissions: Set restrictive directory permissions on the upload directories used by OctoberCMS to limit access to only the web server user and necessary processes.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Remote Code Execution (RCE) via File Upload (High Severity): Preventing script execution in upload directories used by OctoberCMS is crucial to mitigate RCE vulnerabilities arising from malicious file uploads.
    • Direct File Access (Medium Severity): Storing files outside the webroot or randomizing filenames makes it harder for attackers to directly access uploaded files managed by OctoberCMS without proper authorization.
  • Impact: High Reduction of risk. Secure file storage is essential to prevent RCE and unauthorized access to uploaded files within the OctoberCMS context.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Files are stored within the webroot in some areas of OctoberCMS file management, and script execution prevention is not consistently enforced across all upload directories. In other areas, files are stored outside webroot.
  • Missing Implementation: Consistent storage of uploaded files outside the webroot wherever feasible within OctoberCMS file management, and robust enforcement of script execution prevention for all upload directories within the webroot used by OctoberCMS.