Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
265 lines (218 loc) · 26.1 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

265 lines (218 loc) · 26.1 KB

Deep Security Analysis of Django

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

Objective:

The objective of this deep analysis is to conduct a thorough security assessment of the key components of the Django web framework. This includes identifying potential vulnerabilities, weaknesses, and attack vectors within the framework itself, and providing actionable mitigation strategies to enhance the security posture of applications built using Django. The analysis focuses on how Django's own code and design choices impact security, not on general web application security best practices.

Scope:

This analysis covers the following key components of Django, as identified in the security design review:

  • ORM (Object-Relational Mapper): Focus on SQL injection prevention mechanisms.
  • Templating Engine: Focus on Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) prevention.
  • Middleware: Analysis of CSRF protection, Clickjacking protection, and Security Middleware.
  • Authentication System (django.contrib.auth): Password hashing, session management, and user authentication flows.
  • Forms Handling: Input validation and sanitization.
  • File Upload Handling: Security of file uploads.
  • HTTP Handling: Host header validation and other HTTP-level security measures.
  • Settings: Security-relevant settings (e.g., SECRET_KEY, ALLOWED_HOSTS).

Methodology:

  1. Code Review: Analyze the Django source code (from the provided GitHub repository) to understand the implementation details of the security controls.
  2. Documentation Review: Examine the official Django documentation to understand the intended behavior and security guarantees of each component.
  3. Threat Modeling: Identify potential threats and attack vectors based on the architecture, components, and data flow inferred from the code and documentation. This will use the STRIDE model (Spoofing, Tampering, Repudiation, Information Disclosure, Denial of Service, Elevation of Privilege).
  4. Vulnerability Analysis: Identify potential vulnerabilities based on the threat model and code review.
  5. Mitigation Strategies: Propose specific and actionable mitigation strategies tailored to Django to address the identified vulnerabilities.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

This section breaks down the security implications of each key component, referencing specific parts of the Django codebase where possible.

2.1 ORM (Object-Relational Mapper)

  • Security Feature: SQL Injection Protection.
  • Implementation: Django's ORM uses parameterized queries. When you use the ORM (e.g., MyModel.objects.filter(name=user_input)), Django constructs the SQL query by separating the SQL code from the user-provided data. The data is passed as parameters to the database driver, which handles escaping appropriately. This is primarily handled within django.db.models.sql and related modules.
  • Threats:
    • SQL Injection (Tampering): If developers bypass the ORM and use raw SQL queries (e.g., cursor.execute("SELECT * FROM myapp_mymodel WHERE name = '" + user_input + "'")), they become responsible for escaping, and are highly vulnerable to SQL injection. Even seemingly safe raw SQL can be vulnerable if string formatting is used improperly.
    • Data Leakage (Information Disclosure): Errors in complex ORM queries, especially those involving joins or subqueries, could theoretically lead to unintended data exposure, although this is less likely than direct SQL injection.
  • Vulnerabilities:
    • Incorrect use of extra(): The extra() method on querysets allows for injecting extra SQL. While it can be used safely with parameterized queries, it's a common source of developer-introduced SQL injection.
    • Incorrect use of raw(): The raw() method executes a raw SQL query and returns model instances. It requires manual escaping of parameters, making it a high-risk area.
    • Database-Specific Vulnerabilities: While rare, vulnerabilities in the underlying database driver (e.g., psycopg2 for PostgreSQL) could potentially bypass Django's protections.
    • Using .annotate() or .aggregate() with unsafe string concatenation can lead to SQL injection.

2.2 Templating Engine

  • Security Feature: Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) Protection.
  • Implementation: Django's templating engine automatically escapes variables rendered in templates by default. This means that characters like <, >, &, ", and ' are converted to their HTML entity equivalents (e.g., &lt;, &gt;). This is handled in django.template.
  • Threats:
    • XSS (Tampering): If auto-escaping is disabled or bypassed, malicious JavaScript code injected by an attacker can be executed in the context of the victim's browser.
  • Vulnerabilities:
    • mark_safe(): The mark_safe() function (from django.utils.safestring) explicitly marks a string as "safe" and prevents auto-escaping. If used incorrectly with user-supplied data, it creates an XSS vulnerability.
    • safe template filter: Similar to mark_safe(), the safe filter disables auto-escaping for a specific variable within a template.
    • autoescape off block: This template tag disables auto-escaping for an entire block of code within a template.
    • Custom Template Tags and Filters: If custom template tags or filters are written without proper escaping, they can introduce XSS vulnerabilities.
    • JavaScript Contexts: Even with auto-escaping, placing user input directly within a <script> tag or an HTML event handler (e.g., onclick) can be dangerous. Django's escaping is designed for HTML contexts, not JavaScript contexts. JSON serialization is often needed here.
    • Template Injection: If the template itself is constructed from user input, this can lead to a much more severe form of injection, allowing arbitrary code execution on the server.

2.3 Middleware

  • Security Features:
    • CSRF Protection: CsrfViewMiddleware adds a hidden field with a CSRF token to forms and validates the token on submission.
    • Clickjacking Protection: XFrameOptionsMiddleware sets the X-Frame-Options header to prevent the page from being embedded in an iframe.
    • Security Middleware: SecurityMiddleware provides several security-related features, including:
      • SECURE_HSTS_SECONDS: Sets the Strict-Transport-Security header (HSTS) to enforce HTTPS.
      • SECURE_SSL_REDIRECT: Redirects HTTP requests to HTTPS.
      • SECURE_CONTENT_TYPE_NOSNIFF: Sets the X-Content-Type-Options: nosniff header to prevent MIME-sniffing attacks.
      • SECURE_REFERRER_POLICY: Controls the Referer header.
  • Threats:
    • CSRF (Spoofing): If CSRF protection is disabled or misconfigured, an attacker can trick a user into performing actions they did not intend.
    • Clickjacking (Tampering): If clickjacking protection is disabled, an attacker can overlay a transparent iframe on top of the legitimate page and trick the user into clicking on something malicious.
    • Various (depending on SecurityMiddleware settings): Misconfiguration of SecurityMiddleware can weaken various security protections.
  • Vulnerabilities:
    • Disabled Middleware: If any of the security-related middleware components are removed from the MIDDLEWARE setting, the corresponding protections are disabled.
    • Incorrect CSRF Token Handling: If the CSRF token is not properly validated (e.g., due to custom view logic that bypasses the middleware), CSRF attacks are possible. This is especially relevant for AJAX requests.
    • Subdomain CSRF: If the CSRF_COOKIE_DOMAIN setting is too broad (e.g., set to .example.com), a vulnerable subdomain could be used to steal CSRF tokens for other subdomains.
    • Missing Vary: Cookie header: In some caching scenarios, the absence of this header can lead to CSRF token leakage.
    • Weak X-Frame-Options Configuration: Using ALLOW-FROM is generally discouraged due to limited browser support and potential security risks. DENY or SAMEORIGIN are preferred.

2.4 Authentication System (django.contrib.auth)

  • Security Features:
    • Password Hashing: Uses PBKDF2 by default, with configurable settings for iterations and salt. Supports other hashing algorithms like Argon2.
    • Session Management: Provides secure session management, including options for HTTPS-only cookies, secure session storage, and session expiration.
    • User Authentication Flows: Provides views and forms for login, logout, password reset, and password change.
  • Threats:
    • Brute-Force Attacks (Spoofing): Attackers can try to guess user passwords by repeatedly submitting login attempts.
    • Session Hijacking (Spoofing): Attackers can steal a user's session ID and impersonate them.
    • Password Reset Poisoning (Spoofing): Attackers can manipulate the password reset process to gain access to user accounts.
  • Vulnerabilities:
    • Weak Password Hashing Configuration: If the PASSWORD_HASHERS setting is misconfigured to use a weak hashing algorithm or a low number of iterations, passwords are more vulnerable to cracking.
    • Insecure Session Storage: If sessions are stored in an insecure location (e.g., a database without encryption), they can be compromised.
    • Session Fixation: If Django is not configured to regenerate the session ID after login, an attacker can fixate a session ID and then hijack the session after the user logs in.
    • Missing or Weak Account Lockout: Without account lockout mechanisms, brute-force attacks are easier.
    • Vulnerable Password Reset Implementation: If the password reset process is not implemented securely (e.g., using predictable tokens, not validating email addresses properly), it can be exploited.
    • Username Enumeration: Default error messages on login or password reset forms can reveal whether a username exists, aiding attackers in targeted attacks.

2.5 Forms Handling

  • Security Feature: Input validation and sanitization.
  • Implementation: Django's forms framework (django.forms) provides built-in validation for various field types (e.g., EmailField, CharField, IntegerField). It also allows for custom validation logic.
  • Threats:
    • Various (depending on the type of input): Invalid or malicious input can lead to various vulnerabilities, including XSS, SQL injection (if the input is used in raw SQL queries), and denial-of-service attacks.
  • Vulnerabilities:
    • Missing or Incomplete Validation: If forms are not properly validated, or if custom validation logic is flawed, malicious input can be processed.
    • Overly Permissive Validation: Using overly permissive validation rules (e.g., allowing any characters in a text field) can increase the risk of vulnerabilities.
    • Client-Side Validation Bypass: Relying solely on client-side validation is insufficient, as attackers can easily bypass it. Server-side validation is essential.
    • Regular Expression Denial of Service (ReDoS): Poorly crafted regular expressions used in form validation can be vulnerable to ReDoS attacks, where a specially crafted input causes the regular expression engine to consume excessive CPU resources.

2.6 File Upload Handling

  • Security Feature: Validation of file types and sizes.
  • Implementation: Django provides mechanisms for handling file uploads, including FileField and ImageField in forms, and settings like MEDIA_ROOT and MEDIA_URL.
  • Threats:
    • Malicious File Upload (Tampering): Attackers can upload malicious files (e.g., web shells, malware) that can be executed on the server or downloaded by other users.
    • Directory Traversal (Tampering): Attackers can manipulate file names to write files to arbitrary locations on the server.
  • Vulnerabilities:
    • Missing or Incomplete File Type Validation: If file types are not properly validated, attackers can upload executable files. Relying solely on the file extension is insufficient; the file content should be checked.
    • Missing or Incomplete File Size Validation: Large file uploads can lead to denial-of-service attacks.
    • Insecure File Storage: Storing uploaded files in a publicly accessible directory without proper access controls can expose them to unauthorized access.
    • Directory Traversal Vulnerabilities: If file names are not properly sanitized, attackers can use ../ sequences to write files outside the intended directory.
    • Unvalidated Redirects/Forwards after upload: If, after a file upload, the application redirects based on user-supplied data (e.g., a filename), this could lead to an open redirect vulnerability.

2.7 HTTP Handling

  • Security Feature: Host header validation.
  • Implementation: Django validates the Host header against the ALLOWED_HOSTS setting.
  • Threats:
    • HTTP Host Header Attacks (Spoofing): Attackers can manipulate the Host header to access the application using an unexpected hostname, potentially bypassing security controls or exploiting vulnerabilities in virtual hosting configurations.
  • Vulnerabilities:
    • Misconfigured ALLOWED_HOSTS: If ALLOWED_HOSTS is set to ['*'] or includes overly broad patterns, it allows requests with any Host header, making the application vulnerable to host header attacks.
    • Bypassing ALLOWED_HOSTS with X-Forwarded-Host: If Django is behind a proxy server that sets the X-Forwarded-Host header, and Django is not configured to use this header for validation (using USE_X_FORWARDED_HOST = True), attackers might be able to bypass ALLOWED_HOSTS.

2.8 Settings

  • Security Feature: Various security-related settings.
  • Implementation: Django's settings file (settings.py) contains numerous settings that affect the security of the application.
  • Threats:
    • Various (depending on the setting): Misconfigured settings can weaken various security protections.
  • Vulnerabilities:
    • SECRET_KEY Compromise: If the SECRET_KEY is compromised (e.g., leaked in source code, stored insecurely), attackers can forge session cookies, CSRF tokens, and other cryptographic signatures.
    • DEBUG = True in Production: Leaving DEBUG enabled in a production environment exposes sensitive information, including source code, database queries, and internal IP addresses.
    • Insecure DATABASES Configuration: Using weak database passwords, storing credentials in plain text, or exposing the database to the public internet can lead to database compromise.
    • Misconfigured Email Settings: Using an insecure email backend or exposing email credentials can lead to email spoofing or spam.

3. Actionable Mitigation Strategies

This section provides specific, actionable mitigation strategies for the vulnerabilities identified above. These are tailored to Django and go beyond general security recommendations.

3.1 ORM Mitigations

  • Avoid Raw SQL: Strive to use the ORM for all database interactions. If raw SQL is absolutely necessary, use cursor.execute() with parameterized queries exclusively. Never use string formatting or concatenation with user input.
  • Review extra() and raw() Usage: Carefully review all instances of extra() and raw() in the codebase. Ensure that they are used with parameterized queries and that user input is properly escaped. Consider replacing them with ORM equivalents whenever possible.
  • Database Driver Updates: Keep the database driver (e.g., psycopg2) up-to-date to address any potential vulnerabilities in the driver itself.
  • Least Privilege: Ensure the database user Django connects with has only the necessary privileges. Avoid using superuser accounts.
  • Input Validation Before ORM: Even though the ORM handles SQL injection, validate data before it reaches the ORM. This adds a layer of defense and can prevent other issues.
  • Safe Annotate/Aggregate: When using .annotate() or .aggregate(), ensure that any string manipulation is done safely, preferably using database functions designed for this purpose (e.g., Concat in Django) rather than Python string concatenation.

3.2 Templating Engine Mitigations

  • Minimize mark_safe() and safe: Avoid using mark_safe() and the safe filter whenever possible. If they are necessary, ensure that the input is absolutely trusted and has been thoroughly sanitized.
  • Review Custom Template Tags and Filters: Carefully review all custom template tags and filters to ensure that they properly escape output.
  • Use json_script Filter: For embedding data in JavaScript contexts, use Django's json_script template filter (available in Django 3.0+). This correctly serializes Python data to JSON and escapes it for safe inclusion in a <script> tag. For older Django versions, use json.dumps() and manually escape the output for HTML.
  • Content Security Policy (CSP): Implement a strong CSP to mitigate the impact of any XSS vulnerabilities that might slip through. This is a crucial defense-in-depth measure.
  • Avoid Template Construction from User Input: Never construct templates directly from user input. Use pre-defined templates and pass data to them as variables.
  • Context-Aware Escaping: Understand the different escaping requirements for different contexts (HTML, JavaScript, CSS, URL). Django's auto-escaping handles HTML contexts; other contexts require specific handling.

3.3 Middleware Mitigations

  • Enable All Security Middleware: Ensure that all relevant security middleware components are enabled in the MIDDLEWARE setting.
  • Configure CSRF Protection:
    • Use {% csrf_token %} in all forms.
    • For AJAX requests, retrieve the CSRF token from the cookie and include it in the X-CSRFToken header.
    • Set CSRF_COOKIE_SECURE = True in production to ensure that the CSRF token is only transmitted over HTTPS.
    • Set CSRF_COOKIE_HTTPONLY = True to prevent JavaScript from accessing the CSRF token.
    • Carefully configure CSRF_COOKIE_DOMAIN to avoid subdomain vulnerabilities.
  • Configure Clickjacking Protection: Set X_FRAME_OPTIONS = 'DENY' or X_FRAME_OPTIONS = 'SAMEORIGIN' in the SecurityMiddleware settings.
  • Configure Security Middleware:
    • Set SECURE_HSTS_SECONDS to a non-zero value (e.g., 31536000 - one year) to enable HSTS.
    • Set SECURE_SSL_REDIRECT = True to redirect HTTP requests to HTTPS.
    • Set SECURE_CONTENT_TYPE_NOSNIFF = True to prevent MIME-sniffing attacks.
    • Configure SECURE_REFERRER_POLICY appropriately.
  • Vary Header: Ensure your web server or cache is configured to include the Vary: Cookie header, especially if you have different content for logged-in and logged-out users.

3.4 Authentication System Mitigations

  • Strong Password Hashing: Use a strong password hashing algorithm (PBKDF2 or Argon2) with a high number of iterations. Configure these settings in PASSWORD_HASHERS.
  • Secure Session Management:
    • Set SESSION_COOKIE_SECURE = True in production.
    • Set SESSION_COOKIE_HTTPONLY = True.
    • Use a secure session storage backend (e.g., encrypted database storage, Redis with TLS).
    • Set SESSION_COOKIE_AGE to a reasonable value (e.g., 2 weeks).
    • Set SESSION_EXPIRE_AT_BROWSER_CLOSE = True to expire sessions when the browser closes.
    • Ensure SESSION_SAVE_EVERY_REQUEST = False unless absolutely necessary, to reduce database load.
  • Account Lockout: Implement account lockout mechanisms to prevent brute-force attacks. Consider using a third-party package like django-axes.
  • Secure Password Reset:
    • Use Django's built-in password reset functionality.
    • Validate email addresses before sending password reset emails.
    • Use unique, time-limited tokens for password reset links.
    • Invalidate old password reset tokens after a successful password change.
  • Prevent Username Enumeration: Use generic error messages on login and password reset forms (e.g., "Invalid username or password"). Avoid messages like "User does not exist."
  • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Strongly consider implementing MFA using a third-party package like django-otp.
  • Session ID Regeneration: Ensure Django is configured to regenerate the session ID upon login. This is the default behavior, but verify it.

3.5 Forms Handling Mitigations

  • Comprehensive Server-Side Validation: Always validate all user input on the server-side using Django's forms framework. Do not rely solely on client-side validation.
  • Whitelist Approach: Use a whitelist approach for input validation (i.e., explicitly define what is allowed) rather than a blacklist approach.
  • Appropriate Field Types: Use the appropriate field types for each input (e.g., EmailField for email addresses, IntegerField for integers).
  • Custom Validation: Implement custom validation logic where necessary to enforce specific business rules.
  • Regular Expression Security: Carefully review all regular expressions used in form validation to avoid ReDoS vulnerabilities. Use tools like Regex101 to test regular expressions with potentially malicious input. Consider using a library that provides safer regular expression handling.
  • Limit Input Length: Use max_length and min_length attributes on form fields to limit the length of input.

3.6 File Upload Handling Mitigations

  • File Type Validation: Validate file types based on their content, not just their extension. Use a library like python-magic to determine the MIME type of a file. Maintain a whitelist of allowed MIME types.
  • File Size Validation: Set FILE_UPLOAD_MAX_MEMORY_SIZE and DATA_UPLOAD_MAX_MEMORY_SIZE to limit the size of uploaded files.
  • Secure File Storage:
    • Store uploaded files outside the web root.
    • Use a dedicated directory for uploaded files (MEDIA_ROOT).
    • Generate unique file names to prevent collisions and overwriting. Consider using UUIDs.
    • Set appropriate file permissions to restrict access.
  • Directory Traversal Prevention: Sanitize file names to remove any ../ sequences or other potentially dangerous characters. Django's get_valid_filename() function can help with this.
  • Content-Disposition Header: Set the Content-Disposition header to attachment to force the browser to download the file instead of displaying it inline, which can prevent XSS attacks.
  • Virus Scanning: Consider integrating with a virus scanning service to scan uploaded files for malware.
  • Avoid Unvalidated Redirects: After an upload, do not redirect to a URL provided in the uploaded data or filename.

3.7 HTTP Handling Mitigations

  • Configure ALLOWED_HOSTS: Set ALLOWED_HOSTS to a list of the specific hostnames that the application should respond to. Do not use ['*'].
  • USE_X_FORWARDED_HOST: If your application is behind a proxy, set USE_X_FORWARDED_HOST = True only if you trust the proxy to set the X-Forwarded-Host header correctly. Validate the proxy's configuration.
  • HTTPS: Enforce HTTPS using SECURE_SSL_REDIRECT and HSTS.

3.8 Settings Mitigations

  • Protect SECRET_KEY:
    • Generate a strong, random SECRET_KEY.
    • Store the SECRET_KEY securely, outside of the source code repository. Use environment variables or a dedicated secrets management system.
    • Never commit the SECRET_KEY to version control.
  • DEBUG = False in Production: Always set DEBUG = False in a production environment.
  • Secure DATABASES Configuration:
    • Use strong, unique passwords for database users.
    • Store database credentials securely, outside of the source code repository.
    • Limit database access to only the necessary hosts.
    • Consider using a managed database service that provides encryption at rest.
  • Secure Email Settings:
    • Use a secure email backend (e.g., SMTP with TLS).
    • Store email credentials securely.
    • Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to prevent email spoofing.
  • Regularly Audit Settings: Periodically review the settings.py file to ensure that all security-related settings are configured correctly.

3.9 General Mitigations (applicable across multiple components)

  • Dependency Management: Regularly update Django and all third-party packages to the latest versions to address security vulnerabilities. Use tools like Dependabot or Snyk to automate this process.
  • Security Linters and Static Analysis: Integrate security linters (e.g., Bandit, Semgrep) into the CI/CD pipeline to automatically detect potential security issues in the codebase.
  • Penetration Testing and Security Audits: Regularly conduct penetration testing and security audits to identify and address vulnerabilities that may not be detected by automated tools.
  • Code Reviews: Enforce mandatory code reviews for all code changes, with a focus on security.
  • Security Training: Provide security training to developers to raise awareness of common web vulnerabilities and secure coding practices.
  • Least Privilege: Apply the principle of least privilege throughout the application and infrastructure. Grant users and services only the minimum necessary permissions.
  • Monitoring and Logging: Implement robust monitoring and logging to detect and respond to security incidents. Log security-relevant events, such as failed login attempts, access to sensitive data, and changes to security settings.
  • Incident Response Plan: Develop and maintain an incident response plan to handle security breaches effectively.

This deep analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the security considerations for Django applications, focusing on the framework's built-in security features and potential vulnerabilities. By implementing the recommended mitigation strategies, developers can significantly enhance the security posture of their Django applications and protect them from a wide range of threats. Remember that security is an ongoing process, and continuous monitoring, testing, and updates are essential to maintain a strong security posture.