Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
269 lines (229 loc) · 23.3 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

269 lines (229 loc) · 23.3 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for home-assistant/core

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update Home Assistant Core

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update Home Assistant Core

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Access your Home Assistant instance through the web interface.
    • Step 2: Navigate to the "Supervisor" or "Settings" -> "System" -> "Updates" section.
    • Step 3: Home Assistant will display available updates if a new version is detected.
    • Step 4: Click the "Update" button to initiate the update process.
    • Step 5: Monitor the update progress in the UI. Home Assistant will typically restart automatically after a successful update.
    • Step 6: Verify Home Assistant functionality after the update.
    • Step 7: Repeat this process whenever update notifications are displayed in the UI.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities: Severity: High
    • Zero-Day Exploits (Reduced Likelihood): Severity: Medium
    • Outdated Dependencies Vulnerabilities: Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities: High Risk Reduction
    • Zero-Day Exploits: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Outdated Dependencies Vulnerabilities: High Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Home Assistant provides update notifications and a user-friendly update process within the Supervisor/Settings panel.
  • Missing Implementation: Automatic updates are not enabled by default. More proactive in-app prompting for updates, especially security-related ones, could be implemented. Granular control over update types (security-only vs. feature updates) is also missing.

Mitigation Strategy: Monitor Security Advisories

Mitigation Strategy: Monitor Security Advisories

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Regularly check official Home Assistant communication channels for security advisories. These include:
      • Home Assistant Blog (via website or RSS feed).
      • Home Assistant Community Forums (security-related categories).
      • GitHub Security Advisories for the home-assistant/core repository (watch the repository).
    • Step 2: When a security advisory is found, read it carefully to understand the vulnerability and affected versions of Home Assistant Core.
    • Step 3: Follow the recommended mitigation steps outlined in the advisory, which usually involves updating Home Assistant Core to a patched version.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exploitation of Newly Disclosed Vulnerabilities: Severity: High
    • Delayed Patching of Vulnerabilities: Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Exploitation of Newly Disclosed Vulnerabilities: High Risk Reduction
    • Delayed Patching of Vulnerabilities: High Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Home Assistant relies on users to proactively monitor external channels for advisories. GitHub security advisories are used for core vulnerabilities.
  • Missing Implementation: No in-application notification system for security advisories within Home Assistant itself. Integrating advisory feeds into the Supervisor or a dedicated security dashboard would improve user awareness.

Mitigation Strategy: Principle of Least Privilege for Integrations

Mitigation Strategy: Principle of Least Privilege for Integrations

  • Description:
    • Step 1: When installing a new integration through the Home Assistant UI (Integrations panel), carefully review any permission requests displayed during the setup process.
    • Step 2: Grant only the necessary permissions for the integration to function as intended. Avoid granting broad or unnecessary permissions if possible.
    • Step 3: If an integration requests permissions that seem excessive or unrelated to its described functionality, investigate further or consider alternative integrations.
    • Step 4: Periodically review the permissions granted to installed integrations (currently requires manual review of integration documentation or code, as there's no central permission management UI in Core).
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Access to System Resources by Compromised Integrations: Severity: High
    • Data Breaches via Integrations with Excessive Permissions: Severity: High
    • Lateral Movement within the System by Malicious Integrations: Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Access to System Resources by Compromised Integrations: High Risk Reduction
    • Data Breaches via Integrations with Excessive Permissions: High Risk Reduction
    • Lateral Movement within the System by Malicious Integrations: High Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Home Assistant's integration framework allows for permission requests during setup. However, visibility and management of granted permissions are limited after initial setup.
  • Missing Implementation: A centralized user interface within Home Assistant to view and manage permissions granted to each integration after installation. More granular permission control and clearer explanation of permission implications during integration setup would be beneficial.

Mitigation Strategy: Utilize Official and Verified Integrations

Mitigation Strategy: Utilize Official and Verified Integrations

  • Description:
    • Step 1: When searching for integrations within Home Assistant's UI (Integrations panel or Add-ons store), prioritize official integrations listed in the core integration directory.
    • Step 2: For integrations not available officially, look for integrations from trusted sources and reputable community developers. Check community forums and documentation for reviews and reputation.
    • Step 3: Exercise caution when installing custom integrations from unknown or unverified sources.
    • Step 4: Before installing a custom integration, check its source code repository (if available on platforms like GitHub) to assess its activity, community feedback, and potential security concerns.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Malicious Integrations from Untrusted Sources: Severity: High
    • Vulnerable Integrations due to Lack of Review: Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Malicious Integrations from Untrusted Sources: High Risk Reduction
    • Vulnerable Integrations due to Lack of Review: Medium Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Home Assistant distinguishes between core integrations and custom integrations. The community provides informal vetting through forums and reviews.
  • Missing Implementation: A formal "verification" or "trust" mechanism for integrations within Home Assistant. A system to rate or certify integrations based on security and quality could be implemented to guide users towards safer options.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Review and Audit Installed Integrations

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Review and Audit Installed Integrations

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Periodically review the list of integrations installed in your Home Assistant instance. Navigate to "Settings" -> "Integrations" in the UI.
    • Step 2: For each integration, consider:
      • Is this integration still actively used and necessary?
      • Is it from a trusted source?
      • Are there any known security vulnerabilities reported for this integration (check community forums or security advisories)?
    • Step 3: Remove any integrations that are no longer needed by clicking the "Delete" button in the Integrations panel.
    • Step 4: Ensure all remaining integrations are updated to their latest versions (Home Assistant usually prompts for updates in the Integrations panel).
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Accumulation of Unnecessary and Potentially Vulnerable Integrations: Severity: Medium
    • Stale Integrations with Unpatched Vulnerabilities: Severity: Medium
    • Unnecessary Attack Surface Expansion: Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Accumulation of Unnecessary and Potentially Vulnerable Integrations: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Stale Integrations with Unpatched Vulnerabilities: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Unnecessary Attack Surface Expansion: Medium Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Home Assistant provides a UI to view and remove installed integrations and prompts for updates.
  • Missing Implementation: No proactive reminders or automated tools within Home Assistant to prompt users to review installed integrations periodically. Integration health checks or basic vulnerability scanning for integrations could be considered.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Secrets Management

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Secrets Management

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Create or edit the secrets.yaml file in your Home Assistant configuration directory.
    • Step 2: Define sensitive information (API keys, passwords, tokens) as secrets in secrets.yaml using the format secret_key: secret_value.
    • Step 3: In your main configuration files (e.g., configuration.yaml, automations.yaml), reference secrets using the !secret secret_key syntax.
    • Step 4: Ensure secrets.yaml is properly secured at the operating system level with appropriate file permissions (read-only for the Home Assistant user).
    • Step 5: Avoid hardcoding sensitive information directly in any configuration files other than secrets.yaml.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exposure of Secrets in Configuration Files: Severity: High
    • Accidental Disclosure of Secrets in Version Control: Severity: High
    • Unauthorized Access to Secrets: Severity: High (Improves local file security)
  • Impact:
    • Exposure of Secrets in Configuration Files: High Risk Reduction
    • Accidental Disclosure of Secrets in Version Control: High Risk Reduction
    • Unauthorized Access to Secrets: High Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Implemented. Home Assistant provides the secrets.yaml feature for secure secrets management.
  • Missing Implementation: No enforced usage of secrets.yaml. Home Assistant could provide warnings or static analysis tools to encourage users to use secrets.yaml and avoid hardcoding secrets.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Review Configuration Files

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Review Configuration Files

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Periodically review your Home Assistant configuration files (configuration.yaml, automations.yaml, secrets.yaml, etc.) located in your configuration directory.
    • Step 2: Look for:
      • Unnecessary or outdated configurations that can be removed.
      • Hardcoded credentials (even if using secrets.yaml, double-check for accidental hardcoding elsewhere).
      • Overly permissive or insecure configurations within integrations or components.
    • Step 3: Remove or update any identified insecure or unnecessary configurations by editing the configuration files.
    • Step 4: Consider using version control (like Git) to track changes to configuration files and easily revert if needed.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Configuration Drift Leading to Security Weaknesses: Severity: Medium
    • Accidental Introduction of Insecure Configurations: Severity: Medium
    • Accumulation of Unnecessary Attack Surface: Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Configuration Drift Leading to Security Weaknesses: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Accidental Introduction of Insecure Configurations: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Accumulation of Unnecessary Attack Surface: Medium Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Not Implemented as a proactive feature within Home Assistant. Users are responsible for manually reviewing their configurations.
  • Missing Implementation: Automated configuration audits or static analysis tools within Home Assistant to identify potential security issues in configurations. Providing configuration templates or best practice examples within the documentation could also guide users towards more secure setups.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Strong Authentication

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Strong Authentication

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Enforce strong passwords for all Home Assistant user accounts. Encourage users to use password managers for complex passwords.
    • Step 2: Enable two-factor authentication (2FA) for all user accounts, especially administrator accounts. Configure 2FA in the "Profile" section of the Home Assistant UI. Home Assistant supports various 2FA methods.
    • Step 3: Regularly review user accounts in "Settings" -> "People" and remove any accounts that are no longer needed.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Brute-Force Password Attacks: Severity: High
    • Credential Stuffing Attacks: Severity: High
    • Unauthorized Access due to Weak Passwords: Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • Brute-Force Password Attacks: High Risk Reduction (Especially with 2FA)
    • Credential Stuffing Attacks: High Risk Reduction (Especially with 2FA and unique passwords)
    • Unauthorized Access due to Weak Passwords: High Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Implemented. Home Assistant supports strong passwords and 2FA configuration within the user profile settings.
  • Missing Implementation: Account lockout policies are not natively implemented in Core. Password complexity enforcement could be improved. More proactive prompting for users to enable 2FA, especially during initial setup or for administrator accounts, would enhance security adoption.

Mitigation Strategy: Disable Unnecessary Components and Services

Mitigation Strategy: Disable Unnecessary Components and Services

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Review the list of enabled Home Assistant components and integrations. Check your configuration.yaml file for configured components and review installed integrations in "Settings" -> "Integrations".
    • Step 2: Identify any components or integrations that are not actively used or necessary for your smart home setup.
    • Step 3: Disable unnecessary components by commenting them out or removing them from your configuration.yaml file. Remove unnecessary integrations via the "Delete" button in the Integrations panel.
    • Step 4: Regularly review enabled components and services and disable any that become obsolete over time.
    • Step 5: Only enable components and services that are strictly required for your desired smart home functionality.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unnecessary Attack Surface Expansion: Severity: Medium
    • Vulnerabilities in Unused Components: Severity: Medium
    • Performance Overhead from Unused Services: Severity: Low (Security-related in terms of resource exhaustion)
  • Impact:
    • Unnecessary Attack Surface Expansion: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Vulnerabilities in Unused Components: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Performance Overhead from Unused Services: Low Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Users can disable components and integrations through configuration files and the UI.
  • Missing Implementation: No proactive recommendations or tools within Home Assistant to identify and suggest disabling unused components or integrations. A component/integration usage analysis tool could be helpful to guide users in minimizing their active setup.

Mitigation Strategy: Enable Automatic Updates (with Caution and Monitoring)

Mitigation Strategy: Enable Automatic Updates (with Caution and Monitoring)

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Configure Home Assistant to automatically install updates. Navigate to "Supervisor" or "Settings" -> "System" -> "Updates" and enable the automatic updates option (if available for your installation method).
    • Step 2: Enable automatic updates with caution, especially for major releases. Consider testing major updates in a separate testing instance first.
    • Step 3: Set up notifications for update processes. Home Assistant usually provides update notifications in the UI. Ensure you monitor these for successful updates or any errors.
    • Step 4: Have a backup and rollback plan in place in case an automatic update introduces issues. Home Assistant snapshots can be used for rollback.
    • Step 5: Regularly review release notes for updates applied automatically to understand changes, including security fixes.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Delayed Patching of Known Vulnerabilities: Severity: High
    • Exploitation of Unpatched Vulnerabilities: Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • Delayed Patching of Known Vulnerabilities: High Risk Reduction
    • Exploitation of Unpatched Vulnerabilities: High Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Home Assistant offers an option for automatic updates, but it is not enabled by default and requires user configuration.
  • Missing Implementation: More granular control over automatic updates (e.g., separate settings for security updates vs. all updates). Improved rollback mechanisms and automated pre-update testing could enhance the safety and user confidence in automatic updates.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Check for Updates Manually

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Check for Updates Manually

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Periodically (e.g., weekly or bi-weekly) manually check for updates in the Home Assistant Supervisor or Settings -> System -> Updates panel.
    • Step 2: Review the release notes for each new version by clicking on the version number or release notes link in the update panel. Pay attention to security-related changes and bug fixes.
    • Step 3: If security updates are included in a new release, prioritize applying the update promptly by clicking the "Update" button.
    • Step 4: If automatic updates are not enabled, make manual updates a regular part of your Home Assistant maintenance routine.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Delayed Patching of Known Vulnerabilities (If automatic updates are disabled or fail): Severity: High
    • Missing Important Security Fixes: Severity: High
  • Impact:
    • Delayed Patching of Known Vulnerabilities: High Risk Reduction
    • Missing Important Security Fixes: High Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Home Assistant provides update notifications and a manual update process within the UI.
  • Missing Implementation: More proactive reminders or notifications to users to check for updates manually, especially when security updates are available. A clearer visual indication of the security importance of pending updates in the UI could also be beneficial.

Mitigation Strategy: Role-Based Access Control (RBAC)

Mitigation Strategy: Role-Based Access Control (RBAC)

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Utilize Home Assistant's user management features to create different user accounts. Navigate to "Settings" -> "People" to manage users.
    • Step 2: Define user roles based on access needs (e.g., Administrator, User). Home Assistant provides basic user roles.
    • Step 3: Assign users to appropriate roles when creating or editing user accounts in the "People" settings. Grant administrator roles only to trusted users who require full access.
    • Step 4: Configure access to specific areas of Home Assistant based on user roles (limited RBAC functionality currently in Core, primarily for UI access).
    • Step 5: Regularly review user roles and access assignments in "Settings" -> "People" and adjust as needed.
    • Step 6: Apply the principle of least privilege by granting users only the minimum necessary access based on their role.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Access to Sensitive Features by Regular Users: Severity: Medium
    • Accidental or Malicious Actions by Users with Excessive Permissions: Severity: Medium
    • Lateral Movement after Account Compromise (Limited by restricted roles): Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Access to Sensitive Features by Regular Users: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Accidental or Malicious Actions by Users with Excessive Permissions: Medium Risk Reduction
    • Lateral Movement after Account Compromise: Medium Risk Reduction
  • Currently Implemented: Implemented. Home Assistant provides user management and basic role-based access control with user roles.
  • Missing Implementation: More granular and flexible RBAC system. Fine-grained permissions for individual entities, services, and features are needed. Pre-defined roles with clearer permission sets and a more comprehensive permission management UI would significantly enhance RBAC capabilities within Core.

Mitigation Strategy: Audit Logging and Monitoring

Mitigation Strategy: Audit Logging and Monitoring

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Enable and configure logging in Home Assistant Core. Configure logging levels in your configuration.yaml file under the logger: section to capture relevant security events (e.g., authentication attempts, errors).
    • Step 2: Configure logging output to a persistent storage location if needed (Home Assistant logs are typically stored in the config/home-assistant.log file by default).
    • Step 3: Regularly review the Home Assistant logs (e.g., home-assistant.log file) for suspicious activities, unauthorized access attempts, and errors that might indicate security issues.
    • Step 4: Consider using external log analysis tools to automate log monitoring and alerting for security-related events.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unnoticed Security Breaches: Severity: High
    • Delayed Detection of Security Incidents: Severity: High
    • Lack of Forensic Evidence after Security Incidents: Severity: Medium
  • Impact:
    • Unnoticed Security Breaches: High Risk Reduction (Enables detection through log review)
    • Delayed Detection of Security Incidents: High Risk Reduction (If logs are monitored regularly)
    • Lack of Forensic Evidence after Security Incidents: High Risk Reduction (Provides audit trails in logs)
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented. Home Assistant has logging capabilities configurable via configuration.yaml. However, comprehensive security-focused logging and automated monitoring require user configuration and potentially external tools.
  • Missing Implementation: More robust built-in audit logging features with security-specific event categories and structured logging formats for easier analysis. Integration with security information and event management (SIEM) systems or simpler in-app log analysis tools could be beneficial for improved security monitoring within Home Assistant Core itself.