Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
98 lines (85 loc) · 8.03 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

98 lines (85 loc) · 8.03 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for z-song/laravel-admin

Objective: Gain unauthorized administrative access to the Laravel application, leading to data exfiltration, data modification, or denial of service.

Attack Tree Visualization

                                  Gain Unauthorized Administrative Access
                                                (Root Node)
                                                    |
                                    -------------------------------------------------
                                    |                                               |
                Exploit Vulnerabilities      Abuse Misconfigurations/Weak Defaults
                in laravel-admin                                  |
                                    |               ---------------------------------
                --------------------                |               |               |
                |                               4. Weak Default    5.  Overly Permissive  6.  Exposed
        3.  Outdated                           Credentials/      RBAC Configuration     Debug/
        Dependencies                           Configuration                                 Dev Features
                |                                   |                       |                       |
    ------------|--------                   ----|----           ----|----------------   ----|----
    |                                       |        |           |                       |

3a. Known CVEs in Used 4a. Default 4b. Easily 5a. All 6a. .env Packages [!] Admin Guessable Permissions Exposure [!] Password [!] Password Granted to "Guest" [!]

Attack Tree Path: 3. Outdated Dependencies

  • 3a. Known CVEs in Used Packages [!]
    • Description: laravel-admin and its extensions rely on third-party packages managed by Composer. If these packages are not updated regularly, they may contain known vulnerabilities (CVEs) that attackers can exploit. This is a critical vulnerability because exploit information is often publicly available, making the attack relatively easy to execute.
    • Likelihood: Medium to High (Depends on update frequency and the number of dependencies)
    • Impact: Low to Very High (Depends on the specific CVE; could range from minor information disclosure to complete system compromise)
    • Effort: Low (Automated scanners can identify vulnerable packages; exploit code may be readily available)
    • Skill Level: Low to Medium (Exploiting a known CVE might require some skill, but information is often publicly available)
    • Detection Difficulty: Low (Vulnerability scanners can easily detect outdated packages)
    • Mitigation:
      • Regularly run composer update and composer audit.
      • Use a dependency vulnerability scanner (e.g., Snyk, Dependabot) to automatically detect and report outdated packages.
      • Prioritize updating packages with known security vulnerabilities.
      • Establish a patch management policy and schedule.

Attack Tree Path: 4. Weak Default Credentials/Configuration

  • 4a. Default Admin Password [!]

    • Description: If the default laravel-admin administrator password is not changed upon installation, an attacker can easily gain full administrative access. This is a critical vulnerability due to its simplicity and high impact.
    • Likelihood: Low (Most administrators will change this, but it's still a risk if overlooked)
    • Impact: Very High (Complete system compromise)
    • Effort: Very Low (Trivial to attempt)
    • Skill Level: Very Low (No technical skill required)
    • Detection Difficulty: Low (Failed login attempts might be logged, but successful logins would appear legitimate)
    • Mitigation:
      • Immediately change the default administrator password after installation.
      • Enforce strong password policies.
      • Document the password change procedure.

  • 4b. Easily Guessable Admin Password

    • Description: Even if the default password is changed, a weak or easily guessable password makes the system vulnerable to brute-force or dictionary attacks.
    • Likelihood: Medium
    • Impact: Very High (Complete system compromise)
    • Effort: Low to Medium (Depends on the password strength and any rate-limiting in place)
    • Skill Level: Very Low to Low
    • Detection Difficulty: Low to Medium (Failed login attempts might be logged; rate limiting can help detect brute-force attempts)
    • Mitigation:
      • Enforce strong password policies (length, complexity, character types).
      • Consider using multi-factor authentication (MFA) for administrator accounts.
      • Implement account lockout policies after a certain number of failed login attempts.
      • Monitor for unusual login activity.

Attack Tree Path: 5. Overly Permissive RBAC Configuration

  • 5a. All Permissions Granted to "Guest" [!]
    • Description: laravel-admin uses a role-based access control (RBAC) system. If the "Guest" role (or any other low-privilege role intended for unauthenticated or minimally privileged users) is accidentally granted excessive permissions, an attacker can gain unauthorized access without even needing valid credentials. This is a critical configuration error.
    • Likelihood: Low (This would be a significant and obvious configuration error)
    • Impact: Very High (Could grant extensive access to the application and data)
    • Effort: Very Low (Trivial to exploit if present)
    • Skill Level: Very Low (No technical skill required)
    • Detection Difficulty: Low (Unusual access patterns might be detected, but the attacker wouldn't need to perform any suspicious actions to gain access)
    • Mitigation:
      • Carefully review the permissions assigned to each role, especially the "Guest" role and any other low-privilege roles.
      • Follow the principle of least privilege: grant only the minimum necessary permissions to each role.
      • Regularly audit role configurations.
      • Test the application from the perspective of an unauthenticated user to ensure no unintended access is possible.

Attack Tree Path: 6. Exposed Debug/Dev Features

  • 6a. .env Exposure [!]
    • Description: The .env file contains sensitive configuration information, including database credentials, API keys, and application secrets. If this file is accidentally exposed to the web (e.g., due to misconfigured web server settings), an attacker can gain access to the database and other critical resources. This is a critical vulnerability.
    • Likelihood: Low (Requires a misconfiguration of the web server or application)
    • Impact: Very High (Exposure of database credentials and other secrets leads to complete system compromise)
    • Effort: Very Low (Trivial to access if exposed – simply requesting the file in a browser)
    • Skill Level: Very Low (No technical skill required)
    • Detection Difficulty: Low (Web server logs might show access to the .env file; security scanners can detect this vulnerability)
    • Mitigation:
      • Ensure that the .env file is never accessible from the webroot.
      • Configure your web server (Apache, Nginx) to explicitly deny access to .env files (and any other sensitive files).
      • Store sensitive configuration information securely (e.g., using environment variables or a secrets management system).
      • Regularly check your web server configuration for errors.