Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
50 lines (40 loc) · 7.35 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

50 lines (40 loc) · 7.35 KB

Threat Model Analysis for phpoffice/phpexcel

Threat: XML External Entity (XXE) Injection (XLSX)

  • Threat: XML External Entity (XXE) Injection (XLSX)

    • Description: An attacker uploads a crafted XLSX file (a zipped XML file) containing malicious XML External Entities (XXE). When PhpSpreadsheet's XML parser processes the file, it may attempt to resolve these external entities if not properly configured. This can lead to:
      • Local File Disclosure: Reading arbitrary files from the server's file system.
      • Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF): Making requests to internal or external services from the server, potentially bypassing firewalls.
      • Denial of Service (DoS): Consuming server resources by resolving large or recursive entities (e.g., "billion laughs" attack).
    • Impact: Information disclosure (sensitive files, internal network information), potential SSRF attacks leading to further compromise, denial of service.
    • Affected PhpSpreadsheet Component: Reader\Xlsx, specifically the underlying XML parsing components (likely those using PHP's SimpleXML or XMLReader). The vulnerability lies in how the XML parser is configured and used within PhpSpreadsheet.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Disable External Entity Loading (Crucial): Configure the XML parser used by PhpSpreadsheet to explicitly disable the loading of external entities and DTDs. This is the primary and most effective mitigation. This is typically done before PhpSpreadsheet is used, using PHP's libxml_disable_entity_loader(true); and potentially other libxml options like LIBXML_NOENT, LIBXML_DTDLOAD, and LIBXML_DTDATTR. Ensure this configuration is applied globally to the PHP environment or specifically to the code that uses PhpSpreadsheet.
      • Input Validation (Secondary): While not a primary defense against XXE, validating the structure of the uploaded XLSX file (as much as is feasible without fully parsing it) might help detect some obviously malformed files. However, this is not reliable.
      • Least Privilege: Ensure the application runs with the minimum necessary file system permissions. This limits the damage an attacker can do if they successfully read a file.

Threat: Code Injection (Vulnerability in PhpSpreadsheet or Dependencies)

  • Threat: Code Injection (Vulnerability in PhpSpreadsheet or Dependencies)

    • Description: This is a hypothetical but critical threat. If a vulnerability exists in PhpSpreadsheet's parsing logic (e.g., a buffer overflow, an unvalidated input used in a code execution context within a Reader or Writer), or in a direct dependency like the XML parser, an attacker could craft a malicious spreadsheet file that exploits this vulnerability to execute arbitrary code on the server. This is less likely with a well-maintained library, but it remains a possibility, especially with older, unpatched versions or if a zero-day vulnerability is discovered.
    • Impact: Remote code execution (RCE) on the server, complete system compromise, potential data breaches, and lateral movement within the network.
    • Affected PhpSpreadsheet Component: Potentially any Reader or Writer component, or even core library functions, depending on the specific vulnerability. The vulnerability could also reside in a direct dependency of PhpSpreadsheet, such as the PHP XML extension.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Keep PhpSpreadsheet Updated (Paramount): This is the single most important mitigation. Regularly update to the latest stable version of PhpSpreadsheet to patch any known vulnerabilities. This includes keeping PHP and its extensions (especially the XML extension) up-to-date.
      • Input Validation (Limited Effectiveness): While rigorous input validation is good practice, it's not a reliable defense against all code injection vulnerabilities. It might mitigate some risks, but it cannot be relied upon as the sole defense.
      • Least Privilege: Run the application with the absolute minimum necessary privileges. This significantly limits the damage an attacker can do if they achieve code execution. Use a dedicated, unprivileged user account for the web server and application.
      • Sandboxing (Strong Mitigation): Run the spreadsheet processing component in a sandboxed environment (e.g., a container like Docker, a chroot jail, or a separate process with severely restricted permissions). This isolates the vulnerable component and prevents it from affecting the rest of the system, even if compromised.
      • Web Application Firewall (WAF): A WAF might be able to detect and block some exploit attempts, but it's not a foolproof solution.
      • Security Audits and Penetration Testing: Regularly conduct security audits and penetration tests of the application and its dependencies to identify and address vulnerabilities.

Threat: Resource Exhaustion (DoS) - Highly Complex File within Parsing Logic

  • Threat: Resource Exhaustion (DoS) - Highly Complex File within Parsing Logic

    • Description: While general resource exhaustion from large files is a concern, this specific threat focuses on vulnerabilities within PhpSpreadsheet's parsing logic that could be triggered by a highly complex but not necessarily large file. For example, a file with deeply nested formulas, unusual object structures, or specific combinations of features could trigger excessive recursion or inefficient processing within PhpSpreadsheet, leading to a denial-of-service. This is distinct from simply uploading a huge file.
    • Impact: Denial of service, application unavailability.
    • Affected PhpSpreadsheet Component: All Reader components (Reader\Xlsx, Reader\Xls, Reader\Csv, Reader\Ods, etc.). The specific component and vulnerability would depend on the crafted file.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Keep PhpSpreadsheet Updated: As with code injection, staying up-to-date is crucial to patch any vulnerabilities in parsing logic.
      • Timeouts (Specific to Parsing): Set timeouts specifically for the PhpSpreadsheet reading operations, independent of any general application timeouts. This prevents a complex file from consuming resources indefinitely.
      • Resource Monitoring: Monitor server resource usage (CPU, memory) during spreadsheet processing and implement alerts for excessive consumption specifically related to PhpSpreadsheet.
      • Input Validation (Structure-Aware): If possible, implement some level of structure-aware input validation. This is difficult to do comprehensively, but even basic checks for excessive nesting or unusual patterns could help. This is not a primary defense.
      • Sandboxing: As with code injection, sandboxing the processing can limit the impact of a DoS vulnerability.
      • Rate Limiting (Targeted): Implement rate limiting specifically for spreadsheet processing, potentially with stricter limits than general file uploads.