Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
134 lines (103 loc) · 12.6 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

134 lines (103 loc) · 12.6 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for plotly/dash

Mitigation Strategy: 1. Mitigation Strategy: Robust Callback Input Validation and Sanitization (Dash-Specific Aspects)

  • Description:

    1. Identify All Dash Callbacks: List all app.callback decorators in the application code.
    2. Define Expected Input Types for Dash Components: For each Input and State in each callback, determine the expected data type and structure based on the specific Dash component it interacts with (e.g., dcc.Dropdown expects a string or list of strings for value, dcc.Graph expects a specific dictionary structure for figure).
    3. Implement Strict Type Checking: Use Python type hints and/or a validation library like pydantic to enforce these Dash-component-specific types and structures. Reject any input that doesn't conform.
    4. Whitelist Allowed Values for Dash Components: For Dash components with a limited set of valid options (e.g., dcc.Dropdown, dcc.RadioItems), create a list of allowed values and check if the input is present in this list server-side. Do not rely solely on the client-side component to enforce this.
    5. Component-Specific Validation: For complex Dash components (e.g., dcc.Graph, dcc.DataTable), validate the entire structure and content of the data passed to them (e.g., the figure property of dcc.Graph). Understand how each component processes data and what constitutes valid input for that component. This goes beyond basic type checking.
    6. Limit Input Length: Set reasonable maximum lengths for all input fields.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Code Injection (Severity: High): Prevents attackers from injecting arbitrary Python code or manipulating Dash's internal state through carefully crafted inputs that exploit Dash's component model and callback handling.
    • Denial-of-Service (DoS) (Severity: Medium): Limits input sizes, preventing attackers from sending excessively large requests designed to overload Dash's callback processing.
    • Data Corruption (Severity: Medium): Ensures that only valid data, conforming to the expected structure of Dash components, is processed, preventing unexpected behavior or errors within Dash's rendering engine.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (Severity: High): Although general input sanitization is crucial for XSS, validating the structure of data passed to Dash components adds another layer of defense, as malicious scripts could be embedded within seemingly valid data structures.

  • Impact:

    • Code Injection: Risk significantly reduced. Strict type and structure validation makes it very difficult to inject malicious code that Dash will execute.
    • DoS: Risk reduced. Length limits and validation prevent simple resource exhaustion attacks targeting Dash callbacks.
    • Data Corruption: Risk significantly reduced. Ensures data integrity within the Dash application.
    • XSS: Risk reduced (in conjunction with general output encoding).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Basic type checking (using Python type hints) is implemented in the update_graph callback.
    • Input length limits are set on the date range picker component.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • pydantic validation is not used, making type checking less robust.
    • Whitelisting is not implemented for the region and product dropdowns (dcc.Dropdown components) in the update_graph callback.
    • No specific validation is performed on the figure data passed to the dcc.Graph component in update_graph. This is a critical missing piece.
    • The file upload callback (process_upload) interacts with dcc.Upload, but doesn't validate the decoded content structure after base64 decoding.

Mitigation Strategy: 2. Mitigation Strategy: Restrict Dash Callback Exposure

  • Description:

    1. Review Callback Necessity: Analyze each app.callback and determine if it's absolutely necessary for the application's functionality. Could any client-side JavaScript handle the interaction without a server round-trip?
    2. Use prevent_initial_call=True: Add prevent_initial_call=True to all app.callback decorators where the initial call on page load is not required. This is a Dash-specific feature.
    3. Remove Unused Callbacks: Delete or comment out any app.callback decorators that are no longer in use.
    4. Prefer State over Input (When Appropriate): When only the current value of a Dash component is needed, and no callback trigger is required, use State instead of Input within the app.callback decorator. This is a key Dash distinction.
    5. Disable unused parts of callbacks: If some parts of callback are not used anymore, remove them.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial-of-Service (DoS) (Severity: Medium): Reduces the number of Dash callbacks that can be triggered, making it harder to overwhelm the server with requests specifically targeting Dash's callback mechanism.
    • Unintended Functionality Exposure (Severity: Medium): Minimizes the attack surface by exposing only necessary Dash callbacks.
    • Information Disclosure (Severity: Low): Reduces the risk of leaking information through unnecessary Dash callback executions.

  • Impact:

    • DoS: Risk moderately reduced. Fewer callbacks mean fewer potential targets for attacks specifically crafted for Dash.
    • Unintended Functionality Exposure: Risk significantly reduced. Only essential Dash callbacks are accessible.
    • Information Disclosure: Risk slightly reduced.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • prevent_initial_call=True is used in the update_graph callback.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • There's a commented-out callback (old_filter_logic) that should be removed.
    • The update_table callback could potentially use State for some inputs instead of Input.

Mitigation Strategy: 3. Mitigation Strategy: Secure Dash Multi-Page App Routing

  • Description:

    1. Identify Page Callbacks: Locate all app.callback decorators that are triggered by changes in dcc.Location (i.e., URL changes). These are the core of Dash's multi-page app functionality.
    2. Implement Server-Side Authorization (Within Dash Callbacks): Within each of these Dash callbacks, before rendering any page content, check if the current user (based on session data) has the necessary permissions to access that page. This authorization logic must reside within the Dash callback.
    3. Validate pathname (Within Dash Callbacks): In the Dash callback triggered by dcc.Location, verify that the pathname property matches one of the expected, valid routes. Reject any unexpected or malformed paths within the Dash callback.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Unauthorized Access (Severity: High): Prevents users from accessing Dash pages they are not authorized to view by enforcing checks within Dash's routing mechanism.
    • Broken Access Control (Severity: High): Enforces proper access control based on user roles and permissions, specifically within the context of Dash's page rendering.

  • Impact:

    • Unauthorized Access: Risk significantly reduced. Server-side checks within Dash callbacks prevent unauthorized page access.
    • Broken Access Control: Risk significantly reduced. Robust authorization logic is enforced within Dash's routing.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Basic authorization check (user logged in) is implemented in the display_page callback.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • The authorization check only verifies login, not role/permissions for the "Admin" page.
    • The pathname is not explicitly validated against a list of allowed routes within the Dash callback.

Mitigation Strategy: 4. Mitigation Strategy: Secure Dash Component Configuration

  • Description:

    1. debug=False in Production: Always set debug=False in the app.run_server() call for the production environment. This is a critical Dash-specific setting.
    2. Review Dash Component Documentation: Thoroughly review the documentation for each Dash component used (e.g., dcc.Graph, dcc.DataTable, dcc.Upload, dcc.Location, dcc.Link). Identify all security-related configuration options and best practices specific to each component.
    3. Disable Unnecessary Dash Component Features: Turn off any Dash component features that are not required. For example, if client-side graph editing is not needed, disable the editable property of dcc.Graph. If certain toolbar options are not needed, remove them.
    4. Implement Content Security Policy (CSP): Define a strict CSP using app.index_string to control the resources the application can load.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Information Disclosure (Severity: High): debug=False prevents sensitive Dash debugging information from being exposed in production.
    • Exploitation of Dash Component Vulnerabilities (Severity: Medium): Disabling unnecessary Dash component features reduces the attack surface specific to those components.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (Severity: High): CSP restricts the sources from which scripts can be loaded.

  • Impact:

    • Information Disclosure: Risk significantly reduced. Dash debug mode is disabled.
    • Exploitation of Dash Component Vulnerabilities: Risk moderately reduced. Fewer Dash component features mean fewer potential vulnerabilities specific to those components.
    • XSS: Risk significantly reduced.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • debug=False is set in the production deployment script.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No Content Security Policy (CSP) is implemented.
    • The dcc.Graph component has editable=True set unnecessarily.

Mitigation Strategy: 5. Mitigation Strategy: Secure Dash File Uploads (using dcc.Upload)

  • Description:

    1. Validate File Type and Size (Within the Dash Callback): In the app.callback that handles dcc.Upload, check the file extension and, if possible, the MIME type. Also, enforce a maximum file size limit within the callback.
    2. Rename Uploaded Files (Within the Dash Callback): Generate a unique, random filename for each uploaded file (e.g., using uuid.uuid4()) within the Dash callback.
    3. Validate File Content (Within the Dash Callback): After base64 decoding the content from dcc.Upload, parse the content (e.g., CSV data) and validate that it conforms to the expected structure and data types within the Dash callback. This is crucial for preventing attacks that embed malicious data within seemingly valid file formats.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Malware Upload (Severity: High): While external malware scanning is important, initial file type and size checks within the Dash callback provide a first line of defense.
    • Denial-of-Service (DoS) (Severity: Medium): File size limits within the Dash callback prevent attackers from uploading excessively large files that could overwhelm Dash's processing.
    • Data Corruption (Severity: Medium): File content validation within the Dash callback ensures that the data processed by Dash is well-formed and conforms to expectations.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (Severity: High): If uploaded files are displayed to other users, proper validation and sanitization prevent XSS attacks.

  • Impact:

    • Malware Upload: Risk reduced (further reduction with external scanning).
    • DoS: Risk reduced, specifically against attacks targeting Dash's upload handling.
    • Data Corruption: Risk significantly reduced within the Dash application.
    • XSS: Risk reduced (in conjunction with general output encoding).

  • Currently Implemented:

    • File extension is checked within the upload callback.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Uploaded files are not renamed within the callback.
    • File size limits are not enforced within the callback.
    • The content of the uploaded CSV file (after base64 decoding) is not validated within the callback. This is a critical missing step.