Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
136 lines (111 loc) · 17.9 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

136 lines (111 loc) · 17.9 KB

Deep Analysis of Symfonycasts Reset Password Bundle Security

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

Objective: To conduct a thorough security analysis of the Symfonycasts Reset Password Bundle, focusing on identifying potential vulnerabilities, assessing their impact, and recommending mitigation strategies. The analysis will cover key components, data flows, and interactions with the broader Symfony application ecosystem. The primary goal is to ensure the bundle's secure implementation and minimize the risk of account takeover or data breaches related to the password reset process.

Scope: This analysis covers the following aspects of the symfonycasts/reset-password-bundle:

  • Token Generation and Management: How tokens are created, stored, validated, and invalidated.
  • Data Storage: How sensitive data (tokens, user identifiers) are stored and protected in the database.
  • Email Communication: Security of the email sending process and the content of the reset email.
  • User Interaction: The security of the user-facing forms and workflows.
  • Integration with Symfony: How the bundle interacts with Symfony's security components and best practices.
  • Configuration Options: The security implications of different configuration settings.
  • Error Handling: How errors and exceptions are handled, and whether they could leak sensitive information.
  • Throttling and Rate Limiting: Mechanisms to prevent brute-force and denial-of-service attacks.
  • Dependencies: Security of any third-party libraries used by the bundle.

Methodology:

  1. Code Review: Examine the bundle's source code (available on GitHub) to understand its internal workings and identify potential vulnerabilities. This includes analyzing the ResetPasswordTokenGenerator, ResetPasswordHelper, repository classes, and controller logic.
  2. Documentation Review: Analyze the official documentation to understand the intended usage, configuration options, and security recommendations.
  3. Architecture Inference: Based on the code and documentation, infer the overall architecture, data flow, and component interactions (as presented in the provided C4 diagrams).
  4. Threat Modeling: Identify potential threats and attack vectors based on the identified architecture and functionality.
  5. Vulnerability Analysis: Assess the likelihood and impact of identified threats, considering existing security controls.
  6. Mitigation Recommendations: Propose specific, actionable mitigation strategies to address identified vulnerabilities and improve the overall security posture.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

This section breaks down the security implications of the key components, referencing the C4 diagrams and the security design review.

  • ResetPasswordTokenGenerator (Service):

    • Security Implication: The core of the security relies on the strength of the generated tokens. Weak or predictable tokens can lead to account takeover.
    • Existing Controls: The design review states "Generation of cryptographically secure random tokens." This implies the use of a strong random number generator (RNG).
    • Code Review (Inferred): The bundle should be using Symfony's TokenGenerator or a similar cryptographically secure RNG. We need to verify this in the code. It's crucial that the token is long enough and has sufficient entropy.
    • Mitigation: Ensure the code uses random_bytes() or Symfony's TokenGeneratorInterface (which likely uses random_bytes() internally). Avoid using weaker alternatives like mt_rand() or custom implementations. The token length should be at least 32 bytes (256 bits) to provide adequate security against brute-force attacks.

  • ResetPasswordHelper (Service):

    • Security Implication: Manages the entire reset password process, including token generation, storage, validation, and user interaction. Vulnerabilities here could compromise the entire flow.
    • Existing Controls: Time-limited tokens, token hashing, throttling.
    • Code Review (Inferred): This service likely interacts with the repository to store and retrieve token data. It also handles token validation against the stored hash and expiration time. We need to examine how these checks are implemented.
    • Mitigation: Ensure strict validation of the token before allowing any password change. Verify that the token matches the stored hash, belongs to the requesting user, and is not expired. Use constant-time comparison functions (like hash_equals()) to prevent timing attacks during hash comparison. Ensure proper exception handling to avoid leaking information about token validity.

  • ResetPasswordRequestRepository (Repository):

    • Security Implication: Responsible for database interactions related to reset password requests. SQL injection vulnerabilities here could expose sensitive data.
    • Existing Controls: The design review mentions "Storage of token hashes rather than plain text tokens."
    • Code Review (Inferred): This repository likely uses Doctrine ORM or a similar database abstraction layer. We need to verify that parameterized queries or prepared statements are used consistently to prevent SQL injection.
    • Mitigation: Ensure that all database queries involving user input (even indirectly, like user IDs) use parameterized queries or prepared statements. Avoid any string concatenation or interpolation that could introduce SQL injection vulnerabilities. Leverage Doctrine's built-in protection mechanisms.

  • ResetPasswordRequestEntity (Entity):

    • Security Implication: Represents the data structure for a reset password request. Data validation issues here could lead to inconsistencies or vulnerabilities.
    • Existing Controls: Data validation (mentioned in the design review).
    • Code Review (Inferred): This entity likely defines properties for the user ID, token hash, expiration timestamp, and potentially other metadata. We need to check for appropriate data types and validation constraints.
    • Mitigation: Use appropriate data types (e.g., datetime for expiration, string for the hashed token). Implement validation constraints (e.g., NotBlank, Type, Length) to ensure data integrity. Consider using a dedicated value object for the token hash to encapsulate its handling.

  • Controller:

    • Security Implication: Handles user input and interacts with the service layer. Vulnerabilities like Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) or Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) could be present.
    • Existing Controls: Input validation, CSRF protection (mentioned in the design review).
    • Code Review (Inferred): The controller likely uses Symfony's form component to handle user input. We need to verify that CSRF protection is enabled and that output is properly escaped to prevent XSS.
    • Mitigation: Ensure CSRF protection is enabled for all forms related to password reset. Use Symfony's built-in CSRF protection mechanisms. Use Twig's auto-escaping feature or explicitly escape any user-provided data rendered in templates to prevent XSS. Validate all user input on the server-side, even if client-side validation is also performed.

  • Mailer Interface (Mailer):

    • Security Implication: Responsible for sending the reset password email. Vulnerabilities here could lead to email spoofing or interception.
    • Existing Controls: Uses secure email protocols (mentioned in the design review).
    • Code Review (Inferred): The bundle likely uses Symfony's Mailer component. We need to verify that it's configured to use secure transport (TLS/SSL).
    • Mitigation: Configure the Mailer component to use TLS/SSL for all outgoing emails. Use a reputable email service provider (as mentioned in the deployment diagram) that supports secure email protocols and sender authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC). Avoid including the actual reset token directly in the email body; instead, include a link containing the token as a query parameter. This prevents the token from being exposed in email logs or if the email is intercepted in transit.

  • Database:

    • Security Implication: Stores user data and reset password tokens. Database breaches could expose sensitive information.
    • Existing Controls: Access controls, encryption at rest, regular backups (mentioned in the design review).
    • Mitigation: Implement strong access controls to limit database access to only authorized users and applications. Enable encryption at rest to protect data stored on disk. Regularly back up the database and store backups securely. Use a robust database system (e.g., PostgreSQL, MySQL) with a strong security track record. Monitor database logs for suspicious activity.

  • Email Server:

    • Security Implication: Handles the delivery of reset password emails. Compromised email servers could be used to send phishing emails or intercept legitimate reset emails.
    • Existing Controls: Secure email protocols, spam filtering, sender authentication (mentioned in the design review).
    • Mitigation: Use a reputable email service provider with strong security measures. Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to prevent email spoofing and improve deliverability. Monitor email logs for suspicious activity.

3. Architecture, Components, and Data Flow (Inferred)

The C4 diagrams provide a good overview of the architecture. The data flow for a password reset request can be summarized as follows:

  1. User Request: The user initiates a password reset request through a form in the Symfony application.
  2. Controller Handling: The controller receives the request, validates the user's email address, and interacts with the ResetPasswordHelper.
  3. Token Generation: The ResetPasswordHelper uses the ResetPasswordTokenGenerator to create a cryptographically secure random token.
  4. Token Storage: The ResetPasswordHelper uses the ResetPasswordRequestRepository to store the token hash, user ID, and expiration timestamp in the database (associated with a ResetPasswordRequestEntity).
  5. Email Sending: The ResetPasswordHelper uses the MailerInterface to send an email to the user containing a link with the reset token.
  6. User Clicks Link: The user clicks the link in the email, which directs them back to the Symfony application.
  7. Token Validation: The controller receives the request, extracts the token from the URL, and passes it to the ResetPasswordHelper.
  8. Token Verification: The ResetPasswordHelper uses the ResetPasswordRequestRepository to retrieve the token data from the database. It verifies that the token matches the stored hash, belongs to the correct user, and is not expired.
  9. Password Update: If the token is valid, the user is presented with a form to enter a new password. The controller validates the new password and updates the user's password in the database (likely using Symfony's security component).
  10. Token Invalidation: After a successful password reset, the token should be invalidated (e.g., by deleting the corresponding record in the database or marking it as used).

4. Specific Security Considerations

  • Token Uniqueness: The bundle must guarantee that generated tokens are unique. Collisions (two users receiving the same token) would allow one user to reset another user's password. This is typically handled by using a sufficiently large random number space and checking for existing tokens in the database before storing a new one.
  • Token Expiration: Tokens must have a limited lifetime. The design review mentions this, but the specific expiration time should be configurable and reasonably short (e.g., 1 hour). Longer expiration times increase the window of opportunity for attackers.
  • Token Invalidation After Use: Tokens must be invalidated after a single successful use. This prevents replay attacks where an attacker could reuse a previously used token.
  • Throttling and Rate Limiting: The bundle must implement throttling to prevent brute-force attacks on the password reset functionality. This includes limiting the number of reset requests per user, per IP address, and globally. The design review mentions throttling, but the specific implementation and configuration options need to be reviewed.
  • Account Enumeration Prevention: The application should not reveal whether an email address exists in the system during the password reset process. A consistent message (e.g., "If an account with that email address exists, instructions to reset your password have been sent.") should be displayed regardless of whether the email is found. This prevents attackers from using the password reset functionality to enumerate valid email addresses.
  • Password Complexity: The application must enforce strong password complexity requirements during the new password setting phase. This is mentioned as a recommended control in the design review. The bundle itself might not handle this directly, but it's a crucial part of the overall password reset security.
  • Session Management: After a successful password reset, the user's existing sessions should be invalidated. This prevents an attacker who might have gained access to an old session from maintaining access after the password has been changed. This is likely handled by Symfony's security component, but it's important to verify.
  • Logging and Auditing: The application should log all password reset attempts, including successful and failed attempts. This allows for monitoring and detection of suspicious activity.

5. Actionable Mitigation Strategies

Based on the analysis, here are specific, actionable mitigation strategies:

  1. Verify Token Generation: Inspect the ResetPasswordTokenGenerator code to confirm it uses random_bytes() or Symfony's TokenGeneratorInterface. Ensure the token length is at least 32 bytes.
  2. Strengthen Token Validation: Review the ResetPasswordHelper's token validation logic. Ensure it checks for:
    • Hash Match: Use hash_equals() for constant-time comparison.
    • User Association: Verify the token belongs to the requesting user.
    • Expiration: Check the expiration timestamp against the current time.
    • One-Time Use: Implement a mechanism to invalidate the token after a single use (e.g., delete the database record or set a "used" flag).
  3. Prevent SQL Injection: Examine all database interactions in the ResetPasswordRequestRepository. Confirm that parameterized queries or prepared statements are used consistently.
  4. Enforce Data Integrity: Review the ResetPasswordRequestEntity and ensure appropriate data types and validation constraints are defined.
  5. Secure Controller Logic: Verify that the controller:
    • Enables CSRF protection for all relevant forms.
    • Uses Twig's auto-escaping or explicitly escapes user input in templates.
    • Performs server-side input validation.
  6. Secure Email Configuration: Configure Symfony's Mailer component to use TLS/SSL. Use a reputable email service provider that supports SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. Do not include the raw token in the email body; use a link with the token as a query parameter.
  7. Implement Robust Throttling: Review the bundle's throttling configuration options. Set appropriate limits for reset requests per user, per IP address, and globally. Consider using a dedicated rate-limiting service if necessary.
  8. Prevent Account Enumeration: Ensure the application displays a consistent message regardless of whether an email address exists in the system.
  9. Enforce Password Complexity: Implement strong password complexity requirements (e.g., minimum length, mixed-case letters, numbers, symbols) using Symfony's validation constraints or a custom validator.
  10. Invalidate Sessions: After a successful password reset, invalidate all existing user sessions.
  11. Implement Logging: Log all password reset attempts (successes and failures) with relevant details (timestamp, user ID, IP address, etc.).
  12. Regular Security Audits: Conduct regular security audits of the codebase and dependencies. Use SAST tools (like Symfony Insight, as mentioned in the build process) and consider dynamic analysis (DAST) as well.
  13. Dependency Management: Keep all dependencies (including the bundle itself and Symfony) up to date to patch security vulnerabilities. Use a dependency management tool (like Composer) and regularly check for updates.
  14. Secrets Management: Securely store sensitive configuration values (e.g., database credentials, API keys) using environment variables or a dedicated secrets management solution (like Kubernetes Secrets, HashiCorp Vault, or AWS Secrets Manager). Do not store secrets directly in the codebase.
  15. Kubernetes Security: If deploying to Kubernetes (as per the deployment diagram), implement appropriate security measures:
    • Network Policies: Restrict network traffic between pods.
    • RBAC: Use Role-Based Access Control to limit access to Kubernetes resources.
    • Pod Security Policies: Define security requirements for pods (e.g., prevent running as root).
    • Image Security Scanning: Scan container images for vulnerabilities before deployment.
    • Ingress Controller Security: Configure the ingress controller to use TLS termination and a web application firewall (WAF).

This deep analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the security considerations for the Symfonycasts Reset Password Bundle. By implementing the recommended mitigation strategies, the development team can significantly reduce the risk of security vulnerabilities and ensure a secure password reset process for users. Remember to prioritize regular security reviews and updates to maintain a strong security posture.